Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2007.02866 · Physical Review A

Ancilla-mediated qubit readout and heralded entanglement between rare-earth dopant ions in crystals

Kamanasish Debnath, Alexander Holm Kiilerich, Klaus Mølmer

Published Apr 8, 2021• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Due to their long excited-state lifetimes, rare-earth ions in crystals are widely used in quantum applications. To allow optical readout of the qubit state of individual ions, we propose to dope the crystal with an additional nearby ancilla ion with a shorter radiative lifetime. We show how a Bayesian analysis exhausts the information about the state of the qubit from the optical signal of the ancilla ion. We study the effects of incoherent processes, and we propose ways to reduce their effect on the readout. Finally, we extend the architecture to ions residing in two remote cavities, and we show how continuous monitoring of fluorescence signals from the two ancilla ions leads to entanglement of the qubit ions.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.103.043705

Related papers

Cerium as a quantum state probe for rare-earth qubits in a crystal

Jenny Karlsson

Rare-earth ions doped into a transparent crystal can have optically excited states with coherence times of milliseconds and hyperfine levels with coherence times of hours when cooled down to liquid helium temperatures. This makes them attractive for developing quantum computing hardware. A quantum transistor can be implemented in a rare-earth-ion-doped crystal by utilizing a dipole blockade effect, where one excited ion prevents nearby ions from being excited. By using single rare-earth ions as qubits, the quantum processor is believed to be scalable to several qubits. In this thesis a readout mechanism for qubits represented by single ions (Eu or Pr) in a Y2SiO5 crystal is explored. A single cerium ion, in the same crystal as the qubits, could potentially be used as an indicator ion for non-demolition quantum state detection of the qubits. Cerium has a strong transition with high fluorescence yield which makes it possible to detect single ions. A cerium ion can be controlled by a qubit via the dipole blockade effect, and fluoresce if the qubit is in state |1> but stay dark if the qubit is in state |0>. Relevant spectroscopic properties of Ce:Y2SiO5 are studied, as well as interactions between cerium ions and qubit ions. The inhomogeneous and homogeneous linewidth of the Ce:Y2SiO5 4f-5d transition is measured and fluorescence spectra for ions in site 1 and site 2 are characterized. The change in electric dipole moment as a cerium ion is brought to the excited state is measured. The static dipole interaction between a single cerium ion and a qubit ion is shown to be strong enough for efficient qubit readout. Energy transfer from cerium to qubit ions is investigated. A lower bound on the cerium-qubit distance is found in order to avoid energy transfer. Satellite lines belonging to cerium-qubit pairs are mapped out. A microscope set-up is built to detect single ions in a crystal. Single ion detection is believed to be within reach.

•Jan 1, 2015•1 citation

Light-Matter Interaction and Quantum Computing in Rare-Earth-Ion-Doped Crystals

Adam Kinos

In this thesis, crystals of yttrium orthosilicate (Y2SiO5) that are randomly doped with another rare-earth element, such as praseodymium (Pr), europium (Eu), or cerium (Ce), are investigated with lasers locked to ultra-stable cavities using the Pound-Drever-Hall locking technique. Many of these rare-earth elements have long-lived 4f-4f transitions, hundreds of microseconds to a few milliseconds, with even longer ground hyperfine lifetimes of up to several days. The coherence properties are, to the best of the author's knowledge, the longest achieved for any material, currently with a record of six hours for the nuclear spin states of Eu3+:Y2SiO5 measured at cryogenic temperatures. Furthermore, due to natural trapping and differences in the local environments, each dopant ion experiences a slightly different crystal field, and thus an inhomogeneity in the 4f-4f transition exists between all ions in a crystal. Since the homogeneous linewidth is in the order of kHz or below, whereas the inhomogeneous profile can be several GHz wide, these materials have dense storing capabilities.This thesis explores how light interacts with such rare-earth-ion-doped crystals; how the absorption and light polarization varies during propagation; how spectral features in the inhomogeneous absorption profile can be tailored to create narrowband spectral filters; how the speed of light is slowed down significantly in such narrow transmission windows; and how that can be used to either frequency shift incoming light, control its group velocity, or temporally compress pulses. It also uses rare-earth-ions to research quantum computing, the field of using quantum mechanical effects such as superpositions and entanglements to outperform classical computers on certain specific problems. This is done by examining how two-color pulses can be used to rapidly induce coherence from an initially mixed state; how qubit-qubit interactions can be performed experimentally using ensemble qubits, which opens the door to two-qubit experiments such as the CNOT-gate and entanglements; how a scalable quantum computer might be constructed using a single ion qubit approach with a dedicated readout ion and buffer ion(s) to improve readout fidelity; and how cerium is investigated as a candidate for such a dedicated readout ion.

