Construction of a series of topologically distinct
ν=2/5 fractional quantum Hall wave functions by conformal field theory
In this paper, a series of
ν=2/5 fractional quantum Hall wave functions are constructed from conformal field theory(CFT). They share the same topological properties with states constructed by Jain's composite fermion approach. Upon exact lowest Landau level(LLL) projection, some of Jain's composite fermion states would not survive if constraints on Landau level indices given in appendices of this paper are not satisfied. By contrast, states constructed from CFT always stay in LLL. These states are characterized by different multi-body relative angular momenta and topological shifts, thus belong to different topological sectors. As a by-product, in appendices we prove the necessary conditions for general $ \nu=p/(2p+1) $ composite fermion states to have non-vanishing LLL-projection.
We show that the quantum Hall wave functions for the ground states in the Jain series nu=n/(2np+1) can be exactly expressed in terms of correlation functions of local vertex operators Vn corresponding to composite fermions in the nth composite-fermion (CF) Landau level. This allows for the powerful mathematics of conformal field theory to be applied to the successful CF phenomenology. Quasiparticle and quasihole states are expressed as correlators of anyonic operators with fractional (local) charge, allowing a simple algebraic understanding of their topological properties that are not manifest in the CF wave functions. Moreover, our construction shows how the states in the nu=n/(2np+1) Jain sequence may be interpreted as condensates of quasiparticles.
It is known that a subset of fractional quantum Hall wave functions has been expressed as conformal field theory (CFT) correlators, notably the Laughlin wave function [Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 1395 (1983)] at filling factor $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕m$ (
m odd) and its quasiholes, and the Pfaffian wave function at $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕2$ and its quasiholes. We develop a general scheme for constructing composite-fermion (CF) wave functions from conformal field theory. Quasiparticles at $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕m$ are created by inserting anyonic vertex operators,
P1∕m(z), that replace a subset of the electron operators in the correlator. The one-quasiparticle wave function is identical to the corresponding CF wave function, and the two-quasiparticle wave function has correct fractional charge and statistics and is numerically almost identical to the corresponding CF wave function. We further show how to exactly represent the CF wave functions in the Jain series $\ensuremath{\nu}=s∕(2sp+1)$ [Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 199 (1989); Composite Fermions (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2007)] as the CFT correlators of a new type of fermionic vertex operators,
Vp,n(z), constructed from
n free compactified bosons; these operators provide the CFT representation of composite fermions carrying
2p flux quanta in the
nth CF Landau level. We also construct the corresponding quasiparticle and quasihole operators and argue that they have the expected fractional charge and statistics. For filling fractions
2∕5 and
3∕7, we show that the chiral CFTs that describe the bulk wave functions are identical to those given by Wen's general classification [Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 6, 1711 (1992); Adv. Phys. 44, 405 (1995)] of quantum Hall states in terms of
K matrices and
l and
t vectors, and we propose that to be generally true. Our results suggest a general procedure for constructing quasiparticle wave functions for other fractional Hall states, as well as for constructing ground states at filling fractions not contained in the principal Jain series.
It has long been known that Laughlin's wave functions, describing the fractional quantum Hall effect at filling fractions ν=1/(2k+1), can be obtained as correlation functions in conformal field theory. We show how to generalize this approach to construct explicit trial wave functions for all states in the quantum Hall hierarchy corresponding to quasiparticle (as opposed to quasihole) condensates, including the recently observed state at ν= 4/11. At the filling fractions ν= n/(2np+1) this construction exactly reproduces Jain's composite fermion wave functions. An explicit connection is made to Wen's topological classification of FQH states.
We propose to describe bulk wave functions of fractional quantum Hall states in terms of correlators of nonunitary
b/c-spin systems. These yield a promising conformal field-theory analogon of the composite fermion picture of Jain. Fractional statistics are described by twist fields which naturally appear in the
b/c-spin systems. We provide a geometrical interpretation of our approach in which bulk wave functions are seen as holomorphic functions over a ramified covering of the complex plane, where the ramification precisely resembles the fractional statistics of the quasiparticle excitations in terms of branch points on the complex plane. To extend Jain's main series, we use the concept of composite fermions pairing to spin singlets, which enjoys a natural description in terms of the particular $c=\ensuremath{-}2$
b/c-spin system as known from the Haldane-Rezayi state. In this way we derive conformal field-theory proposals for lowest Landau-level bulk wave functions for more general filling fractions. We obtain a natural classification of the experimentally confirmed filling fractions, which does not contain prominent unobserved fillings. Furthermore, our scheme fits together with classifications in terms of K matrices of effective multilayer theories leading to striking restrictions of these coupling matrices.
We show that all lowest Landau-level projected and unprojected chiral parton type fractional quantum Hall ground and edge-state trial wave functions, which take the form of products of integer quantum Hall wave functions, can be expressed as conformal field theory (CFT) correlation functions, where we can associate a chiral algebra to each parton state such that the CFT defined by the algebra is the “smallest” such CFT that can generate the corresponding ground and edge-state trial wave functions (assuming that the corresponding chiral algebra does indeed define a physically “sensible” CFT). A field-theoretic generalization of Laughlin's plasma analogy, known as generalized screening, is formulated for these states. If this holds, along with an additional assumption, we argue that the inner products of edge-state trial wave functions, for parton states where the “densest” trial wave function is unique, can be expressed as matrix elements of an exponentiated local action operator of the CFT, generalizing the result of Dubail [], which implies the equality between edge-state and entanglement level counting to state counting in the corresponding CFT. We numerically test this result in the case of the unprojected ν=2/5 composite fermion state and the bosonic ν=1ϕ22 parton state. We discuss how Read's arguments [] still apply, implying that conformal blocks of the CFT defined by the corresponding chiral algebra are valid quasihole trial wave functions, with the adiabatic braiding statistics given by the monodromy of these functions, assuming the existence of a quasiparticle trapping Hamiltonian. Generalizations of these constructions are discussed, with particular attention given to simple current constructions. It is shown that all chiral composite fermion wave functions can be expressed as CFT correlation functions without explicit symmetrization or antisymmetrization and that the ground, edge, and certain quasihole trial wave functions of the ϕnm parton states can be expressed as the conformal blocks of the U(1)⊗SU(n)m WZW models. Finally, we discuss the relation of the ϕ2k series with the Read-Rezayi series, where several examples of quasihole braiding statistics calculations are given. Published by the American Physical Society 2024