Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2003.00794 · Physical Review Letters

Quantum Refrigeration with Indefinite Causal Order

David Felce, Vlatko Vedral

Published Aug 11, 2020• 114 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose a thermodynamic refrigeration cycle which uses indefinite causal orders to achieve nonclassical cooling. The cycle cools a cold reservoir while consuming purity in a control qubit. We first show that the application to an input state of two identical thermalizing channels of temperature T in an indefinite causal order can result in an output state with a temperature not equal to T. We investigate the properties of the refrigeration cycle and show that thermodynamically, the result is compatible with unitary quantum mechanics in the circuit model but could not be achieved classically. We believe that this cycle could be implemented experimentally using tabletop photonics. Our result suggests the development of a new class of thermodynamic resource theories in which operations are allowed to be performed in an indefinite causal order.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.125.070603

Related papers

Quantum simulation of indefinite causal order induced quantum refrigeration

Huan Cao, Ning-Ning Wang, Zhian Jia +6 more

In the classical world, physical events always happen in a fixed causal order.However, it was recently revealed that quantum mechanics allows events to occur with indefinite causal order (ICO).In this study, we use an optical quantum switch to experimentally investigate the application of ICO in thermodynamic tasks.Specifically, we simulate the working system interacting with two identical thermal reservoirs in an ICO, observing the quantum heat extraction even though they are in thermal equilibrium where heat extraction is inaccessible by traditional thermal contact.Using such a process, we simulate an ICO refrigeration cycle and investigate its properties.We also show that by passing through the ICO channel multiple times, one can extract more heat per cycle and thus obtain a higher refrigeration performance.Our results suggest that the causal nonseparability can be a powerful resource for quantum thermodynamic tasks.

arXiv:2101.07979•Physical Review Research•Aug 16, 2022•32 citations

Experimental Realization of a Quantum Refrigerator Driven by Indefinite Causal Orders

Xinfang Nie, Xuanran Zhu, Keyi Huang +11 more

Indefinite causal order (ICO) is playing a key role in recent quantum technologies. Here, we experimentally study quantum thermodynamics driven by ICO on nuclear spins using the nuclear magnetic resonance system. We realize the ICO of two thermalizing channels to exhibit how the mechanism works, and show that the working substance can be cooled or heated albeit it undergoes thermal contacts with reservoirs of the same temperature. Moreover, we construct a single cycle of the ICO refrigerator based on the Maxwell's demon mechanism, and evaluate its performance by measuring the work consumption and the heat energy extracted from the low-temperature reservoir. Unlike classical refrigerators in which the coefficient of performance (COP) is perversely higher the closer the temperature of the high-temperature and low-temperature reservoirs are to each other, the ICO refrigerator's COP is always bounded to small values due to the nonunit success probability in projecting the ancillary qubit to the preferable subspace. To enhance the COP, we propose and experimentally demonstrate a general framework based on the density matrix exponentiation (DME) approach, as an extension to the ICO refrigeration. The COP is observed to be enhanced by more than 3 times with the DME approach. Our Letter demonstrates a new way for nonclassical heat exchange, and paves the way towards construction of quantum refrigerators on a quantum system.

arXiv:2011.12580•Physical Review Letters•Sep 1, 2022•67 citations

Anomalous heat flow and quantum Otto cycle with indefinite causal order

Qing-Feng Xue, Qi Zhang, Xu-Cai Zhuang +5 more

The principle that heat spontaneously flows from higher temperature to lower temperature is a cornerstone of classical thermodynamics, often assumed to be independent of the sequence of interactions. While this holds true for macroscopic systems at equilibrium, here we show that, when the order of interactions between two identical thermalization channels is indefinite, an anomalous heat flow emerges, whereby heat can sometime flow from a colder entity to a hotter one. Taking advantage of this anomalous heat flow, we design a quantum Otto cycle with indefinite causal order, which not only achieves refrigeration but also generates work. The anomalous heat flow and the quantum Otto cycle are experimentally simulated in a photonic quantum setup, which provides a proof-of-principle demonstration of the theory.

