Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2004.02422 · Physical Review A

Direct estimation of minimum gate fidelity

Yiping Lu, Jun Yan Sim, Jun Suzuki, Berthold‐Georg Englert, Hui Khoon Ng

Published Aug 18, 2020• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

With the current interest in building quantum computers, there is a strong need for accurate and efficient characterization of the noise in quantum gate implementations. A key measure of the performance of a quantum gate is the minimum gate fidelity, i.e., the fidelity of the gate, minimized over all input states. Conventionally, the minimum fidelity is estimated by first accurately reconstructing the full gate process matrix using the experimental procedure of quantum process tomography (QPT). Then, a numerical minimization is carried out to find the minimum fidelity. QPT is, however, well known to be costly, and it might appear that we can do better if the goal is only to estimate one single number. In this work, we propose a hybrid numerical-experimental scheme that employs a numerical gradient-free minimization (GFM) and an experimental target-fidelity estimation procedure to directly estimate the minimum fidelity without reconstructing the process matrix. We compare this to an alternative scheme, referred to as QPT fidelity estimation, that does use QPT, but directly employs the minimum gate fidelity as the termination criterion. Both approaches can thus be considered as direct estimation schemes. General resource estimates suggest a significant resource savings for the GFM scheme over QPT fidelity estimation; numerical simulations for specific classes of noise, however, show that both schemes have similar performance, reminding us of the need for caution when using general bounds for specific examples. The GFM scheme, however, presents potential for future improvements in resource cost, with the development of even more efficient GFM algorithms.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.022410

Related papers

Optimizing resource bounds in direct fidelity estimation

Netanel Barel, Lee Peleg, Yotam Kadish +2 more

Direct fidelity estimation provides a way to estimate the fidelity between an experimentally prepared state and a desired pure target state without performing full tomography. Two influential formulations were introduced in 2011 by Flammia and Liu and by da Silva, Landon-Cardinal, and Poulin. In these protocols, the total estimation error is controlled through two distinct probabilistic steps: first, the fidelity is approximated using randomly sampled Pauli observables; second, each sampled expectation value is estimated from finitely many measurement outcomes. In this work we show that additional structural information about the noise can substantially sharpen the corresponding resource bounds. In particular, for some canonical channels the effective number of sampled Pauli settings can be reduced, leading to lower measurement cost both in the general pure-state setting and in the case of a stabilizer state. These results illustrate a broader point: worst-case confidence bounds in direct fidelity estimation can be significantly conservative when experimentally relevant structure is ignored. As a technical ingredient, we also revisit the allocation of the total accuracy and confidence budgets between the two probabilistic steps. Reformulating the analysis in terms of separate error parameters yields a constrained optimization problem whose solution lowers the average number of measurements in the general pure-state setting. Numerical simulations based on quantum circuits implemented in Qiskit illustrate both the improvement obtained under structured-noise assumptions and the conservativeness of the original worst-case bounds.

quant-pharXiv:2606.16336•Jun 16, 2026•0 citations

Compressed Gate Characterization for Quantum Devices with Time-Correlated Noise

Michael J. Gullans, M. Caranti, Adam Mills +1 more

As quantum devices make steady progress towards intermediate scale and fault-tolerant quantum computing, it is essential to develop rigorous and efficient measurement protocols that account for known sources of noise. Most existing quantum characterization protocols such as gate-set tomography and randomized benchmarking assume the noise acting on the qubits is Markovian. However, this assumption is often not valid, as for the case of 1/f charge noise or hyperfine nuclear spin noise. Here, we present a general framework for quantum process tomography (QPT) in the presence of time-correlated noise. We further introduce fidelity benchmarks that quantify the relative strength of different sources of Markovian and non-Markovian noise. As an application of our method, we perform a comparative theoretical and experimental analysis of silicon spin qubits. We first develop a detailed noise model that accounts for the dominant sources of noise and validate the model against experimental data. Applying our framework for time-correlated QPT, we find that the number of independent parameters needed to characterize one- and two-qubit gates can be compressed by 10× and 100× , respectively, when compared to the fully generic case. These compressions reduce the amount of tomographic measurements needed in experiment, while also significantly speeding up numerical simulations of noisy quantum circuit dynamics compared to time-dependent Hamiltonian simulation. Using this compressed noise model, we find good agreement between our theoretically predicted process fidelities and two-qubit interleaved randomized benchmarking fidelities of 99.8% measured in recent experiments on silicon spin qubits. More broadly, our formalism can be directly extended to develop efficient and scalable tuning protocols for high-fidelity control of large arrays of quantum devices with non-Markovian noise. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2307.14432•PRX Quantum•Jan 18, 2024•8 citations