•Feb 5, 2018•0 citations

Towards single Ce ion detection in a bulk crystal for the development of a single-ion qubit readout scheme

Ying Lin Yan

The work presented in this thesis was concerned with investigating the relevant spectroscopic properties of Ce ions randomly doped in an Y2SiO5 crystal at low temperatures (around 4 K), in order to develop a technique and an experimental set-up to detect the fluorescence photons emitted by a single Ce ion. The aim of the work was to determine whether a single Ce ion (referred to as the readout ion) can be used as a local probe to sense the quantum state of a neighbouring single-ion qubit via a state-selective interaction between the readout and qubit ion. More precisely, if the qubit ion is in state |1> or |0> state, the single Ce ion will, or will not, emit fluorescence photons. This single ion readout concept is a key step towards single-rare-earth-ion quantum computing, which is believed to be a promising approach for a scalable quantum computer. Rare-earth ion based quantum computing is an attractive scheme for several reasons. Firstly, the qubit coherence time can be on the timescale of a minute while the optical coherence time can be on the millisecond timescale, despite the fact that the ions are in a solid (crystal), which means that more than 10000 optical pulses could be implemented before the system decoheres. Secondly, any sub-ensemble of ions in a frequency interval equal to or larger than the homogeneous linewidth within the inhomogeneously broadened absorption line can be used as a frequency-selectively addressed qubit. The proof of principle of the qubit-qubit interaction has been previously demonstrated. Thirdly, no special material engineering is required, and the crystal is commercially available. Ways of initializing a sub-ensemble of Pr ions as a qubit in the random system, manipulating the quantum state of the ions in a controlled way, and characterizing the quantum state created are presented. In order to achieve better scalability, the idea of letting a single rare-earth ion represent a qubit was investigated. The fidelity of the single-ion readout scheme was briefly studied. The influence of the energy transfer process between two neighbouring ions on quantum computing is discussed. A readout ion should possess a number of specific spectroscopic properties. Therefore, the position and the linewidths of the zero-phonon line of Ce ions were measured using an external cavity diode laser (at 371 nm) as the excitation source. The difference in the permanent dipole moment of the ground and excited states of Ce ions was measured in a photon echo experiment on Pr ions in a Ce-Pr co-doped Y2SiO5 crystal. The last and most important task was to realize single Ce ion detection. Fluorescence of Ce ions has been detected from a crystal, where there is on average 1 ion within 4.6 \micro m$^3$ interacting with the excitation laser at a time. Estimates were made of the number of ions contributing to an observed signal. A trial experiment to investigate whether the signal was emitted by a single Ce ion was carried out, but was unsuccessful. Potential reasons why the experiment failed are presented.