quant-pharXiv:2511.04028•Nov 7, 2025•0 citations

Quantum cooling activated by coherently-controlled thermalisation

Hanlin Nie, Tianfeng Feng, Samuel Longden +1 more

In this paper, we show that it is possible to significantly boost the heat extraction ability of the ICO fridge by applying N identical thermalising channels in a superposition of N cyclic causal orders[2], and that this can be further boosted in the ultracold regime by replacing the working qubit with a quDit working substance. Moreover, we show that for the alternative controlled-SWAPs scheme presented in [1] where one additionally has access to the reservoir qubits which are quantum correlated with the control-target system, the performance can be greatly enhanced in general (tripled for all N and temperatures). Then inspired by [3, 4], we show that quantum coherent control between thermalising a working system with one of N identical thermalising channels (where causal indefiniteness plays no role) yield same advantages in controlled-SWAPs scheme compared to the generalised N-SWITCH protocol for the thermodynamic task described in [1]. We also provide an experimental simulatable quantum cooling protocol with coherently-controlled thermalising channels and notice that it can outperform ICO refrigerator with some specific implementations of the thermalising channel in the case when we only have access to the control-target system. These 2 quantum cooling protocols bear much lower circuit complexity compared to the one with indefinite causal order which makes it more accessible for implementation of this type of nonclassical refrigerator with cutting edge quantum technologies.

arXiv:2201.06954•Jan 18, 2022•2 citations

Optimal Thermalization under Indefinite Causal Order with Identical and Asymmetric Baths

Neeraj Sharma, Parveen Kumar

Indefinite causal order (ICO), in which the order of quantum operations is placed in a coherent superposition, has been demonstrated to enhance various information-processing tasks. Here, we investigate its impact on the thermodynamic processes generated by thermalizing quantum channels. We consider a two-level system interacting with two thermal baths under a quantum SWITCH, with the channel order controlled coherently by an ancillary qubit. We derive closed-form expressions for the effective inverse temperature $β_f$ of the postselected system state for both identical and distinct bath temperatures, and identify the control-qubit parameters that maximize heating or cooling. Our analysis reveals how the diagonal and coherent components of the control-qubit state contribute separately to the temperature shift, and how their interplay enables departures from the thermal response attainable under protocols with a definite causal order within the thermodynamic setting considered here. Bath asymmetry enhances these effects, while reduced purity of the control qubit state suppresses them. These results provide a systematic framework for assessing SWITCH-based thermalization in the setting of indefinite causal order, and identify control-qubit coherence as a tunable resource.

quant-pharXiv:2511.17357•Physical Review A•Nov 24, 2025•0 citations

Refrigeration with Indefinite Causal Orders on a Cloud Quantum Computer

David Felce, Vlatko Vedral, Felix Tennie

We demonstrate non-classical cooling on the IBMq cloud quantum computer. We implement a recently proposed refrigeration protocol which relies upon indefinite causal order for its quantum advantage. We use quantum channels which, when used in a well-defined order, are useless for refrigeration. We are able to use them for refrigeration, however, by applying them in a superposition of different orders. Our protocol is by nature relatively robust to noise, and so can be implemented on this noisy platform. As far as the authors are aware, this is the first example of cloud quantum refrigeration.

