Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2005.07485 · Physical Review Research

Superfluid vortices in four spatial dimensions

Ben McCanna, Hannah M. Price

Published May 10, 2021• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum vortices in superfluids have been an important research area for many decades. Naturally, research on this topic has focused on two and three-dimensional superfluids, in which vortex cores form points and lines, respectively. Very recently, however, there has been growing interest in the quantum simulation of systems with four spatial dimensions; this raises the question of how vortices would behave in a higher-dimensional superfluid. In this paper, we begin to establish the phenomenology of vortices in 4D superfluids under rotation, where the vortex core can form a plane. In 4D, the most generic type of rotation is a "double rotation" with two angles (or frequencies). We show, by solving the Gross-Pitaesvkii equation, that the simplest case of equal-frequency double rotation can stabilise a pair of vortex planes intersecting at a point. This opens up a wide number of future research topics, including unequal-frequency double rotations; the stability and reconnection dynamics of intersecting vortex surfaces; and the possibility of closed vortex surfaces.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.3.023105

Related papers

Curved vortex surfaces in four-dimensional superfluids. I. Unequal-frequency double rotations

Ben McCanna, Hannah M. Price

The study of superfluid quantum vortices has long been an important area of research, with previous work naturally focusing on two-dimensional and three-dimensional systems, where rotation stabilizes point vortices and line vortices respectively. Interestingly, this physics generalizes for a hypothetical four-dimensional (4D) superfluid to include vortex planes, which can have a much richer phenomenology. In this paper we study the possibility of skewed and curved vortex planes, which have no direct analog in lower dimensions. By analytically and numerically studying the 4D Gross-Pitaevskii equation, we show that such vortex surfaces can be stabilized and favored by double rotation with unequal rotation frequencies. Our work raises open questions for further research into the physics of these vortex surfaces and suggests interesting future extensions to tilted vortex surfaces under equal-frequency double rotation and to more realistic 4D models. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2309.08015•Physical Review A•Jul 25, 2024•3 citations

Curved vortex surfaces in four-dimensional superfluids. II. Equal-frequency double rotations

Ben McCanna, Hannah M. Price

As is well known, two-dimensional and three-dimensional superfluids under rotation can support topological excitations such as quantized point vortices and line vortices, respectively. Recently, we have studied how, in a hypothetical four-dimensional (4D) superfluid, such excitations can be generalized to vortex planes and surfaces. In this paper we continue our analysis of skewed and curved vortex surfaces based on the 4D Gross-Pitaevskii equation and show that certain types of such states can be stabilized by equal-frequency double rotations for suitable parameters. This work extends the rich phenomenology of vortex surfaces in four dimensions and raises interesting questions about vortex reconnections and the competition between various vortex structures which have no direct analog in lower dimensions. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2309.08016•Physical Review A•Jul 25, 2024•3 citations

Interactions and reconnections of four-dimensional quantum vortices

H. A. J. Middleton-Spencer, Ben McCanna, Davide Proment +1 more

Interactions and reconnections of vortices are fundamental in many areas of physics, including classical and quantum fluids where they are central to understanding phenomena such as turbulence. In three-dimensional (3D) superfluids, quantum vortices are one-dimensional filaments that can intersect, reconnect, and recoil with irreversible dynamics described by near-universal scaling laws. We explore quantum-vortex reconnections in a four-dimensional superfluid, where a vortex is a two-dimensional surface. Using real-time numerical simulations, we find much richer behavior than in 3D, including stable intersecting vortex surfaces which do not reconnect, and unusual vortex reconnections which occur without significant energy dissipation, which may indicate quasireversible dynamics. Our work raises many interesting questions about vortex physics in extradimensional systems and may be further extended to look at vortex dynamics and turbulence in higher-dimensional spaces.

arXiv:2411.07943•Physical Review Fluids•Jul 13, 2026•0 citations

Non-equilibrium Dynamics and Universality of 4D Quantum Vortices and Turbulence

Wei-Can Yang

The study of quantum vortices provides critical insights into non-equilibrium dynamics across diverse physical systems. While previous research has focused on point-like vortices in two dimensions and line-like vortices in three dimensions, quantum vortices in four spatial dimensions are expected to take the form of extended vortex surfaces, thereby fundamentally enriching dynamics. Here, we conduct a comprehensive numerical study of 4D quantum vortices and turbulence. Using a special visualization method, we discovered the decay of topological numbers that does not exist in low dimensions, as well as the high-dimensional counterpart of the vortex reconnection process. We further explore quench dynamics across phase transitions in four dimensions and verify the applicability of the higher-dimensional Kibble-Zurek mechanism. Our simulations provide numerical evidence of 4D quantum turbulence, characterized by universal power-law behavior. These findings reveal universal principles governing topological defects in higher dimensions, offering insights for future experimental realizations using synthetic dimensions.