Sample- and Hardware-Efficient Fidelity Estimation by Stripping Phase-Dominated Magic

Guedong Park, Jaekwon Chang, Yosep Kim +2 more

Direct fidelity estimation (DFE) is a famous tool for estimating the fidelity with a target pure state. However, such a method generally requires exponentially many sampling copies due to the large magic of the target state. This work proposes a sample- and gate-efficient fidelity estimation algorithm that is affordable within feasible quantum devices. We show that the fidelity estimation with pure states close to the structure of phase states, for which sample-efficient DFE is limited by their strong entanglement and magic, can be done by using $\mathcal{O}({\rm poly}(n))$ sampling copies, with a single $n$-qubit fan-out gate. As the target state becomes a phase state, the sampling complexity reaches $\mathcal{O}(1)$. Such a drastic improvement stems from a crucial step in our scheme, the so-called phase stripping, which can significantly reduce the target-state magic. Furthermore, we convert a complex diagonal gate resource, which is needed to design a phase-stripping-adapted algorithm, into nonlinear classical post-processing of Pauli measurements so that we only require a single fan-out gate. Additionally, as another variant using the nonlinear post-processing, we propose a nonlinear extension of the conventional DFE scheme. Here, the sampling reduction compared to DFE is also guaranteed, while preserving the Pauli measurement as the only circuit resource. We expect our work to contribute to establishing noise-resilient quantum algorithms by enabling a significant reduction in sampling overhead for fidelity estimation under the restricted gate resources, and ultimately to clarifying a fundamental gap between the resource overhead required to understand complex physical properties and that required to generate them.

quant-pharXiv:2602.09710•Feb 11, 2026•0 citations

Practical Fidelity Estimation for Noisy Quantum Devices Using Direct and Survival-Probability-Based Protocols

Ahmed Aman, Kaustav Chatterjee, Younes Javanmard +1 more

Reliable characterization of quantum states and quantum processes is central to the development of scalable quantum computing. Standard characterization techniques such as full quantum state tomography become rapidly impractical as system size increases. In this work we present two software-oriented fidelity estimation protocols that avoid full tomographic reconstruction while remaining experimentally relevant for noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices. The first protocol is direct fidelity estimation (DFE), where the fidelity between a target state and an experimentally prepared state is estimated from importance-sampled Pauli measurements. The second protocol is a survival-probability-based method that reconstructs fidelity from experimentally accessible moments of a noisy evolution and its approximate inverse, and is intrinsically robust against state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) errors. We discuss the theoretical basis of both approaches, analyze their noise sensitivity, and present numerical evidence on representative multiqubit states under depolarizing, dephasing, and amplitude-damping channels. For DFE we show that attenuation-aware correction improves robustness against measurement noise. For the survival-probability approach we show that an $L_2$-optimized expansion substantially outperforms naive Taylor truncation in high-noise regimes.

