Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2004.06609 · Physical Review A

Experimental quantum probing measurements with no knowledge of the system-probe interaction

Henri Lyyra, Olli Siltanen, Jyrki Piilo, Subhashish Banerjee, Tom Kuusela

Published Aug 31, 2020• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In any natural science, measurements are the essential link between theory and observable reality. Is it possible to obtain accurate and relevant information via measurement whose action on the probed system is unknown? In other words, can one be convinced to know something about the nature without knowing in detail how the information was obtained? In this paper, we show that the answer is, surprisingly, yes. We construct and experimentally implement a quantum optical probing measurement where measurements on the probes, i.e., the photons' polarization states, are used to extract information on the systems, i.e., the frequency spectra of the same photons. Unlike the preexisting probing protocols, our measurement does not require any knowledge of the interaction between the probe and the system.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.022232

Related papers

Optimization of Quantum Optical Metrology Systems

Studer, Nicholas Michael

It can be said that all of humanity's efforts can be understood as a problem of optimization. We each have a natural sense of what is ``good'' or ``bad'' and thus our actions tend towards maximizing -- or optimizing -- some notion of good and minimizing those things we perceive as bad or undesirable. Within the sciences, the greatest form of good is knowledge. It is this pursuit of knowledge that leads to not only life-saving innovations and technology, but also to furthering our understanding of our natural world and driving our philosophical pursuits. The principle method of obtaining knowledge in the sciences is by performing measurements; the simple act of comparing one attribute of a system to a known standard and recording the observed value is how all scientific progress is made. The act of performing measurements is in fact so important that there is an entire field of study surrounding it: metrology. One critical component of metrology is the development of new techniques to perform measurements, or alternative measurement schemes that are more optimal in some way. This is where there is room to exploit quantum physics to improve our techniques \--- we can perform quantum metrology. In quantum mechanics we routinely deal with the smallest, weakest, most delicate of systems. Quantum properties are inherently very sensitive to their environment; this of course makes them highly intolerant of noise but also makes them great resources to perform sensitive measurements. Quantum metrology concerns itself with utilizing quantum phenomena to extract more information from the natural world than is possible by conventional, or classical, means. To perform optimal measurements, these quantum systems must of course be optimal by some metric. Performing the ``optimal'' measurement requires several ingredients. First, we need the optimal tools or instrumentation. In quantum mechanical language, this means we need the optimal probe state. Then, we need to optimize the interaction of our instrumentation with the system we which to interrogate so that we can extract the desired information. This translates to needing the best possible interaction between the probe state and the system in question -- in other words, we need to optimize the evolution of the probe. Finally, we must take care to extract the most information as possible at the output; we must not neglect any information present in the evolved probe state. The entire quantum metrology process can be summarized as thus: probe

Civil War Book Review•Mar 18, 2019•0 citations

Quantum Measurement: Concepts, Algorithms, and Experiments in Photonic Quantum Information Science

Brendon L. Higgins

The application of concepts from quantum information science to the task of measuring properties of physical systems allows precision and perspectives going beyond that available through classical approaches. This thesis presents experimental and theoretical work that demonstrates this in the context of optical quantum systems, with particular emphasis on photonics.

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Information and coherence as resources for work extraction from unknown quantum state and providing quantum advantages

Tanmoy Biswas

The amount of extractable work from a physical system is fundamentally connected to the information available about its state, as illustrated by Maxwell's demon and the Gibbs paradox. In standard thermodynamic protocols involving system--bath interactions, the maximum work is given by the free-energy difference between the initial state and the corresponding Gibbs state at the bath temperature. This motivates a natural question: does information also limit work extraction in closed quantum systems that do not involve a heat bath and where work is obtained through unitary operations generated by a time-dependent Hamiltonian? While ergotropy quantifies the maximum work extractable via unitary operations, it assumes complete knowledge of the quantum state, typically requiring full state tomography. In realistic scenarios, however, only partial information is accessible. In this case, the relevant figure of merit is observational ergotropy, which depends explicitly on the measurement used to probe the system. We show that observational ergotropy decreases under classical post-processing of measurement outcomes, implying that fine-grained measurements allow greater work extraction than coarse-grained ones. Moreover, maximizing observational ergotropy over all possible measurements recovers standard ergotropy, which decomposes into incoherent (classical) and coherent (quantum) contributions. Our results demonstrate that coherence in the measurement projectors constitutes the key resource, enabling work extraction beyond the incoherent limit and establishing coherence as the origin of quantum advantage in observational ergotropy extraction.

