Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2006.06559 · International Journal of Quantum Information

Self-consistent tomography and measurement-device independent cryptography

I. D. Moore, S. J. van Enk

Published Jul 4, 2020• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A recurring problem in quantum mechanics is to estimate either the state of a quantum system or the measurement operator applied to it. If we wish to estimate both, then the difficulty is that the state and the measurement always appear together: to estimate the state, we must use a measurement; to estimate the measurement operator, we must use a state. The data of such quantum estimation experiments come in the form of measurement frequencies. Ideally, the measured average frequencies can be attributed to an average state and an average measurement operator. If this is not the case, we have correlated state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) errors. We extend some tests developed to detect such correlated errors to apply to a cryptographic scenario in which two parties trust their individual states but not the measurement performed on the joint state.

DOI
10.1142/s0219749920400031

Related papers

Detecting correlated errors in state-preparation-and-measurement tomography

Christopher S. Jackson, S. J. van Enk

Whereas in standard quantum-state tomography one estimates an unknown state by performing various measurements with known devices, and whereas in detector tomography one estimates the positive-operator-valued-measurement elements of a measurement device by subjecting to it various known states, we consider here the case of SPAM (state preparation and measurement) tomography where neither the states nor the measurement device are assumed known. For $d$-dimensional systems measured by $d$-outcome detectors, we find there are at most ${d}^{2}({d}^{2}\ensuremath{-}1)$ ``gauge'' parameters that can never be determined by any such experiment, irrespective of the number of unknown states and unknown devices. For the case $d=2$ we find gauge-invariant quantities that can be accessed directly experimentally and that can be used to detect and describe SPAM errors. In particular, we identify conditions whose violations detect the presence of correlations between SPAM errors. From the perspective of SPAM tomography, standard quantum-state tomography and detector tomography are protocols that fix the gauge parameters through the assumption that some set of fiducial measurements is known or that some set of fiducial states is known, respectively.

arXiv:1508.05633•Physical Review A•Oct 12, 2015•35 citations

Detecting false correlations: Uncovering a faked Bell-inequality violation

M. E. Feldman, G. K. Juul, S. J. van Enk +1 more

It is possible for two parties, Alice and Bob, to establish a secure communication link by sharing an ensemble of entangled particles, and then using these particles to generate a secret key. One way to establish that the particles are indeed entangled is to verify that they violate a Bell inequality. However, it might be the case that Bob is not trustworthy and wishes Alice to believe that their communications are secure, when in fact they are not. He can do this by managing to have prior knowledge of Alice's measurement device settings and then modifying his own settings based upon this information. In this case it is possible for shared particle states that must satisfy a Bell inequality to appear to violate this inequality, which would also make the system appear secure. When Bob modifies his measurement settings, however, he produces false correlations. Here we demonstrate experimentally that Alice can detect these false correlations, and uncover Bob's trickery, by using loop-state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) tomography. More generally, we demonstrate that loop SPAM tomography can detect false correlations (correlated errors) in a two-qubit system without needing to know anything about the prepared states or the measurements, other than the dimensions of the operators that describe them.

arXiv:1802.02526•Feb 7, 2018•0 citations

Loop state-preparation-and-measurement tomography of a two-qubit system

M. E. Feldman, G. K. Juul, S. J. van Enk +1 more

We experimentally demonstrate that loop state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) tomography is capable of detecting correlated errors in a two-qubit system. We prepare photon pairs in a state that approximates a Werner state, which may or may not be entangled. By performing measurements with multiple different detector settings, we are able to detect correlated errors between two single-qubit measurements performed in different locations. No assumptions are made concerning either the state preparations or the measurements, other than that the dimensions of the states and the positive-operator-valued measures describing the detectors are known. The only other needed information is experimentally measured expectation values, which are analyzed for self-consistency. This demonstrates that loop SPAM tomography is a useful technique for detecting errors that would degrade the performance of multiple-qubit quantum information processors.

arXiv:1806.06697•Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Jul 9, 2018•3 citations