Lund reports on atomic physics•Jan 1, 2013•1 citation

Coherent Processes in Rare-Earth-Ion-Doped Solids

Andreas Walther

This thesis describes a number of coherent processes, such as quantum information processing, superradiance and electromagnetically induced transparency, which have been experimentally implemented using rare-earth-ion-doped crystals. The rare-earths are a class of elements that have in common, an atomic structure that allows for very long lifetimes as well as coherence times, both on optical transitions and on spin transitions. These ions can be naturally trapped inside host crystals, and with the phonon vibrations removed by cooling down to cryogenic temperatures (< 4 K), they can be used for a number of different quantum information processes. Most experiments were carried out using PrYSO, but also other crystal types were investigated, such as Nd:YVO4, and La2(WO4)3. The characterization of the ions were done with a variety of methods, including among others, photon echo techniques and electromagnetically induced transparency. Quantum computing is a rapidly growing field and there are still many potential candidates for its implementation. In our work we have utilized the spin states of the Pr rare-earth ion as a qubit, and demonstrated arbitrary single qubit gates, which are important pieces towards a quantum computing realization in these systems. Most of the experimental work done for the thesis was carried out using an ensemble approach, that has the advantage of giving a strong readout signal, but for future scaling to multiple qubits, single instances are more promising, which is discussed. Quantum memories are crucial components in applications such as quantum networks and long distance quantum communication. In this thesis, work has been done to investigate how quantum memories can be implemented in rare-earth crystals. In particular, there are two protocols, CRIB and AFC, which were suggested with rare-earth crystals directly in mind, and both of these require high optical depth, for maximum recall efficiency. In this thesis, implications of being in the high optical depth regime, with phenomena such as superradiance, a collective effect that could cause the stored light to be immediately reemitted, and slow light effects that come from performing the storage inside spectrally structured materials, were investigated. In order to carry out the phase-sensitive experiments, a laser system with a very narrow linewidth of ~1 kHz at 606 nm was constructed, by locking the laser to a semi-persistent spectral hole. In addition, many experiments required advanced pulse shapes, such as complex sechyp pulses or pulses obtained from optimal control theory. In order to be able to accurately create such shapes, an elaborate system using an arbitrary waveform generator and two well calibrated AOMs, controlled from a computer, was also built.

•Jan 1, 2009•5 citations

Extracting high fidelity quantum computer hardware from random systems

Andreas Walther, Brian Julsgaard, Lars Rippe +4 more

An overview of current status and prospects of the development of quantum computer hardware based on inorganic crystals doped with rare-earth ions are presented. Major parts of the experimental work in this area have been done in two places, Canberra, Australia and Lund, Sweden, and the present description follows more closely the Lund work. Techniques will be described that include optimal filtering of the initially inhomogeneously broadened profile down to well separated and narrow ensembles, as well as the use of advanced pulse-shaping in order to achieve robust arbitrary single-qubit operations with fidelities above 90%, as characterized by quantum state tomography. It is expected that full scalability of these systems will require the ability to determine the state of single rare-earth ions. It has been proposed that this can be done using special readout ions doped into the crystal and an update is given on the work to find and characterize such ions. Finally, a few aspects on possibilities for remote entanglement of ions in separate rare-earth-ion-doped crystals are considered.

arXiv:1001.1664•Physica Scripta•Dec 1, 2009•24 citations

Towards cavity enhanced detection of single ions in the solid-state

Van Valkenhoef, Céline Hélène Ida

Entanglement between single spins and photons is an important resource in quantum information science, e.g. in quantum networking. Rare-earth ions in dielectric crystals have emerged as a promising candidate for this task. Rare-earth ion doped solids have been used so far mostly as ensemble-based quantum memories. However, they also feature promising properties for single ion detection and manipulation, such as long-lived spins, narrow optical transitions and preservation of coherence properties when inserted in nanostructures. Because of the long lifetimes of the optical t

