Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2004.08162 · Physical Review Letters

Benchmarking a High-Fidelity Mixed-Species Entangling Gate

A. C. Hughes, Vera M. Schäfer, K. Thirumalai, D. P. Nadlinger, S. R. Woodrow, D. M. Lucas, Christopher J. Ballance

Published Aug 18, 2020• 52 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We implement a two-qubit logic gate between a ^{43}Ca^{+} hyperfine qubit and a ^{88}Sr^{+} Zeeman qubit. For this pair of ion species, the S-P optical transitions are close enough that a single laser of wavelength 402 nm can be used to drive the gate but sufficiently well separated to give good spectral isolation and low photon scattering errors. We characterize the gate by full randomized benchmarking, gate set tomography, and Bell state analysis. The latter method gives a fidelity of 99.8(1)%, comparable to that of the best same-species gates and consistent with known sources of error.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.125.080504

Related papers

High-fidelity mixed species entanglement of trapped ions

K. Thirumalai

Harnessing quantum mechanics to solve problems intractable on classical computers is one of the foremost goals of applied physics. Trapped ions make an excellent physical platform for such a quantum computer, as they have demonstrated unparalleled qubit operation fidelities and memory times, but significant challenges remain in scaling up these systems. A promising scalable architecture is a photonically connected network of mixed element trapped ion nodes, each containing a few ions of two species. Poor quality remote entanglement links between nodes can be tolerated, if entanglement between ions in the same node can be achieved with high fidelity. While local gates have been repeatedly demonstrated between ions of the same species, the fidelity of mixed element quantum gates have not previously surpassed the fault tolerant threshold, above which errors can in principle be corrected. In this thesis we demonstrate an entangling operation between 43Ca+, useful for its long lived qubits, and 88Sr+, well suited for remote entanglement, using a novel mechanism requiring only one laser to manipulate both species. This relatively simple scheme, which is independent of either qubit frequency, allows us to achieve Bell state fidelities of F = 99.8(1)%. We assess the operation of the gate further with state and process tomography, which achieve Bell state fidelity F = 98.1% and average gate fidelity F̅ = 99.05(6)% respectively, though they are hampered by experimental drifts during the long data collection. Finally, we use interleaved randomised benchmarking to get the best estimate of our gate errors, finding an average gate fidelity of F̅ = 99.62(3)% for a sequence of 60 interleaved gates. Along with a demonstration of entanglement between two 88Sr+ ions, achieved with fidelity F = 95.9(4)%, this work paves the way towards demonstrating an elementary mixed species quantum network in future experiments.

•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations

High-Fidelity Bell-State Preparation with Ca + 40 Optical Qubits

Craig R. Clark, Holly N. Tinkey, Brian C. Sawyer +10 more

Entanglement generation in trapped-ion systems has relied thus far on two distinct but related geometric phase gate techniques: Mølmer-Sørensen and light-shift gates. We recently proposed a variant of the light-shift scheme where the qubit levels are separated by an optical frequency [B. C. Sawyer and K. R. Brown, Phys. Rev. A 103, 022427 (2021)PLRAAN2469-992610.1103/PhysRevA.103.022427]. Here we report an experimental demonstration of this entangling gate using a pair of ^{40}Ca^{+} ions in a cryogenic surface-electrode ion trap and a commercial, high-power, 532 nm Nd:YAG laser. Generating a Bell state in 35 μs, we directly measure an infidelity of 6(3)×10^{-4} without subtraction of experimental errors. The 532 nm gate laser wavelength suppresses intrinsic photon scattering error to ∼1×10^{-5}.