Detecting correlated errors in twin-field quantum key distribution

B. Panchumarthi, A. Stephens, M. Beck

We experimentally demonstrate that we can detect correlated errors in a twin-field quantum key distribution (TFQKD) system by using a technique that is related to self-consistent tomography. We implement a TFQKD system based on a fiber-Sagnac loop, in which Alice and Bob encode information in the phase of weak coherent states that propagate in opposite directions around the loop. These states interfere as they exit the loop and are detected by a third party, Charlie, who reports the results of their measurements to Alice and Bob. We find that it is possible for Alice and Bob to detect correlated state-preparation and measurement errors while trusting only their own individual states, and without trusting Charlie’s measurements.

arXiv:2212.06955•Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Dec 13, 2022•0 citations

Experimental demonstration of loop state-preparation-and-measurement tomography

A. F. McCormick, S. J. van Enk, M. Beck

We have performed an experiment demonstrating that loop state-preparation-and-measurement tomography [Jackson and van Enk, Phys. Rev. A 92, 042312 (2015)] is capable of detecting correlated errors between the preparation and the measurement of a quantum system. Specifically, we have prepared pure and mixed states of single qubits encoded in the polarization of heralded individual photons. By performing measurements using multiple state preparations and multiple measurement device settings we are able to detect if there are any correlated errors between them, and we are also able to determine which state preparations are correlated with which measurements. This is accomplished by going around a ``loop'' in parameter space, which allows us to check for self-consistency. No assumptions are made concerning either the state preparations or the measurements, other than that the dimensions of the states and the positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs) describing the detector are known. In cases where no correlations are found we are able to perform quantum state tomography of the polarization qubits by using knowledge of the detector POVMs, or quantum detector tomography by using knowledge of the state preparations. Note, however, that the detection of correlated errors does not require estimating any state or measurement parameters.

arXiv:1701.06498•Physical Review A•Apr 20, 2017•10 citations

Reliable characterization of super-accurate quantum operations

Takanori Sugiyama, Shinpei Imori, Fuyuhiko Tanaka

Improving accuracy of quantum operations is an indispensable task for realizing a practical quantum computer. A reliable method for characterizing quantum operations is a useful tool towards further improvements of the accuracy. Quantum tomography and randomized benchmarking protocols are current standard methods for evaluating accuracies of quantum operations, but their estimates lack reliability because of high sensitivity to state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors or they use multiple approximations. Here we propose a self-consistent quantum tomographic method. First, we derive a sufficient condition on experiments for characterizing quantum operations except for the gauge degrees of freedom. Second, we propose a new self-consistent estimator. We mathematically prove that, when the sufficient condition is satisfied, the estimator provides estimates that are always physical and converge to the gauge-equivalence class of the quantum operations of interest at the limit of data size going to infinity. We also derive the rate of the asymptotic convergence. These results theoretically guarantee that the method makes it possible to reliably characterize accurate quantum operations.