arXiv:2504.04409•Apr 6, 2025•0 citations

Dynamics of vortex cluster crystallisation and single-vortex pinning in two-dimensional superfluids

Oliver R. Stockdale

In this thesis, we analytically and numerically study two different scenarios of vortex dynamics in a two-dimensional superfluid. The first system we explore is an expanding cluster of like-sign vortices, which recently suggested it could explain observations in a superfluid optomechanics experiment. We employ a recent theoretical model that approximates large collections of vortices as a fluid and present an analytic solution for its dynamics. Analysis suggests that as a cluster expands due to thermal friction, it forms a Rankine vortex (i.e., a top-hat distribution) that expands self-similarly in time regardless of initial vorticity distribution. Numerical simulations of point vortices confirm this universal expanding regime and further demonstrates vortex lattice formation that goes beyond the vortex fluid theory. We analyse correlations that emerge in the resulting lattices and observe decaying disorder as the cluster expands. Furthermore, we analyse experimental data from a quasi-two-dimensional 87Rb Bose-Einstein condensate, which supports the vortex fluid theory’s predictions.The second scenario considers the dynamics of a scattering event where a single quantum vortex interacts with a uniform, circular pinning potential in a steady two-dimensional superfluid flow. We first develop an approximate hydrodynamical model to understand the interaction between the vortex and the pinning potential in the conservative regime and find it is in good agreement with the mean-field Gross-Pitaevskii equation in the low-velocity limit. We further solve the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for higher background velocities to study how the vortex moves around pinning sites, interacts with it, and ultimately becomes pinned. We uncover four different regimes of vortex pinning, each marked with a characteristic emission of sound energy. Finally, we study how vortices become unpinned from a pinning site, revealing large vortex dipoles form to stabilise the system.Our work in this thesis takes significant steps towards advancing knowledge of both the collective dynamics of vortices and their individual interaction with defects upon surface substrates. Our numerical and analytical results opens up new avenues of exploration be it further understanding dissipation mechanisms in two-dimensional superfluids, or elucidating the nature of vortex pinning in systems such as neutron stars.