arXiv:2105.05828•Physical Review Letters•Sep 24, 2021•165 citations

Trapped Ion Qubit Gates and Entanglement Driven by an Integrated Photonic Laser

Chris Caron, Zhenyu Wei, Andrei Isichenko +8 more

Trapped ions are a leading technology for quantum computing, but their reliance on bespoke tabletop laser and optical systems remains a major obstacle to scaling and robustness. Integrated silicon nitride lasers, compatible with future monolithic integration with surface electrode ion traps, have recently demonstrated frequency-selective qubit state preparation and measurement as well as interrogation of an optical clock transition. However, coherent qubit gates impose even more stringent requirements on laser phase noise, and their implementation with integrated laser sources has remained an outstanding challenge. Here, we use a visible-wavelength integrated Brillouin laser stabilized to an integrated coil resonator to drive coherent single- and two-qubit gates with \Sr optical qubits. We measure an average single-qubit fidelity of $99.61\%\pm 0.03\%$ per Clifford gate with randomized benchmarking and use a two-qubit Mølmer-Sørensen interaction to generate an entangled Bell state with a fidelity of $92.35\% \pm 1.50\%$. The qubit exhibits a bare Ramsey coherence time of $659 \pm 9~μ$s, more than a tenfold improvement over our previous implementation, which extends to $1.750 \pm 0.033$~ms with an echo. These results demonstrate, for the first time, that integrated visible-wavelength narrow-linewidth photonic lasers can meet the phase-noise requirements for coherent quantum logic with trapped ion optical qubits, providing a path for scalable optical systems integrated within trapped ion quantum processors.

quant-pharXiv:2609.07708•Sep 8, 2026•0 citations

High-Fidelity Entangling Gates with Trapped-Ions

Ting Rei Tan

Quantum entangling logic gates are key ingredients for the implementation of a quantum information processing device. In this thesis, we focus on experimental implementations of three types of entangling geometric-phase gates with trapped ions, which rely on the effective spin-spin interactions generated with state-dependent forces. First, a mixed-species entangling gate is demonstrated using a 9Be+ and a 25Mg+ ion to create a Bell state with a fidelity of 0.979(1). Combined with single-qubit gates, we use this mixed-species gate to implement controlled-NOT and SWAP gates. Second, we implement a high-fidelity universal gate set with 9Be+ ions. Single-qubit gates with error per gate of 3.8(1)x10-5 are achieved. By creating a Bell state with a deterministic two-qubit entangling gate, we deduce a gate error as low as 8(4)x10-4. Third, a novel two-qubit entangling gate with dynamical decoupling built-in is demonstrated with a fidelity of 0.974(4). This gate is robust against qubit dephasing errors and offers simplifications in experimental implementation compared to some other gates with trapped ions. Errors in the above implementations are evaluated and methods to further reduce imperfections are discussed. In a separate experiment, correlated measurements made on pairs of ions violate a "chained" Bell inequality obeyed by any local-realistic theory. The lowest chained Bell inequality parameter determined from our measurements is 0.296(12), this value is significantly lower than 0.586, the minimum value derived from a perfect Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Horne (CHSH) Bell inequality experiment. Furthermore, our CHSH Bell inequality results provide a device-independent certification of the deterministically created Bell states.

•Jan 1, 2016•1 citation

High-fidelity entanglement of Ca+43 hyperfine clock states

Gerhard Kirchmair, Jan Benhelm, F. Zähringer +3 more

In an experiment using the odd calcium isotope $^{43}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}$, we combine the merits of a high-fidelity entangling operation on an optical transition (optical qubit) with the long coherence times of two ``clock'' states in the hyperfine ground state (hyperfine qubit) by mapping between these two qubits. For state initialization, state detection, global qubit rotations, and mapping operations, errors smaller than 1% are achieved, whereas the entangling gate adds errors of 2.3%. Based on these operations, we create Bell states with a fidelity of 96.9(3)% in the optical qubit and a fidelity of 96.7(3)% when mapped to the hyperfine states. In the latter case, the entanglement is preserved for $96(3)\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{ms}$, exceeding the duration of a single gate operation by three orders of magnitude.