quant-pharXiv:2602.22893•Feb 27, 2026•0 citations

Controlling dynamics of open quantum systems

Henri Lyyra

Quantum mechanics has both deepened our understanding of the physical reality and allowed development of quantum technologies beating their classical counterparts in efficiency, security, and sensitivity. As a major downside, the quantum properties behind these technologies are very sensitive to the effects the system’s interaction with its environment. The theory of open quantum systems describes how such interaction influences the system, and as a consequence, how the quantum features are lost, controlled, and possibly returned by manipulating the environment. This thesis begins with a short description of the most relevant features and results of the open quantum system theory. We continue by presenting some commonly used measures to quantify the information encoded in quantum systems and the correlations between spatially or temporally separated parties. The literature review ends with discussion of non-Markovianity and memory effects which combine the fields of open quantum systems and quantum information in a natural way. The rest of the thesis presents the main results of Publications I – VII. We study the memory effects and physicality conditions of open system dynamics described by the vast family of phase-covariant master equations. We show how the open quantum system picture can be exploited to design probing protocols to extract information without knowing how the probe and system interact. Such protocols are considered also from the point-of view of efficiently obtaining the information required in the probing, both in theory and by experimental implementation. The experiment serves also as evidence for applicability of recently developed geometric tools to design informationally incomplete measurements for solving so-called membership problems. We present and experimentally realize a protocol where control over intial correlations between polarization and frequency gives full freedom to implement any dephasing dynamics in the open system polarization, thus dictating how its information content changes in time. We study the two-qubit memory effects of dephasing dynamics and compare them to the effect of such noise in the transmission efficiency in superdense coding. Optimal noise configurations in different situations are found. Finally, we characterize the families of initial states for which the decay of quantum correlations depends or does not depend on the noise location.

•Oct 5, 2019•0 citations

Quantum measurement and uncertainty relations in photon polarization

Keiichi Edamatsu

Abstract Recent theoretical and experimental studies have given raise to new aspects in quantum measurements and error-disturbance uncertainty relations. After a brief review of these issues, we present an experimental test of the error-disturbance uncertainty relations in photon polarization measurements. Using a generalized, strength-variable measurement of a single photon polarization state, we experimentally evaluate the error and disturbance in the measurement process and demonstrate the validity of recently proposed uncertainty relations.

