We present a general and systematic study of how a Bell experiment on the cosmic microwave background could be carried out. We introduce different classes of pseudo-spin operators and show that, if the system is placed in a two-mode squeezed state as inflation predicts, they all lead to a violation of the Bell inequality. However, we also discuss the obstacles that one faces in order to realize this program in practice and show that they are probably insurmountable. We suggest alternative methods that could reveal the quantum origin of cosmological structures without relying on Bell experiments.
One of the cornerstones of inflationary cosmology is that primordial density fluctuations have a quantum mechanical origin. However, most physicists consider that such quantum mechanical effects disappear in CMB data due to decoherence. In this conference report, we show that the violation of Bell inequalities in an initial state of our universe increases exponentially with the number of modes to measure in inflation. This indicates that some evidence that our universe has a quantum mechanical origin may survive in CMB data, even if quantum entanglement decays exponentially afterward due to decoherence.
Bell inequalities for continuous-variable bipartite systems are studied. The inequalities are expressed in terms of pseudo--spin operators, and quantum expectation values are calculated for generic two-mode squeezed states characterized by a squeezing parameter
r and a squeezing angle $\ensuremath{\varphi}$. Allowing for generic values of the squeezing angle is especially relevant when $\ensuremath{\varphi}$ is not under experimental control, such as in cosmic inflation, where small quantum fluctuations in the early universe are responsible for structures formation. Compared to previous studies restricted to $\ensuremath{\varphi}=0$ and to a fixed orientation of the pseudo--spin operators, allowing for $\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremath{\ne}0$ and optimizing the angular configuration leads to a completely new and rich phenomenology. Two dual schemes of approximation are designed that allow for comprehensive exploration of the squeezing parameter space. In particular, it is found that Bell inequalities can be violated when the squeezing parameter
r is large enough, $r\ensuremath{\gtrsim}1.12$, and the squeezing angle $\ensuremath{\varphi}$ is small enough, $\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremath{\lesssim}0.34\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}r}$.
We investigate the role of the bipartite temporal Bell inequality, an analogue of the spatial Bell inequality, in probing the quantum imprints of primordial perturbations when the initially chosen Bunch-Davies vacuum is replaced by a coherent state. Although it is based on the same principles of locality and realism, its primary advantage lies in the fact that it does not require two distinct set of observable for its construction. Instead, measurements performed on a single component of the pseudo-spin operator at different times are sufficient. Consequently, it is particularly well suited for cosmological scenarios, where observational constraints typically allow access to only one component of the pseudo-spin operator. Assuming a coherent state as the initial condition, we derive an analytical expression for the expectation value of the bipartite temporal Bell operator and demonstrate the absence of temporal Bell violation in such a scenario. Interestingly, the results for squeezed coherent state is found to differ - albeit slightly - from those of squeezed vacuum state for large values of the squeezing parameter. This suggests that the ability to distinguish among different initial states of primordial perturbations does not rely on the violation of temporal Bell inequality. Furthermore, the dependence of the temporal Bell inequality on a purely imaginary phase factor of the wave function appears to be an unique feature, which is entirely absent in the context of spatial Bell inequalities.
Abstract The inflationary universe creates particle pairs, which are entangled in their momenta due to momentum conservation. Operators involving the momenta of the fluctuations can be rewritten into pseudo-spin operators, such as the Gour-Khanna-Mann-Revzen (GKMR) pseudo-spin. Making use of these pseudo-spin operators, cosmological Bell inequalities can be formulated. The violation of these Bell inequalities indicates the quantum nature of primordial fluctuations. In this work, we focus on primordial curvature perturbations. Since curvature perturbations arise from gravity, their action includes the Gibbons-Hawking-York boundary term. We clarify the role of the boundary term in selecting suitable initial conditions for linear perturbations. After that, we proceed to the interactions of cosmological perturbations, including the bulk and boundary interaction terms, which introduce decoherence effects. These decoherence effects change the expectation value of the Bell operator, and gradually restore the Bell inequality. We describe this process by a “Bell test curve”, which offers a window around 5 e-folds for testing the quantum origin of cosmological perturbations. We also explore the possibility of extracting the information of the decoherence rate and the structure of primordial interactions from the Bell test curve.
The temperature measurements,
T, of the perturbed cosmic microwave background, performed by the cosmic background explorer satellite (COBE), are considered. A dichotomist function, $f=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$, is defined such that
f=+1 if $\ensuremath{\delta}T>0$ and $f=\ensuremath{-}1$ if $\ensuremath{\delta}T<0$, where $\ensuremath{\delta}T$ stands for the fluctuation of
T. Then, it is assumed that behind the appearance of these fluctuations there is local realism. Under this assumption, some specific Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequalities are proved for these fluctuation temperatures measured by COBE in the different sky directions. The calculation of these inequalities from the actual temperature measurements shows that these inequalities are not violated. This result cannot be anticipated by calculating the commutators of the cosmic density quantum operators. This must be remarked here since, in the case of a system of two entangled spin
21 particles, its CHSH inequalities violation can be inferred from the nonvanishing value of the corresponding spin measurement commutators. The above nonviolation of the observed cosmic CHSH inequalities is compatible with the existence of local realism behind the cosmic measurement results. Nevertheless, assuming again local realism, some new cosmic CHSH inequalities can be derived for the case of the WMAP measurements whose accuracy is better than the one of the above considered COBE measurements. More specifically, in the WMAP case, some significant cross correlations between the temperature and polarization maps are detected, and the new cosmic CHSH inequalities are the ones built with these cross correlations. Now, the occasional violation of these CHSH inequalities would mean the failure of the assumed local realism in accordance with the quantum origin of the primordial temperature and polarization fluctuations in the framework of standard inflation.