arXiv:2107.12413•Jul 26, 2021•7 citations
We propose a thermodynamic refrigeration cycle which uses indefinite causal orders to achieve nonclassical cooling. The cycle cools a cold reservoir while consuming purity in a control qubit. We first show that the application to an input state of two identical thermalizing channels of temperature T in an indefinite causal order can result in an output state with a temperature not equal to T. We investigate the properties of the refrigeration cycle and show that thermodynamically, the result is compatible with unitary quantum mechanics in the circuit model but could not be achieved classically. We believe that this cycle could be implemented experimentally using tabletop photonics. Our result suggests the development of a new class of thermodynamic resource theories in which operations are allowed to be performed in an indefinite causal order.
In the classical world, physical events always happen in a fixed causal order.However, it was recently revealed that quantum mechanics allows events to occur with indefinite causal order (ICO).In this study, we use an optical quantum switch to experimentally investigate the application of ICO in thermodynamic tasks.Specifically, we simulate the working system interacting with two identical thermal reservoirs in an ICO, observing the quantum heat extraction even though they are in thermal equilibrium where heat extraction is inaccessible by traditional thermal contact.Using such a process, we simulate an ICO refrigeration cycle and investigate its properties.We also show that by passing through the ICO channel multiple times, one can extract more heat per cycle and thus obtain a higher refrigeration performance.Our results suggest that the causal nonseparability can be a powerful resource for quantum thermodynamic tasks.
Indefinite causal order (ICO) is playing a key role in recent quantum technologies. Here, we experimentally study quantum thermodynamics driven by ICO on nuclear spins using the nuclear magnetic resonance system. We realize the ICO of two thermalizing channels to exhibit how the mechanism works, and show that the working substance can be cooled or heated albeit it undergoes thermal contacts with reservoirs of the same temperature. Moreover, we construct a single cycle of the ICO refrigerator based on the Maxwell's demon mechanism, and evaluate its performance by measuring the work consumption and the heat energy extracted from the low-temperature reservoir. Unlike classical refrigerators in which the coefficient of performance (COP) is perversely higher the closer the temperature of the high-temperature and low-temperature reservoirs are to each other, the ICO refrigerator's COP is always bounded to small values due to the nonunit success probability in projecting the ancillary qubit to the preferable subspace. To enhance the COP, we propose and experimentally demonstrate a general framework based on the density matrix exponentiation (DME) approach, as an extension to the ICO refrigeration. The COP is observed to be enhanced by more than 3 times with the DME approach. Our Letter demonstrates a new way for nonclassical heat exchange, and paves the way towards construction of quantum refrigerators on a quantum system.
The principle that heat spontaneously flows from higher temperature to lower temperature is a cornerstone of classical thermodynamics, often assumed to be independent of the sequence of interactions. While this holds true for macroscopic systems at equilibrium, here we show that, when the order of interactions between two identical thermalization channels is indefinite, an anomalous heat flow emerges, whereby heat can sometime flow from a colder entity to a hotter one. Taking advantage of this anomalous heat flow, we design a quantum Otto cycle with indefinite causal order, which not only achieves refrigeration but also generates work. The anomalous heat flow and the quantum Otto cycle are experimentally simulated in a photonic quantum setup, which provides a proof-of-principle demonstration of the theory.
In this paper, we show that it is possible to significantly boost the heat extraction ability of the ICO fridge by applying N identical thermalising channels in a superposition of N cyclic causal orders[2], and that this can be further boosted in the ultracold regime by replacing the working qubit with a quDit working substance. Moreover, we show that for the alternative controlled-SWAPs scheme presented in [1] where one additionally has access to the reservoir qubits which are quantum correlated with the control-target system, the performance can be greatly enhanced in general (tripled for all N and temperatures). Then inspired by [3, 4], we show that quantum coherent control between thermalising a working system with one of N identical thermalising channels (where causal indefiniteness plays no role) yield same advantages in controlled-SWAPs scheme compared to the generalised N-SWITCH protocol for the thermodynamic task described in [1]. We also provide an experimental simulatable quantum cooling protocol with coherently-controlled thermalising channels and notice that it can outperform ICO refrigerator with some specific implementations of the thermalising channel in the case when we only have access to the control-target system. These 2 quantum cooling protocols bear much lower circuit complexity compared to the one with indefinite causal order which makes it more accessible for implementation of this type of nonclassical refrigerator with cutting edge quantum technologies.
Indefinite causal order (ICO), in which the order of quantum operations is placed in a coherent superposition, has been demonstrated to enhance various information-processing tasks. Here, we investigate its impact on the thermodynamic processes generated by thermalizing quantum channels. We consider a two-level system interacting with two thermal baths under a quantum SWITCH, with the channel order controlled coherently by an ancillary qubit. We derive closed-form expressions for the effective inverse temperature βfβ_fβf​ of the postselected system state for both identical and distinct bath temperatures, and identify the control-qubit parameters that maximize heating or cooling. Our analysis reveals how the diagonal and coherent components of the control-qubit state contribute separately to the temperature shift, and how their interplay enables departures from the thermal response attainable under protocols with a definite causal order within the thermodynamic setting considered here. Bath asymmetry enhances these effects, while reduced purity of the control qubit state suppresses them. These results provide a systematic framework for assessing SWITCH-based thermalization in the setting of indefinite causal order, and identify control-qubit coherence as a tunable resource.
We demonstrate non-classical cooling on the IBMq cloud quantum computer. We implement a recently proposed refrigeration protocol which relies upon indefinite causal order for its quantum advantage. We use quantum channels which, when used in a well-defined order, are useless for refrigeration. We are able to use them for refrigeration, however, by applying them in a superposition of different orders. Our protocol is by nature relatively robust to noise, and so can be implemented on this noisy platform. As far as the authors are aware, this is the first example of cloud quantum refrigeration.