•Jun 7, 2018•2 citations
A recurring problem in quantum mechanics is to estimate either the state of a quantum system or the measurement operator applied to it. If we wish to estimate both, then the difficulty is that the state and the measurement always appear together: to estimate the state, we must use a measurement; to estimate the measurement operator, we must use a state. The data of such quantum estimation experiments come in the form of measurement frequencies. Ideally, the measured average frequencies can be attributed to an average state and an average measurement operator. If this is not the case, we have correlated state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) errors. We extend some tests developed to detect such correlated errors to apply to a cryptographic scenario in which two parties trust their individual states but not the measurement performed on the joint state.
Whereas in standard quantum-state tomography one estimates an unknown state by performing various measurements with known devices, and whereas in detector tomography one estimates the positive-operator-valued-measurement elements of a measurement device by subjecting to it various known states, we consider here the case of SPAM (state preparation and measurement) tomography where neither the states nor the measurement device are assumed known. For ddd-dimensional systems measured by ddd-outcome detectors, we find there are at most ${d}^{2}({d}^{2}\ensuremath{-}1)$ ``gauge'' parameters that can never be determined by any such experiment, irrespective of the number of unknown states and unknown devices. For the case d=2d=2d=2 we find gauge-invariant quantities that can be accessed directly experimentally and that can be used to detect and describe SPAM errors. In particular, we identify conditions whose violations detect the presence of correlations between SPAM errors. From the perspective of SPAM tomography, standard quantum-state tomography and detector tomography are protocols that fix the gauge parameters through the assumption that some set of fiducial measurements is known or that some set of fiducial states is known, respectively.
It is possible for two parties, Alice and Bob, to establish a secure communication link by sharing an ensemble of entangled particles, and then using these particles to generate a secret key. One way to establish that the particles are indeed entangled is to verify that they violate a Bell inequality. However, it might be the case that Bob is not trustworthy and wishes Alice to believe that their communications are secure, when in fact they are not. He can do this by managing to have prior knowledge of Alice's measurement device settings and then modifying his own settings based upon this information. In this case it is possible for shared particle states that must satisfy a Bell inequality to appear to violate this inequality, which would also make the system appear secure. When Bob modifies his measurement settings, however, he produces false correlations. Here we demonstrate experimentally that Alice can detect these false correlations, and uncover Bob's trickery, by using loop-state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) tomography. More generally, we demonstrate that loop SPAM tomography can detect false correlations (correlated errors) in a two-qubit system without needing to know anything about the prepared states or the measurements, other than the dimensions of the operators that describe them.
We experimentally demonstrate that loop state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) tomography is capable of detecting correlated errors in a two-qubit system. We prepare photon pairs in a state that approximates a Werner state, which may or may not be entangled. By performing measurements with multiple different detector settings, we are able to detect correlated errors between two single-qubit measurements performed in different locations. No assumptions are made concerning either the state preparations or the measurements, other than that the dimensions of the states and the positive-operator-valued measures describing the detectors are known. The only other needed information is experimentally measured expectation values, which are analyzed for self-consistency. This demonstrates that loop SPAM tomography is a useful technique for detecting errors that would degrade the performance of multiple-qubit quantum information processors.
We experimentally demonstrate that we can detect correlated errors in a twin-field quantum key distribution (TFQKD) system by using a technique that is related to self-consistent tomography. We implement a TFQKD system based on a fiber-Sagnac loop, in which Alice and Bob encode information in the phase of weak coherent states that propagate in opposite directions around the loop. These states interfere as they exit the loop and are detected by a third party, Charlie, who reports the results of their measurements to Alice and Bob. We find that it is possible for Alice and Bob to detect correlated state-preparation and measurement errors while trusting only their own individual states, and without trusting Charlie’s measurements.
We have performed an experiment demonstrating that loop state-preparation-and-measurement tomography [Jackson and van Enk, Phys. Rev. A 92, 042312 (2015)] is capable of detecting correlated errors between the preparation and the measurement of a quantum system. Specifically, we have prepared pure and mixed states of single qubits encoded in the polarization of heralded individual photons. By performing measurements using multiple state preparations and multiple measurement device settings we are able to detect if there are any correlated errors between them, and we are also able to determine which state preparations are correlated with which measurements. This is accomplished by going around a ``loop'' in parameter space, which allows us to check for self-consistency. No assumptions are made concerning either the state preparations or the measurements, other than that the dimensions of the states and the positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs) describing the detector are known. In cases where no correlations are found we are able to perform quantum state tomography of the polarization qubits by using knowledge of the detector POVMs, or quantum detector tomography by using knowledge of the state preparations. Note, however, that the detection of correlated errors does not require estimating any state or measurement parameters.
Improving accuracy of quantum operations is an indispensable task for realizing a practical quantum computer. A reliable method for characterizing quantum operations is a useful tool towards further improvements of the accuracy. Quantum tomography and randomized benchmarking protocols are current standard methods for evaluating accuracies of quantum operations, but their estimates lack reliability because of high sensitivity to state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors or they use multiple approximations. Here we propose a self-consistent quantum tomographic method. First, we derive a sufficient condition on experiments for characterizing quantum operations except for the gauge degrees of freedom. Second, we propose a new self-consistent estimator. We mathematically prove that, when the sufficient condition is satisfied, the estimator provides estimates that are always physical and converge to the gauge-equivalence class of the quantum operations of interest at the limit of data size going to infinity. We also derive the rate of the asymptotic convergence. These results theoretically guarantee that the method makes it possible to reliably characterize accurate quantum operations.