Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2005.11340 · Physical Review A

Impossibility of memory in hidden-signaling models for quantum correlations

Ignacio Perito, Guido Bellomo, Daniel Galicer, Santiago Daniel Figueira, Augusto J. Roncaglia, Ariel Bendersky

Published Nov 5, 2020• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a toy model for nonlocal quantum correlations in which nature resorts to some form of hidden signaling (i.e., signaling between boxes but not available to the users) to generate correlations. We show that if such a model also had memory, the parties would be able to exploit the hidden signaling and use it to send a message, achieving faster-than-light communication. Given that memory is a resource easily available for any physical system, our results add evidence against hidden signaling as the mechanism behind nature's nonlocal behavior.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.052207

Related papers

Nonsignaling Deterministic Models for Nonlocal Correlations have to be Uncomputable

Ariel Bendersky, Gabriel Senno, Gonzalo de la Torre +2 more

Quantum mechanics postulates random outcomes. However, a model making the same output predictions but in a deterministic manner would be, in principle, experimentally indistinguishable from quantum theory. In this work we consider such models in the context of nonlocality on a device-independent scenario. That is, we study pairs of nonlocal boxes that produce their outputs deterministically. It is known that, for these boxes to be nonlocal, at least one of the boxes' outputs has to depend on the other party's input via some kind of hidden signaling. We prove that, if the deterministic mechanism is also algorithmic, there is a protocol that, with the sole knowledge of any upper bound on the time complexity of such an algorithm, extracts that hidden signaling and uses it for the communication of information.

arXiv:1606.08403•Physical Review Letters•Mar 28, 2017•19 citations

Bell scenarios with communication

J B Brask, R Chaves

Abstract Classical and quantum physics provide fundamentally different predictions about experiments with separate observers that do not communicate, a phenomenon known as quantum nonlocality. This insight is a key element of our present understanding of quantum physics, and also enables a number of information processing protocols with security beyond what is classically attainable. Relaxing the pivotal assumption of no communication leads to new insights into the nature quantum correlations, and may enable new applications where security can be established under less strict assumptions. Here, we study such relaxations where different forms of communication are allowed. We consider communication of inputs, outputs, and of a message between the parties. Using several measures, we study how much communication is required for classical models to reproduce quantum or general no-signalling correlations, as well as how quantum models can be augmented with classical communication to reproduce no-signalling correlations.

arXiv:1607.08182•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 10, 2017•38 citations

Photonic Simulation of Beyond-Quantum Nonlocal Correlations (e.g. Popescu-Rohrlich Box) with Non-Signaling Quantum Resources

Shukla, Kunal, Anirudh Verma, Kanad Sengupta +3 more

Bell nonlocality exemplifies the most profound departure of quantum theory from classical realism. Yet, the extent of nonlocality in quantum theory is intrinsically bounded, falling short of the correlations permitted by the relativistic causality (the no-signaling) principle. A paradigmatic example is the Popescu-Rohrlich correlation: two distant parties sharing arbitrary entanglement cannot achieve this correlation, though it can be simulated with classical communication between them. Here we show how such post-quantum correlations can instead be simulated using intrinsically non-signaling physical resources, and implement the proposed scheme using a quantum circuit on a four-qubit photonic platform. Unlike the conventional approaches, our method exploits dynamical correlations between distinct physical systems, with intrinsic randomness suppressing any signaling capacity. This enables the realization of post-quantum correlations both with and without entanglement. We also analyze how the simulation scheme extends to beyond quantum nonlocal correlations in multipartite systems. Our experimental demonstration using a photonic system establishes a versatile framework for exploring post-quantum correlations in both foundational settings and as a resource for computation and security applications.

arXiv:2509.26271•Sep 30, 2025•0 citations

Nonlocal correlations as an information-theoretic resource

Jonathan Barrett, Noah Linden, Serge Massar +3 more

It is well known that measurements performed on spatially separated entangled quantum systems can give rise to correlations that are nonlocal, in the sense that a Bell inequality is violated. They cannot, however, be used for superluminal signaling. It is also known that it is possible to write down sets of ``superquantum'' correlations that are more nonlocal than is allowed by quantum mechanics, yet are still nonsignaling. Viewed as an information-theoretic resource, superquantum correlations are very powerful at reducing the amount of communication needed for distributed computational tasks. An intriguing question is why quantum mechanics does not allow these more powerful correlations. We aim to shed light on the range of quantum possibilities by placing them within a wider context. With this in mind, we investigate the set of correlations that are constrained only by the no-signaling principle. These correlations form a polytope, which contains the quantum correlations as a (proper) subset. We determine the vertices of the no-signaling polytope in the case that two observers each choose from two possible measurements with $d$ outcomes. We then consider how interconversions between different sorts of correlations may be achieved. Finally, we consider some multipartite examples.

arXiv:quant-ph/0404097•Physical Review A•Feb 2, 2005•627 citations

Limit on Nonlocality in Any World in Which Communication Complexity Is Not Trivial

Gilles Brassard, Harry Buhrman, Noah Linden +3 more

Bell proved that quantum entanglement enables two spacelike separated parties to exhibit classically impossible correlations. Even though these correlations are stronger than anything classically achievable, they cannot be harnessed to make instantaneous (faster than light) communication possible. Yet, Popescu and Rohrlich have shown that even stronger correlations can be defined, under which instantaneous communication remains impossible. This raises the question: Why are the correlations achievable by quantum mechanics not maximal among those that preserve causality? We give a partial answer to this question by showing that slightly stronger correlations would result in a world in which communication complexity becomes trivial.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508042•Physical Review Letters•Jun 27, 2006•409 citations

