arXiv:2005.10423 · Physical Review Letters

Direct Characterization of Quantum Measurements Using Weak Values

Liang Xu, Huichao Xu, Tao Jiang, Feixiang Xu, Kaimin Zheng, Ben Wang, Aonan Zhang, Lijian Zhang

Published Oct 28, 2021• 22 citations

Abstract

The time-symmetric formalism endows the weak measurement and its outcome, the weak value, with many unique features. In particular, it allows a direct tomography of quantum states without resorting to complicated reconstruction algorithms and provides an operational meaning to wave functions and density matrices. Here, we propose and experimentally demonstrate the direct tomography of a measurement apparatus by taking the backward direction of weak measurement formalism. Our protocol works rigorously with the arbitrary measurement strength, which offers improved accuracy and precision. The precision can be further improved by taking into account the completeness condition of the measurement operators, which also ensures the feasibility of our protocol for the characterization of the arbitrary quantum measurement. Our work provides new insight on the symmetry between quantum states and measurements, as well as an efficient method to characterize a measurement apparatus.

DOI: 10.1103/physrevlett.127.180401

Related papers

Strong Measurements Give a Better Direct Measurement of the Quantum Wave Function

Giuseppe Vallone, Daniele Dequal

Weak measurements have thus far been considered instrumental in the so-called direct measurement of the quantum wave function [4J. S. Lundeen, Nature (London) 474, 188 (2011).]. Here we show that a direct measurement of the wave function can be obtained by using measurements of arbitrary strength. In particular, in the case of strong measurements, i.e., those in which the coupling between the system and the measuring apparatus is maximum, we compared the precision and the accuracy of the two methods, by showing that strong measurements outperform weak measurements in both for arbitrary quantum states in most cases. We also give the exact expression of the difference between the original and reconstructed wave function obtained by the weak measurement approach; this will allow one to define the range of applicability of such a method.

arXiv:1504.06551Physical Review LettersJan 29, 201698 citations

Direct measurement of nonlocal quantum states without approximation

Gang 冈 Yang 杨, Ran 然 Yang 杨, Yan-Xiao Gong +1 more

Efficient acquiring information from a quantum state is important for research in fundamental quantum physics and quantum information applications. Instead of using standard quantum state tomography method with reconstruction algorithm, weak values were proposed to directly measure density matrix elements of quantum state. Recently, similar to the concept of weak value, modular values were introduced to extend the direct measurement scheme to nonlocal quantum wavefunction. However, this method still involves approximations, which leads to inherent low precision. Here, we propose a new scheme which enables direct measurement for ideal value of the nonlocal density matrix element without taking approximations. Our scheme allows more accurate characterization of nonlocal quantum states, and therefore has greater advantages in practical measurement scenarios.

Chinese Physics BSep 1, 20233 citations

Direct Reconstruction of the Quantum Density Matrix by Strong Measurements

Luca Calderaro, Giulio Foletto, Daniele Dequal +2 more

New techniques based on weak measurements have recently been introduced to the field of quantum state reconstruction. Some of them allow the direct measurement of each matrix element of an unknown density operator and need only O(d) different operations, compared to d^{2} linearly independent projectors in the case of standard quantum state tomography, for the reconstruction of an arbitrary mixed state. However, due to the weakness of these couplings, these protocols are approximated and prone to large statistical errors. We propose a method which is similar to the weak measurement protocols but works regardless of the coupling strength: our protocol is not approximated and thus improves the accuracy and precision of the results with respect to weak measurement schemes. We experimentally apply it to the polarization state of single photons and compare the results to those of preexisting methods for different values of the coupling strength. Our results show that our method outperforms previous proposals in terms of accuracy and statistical errors.

arXiv:1803.10703Physical Review LettersDec 7, 201856 citations

Ultimate precision of direct tomography of wave functions

Xuan-Hoai Thi Nguyen, Mahn‐Soo Choi

Abstract In contrast to the standard quantum state tomography, the direct tomography seeks a direct access to the complex values of the wave function at particular positions. Originally put forward as a special case of weak measurement, it has been extended to arbitrary measurement setup. We generalize the idea of “quantum metrology,” where a real-valued phase is estimated, to the estimation of complex-valued phase. We show that it enables to identify the optimal measurements and investigate the fundamental precision limit of the direct tomography. We propose a few experimentally feasible examples of direct tomography schemes and, based on the complex phase estimation formalism, demonstrate that direct tomography can reach the Heisenberg limit.

arXiv:1911.07674Quantum Information ProcessingJul 1, 20211 citation

Efficient Direct Measurement of Arbitrary Quantum Systems via Weak Measurement

Changliang Ren, Ya Wang, Jiangfeng Du

Efficient, reliable determination of a system's state is at the heart of quantum science. Directly measuring any desired density-matrix elements is a unique challenge for both theorists and experimentalists, as standard methods have always suffered from the rapid increase in complexity of measurements and reconstruction algorithms. This study presents an efficient scheme for directly measuring arbitrary density matrices with only one strong measurement, or a weak measurement, of each qudit. This method is important for characterizing large-scale quantum systems, and the technology that will be derived from it will be easy to expand and integrate, for example, on a quantum chip.

Physical Review AppliedJul 24, 201914 citations

Unified Framework for Direct Characterization of Kraus Operators, Observables, Density Matrices, and Weak Values Without Weak Interaction

Sahil Sahil, S Sohail

Generalized quantum measurements, described by positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), are essential for modeling realistic processes in open quantum systems. While quantum process tomography can fully characterize a POVM, it is resource-intensive and impractical when only specific POVM elements or matrix elements of a particular POVM element are of interest. Direct quantum measurement tomography offers a more efficient alternative but typically relies on weak interactions and complex structures of the system, environment, and probe as the dimension of the system increases, limiting its precision and scalability. Furthermore, characterizing a POVM element alone is insufficient to determine the underlying physical mechanism, as multiple Kraus operators can yield the same measurement statistics. In this work, we present a unified framework for the direct characterization of individual matrix elements of Kraus operators associated with specific POVM elements and arbitrary input states without requiring weak interaction, complex structures of the system-environment-probe or full process and state tomography. This framework naturally extends to projective measurements, enabling direct observable tomography, and to the characterization of unitary operations. Our method also captures modular and weak values of observables and Kraus operators, without invoking weak interaction approximations. We demonstrate potential implementations in optical systems, highlighting the experimental feasibility of our approach.

arXiv:2510.07789Oct 8, 20250 citations