Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2007.11980 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Gravitational interaction through a feedback mechanism

José Luis Gaona-Reyes, Matteo Carlesso, Angelo Bassi

Published Mar 19, 2021• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the models of Kafri et al. (KTM) and Tilloy and Di\'osi (TD), both of which implement gravity between quantum systems through a continuous measurement and feedback mechanism. The first model is for two particles, moving in one dimension, where the Newtonian potential is linearized. The second is applicable to any quantum system, within the context of Newtonian gravity. We address the issue of how to generalize the KTM model for an arbitrary finite number of particles. We find that the most straightforward generalizations are either inconsistent or are ruled out by experimental evidence. We also show that the TD model does not reduce to the KTM model under the approximations, which define the latter model. We then argue that under the simplest conditions, the TD model is the only viable implementation of a full-Newtonian interaction through a continuous measurement and feedback mechanism.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.103.056011

Related papers

Gravity as a classical channel and its dissipative generalization

Giovanni Di Bartolomeo, Matteo Carlesso, Angelo Bassi

Recent models formulated by Kafri, Taylor, and Milburn and by Tilloy and Diosi describe the gravitational interaction through a continuous measurement and feedback protocol. In such a way, although gravity is ultimately treated as classical, they can reconstruct the proper quantum gravitational interaction at the level of the master equation for the statistical operator. Following this procedure, the price to pay is the presence of decoherence effects leading to an asymptotic energy divergence. One does not expect the latter in isolated systems. Here, we propose a dissipative generalization of these models. We show that, in these generalizations, in the long time limit, the system thermalizes to an effective finite temperature.

arXiv:2106.13305•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Nov 10, 2021•10 citations

The quantum and the gravity: Newtonian and Cosmological applications

Natacha Altamirano

The gravitational decoherence field studies the suppression of coherence in quantum systems caused by effects rooted in the gravitational interaction. This models are not just important to yield interesting ideas about the search, in regimes others than the Planck scale, for the interplay between quantum mechanics and general relativity, but also from a theoretical point of view. The fact that the gravitational field can not be shielded opens the question of how strong will the gravitational ‘environment’ decohere a quantum system? and if this decoherence can somehow explain the absence of macroscopical super- positions? This thesis studies in depth the ‘Classical Channel Gravity’ (CCG) model, a recent proposal of gravitational decoherence that assumes that the gravitational interac- tion is always accompanied with an intrinsic decoherence mechanism which ensures that there is no transmission of quantum information between the parties involved. This model can be understood a series of weak continuous quantum measurements accompanied with a feedback term produced by some underlying hidden gravitational degrees of freedom. We first study all the possible emergent dynamics from collisional Markovian dynamics; these ones range from exact unitary to arbitrary fast decoherence (Zeno effect). The second part of the thesis is devoted to study the Newtonian and post Newtonian limits of the CCG model, with particular focus on the testability features of CCG. In particular, we apply this model to coupled clocks and find that the amount of decoherence predicted by CCG is the same as the decoherence that an ‘environment of clocks’ will imprint in a single clock in the context of unitary evolution. On the other hand, we find that this effect is far from being detectable with the current achieved time accuracy. However, CCG as a model for multi partite systems and two systems with very different masses seems to yield an amount of decoherence that is not only able to be detectable with current experiments but also seems to indicate that this model is ruled out. Nevertheless, we also mention potential caveats with our assumptions and discuss other physically motivated directions to further study this result. Finally, we also explore the extension of CCG for the cosmological scenario. In this context the scale factor is being decohered by test particles ‘sitting’ on spacetime. We find that this decoherence will be seen by an observer unaware of the CCG fundamental mechanism as an emergent form of dark energy filling the universe.