Superluminal hidden communication as the underlying mechanism for quantum correlations: constraining models

Valerio Scarani, Nicolas Gisin

Since Bell's theorem, it is known that quantum correlations cannot be described by local variables (LV) alone: if one does not want to abandon classical mechanisms for correlations, a superluminal form of communication among the particles must be postulated. A natural question is whether such a postulate would imply the possibility of superluminal signaling. Here we show that the assumption of finite-speed superluminal communication indeed leads to signaling when no LV are present, and more generally when only LV derivable from quantum statistics are allowed. When the most general LV are allowed, we prove in a specific case that the model can be made again consistent with relativity, but the question remains open in general.

arXiv:quant-ph/0410025•Brazilian Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 2005•41 citations
We consider a toy model for nonlocal quantum correlations in which nature resorts to some form of hidden signaling (i.e., signaling between boxes but not available to the users) to generate correlations. We show that if such a model also had memory, the parties would be able to exploit the hidden signaling and use it to send a message, achieving faster-than-light communication. Given that memory is a resource easily available for any physical system, our results add evidence against hidden signaling as the mechanism behind nature's nonlocal behavior.
Quantum mechanics postulates random outcomes. However, a model making the same output predictions but in a deterministic manner would be, in principle, experimentally indistinguishable from quantum theory. In this work we consider such models in the context of nonlocality on a device-independent scenario. That is, we study pairs of nonlocal boxes that produce their outputs deterministically. It is known that, for these boxes to be nonlocal, at least one of the boxes' outputs has to depend on the other party's input via some kind of hidden signaling. We prove that, if the deterministic mechanism is also algorithmic, there is a protocol that, with the sole knowledge of any upper bound on the time complexity of such an algorithm, extracts that hidden signaling and uses it for the communication of information.
Abstract Classical and quantum physics provide fundamentally different predictions about experiments with separate observers that do not communicate, a phenomenon known as quantum nonlocality. This insight is a key element of our present understanding of quantum physics, and also enables a number of information processing protocols with security beyond what is classically attainable. Relaxing the pivotal assumption of no communication leads to new insights into the nature quantum correlations, and may enable new applications where security can be established under less strict assumptions. Here, we study such relaxations where different forms of communication are allowed. We consider communication of inputs, outputs, and of a message between the parties. Using several measures, we study how much communication is required for classical models to reproduce quantum or general no-signalling correlations, as well as how quantum models can be augmented with classical communication to reproduce no-signalling correlations.
Bell nonlocality exemplifies the most profound departure of quantum theory from classical realism. Yet, the extent of nonlocality in quantum theory is intrinsically bounded, falling short of the correlations permitted by the relativistic causality (the no-signaling) principle. A paradigmatic example is the Popescu-Rohrlich correlation: two distant parties sharing arbitrary entanglement cannot achieve this correlation, though it can be simulated with classical communication between them. Here we show how such post-quantum correlations can instead be simulated using intrinsically non-signaling physical resources, and implement the proposed scheme using a quantum circuit on a four-qubit photonic platform. Unlike the conventional approaches, our method exploits dynamical correlations between distinct physical systems, with intrinsic randomness suppressing any signaling capacity. This enables the realization of post-quantum correlations both with and without entanglement. We also analyze how the simulation scheme extends to beyond quantum nonlocal correlations in multipartite systems. Our experimental demonstration using a photonic system establishes a versatile framework for exploring post-quantum correlations in both foundational settings and as a resource for computation and security applications.
It is well known that measurements performed on spatially separated entangled quantum systems can give rise to correlations that are nonlocal, in the sense that a Bell inequality is violated. They cannot, however, be used for superluminal signaling. It is also known that it is possible to write down sets of ``superquantum'' correlations that are more nonlocal than is allowed by quantum mechanics, yet are still nonsignaling. Viewed as an information-theoretic resource, superquantum correlations are very powerful at reducing the amount of communication needed for distributed computational tasks. An intriguing question is why quantum mechanics does not allow these more powerful correlations. We aim to shed light on the range of quantum possibilities by placing them within a wider context. With this in mind, we investigate the set of correlations that are constrained only by the no-signaling principle. These correlations form a polytope, which contains the quantum correlations as a (proper) subset. We determine the vertices of the no-signaling polytope in the case that two observers each choose from two possible measurements with ddd outcomes. We then consider how interconversions between different sorts of correlations may be achieved. Finally, we consider some multipartite examples.
Bell proved that quantum entanglement enables two spacelike separated parties to exhibit classically impossible correlations. Even though these correlations are stronger than anything classically achievable, they cannot be harnessed to make instantaneous (faster than light) communication possible. Yet, Popescu and Rohrlich have shown that even stronger correlations can be defined, under which instantaneous communication remains impossible. This raises the question: Why are the correlations achievable by quantum mechanics not maximal among those that preserve causality? We give a partial answer to this question by showing that slightly stronger correlations would result in a world in which communication complexity becomes trivial.
Since Bell's theorem, it is known that quantum correlations cannot be described by local variables (LV) alone: if one does not want to abandon classical mechanisms for correlations, a superluminal form of communication among the particles must be postulated. A natural question is whether such a postulate would imply the possibility of superluminal signaling. Here we show that the assumption of finite-speed superluminal communication indeed leads to signaling when no LV are present, and more generally when only LV derivable from quantum statistics are allowed. When the most general LV are allowed, we prove in a specific case that the model can be made again consistent with relativity, but the question remains open in general.