arXiv:0812.1976•Physical Review A•Feb 17, 2009•27 citations

Experimental Realization of Direct Entangling Gates between Dual-Type Qubits

Chenxi Wang, Chuanxin Huang, Hongxuan Zhang +6 more

Dual-type qubits have become a promising way to suppress the crosstalk error of auxiliary operations in large-scale ion trap quantum computation. Here we demonstrate a direct entangling gate between dual-type qubits encoded in the S_{1/2} and D_{5/2} hyperfine manifolds of ^{137}Ba^{+} ions. Our scheme is economic in the hardware, requiring only a single 532 nm laser system to entangle both qubit types by driving their Raman transitions. We achieve a Bell state fidelity of 96.3(4)% for the dual-type Molmer-Sorensen gate between an S-D ion pair, comparable to that for the same-type S-S or D-D gates. This technique can reduce the overhead for back-and-forth conversions between dual-type qubits in the quantum circuit with wide applications in quantum error correction and ion-photon quantum networks.

arXiv:2410.05659•Physical Review Letters•Jan 3, 2025•5 citations
We implement a two-qubit logic gate between a ^{43}Ca^{+} hyperfine qubit and a ^{88}Sr^{+} Zeeman qubit. For this pair of ion species, the S-P optical transitions are close enough that a single laser of wavelength 402 nm can be used to drive the gate but sufficiently well separated to give good spectral isolation and low photon scattering errors. We characterize the gate by full randomized benchmarking, gate set tomography, and Bell state analysis. The latter method gives a fidelity of 99.8(1)%, comparable to that of the best same-species gates and consistent with known sources of error.
Harnessing quantum mechanics to solve problems intractable on classical computers is one of the foremost goals of applied physics. Trapped ions make an excellent physical platform for such a quantum computer, as they have demonstrated unparalleled qubit operation fidelities and memory times, but significant challenges remain in scaling up these systems. A promising scalable architecture is a photonically connected network of mixed element trapped ion nodes, each containing a few ions of two species. Poor quality remote entanglement links between nodes can be tolerated, if entanglement between ions in the same node can be achieved with high fidelity. While local gates have been repeatedly demonstrated between ions of the same species, the fidelity of mixed element quantum gates have not previously surpassed the fault tolerant threshold, above which errors can in principle be corrected. In this thesis we demonstrate an entangling operation between 43Ca+, useful for its long lived qubits, and 88Sr+, well suited for remote entanglement, using a novel mechanism requiring only one laser to manipulate both species. This relatively simple scheme, which is independent of either qubit frequency, allows us to achieve Bell state fidelities of F = 99.8(1)%. We assess the operation of the gate further with state and process tomography, which achieve Bell state fidelity F = 98.1% and average gate fidelity F̅ = 99.05(6)% respectively, though they are hampered by experimental drifts during the long data collection. Finally, we use interleaved randomised benchmarking to get the best estimate of our gate errors, finding an average gate fidelity of F̅ = 99.62(3)% for a sequence of 60 interleaved gates. Along with a demonstration of entanglement between two 88Sr+ ions, achieved with fidelity F = 95.9(4)%, this work paves the way towards demonstrating an elementary mixed species quantum network in future experiments.
Entanglement generation in trapped-ion systems has relied thus far on two distinct but related geometric phase gate techniques: Mølmer-Sørensen and light-shift gates. We recently proposed a variant of the light-shift scheme where the qubit levels are separated by an optical frequency [B. C. Sawyer and K. R. Brown, Phys. Rev. A 103, 022427 (2021)PLRAAN2469-992610.1103/PhysRevA.103.022427]. Here we report an experimental demonstration of this entangling gate using a pair of ^{40}Ca^{+} ions in a cryogenic surface-electrode ion trap and a commercial, high-power, 532 nm Nd:YAG laser. Generating a Bell state in 35 μs, we directly measure an infidelity of 6(3)×10^{-4} without subtraction of experimental errors. The 532 nm gate laser wavelength suppresses intrinsic photon scattering error to ∼1×10^{-5}.