•Sep 6, 2018•0 citations
Due to their long excited-state lifetimes, rare-earth ions in crystals are widely used in quantum applications. To allow optical readout of the qubit state of individual ions, we propose to dope the crystal with an additional nearby ancilla ion with a shorter radiative lifetime. We show how a Bayesian analysis exhausts the information about the state of the qubit from the optical signal of the ancilla ion. We study the effects of incoherent processes, and we propose ways to reduce their effect on the readout. Finally, we extend the architecture to ions residing in two remote cavities, and we show how continuous monitoring of fluorescence signals from the two ancilla ions leads to entanglement of the qubit ions.
Rare-earth ions doped into a transparent crystal can have optically excited states with coherence times of milliseconds and hyperfine levels with coherence times of hours when cooled down to liquid helium temperatures. This makes them attractive for developing quantum computing hardware. A quantum transistor can be implemented in a rare-earth-ion-doped crystal by utilizing a dipole blockade effect, where one excited ion prevents nearby ions from being excited. By using single rare-earth ions as qubits, the quantum processor is believed to be scalable to several qubits. In this thesis a readout mechanism for qubits represented by single ions (Eu or Pr) in a Y2SiO5 crystal is explored. A single cerium ion, in the same crystal as the qubits, could potentially be used as an indicator ion for non-demolition quantum state detection of the qubits. Cerium has a strong transition with high fluorescence yield which makes it possible to detect single ions. A cerium ion can be controlled by a qubit via the dipole blockade effect, and fluoresce if the qubit is in state |1> but stay dark if the qubit is in state |0>. Relevant spectroscopic properties of Ce:Y2SiO5 are studied, as well as interactions between cerium ions and qubit ions. The inhomogeneous and homogeneous linewidth of the Ce:Y2SiO5 4f-5d transition is measured and fluorescence spectra for ions in site 1 and site 2 are characterized. The change in electric dipole moment as a cerium ion is brought to the excited state is measured. The static dipole interaction between a single cerium ion and a qubit ion is shown to be strong enough for efficient qubit readout. Energy transfer from cerium to qubit ions is investigated. A lower bound on the cerium-qubit distance is found in order to avoid energy transfer. Satellite lines belonging to cerium-qubit pairs are mapped out. A microscope set-up is built to detect single ions in a crystal. Single ion detection is believed to be within reach.
In this thesis, crystals of yttrium orthosilicate (Y2SiO5) that are randomly doped with another rare-earth element, such as praseodymium (Pr), europium (Eu), or cerium (Ce), are investigated with lasers locked to ultra-stable cavities using the Pound-Drever-Hall locking technique. Many of these rare-earth elements have long-lived 4f-4f transitions, hundreds of microseconds to a few milliseconds, with even longer ground hyperfine lifetimes of up to several days. The coherence properties are, to the best of the author's knowledge, the longest achieved for any material, currently with a record of six hours for the nuclear spin states of Eu3+:Y2SiO5 measured at cryogenic temperatures. Furthermore, due to natural trapping and differences in the local environments, each dopant ion experiences a slightly different crystal field, and thus an inhomogeneity in the 4f-4f transition exists between all ions in a crystal. Since the homogeneous linewidth is in the order of kHz or below, whereas the inhomogeneous profile can be several GHz wide, these materials have dense storing capabilities.This thesis explores how light interacts with such rare-earth-ion-doped crystals; how the absorption and light polarization varies during propagation; how spectral features in the inhomogeneous absorption profile can be tailored to create narrowband spectral filters; how the speed of light is slowed down significantly in such narrow transmission windows; and how that can be used to either frequency shift incoming light, control its group velocity, or temporally compress pulses. It also uses rare-earth-ions to research quantum computing, the field of using quantum mechanical effects such as superpositions and entanglements to outperform classical computers on certain specific problems. This is done by examining how two-color pulses can be used to rapidly induce coherence from an initially mixed state; how qubit-qubit interactions can be performed experimentally using ensemble qubits, which opens the door to two-qubit experiments such as the CNOT-gate and entanglements; how a scalable quantum computer might be constructed using a single ion qubit approach with a dedicated readout ion and buffer ion(s) to improve readout fidelity; and how cerium is investigated as a candidate for such a dedicated readout ion.
The work presented in this thesis was concerned with investigating the relevant spectroscopic properties of Ce ions randomly doped in an Y2SiO5 crystal at low temperatures (around 4 K), in order to develop a technique and an experimental set-up to detect the fluorescence photons emitted by a single Ce ion. The aim of the work was to determine whether a single Ce ion (referred to as the readout ion) can be used as a local probe to sense the quantum state of a neighbouring single-ion qubit via a state-selective interaction between the readout and qubit ion. More precisely, if the qubit ion is in state |1> or |0> state, the single Ce ion will, or will not, emit fluorescence photons. This single ion readout concept is a key step towards single-rare-earth-ion quantum computing, which is believed to be a promising approach for a scalable quantum computer. Rare-earth ion based quantum computing is an attractive scheme for several reasons. Firstly, the qubit coherence time can be on the timescale of a minute while the optical coherence time can be on the millisecond timescale, despite the fact that the ions are in a solid (crystal), which means that more than 10000 optical pulses could be implemented before the system decoheres. Secondly, any