quant-pharXiv:2610.21606•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

PCA-based post-processing in quantum process tomography: An experimental study

Md. Zubair, Md. Sazid-Al-Emon, Mohammad Obaidur Rahman +1 more

Quantum Process Tomography (QPT) is a fundamental technique to characterize quantum operations. However, its precision gets hampered while running in real quantum hardware due to inherent noise. In our study, we propose a post-processing method using principal component analysis (PCA) to improve the fidelity of noisy gates. We first implemented the standard QPT on various gates ranging from single-qubit to three-qubit in simulation under depolarizing error scenarios and on Fake IBM_Brisbane and ran single and two-qubit gates (H, CX, and SQSCZ) on real quantum hardware (IBM_Brisbane); the three-qubit CCX is evaluated in simulation only. After that, the reconstructed Choi matrix is decomposed into real and imaginary components. Then, by applying a PCA-based approach, we show steady improvements in a variety of quantitative performance indicators in addition to process fidelity while also maintaining the physical constraints of the Choi matrix. Additionally, PCA performed better or similarly when compared to CVX-based maximum-likelihood reconstruction and linear inversion. Although PCA improves QPT reconstructions, it is unable to address the fundamental scalability issue of QPT since it cannot overcome the exponential scaling with qubit number.

AVS Quantum Science•Feb 23, 2026•0 citations

Quantum measurement tomography with mini-batch stochastic gradient descent

Akshay Gaikwad, Manuel Sebastian Torres, Anton Frisk Kockum

Drawing inspiration from gradient-descent methods developed for data processing in quantum state tomography [\href{https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/2058-9565/ae0baa}{Quantum Sci.~Technol.~\textbf{10} 045055 (2025)}] and quantum process tomography [\href{https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.130.150402}{Phys.~Rev.~Lett.~\textbf{130}, 150402 (2023)}], we introduce stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithms for fast quantum measurement tomography (QMT), applicable to both discrete- and continuous-variable quantum systems -- thus completing the tomography trio. A measurement device or detector in a quantum experiment is characterized by a set of positive operator-valued measure (POVM) elements; the goal of QMT is to estimate these operators from experimental data. To ensure physically valid (positive and complete) POVM reconstructions, we propose two distinct parameterization schemes within the SGD framework: one leveraging optimization on a Stiefel manifold and one based on Hermitian operator normalization via eigenvalue scaling. Within the SGD-QMT framework, we further investigate two loss functions: mean squared error, equivalent to L2 or Euclidean norm, and average negative log-likelihood, inspired by maximum likelihood estimation. We benchmark performance against state-of-the-art constrained convex optimization methods. Numerical simulations demonstrate that, compared to standard methods, our SGD-QMT algorithms offer significantly lower computational cost, superior reconstruction fidelity, and enhanced robustness to noise. We make a Python implementation of the SGD-QMT algorithms publicly available at \href{https://github.com/agtomo/SGD-QMT}{github.com/agtomo/SGD-QMT}.