•Jul 18, 2018•0 citations

Gravitational entropy production in a quantum low-energy gravity model free from causality violation problems

Filippo Maimone, Giovanni Scelza, Adele Naddeo

Wave-function collapse following a measurement process is a longstanding controversial issue of quantum physics. It introduces an element of strong non-linearity and irreversibility in an otherwise unitary and reversible dynamics. Several proposals of modification of Quantum Mechanics have been put forward in the past few decades in order to solve such a dichotomy. Among them, some approaches and explicit models considered the possible role of gravity in the wave-function collapse as a result of the incompatibility of general relativity and unitary time evolution of Quantum Mechanics. In this contribution we present some results based on one of such models, De Filippo’s Nonunitary Newtonian Gravity, which shows several appealing features: while reproducing at a macroscopic level the ordinary Newtonian interaction, it presents a mass threshold for gravitational localization. In particular, it provides a mechanism for the evolution of macroscopic coherent superpositions of states into ensembles of pure states. On one hand, we show the results of a numerical simulation of a simple system, i.e. two particles in a harmonic trap interacting via an ‘electrical’ delta-like potential and gravitational interaction. Starting from an energy eigenstate within the ordinary setting, we find that, while energy expectation remains constant, a slow net variation of the von Neumann entropy for the system as a whole takes place, with a small modulation induced on the relative entanglement entropy of the two particles. On the other hand, we explicitly show how a one-parameter generalization of the model, reproducing the nonlinear Newton-Schrödinger equation as the parameter goes to infinity, is free from any causality-violation problem for any finite value of it.

The Ninth Marcel Grossmann Meeting•Jun 22, 2022•0 citations

Experimental prospects for detecting the quantum nature of spacetime

Paulina Corona-Ugalde

This thesis is concerned with advancing the confrontation between relativistic quantum information (RQI) and experiment. We investigate the lessons that some present-day experiments can teach us about the relationship between quantum information, relativistic motion and gravitation. \n \nFirst, we look at the insights we can gain within the framework of quantum field theory in curved spacetimes. Particularly, we propose a generalization of the superconducting circuit simulation of the dynamical Casimir effect where we consider relativistically moving boundary conditions following different trajectories. We study the feasibility of extending the experimental setup to reproduce richer relativistic trajectories. \n \nNext, motivated by recent efforts to describe the gravitational interaction as a classical channel arising from continuous quantum measurements, we study what types of dynamics can emerge from a collisional model of repeated interactions between a system and a set of ancillae. We use these results in the context of gravitational interactions and show how our general framework recovers the gravitational decoherence model of Kafri, Taylor and Milburn (KTM). \n \nFinally, we argue that single-atom interference experiments achieving large spatial superpositions can rule out a particular realization of the KTM model where gravitational interactions act pairwise between massive particles as classical channels, approximating Newtonian pair-potential at low energies. Our findings counteract the present belief that gravity-inspired decoherence models cannot be confronted by experiment. Specifically, we find experimental indications which show that if gravity does reduce to pairwise Newtonian interactions between atoms in a non-relativistic limit, these interactions cannot be fundamentally classical. \n \nOur work shows that state-of-the-art technology can be used as a tool to test the quantum character of spacetime and that further efforts should be spent in analyzing how current experimental setups can guide us towards building a complete theory of quantum gravity.

•Sep 21, 2017•1 citation

Hybrid classical-quantum Newtonian gravity with stable vacuum

Nicolò Piccione, Angelo Bassi

Abstract We investigate the gravitational Poissonian spontaneous localization (GPSL) model, a hybrid classical-quantum model in which classical Newtonian gravity emerges from stochastic collapses of the mass density operator, and consistently couples to quantum matter. Unlike models based on continuous weak measurement schemes, we show that GPSL ensures vacuum stability; this, together with its applicability to identical particles and fields, makes it a promising candidate for a relativistic generalization. We analyze the model’s general properties, and compare its predictions with those based on continuous weak measurement schemes. Notably, here the gravitational feedback enters entirely through the non-Hermitian jump operators, without modifying the unitary part of the dynamics. We show that this leads to a short-range gravitational back-reaction and permits decoherence rates below those of any model based on continuous weak measurement schemes. We provide explicit examples, including the dynamics of a single particle and a rigid sphere, to illustrate the distinctive phenomenology of the model. Finally, we discuss the experimental testability of GPSL, highlighting both interferometric and non-interferometric strategies to constrain its parameters and distinguish it from competing models.

arXiv:2502.04996•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Oct 20, 2025•5 citations