sub-ensemble of ions in a frequency interval equal to or larger than the homogeneous linewidth within the inhomogeneously broadened absorption line can be used as a frequency-selectively addressed qubit. The proof of principle of the qubit-qubit interaction has been previously demonstrated. Thirdly, no special material engineering is required, and the crystal is commercially available. Ways of initializing a sub-ensemble of Pr ions as a qubit in the random system, manipulating the quantum state of the ions in a controlled way, and characterizing the quantum state created are presented. In order to achieve better scalability, the idea of letting a single rare-earth ion represent a qubit was investigated. The fidelity of the single-ion readout scheme was briefly studied. The influence of the energy transfer process between two neighbouring ions on quantum computing is discussed. A readout ion should possess a number of specific spectroscopic properties. Therefore, the position and the linewidths of the zero-phonon line of Ce ions were measured using an external cavity diode laser (at 371 nm) as the excitation source. The difference in the permanent dipole moment of the ground and excited states of Ce ions was measured in a photon echo experiment on Pr ions in a Ce-Pr co-doped Y2SiO5 crystal. The last and most important task was to realize single Ce ion detection. Fluorescence of Ce ions has been detected from a crystal, where there is on average 1 ion within 4.6 \micro m3^33 interacting with the excitation laser at a time. Estimates were made of the number of ions contributing to an observed signal. A trial experiment to investigate whether the signal was emitted by a single Ce ion was carried out, but was unsuccessful. Potential reasons why the experiment failed are presented.
This thesis describes a number of coherent processes, such as quantum information processing, superradiance and electromagnetically induced transparency, which have been experimentally implemented using rare-earth-ion-doped crystals. The rare-earths are a class of elements that have in common, an atomic structure that allows for very long lifetimes as well as coherence times, both on optical transitions and on spin transitions. These ions can be naturally trapped inside host crystals, and with the phonon vibrations removed by cooling down to cryogenic temperatures (< 4 K), they can be used for a number of different quantum information processes. Most experiments were carried out using PrYSO, but also other crystal types were investigated, such as Nd:YVO4, and La2(WO4)3. The characterization of the ions were done with a variety of methods, including among others, photon echo techniques and electromagnetically induced transparency. Quantum computing is a rapidly growing field and there are still many potential candidates for its implementation. In our work we have utilized the spin states of the Pr rare-earth ion as a qubit, and demonstrated arbitrary single qubit gates, which are important pieces towards a quantum computing realization in these systems. Most of the experimental work done for the thesis was carried out using an ensemble approach, that has the advantage of giving a strong readout signal, but for future scaling to multiple qubits, single instances are more promising, which is discussed. Quantum memories are crucial components in applications such as quantum networks and long distance quantum communication. In this thesis, work has been done to investigate how quantum memories can be implemented in rare-earth crystals. In particular, there are two protocols, CRIB and AFC, which were suggested with rare-earth crystals directly in mind, and both of these require high optical depth, for maximum recall efficiency. In this thesis, implications of being in the high optical depth regime, with phenomena such as superradiance, a collective effect that could cause the stored light to be immediately reemitted, and slow light effects that come from performing the storage inside spectrally structured materials, were investigated. In order to carry out the phase-sensitive experiments, a laser system with a very narrow linewidth of ~1 kHz at 606 nm was constructed, by locking the laser to a semi-persistent spectral hole. In addition, many experiments required advanced pulse shapes, such as complex sechyp pulses or pulses obtained from optimal control theory. In order to be able to accurately create such shapes, an elaborate system using an arbitrary waveform generator and two well calibrated AOMs, controlled from a computer, was also built.
An overview of current status and prospects of the development of quantum computer hardware based on inorganic crystals doped with rare-earth ions are presented. Major parts of the experimental work in this area have been done in two places, Canberra, Australia and Lund, Sweden, and the present description follows more closely the Lund work. Techniques will be described that include optimal filtering of the initially inhomogeneously broadened profile down to well separated and narrow ensembles, as well as the use of advanced pulse-shaping in order to achieve robust arbitrary single-qubit operations with fidelities above 90%, as characterized by quantum state tomography. It is expected that full scalability of these systems will require the ability to determine the state of single rare-earth ions. It has been proposed that this can be done using special readout ions doped into the crystal and an update is given on the work to find and characterize such ions. Finally, a few aspects on possibilities for remote entanglement of ions in separate rare-earth-ion-doped crystals are considered.
Entanglement between single spins and photons is an important resource in quantum information science, e.g. in quantum networking. Rare-earth ions in dielectric crystals have emerged as a promising candidate for this task. Rare-earth ion doped solids have been used so far mostly as ensemble-based quantum memories. However, they also feature promising properties for single ion detection and manipulation, such as long-lived spins, narrow optical transitions and preservation of coherence properties when inserted in nanostructures. Because of the long lifetimes of the optical t