Trapped ions are a leading technology for quantum computing, but their reliance on bespoke tabletop laser and optical systems remains a major obstacle to scaling and robustness. Integrated silicon nitride lasers, compatible with future monolithic integration with surface electrode ion traps, have recently demonstrated frequency-selective qubit state preparation and measurement as well as interrogation of an optical clock transition. However, coherent qubit gates impose even more stringent requirements on laser phase noise, and their implementation with integrated laser sources has remained an outstanding challenge. Here, we use a visible-wavelength integrated Brillouin laser stabilized to an integrated coil resonator to drive coherent single- and two-qubit gates with \Sr optical qubits. We measure an average single-qubit fidelity of 99.61%±0.03%99.61\%\pm 0.03\%99.61%±0.03% per Clifford gate with randomized benchmarking and use a two-qubit Mølmer-Sørensen interaction to generate an entangled Bell state with a fidelity of 92.35%±1.50%92.35\% \pm 1.50\%92.35%±1.50%. The qubit exhibits a bare Ramsey coherence time of 659±9 μ659 \pm 9~μ659±9 μs, more than a tenfold improvement over our previous implementation, which extends to 1.750±0.0331.750 \pm 0.0331.750±0.033~ms with an echo. These results demonstrate, for the first time, that integrated visible-wavelength narrow-linewidth photonic lasers can meet the phase-noise requirements for coherent quantum logic with trapped ion optical qubits, providing a path for scalable optical systems integrated within trapped ion quantum processors.
Quantum entangling logic gates are key ingredients for the implementation of a quantum information processing device. In this thesis, we focus on experimental implementations of three types of entangling geometric-phase gates with trapped ions, which rely on the effective spin-spin interactions generated with state-dependent forces. First, a mixed-species entangling gate is demonstrated using a 9Be+ and a 25Mg+ ion to create a Bell state with a fidelity of 0.979(1). Combined with single-qubit gates, we use this mixed-species gate to implement controlled-NOT and SWAP gates. Second, we implement a high-fidelity universal gate set with 9Be+ ions. Single-qubit gates with error per gate of 3.8(1)x10-5 are achieved. By creating a Bell state with a deterministic two-qubit entangling gate, we deduce a gate error as low as 8(4)x10-4. Third, a novel two-qubit entangling gate with dynamical decoupling built-in is demonstrated with a fidelity of 0.974(4). This gate is robust against qubit dephasing errors and offers simplifications in experimental implementation compared to some other gates with trapped ions. Errors in the above implementations are evaluated and methods to further reduce imperfections are discussed. In a separate experiment, correlated measurements made on pairs of ions violate a "chained" Bell inequality obeyed by any local-realistic theory. The lowest chained Bell inequality parameter determined from our measurements is 0.296(12), this value is significantly lower than 0.586, the minimum value derived from a perfect Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Horne (CHSH) Bell inequality experiment. Furthermore, our CHSH Bell inequality results provide a device-independent certification of the deterministically created Bell states.
In an experiment using the odd calcium isotope 43Ca+^{43}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}43Ca+, we combine the merits of a high-fidelity entangling operation on an optical transition (optical qubit) with the long coherence times of two ``clock'' states in the hyperfine ground state (hyperfine qubit) by mapping between these two qubits. For state initialization, state detection, global qubit rotations, and mapping operations, errors smaller than 1% are achieved, whereas the entangling gate adds errors of 2.3%. Based on these operations, we create Bell states with a fidelity of 96.9(3)% in the optical qubit and a fidelity of 96.7(3)% when mapped to the hyperfine states. In the latter case, the entanglement is preserved for 96(3)ms96(3)\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{ms}96(3)ms, exceeding the duration of a single gate operation by three orders of magnitude.
Dual-type qubits have become a promising way to suppress the crosstalk error of auxiliary operations in large-scale ion trap quantum computation. Here we demonstrate a direct entangling gate between dual-type qubits encoded in the S_{1/2} and D_{5/2} hyperfine manifolds of ^{137}Ba^{+} ions. Our scheme is economic in the hardware, requiring only a single 532 nm laser system to entangle both qubit types by driving their Raman transitions. We achieve a Bell state fidelity of 96.3(4)% for the dual-type Molmer-Sorensen gate between an S-D ion pair, comparable to that for the same-type S-S or D-D gates. This technique can reduce the overhead for back-and-forth conversions between dual-type qubits in the quantum circuit with wide applications in quantum error correction and ion-photon quantum networks.