Classical Channel Gravity in the Newtonian Limit

Kiran E. Khosla, Stefan Nimmrichter

We present a minimal model for the quantum evolution of matter under the influence of classical gravity in the Newtonian limit. Based on a continuous measurement-feedback channel that acts simultaneously on all constituent masses of a given quantum system, the model scales and applies consistently to arbitrary mass densities, and it recovers the classical Newton force between macroscopic masses. The concomitant loss of coherence is set by a model parameter, does not depend on mass, and can thus be confined to unobservable time scales for micro- and macroscopic systems alike. The model can be probed in high-precision matter-wave interferometry, and ultimately tested in recently proposed optomechanical quantum gravity experiments.

arXiv:1812.03118•Dec 7, 2018•14 citations
We study the models of Kafri et al. (KTM) and Tilloy and Di'osi (TD), both of which implement gravity between quantum systems through a continuous measurement and feedback mechanism. The first model is for two particles, moving in one dimension, where the Newtonian potential is linearized. The second is applicable to any quantum system, within the context of Newtonian gravity. We address the issue of how to generalize the KTM model for an arbitrary finite number of particles. We find that the most straightforward generalizations are either inconsistent or are ruled out by experimental evidence. We also show that the TD model does not reduce to the KTM model under the approximations, which define the latter model. We then argue that under the simplest conditions, the TD model is the only viable implementation of a full-Newtonian interaction through a continuous measurement and feedback mechanism.
Recent models formulated by Kafri, Taylor, and Milburn and by Tilloy and Diosi describe the gravitational interaction through a continuous measurement and feedback protocol. In such a way, although gravity is ultimately treated as classical, they can reconstruct the proper quantum gravitational interaction at the level of the master equation for the statistical operator. Following this procedure, the price to pay is the presence of decoherence effects leading to an asymptotic energy divergence. One does not expect the latter in isolated systems. Here, we propose a dissipative generalization of these models. We show that, in these generalizations, in the long time limit, the system thermalizes to an effective finite temperature.
The gravitational decoherence field studies the suppression of coherence in quantum systems caused by effects rooted in the gravitational interaction. This models are not just important to yield interesting ideas about the search, in regimes others than the Planck scale, for the interplay between quantum mechanics and general relativity, but also from a theoretical point of view. The fact that the gravitational field can not be shielded opens the question of how strong will the gravitational ‘environment’ decohere a quantum system? and if this decoherence can somehow explain the absence of macroscopical super- positions? This thesis studies in depth the ‘Classical Channel Gravity’ (CCG) model, a recent proposal of gravitational decoherence that assumes that the gravitational interac- tion is always accompanied with an intrinsic decoherence mechanism which ensures that there is no transmission of quantum information between the parties involved. This model can be understood a series of weak continuous quantum measurements accompanied with a feedback term produced by some underlying hidden gravitational degrees of freedom. We first study all the possible emergent dynamics from collisional Markovian dynamics; these ones range from exact unitary to arbitrary fast decoherence (Zeno effect). The second part of the thesis is devoted to study the Newtonian and post Newtonian limits of the CCG model, with particular focus on the testability features of CCG. In particular, we apply this model to coupled clocks and find that the amount of decoherence predicted by CCG is the same as the decoherence that an ‘environment of clocks’ will imprint in a single clock in the context of unitary evolution. On the other hand, we find that this effect is far from being detectable with the current achieved time accuracy. However, CCG as a model for multi partite systems and two systems with very different masses seems to yield an amount of decoherence that is not only able to be detectable with current experiments but also seems to indicate that this model is ruled out. Nevertheless, we also mention potential caveats with our assumptions and discuss other physically motivated directions to further study this result. Finally, we also explore the extension of CCG for the cosmological scenario. In this context the scale factor is being decohered by test particles ‘sitting’ on spacetime. We find that this decoherence will be seen by an observer unaware of the CCG fundamental mechanism as an emergent form of dark energy filling the universe.