arXiv:1606.07275•Physica Scripta•Jun 1, 2016•10 citations

Measurement of quantum polarization properties of three-photon states

Yosep Kim, Gunnar G. Bjork, Yoon-Ho Kim

We experimentally investigate quantum polarization of three-photon states. A number of representative three-photon states are prepared and tested for quantum polarization properties. Our results reveal interesting properties like hidden polarization.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations
In any natural science, measurements are the essential link between theory and observable reality. Is it possible to obtain accurate and relevant information via measurement whose action on the probed system is unknown? In other words, can one be convinced to know something about the nature without knowing in detail how the information was obtained? In this paper, we show that the answer is, surprisingly, yes. We construct and experimentally implement a quantum optical probing measurement where measurements on the probes, i.e., the photons' polarization states, are used to extract information on the systems, i.e., the frequency spectra of the same photons. Unlike the preexisting probing protocols, our measurement does not require any knowledge of the interaction between the probe and the system.
It can be said that all of humanity's efforts can be understood as a problem of optimization. We each have a natural sense of what is ``good'' or ``bad'' and thus our actions tend towards maximizing -- or optimizing -- some notion of good and minimizing those things we perceive as bad or undesirable. Within the sciences, the greatest form of good is knowledge. It is this pursuit of knowledge that leads to not only life-saving innovations and technology, but also to furthering our understanding of our natural world and driving our philosophical pursuits. The principle method of obtaining knowledge in the sciences is by performing measurements; the simple act of comparing one attribute of a system to a known standard and recording the observed value is how all scientific progress is made. The act of performing measurements is in fact so important that there is an entire field of study surrounding it: metrology. One critical component of metrology is the development of new techniques to perform measurements, or alternative measurement schemes that are more optimal in some way. This is where there is room to exploit quantum physics to improve our techniques \--- we can perform quantum metrology. In quantum mechanics we routinely deal with the smallest, weakest, most delicate of systems. Quantum properties are inherently very sensitive to their environment; this of course makes them highly intolerant of noise but also makes them great resources to perform sensitive measurements. Quantum metrology concerns itself with utilizing quantum phenomena to extract more information from the natural world than is possible by conventional, or classical, means. To perform optimal measurements, these quantum systems must of course be optimal by some metric. Performing the ``optimal'' measurement requires several ingredients. First, we need the optimal tools or instrumentation. In quantum mechanical language, this means we need the optimal probe state. Then, we need to optimize the interaction of our instrumentation with the system we which to interrogate so that we can extract the desired information. This translates to needing the best possible interaction between the probe state and the system in question -- in other words, we need to optimize the evolution of the probe. Finally, we must take care to extract the most information as possible at the output; we must not neglect any information present in the evolved probe state. The entire quantum metrology process can be summarized as thus: probe
The amount of extractable work from a physical system is fundamentally connected to the information available about its state, as illustrated by Maxwell's demon and the Gibbs paradox. In standard thermodynamic protocols involving system--bath interactions, the maximum work is given by the free-energy difference between the initial state and the corresponding Gibbs state at the bath temperature. This motivates a natural question: does information also limit work extraction in closed quantum systems that do not involve a heat bath and where work is obtained through unitary operations generated by a time-dependent Hamiltonian? While ergotropy quantifies the maximum work extractable via unitary operations, it assumes complete knowledge of the quantum state, typically requiring full state tomography. In realistic scenarios, however, only partial information is accessible. In this case, the relevant figure of merit is observational ergotropy, which depends explicitly on the measurement used to probe the system. We show that observational ergotropy decreases under classical post-processing of measurement outcomes, implying that fine-grained measurements allow greater work extraction than coarse-grained ones. Moreover, maximizing observational ergotropy over all possible measurements recovers standard ergotropy, which decomposes into incoherent (classical) and coherent (quantum) contributions. Our results demonstrate that coherence in the measurement projectors constitutes the key resource, enabling work extraction beyond the incoherent limit and establishing coherence as the origin of quantum advantage in observational ergotropy extraction.
Quantum mechanics has both deepened our understanding of the physical reality and allowed development of quantum technologies beating their classical counterparts in efficiency, security, and sensitivity. As a major downside, the quantum properties behind these technologies are very sensitive to the effects the system’s interaction with its environment. The theory of open quantum systems describes how such interaction influences the system, and as a consequence, how the quantum features are lost, controlled, and possibly returned by manipulating the environment. This thesis begins with a short description of the most relevant features and results of the open quantum system theory. We continue by presenting some commonly used measures to quantify the information encoded in quantum systems and the correlations between spatially or temporally separated parties. The literature review ends with discussion of non-Markovianity and memory effects which combine the fields of open quantum systems and quantum information in a natural way. The rest of the thesis presents the main results of Publications I – VII. We study the memory effects and physicality conditions of open system dynamics described by the vast family of phase-covariant master equations. We show how the open quantum system picture can be exploited to design probing protocols to extract information without knowing how the probe and system interact. Such protocols are considered also from the point-of view of efficiently obtaining the information required in the probing, both in theory and by experimental implementation. The experiment serves also as evidence for applicability of recently developed geometric tools to design informationally incomplete measurements for solving so-called membership problems. We present and experimentally realize a protocol where control over intial correlations between polarization and frequency gives full freedom to implement any dephasing dynamics in the open system polarization, thus dictating how its information content changes in time. We study the two-qubit memory effects of dephasing dynamics and compare them to the effect of such noise in the transmission efficiency in superdense coding. Optimal noise configurations in different situations are found. Finally, we characterize the families of initial states for which the decay of quantum correlations depends or does not depend on the noise location.
Abstract Recent theoretical and experimental studies have given raise to new aspects in quantum measurements and error-disturbance uncertainty relations. After a brief review of these issues, we present an experimental test of the error-disturbance uncertainty relations in photon polarization measurements. Using a generalized, strength-variable measurement of a single photon polarization state, we experimentally evaluate the error and disturbance in the measurement process and demonstrate the validity of recently proposed uncertainty relations.