•Mar 1, 2021•0 citations

Dynamics of Quantised Vortices in Superfluids

Edouard B Sonin

A comprehensive overview of the basic principles of vortex dynamics in superfluids, this book addresses the problems of vortex dynamics in all three superfluids available in laboratories (4He, 3He, and BEC of cold atoms) alongside discussions of the elasticity of vortices, forces on vortices, and vortex mass. Beginning with a summary of classical hydrodynamics, the book guides the reader through examinations of vortex dynamics from large scales to the microscopic scale. Topics such as vortex arrays in rotating superfluids, bound states in vortex cores and interaction of vortices with quasiparticles are discussed. The final chapter of the book considers implications of vortex dynamics to superfluid turbulence using simple scaling and symmetry arguments. Written from a unified point of view that avoids complicated mathematical approaches, this text is ideal for students and researchers working with vortex dynamics in superfluids, superconductors, magnetically ordered materials, neutron stars and cosmological models.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 31, 2015•71 citations
Quantum vortices in superfluids have been an important research area for many decades. Naturally, research on this topic has focused on two and three-dimensional superfluids, in which vortex cores form points and lines, respectively. Very recently, however, there has been growing interest in the quantum simulation of systems with four spatial dimensions; this raises the question of how vortices would behave in a higher-dimensional superfluid. In this paper, we begin to establish the phenomenology of vortices in 4D superfluids under rotation, where the vortex core can form a plane. In 4D, the most generic type of rotation is a "double rotation" with two angles (or frequencies). We show, by solving the Gross-Pitaesvkii equation, that the simplest case of equal-frequency double rotation can stabilise a pair of vortex planes intersecting at a point. This opens up a wide number of future research topics, including unequal-frequency double rotations; the stability and reconnection dynamics of intersecting vortex surfaces; and the possibility of closed vortex surfaces.
The study of superfluid quantum vortices has long been an important area of research, with previous work naturally focusing on two-dimensional and three-dimensional systems, where rotation stabilizes point vortices and line vortices respectively. Interestingly, this physics generalizes for a hypothetical four-dimensional (4D) superfluid to include vortex planes, which can have a much richer phenomenology. In this paper we study the possibility of skewed and curved vortex planes, which have no direct analog in lower dimensions. By analytically and numerically studying the 4D Gross-Pitaevskii equation, we show that such vortex surfaces can be stabilized and favored by double rotation with unequal rotation frequencies. Our work raises open questions for further research into the physics of these vortex surfaces and suggests interesting future extensions to tilted vortex surfaces under equal-frequency double rotation and to more realistic 4D models. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
As is well known, two-dimensional and three-dimensional superfluids under rotation can support topological excitations such as quantized point vortices and line vortices, respectively. Recently, we have studied how, in a hypothetical four-dimensional (4D) superfluid, such excitations can be generalized to vortex planes and surfaces. In this paper we continue our analysis of skewed and curved vortex surfaces based on the 4D Gross-Pitaevskii equation and show that certain types of such states can be stabilized by equal-frequency double rotations for suitable parameters. This work extends the rich phenomenology of vortex surfaces in four dimensions and raises interesting questions about vortex reconnections and the competition between various vortex structures which have no direct analog in lower dimensions. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Interactions and reconnections of vortices are fundamental in many areas of physics, including classical and quantum fluids where they are central to understanding phenomena such as turbulence. In three-dimensional (3D) superfluids, quantum vortices are one-dimensional filaments that can intersect, reconnect, and recoil with irreversible dynamics described by near-universal scaling laws. We explore quantum-vortex reconnections in a four-dimensional superfluid, where a vortex is a two-dimensional surface. Using real-time numerical simulations, we find much richer behavior than in 3D, including stable intersecting vortex surfaces which do not reconnect, and unusual vortex reconnections which occur without significant energy dissipation, which may indicate quasireversible dynamics. Our work raises many interesting questions about vortex physics in extradimensional systems and may be further extended to look at vortex dynamics and turbulence in higher-dimensional spaces.
The study of quantum vortices provides critical insights into non-equilibrium dynamics across diverse physical systems. While previous research has focused on point-like vortices in two dimensions and line-like vortices in three dimensions, quantum vortices in four spatial dimensions are expected to take the form of extended vortex surfaces, thereby fundamentally enriching dynamics. Here, we conduct a comprehensive numerical study of 4D quantum vortices and turbulence. Using a special visualization method, we discovered the decay of topological numbers that does not exist in low dimensions, as well as the high-dimensional counterpart of the vortex reconnection process. We further explore quench dynamics across phase transitions in four dimensions and verify the applicability of the higher-dimensional Kibble-Zurek mechanism. Our simulations provide numerical evidence of 4D quantum turbulence, characterized by universal power-law behavior. These findings reveal universal principles governing topological defects in higher dimensions, offering insights for future experimental realizations using synthetic dimensions.
In this thesis, we analytically and numerically study two different scenarios of vortex dynamics in a two-dimensional superfluid. The first system we explore is an expanding cluster of like-sign vortices, which recently suggested it could explain observations in a superfluid optomechanics experiment. We employ a recent theoretical model that approximates large collections of vortices as a fluid and present an analytic solution for its dynamics. Analysis suggests that as a cluster expands due to thermal friction, it forms a Rankine vortex (i.e., a top-hat distribution) that expands self-similarly in time regardless of initial vorticity distribution. Numerical simulations of point vortices confirm this universal expanding regime and further demonstrates vortex lattice formation that goes beyond the vortex fluid theory. We analyse correlations that emerge in the resulting lattices and observe decaying disorder as the cluster expands. Furthermore, we analyse experimental data from a quasi-two-dimensional 87Rb Bose-Einstein condensate, which supports the vortex fluid theory’s predictions.The second scenario considers the dynamics of a scattering event where a single quantum vortex interacts with a uniform, circular pinning potential in a steady two-dimensional superfluid flow. We first develop an approximate hydrodynamical model to understand the interaction between the vortex and the pinning potential in the conservative regime and find it is in good agreement with the mean-field Gross-Pitaevskii equation in the low-velocity limit. We further solve the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for higher background velocities to study how the vortex moves around pinning sites, interacts with it, and ultimately becomes pinned. We uncover four different regimes of vortex pinning, each marked with a characteristic emission of sound energy. Finally, we study how vortices become unpinned from a pinning site, revealing large vortex dipoles form to stabilise the system.Our work in this thesis takes significant steps towards advancing knowledge of both the collective dynamics of vortices and their individual interaction with defects upon surface substrates. Our numerical and analytical results opens up new avenues of exploration be it further understanding dissipation mechanisms in two-dimensional superfluids, or elucidating the nature of vortex pinning in systems such as neutron stars.
A comprehensive overview of the basic principles of vortex dynamics in superfluids, this book addresses the problems of vortex dynamics in all three superfluids available in laboratories (4He, 3He, and BEC of cold atoms) alongside discussions of the elasticity of vortices, forces on vortices, and vortex mass. Beginning with a summary of classical hydrodynamics, the book guides the reader through examinations of vortex dynamics from large scales to the microscopic scale. Topics such as vortex arrays in rotating superfluids, bound states in vortex cores and interaction of vortices with quasiparticles are discussed. The final chapter of the book considers implications of vortex dynamics to superfluid turbulence using simple scaling and symmetry arguments. Written from a unified point of view that avoids complicated mathematical approaches, this text is ideal for students and researchers working with vortex dynamics in superfluids, superconductors, magnetically ordered materials, neutron stars and cosmological models.