Wave-function collapse following a measurement process is a longstanding controversial issue of quantum physics. It introduces an element of strong non-linearity and irreversibility in an otherwise unitary and reversible dynamics. Several proposals of modification of Quantum Mechanics have been put forward in the past few decades in order to solve such a dichotomy. Among them, some approaches and explicit models considered the possible role of gravity in the wave-function collapse as a result of the incompatibility of general relativity and unitary time evolution of Quantum Mechanics. In this contribution we present some results based on one of such models, De Filippo’s Nonunitary Newtonian Gravity, which shows several appealing features: while reproducing at a macroscopic level the ordinary Newtonian interaction, it presents a mass threshold for gravitational localization. In particular, it provides a mechanism for the evolution of macroscopic coherent superpositions of states into ensembles of pure states. On one hand, we show the results of a numerical simulation of a simple system, i.e. two particles in a harmonic trap interacting via an ‘electrical’ delta-like potential and gravitational interaction. Starting from an energy eigenstate within the ordinary setting, we find that, while energy expectation remains constant, a slow net variation of the von Neumann entropy for the system as a whole takes place, with a small modulation induced on the relative entanglement entropy of the two particles. On the other hand, we explicitly show how a one-parameter generalization of the model, reproducing the nonlinear Newton-Schrödinger equation as the parameter goes to infinity, is free from any causality-violation problem for any finite value of it.
This thesis is concerned with advancing the confrontation between relativistic quantum information (RQI) and experiment. We investigate the lessons that some present-day experiments can teach us about the relationship between quantum information, relativistic motion and gravitation. \n \nFirst, we look at the insights we can gain within the framework of quantum field theory in curved spacetimes. Particularly, we propose a generalization of the superconducting circuit simulation of the dynamical Casimir effect where we consider relativistically moving boundary conditions following different trajectories. We study the feasibility of extending the experimental setup to reproduce richer relativistic trajectories. \n \nNext, motivated by recent efforts to describe the gravitational interaction as a classical channel arising from continuous quantum measurements, we study what types of dynamics can emerge from a collisional model of repeated interactions between a system and a set of ancillae. We use these results in the context of gravitational interactions and show how our general framework recovers the gravitational decoherence model of Kafri, Taylor and Milburn (KTM). \n \nFinally, we argue that single-atom interference experiments achieving large spatial superpositions can rule out a particular realization of the KTM model where gravitational interactions act pairwise between massive particles as classical channels, approximating Newtonian pair-potential at low energies. Our findings counteract the present belief that gravity-inspired decoherence models cannot be confronted by experiment. Specifically, we find experimental indications which show that if gravity does reduce to pairwise Newtonian interactions between atoms in a non-relativistic limit, these interactions cannot be fundamentally classical. \n \nOur work shows that state-of-the-art technology can be used as a tool to test the quantum character of spacetime and that further efforts should be spent in analyzing how current experimental setups can guide us towards building a complete theory of quantum gravity.
Abstract We investigate the gravitational Poissonian spontaneous localization (GPSL) model, a hybrid classical-quantum model in which classical Newtonian gravity emerges from stochastic collapses of the mass density operator, and consistently couples to quantum matter. Unlike models based on continuous weak measurement schemes, we show that GPSL ensures vacuum stability; this, together with its applicability to identical particles and fields, makes it a promising candidate for a relativistic generalization. We analyze the model’s general properties, and compare its predictions with those based on continuous weak measurement schemes. Notably, here the gravitational feedback enters entirely through the non-Hermitian jump operators, without modifying the unitary part of the dynamics. We show that this leads to a short-range gravitational back-reaction and permits decoherence rates below those of any model based on continuous weak measurement schemes. We provide explicit examples, including the dynamics of a single particle and a rigid sphere, to illustrate the distinctive phenomenology of the model. Finally, we discuss the experimental testability of GPSL, highlighting both interferometric and non-interferometric strategies to constrain its parameters and distinguish it from competing models.
We present a minimal model for the quantum evolution of matter under the influence of classical gravity in the Newtonian limit. Based on a continuous measurement-feedback channel that acts simultaneously on all constituent masses of a given quantum system, the model scales and applies consistently to arbitrary mass densities, and it recovers the classical Newton force between macroscopic masses. The concomitant loss of coherence is set by a model parameter, does not depend on mass, and can thus be confined to unobservable time scales for micro- and macroscopic systems alike. The model can be probed in high-precision matter-wave interferometry, and ultimately tested in recently proposed optomechanical quantum gravity experiments.