quant-pharXiv:2511.15682•Nov 20, 2025•0 citations
With the current interest in building quantum computers, there is a strong need for accurate and efficient characterization of the noise in quantum gate implementations. A key measure of the performance of a quantum gate is the minimum gate fidelity, i.e., the fidelity of the gate, minimized over all input states. Conventionally, the minimum fidelity is estimated by first accurately reconstructing the full gate process matrix using the experimental procedure of quantum process tomography (QPT). Then, a numerical minimization is carried out to find the minimum fidelity. QPT is, however, well known to be costly, and it might appear that we can do better if the goal is only to estimate one single number. In this work, we propose a hybrid numerical-experimental scheme that employs a numerical gradient-free minimization (GFM) and an experimental target-fidelity estimation procedure to directly estimate the minimum fidelity without reconstructing the process matrix. We compare this to an alternative scheme, referred to as QPT fidelity estimation, that does use QPT, but directly employs the minimum gate fidelity as the termination criterion. Both approaches can thus be considered as direct estimation schemes. General resource estimates suggest a significant resource savings for the GFM scheme over QPT fidelity estimation; numerical simulations for specific classes of noise, however, show that both schemes have similar performance, reminding us of the need for caution when using general bounds for specific examples. The GFM scheme, however, presents potential for future improvements in resource cost, with the development of even more efficient GFM algorithms.
Direct fidelity estimation provides a way to estimate the fidelity between an experimentally prepared state and a desired pure target state without performing full tomography. Two influential formulations were introduced in 2011 by Flammia and Liu and by da Silva, Landon-Cardinal, and Poulin. In these protocols, the total estimation error is controlled through two distinct probabilistic steps: first, the fidelity is approximated using randomly sampled Pauli observables; second, each sampled expectation value is estimated from finitely many measurement outcomes. In this work we show that additional structural information about the noise can substantially sharpen the corresponding resource bounds. In particular, for some canonical channels the effective number of sampled Pauli settings can be reduced, leading to lower measurement cost both in the general pure-state setting and in the case of a stabilizer state. These results illustrate a broader point: worst-case confidence bounds in direct fidelity estimation can be significantly conservative when experimentally relevant structure is ignored. As a technical ingredient, we also revisit the allocation of the total accuracy and confidence budgets between the two probabilistic steps. Reformulating the analysis in terms of separate error parameters yields a constrained optimization problem whose solution lowers the average number of measurements in the general pure-state setting. Numerical simulations based on quantum circuits implemented in Qiskit illustrate both the improvement obtained under structured-noise assumptions and the conservativeness of the original worst-case bounds.
As quantum devices make steady progress towards intermediate scale and fault-tolerant quantum computing, it is essential to develop rigorous and efficient measurement protocols that account for known sources of noise. Most existing quantum characterization protocols such as gate-set tomography and randomized benchmarking assume the noise acting on the qubits is Markovian. However, this assumption is often not valid, as for the case of 1/f charge noise or hyperfine nuclear spin noise. Here, we present a general framework for quantum process tomography (QPT) in the presence of time-correlated noise. We further introduce fidelity benchmarks that quantify the relative strength of different sources of Markovian and non-Markovian noise. As an application of our method, we perform a comparative theoretical and experimental analysis of silicon spin qubits. We first develop a detailed noise model that accounts for the dominant sources of noise and validate the model against experimental data. Applying our framework for time-correlated QPT, we find that the number of independent parameters needed to characterize one- and two-qubit gates can be compressed by 10× and 100× , respectively, when compared to the fully generic case. These compressions reduce the amount of tomographic measurements needed in experiment, while also significantly speeding up numerical simulations of noisy quantum circuit dynamics compared to time-dependent Hamiltonian simulation. Using this compressed noise model, we find good agreement between our theoretically predicted process fidelities and two-qubit interleaved randomized benchmarking fidelities of 99.8% measured in recent experiments on silicon spin qubits. More broadly, our formalism can be directly extended to develop efficient and scalable tuning protocols for high-fidelity control of large arrays of quantum devices with non-Markovian noise. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Direct fidelity estimation (DFE) is a famous tool for estimating the fidelity with a target pure state. However, such a method generally requires exponentially many sampling copies due to the large magic of the target state. This work proposes a sample- and gate-efficient fidelity estimation algorithm that is affordable within feasible quantum devices. We show that the fidelity estimation with pure states close to the structure of phase states, for which sample-efficient DFE is limited by their strong entanglement and magic, can be done by using O(poly(n))\mathcal{O}({\rm poly}(n))O(poly(n)) sampling copies, with a single nnn-qubit fan-out gate. As the target state becomes a phase state, the sampling complexity reaches O(1)\mathcal{O}(1)O(1). Such a drastic improvement stems from a crucial step in our scheme, the so-called phase stripping, which can significantly reduce the target-state magic. Furthermore, we convert a complex diagonal gate resource, which is needed to design a phase-stripping-adapted algorithm, into nonlinear classical post-processing of Pauli measurements so that we only require a single fan-out gate. Additionally, as another variant using the nonlinear post-processing, we propose a nonlinear extension of the conventional DFE scheme. Here, the sampling reduction compared to DFE is also guaranteed, while preserving the Pauli measurement as the only circuit resource. We expect our work to contribute to establishing noise-resilient quantum algorithms by enabling a significant reduction in sampling overhead for fidelity estimation under the restricted gate resources, and ultimately to clarifying a fundamental gap between the resource overhead required to understand complex physical properties and that required to generate them.
Reliable characterization of quantum states and quantum processes is central to the development of scalable quantum computing. Standard characterization techniques such as full quantum state tomography become rapidly impractical as system size increases. In this work we present two software-oriented fidelity estimation protocols that avoid full tomographic reconstruction while remaining experimentally relevant for noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices. The first protocol is direct fidelity estimation (DFE), where the fidelity between a target state and an experimentally prepared state is estimated from importance-sampled Pauli measurements. The second protocol is a survival-probability-based method that reconstructs fidelity from experimentally accessible moments of a noisy evolution and its approximate inverse, and is intrinsically robust against state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) errors. We discuss the theoretical basis of both approaches, analyze their noise sensitivity, and present numerical evidence on representative multiqubit states under depolarizing, dephasing, and amplitude-damping channels. For DFE we show that attenuation-aware correction improves robustness against measurement noise. For the survival-probability approach we show that an L2L_2L2​-optimized expansion substantially outperforms naive Taylor truncation in high-noise regimes.
Quantum Process Tomography (QPT) is a fundamental technique to characterize quantum operations. However, its precision gets hampered while running in real quantum hardware due to inherent noise. In our study, we propose a post-processing method using principal component analysis (PCA) to improve the fidelity of noisy gates. We first implemented the standard QPT on various gates ranging from single-qubit to three-qubit in simulation under depolarizing error scenarios and on Fake IBM_Brisbane and ran single and two-qubit gates (H, CX, and SQSCZ) on real quantum hardware (IBM_Brisbane); the three-qubit CCX is evaluated in simulation only. After that, the reconstructed Choi matrix is decomposed into real and imaginary components. Then, by applying a PCA-based approach, we show steady improvements in a variety of quantitative performance indicators in addition to process fidelity while also maintaining the physical constraints of the Choi matrix. Additionally, PCA performed better or similarly when compared to CVX-based maximum-likelihood reconstruction and linear inversion. Although PCA improves QPT reconstructions, it is unable to address the fundamental scalability issue of QPT since it cannot overcome the exponential scaling with qubit number.
Drawing inspiration from gradient-descent methods developed for data processing in quantum state tomography [\href{https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/2058-9565/ae0baa}{Quantum Sci.~Technol.~\textbf{10} 045055 (2025)}] and quantum process tomography [\href{https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.130.150402}{Phys.~Rev.~Lett.~\textbf{130}, 150402 (2023)}], we introduce stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithms for fast quantum measurement tomography (QMT), applicable to both discrete- and continuous-variable quantum systems -- thus completing the tomography trio. A measurement device or detector in a quantum experiment is characterized by a set of positive operator-valued measure (POVM) elements; the goal of QMT is to estimate these operators from experimental data. To ensure physically valid (positive and complete) POVM reconstructions, we propose two distinct parameterization schemes within the SGD framework: one leveraging optimization on a Stiefel manifold and one based on Hermitian operator normalization via eigenvalue scaling. Within the SGD-QMT framework, we further investigate two loss functions: mean squared error, equivalent to L2 or Euclidean norm, and average negative log-likelihood, inspired by maximum likelihood estimation. We benchmark performance against state-of-the-art constrained convex optimization methods. Numerical simulations demonstrate that, compared to standard methods, our SGD-QMT algorithms offer significantly lower computational cost, superior reconstruction fidelity, and enhanced robustness to noise. We make a Python implementation of the SGD-QMT algorithms publicly available at \href{https://github.com/agtomo/SGD-QMT}{github.com/agtomo/SGD-QMT}.