In quantum lattice systems, we prove that any stationary state with power-law (or even exponential) decay of spatial correlations has vanishing macroscopic temporal order in the thermodynamic limit. Assuming translational invariance, we obtain a similar bound on the temporal order between local operators at late times. Our proofs do not require any locality of the Hamiltonian. Applications in quantum time crystals are briefly discussed.
In quantum lattice systems, we prove that any stationary state with power-law (or even exponential) decay of spatial correlations has vanishing macroscopic temporal order in the thermodynamic limit. Assuming translational invariance, we obtain a similar bound on the temporal order between local operators at late times. Our proofs do not require any locality of the Hamiltonian. Applications in quantum time crystals are briefly discussed.
Abstract We address the question whether time translation symmetry can be spontaneously broken in a quantum many-body system. One way of detecting such a symmetry breaking is to examine the time-dependence of a correlation function. If the large-distance behavior of the correlation function exhibits a nontrivial time-dependence in the thermodynamic limit, the system would develop a temporal long-range order, realizing a time crystal. In an earlier publication, we sketched a proof for the absence of such time dependence in the thermal equilibrium described by the Gibbs state (Watanabe and Oshikawa in Phys Rev Lett 114:251603, 2015). Here we present a complete proof and extend the argument to a more general class of stationary states than the Gibbs states.
We study the relation between the spectral gap above the ground state and the decay of the correlations in the ground state in quantum spin and fermion systems with short-range interactions on a wide class of lattices. We prove that, if two observables anticommute with each other at large distance, then the nonvanishing spectral gap implies exponential decay of the corresponding correlation. When two observables commute with each other at large distance, the connected correlation function decays exponentially under the gap assumption. If the observables behave as a vector under the U(1) rotation of a global symmetry of the system, we use previous results on the large distance decay of the correlation function to show the stronger statement that the correlation function itself, rather than just the connected correlation function, decays exponentially under the gap assumption on a lattice with a certain self-similarity in (fractal) dimensions D < 2. In particular, if the system is translationally invariant in one of the spatial directions, then this self-similarity condition is automatically satisfied. We also treat systems with long-range, power-law decaying interactions. Spectral Gap and Exponential Decay of Correlations 2 1
We study correlations in fermionic lattice systems with long-range interactions in thermal equilibrium. We prove a bound on the correlation decay between anticommuting operators and generalize a long-range Lieb-Robinson-type bound. Our results show that in these systems of spatial dimension D with, not necessarily translation invariant, two-site interactions decaying algebraically with the distance with an exponent α≥2D, correlations between such operators decay at least algebraically to 0 with an exponent arbitrarily close to α at any nonzero temperature. Our bound is asymptotically tight, which we demonstrate by a high temperature expansion and by numerically analyzing density-density correlations in the one-dimensional quadratic (free, exactly solvable) Kitaev chain with long-range pairing.
It has been proved that in gapped ground states of locally interacting lattice quantum systems with a finite local Hilbert space, the effect of local perturbations decays exponentially with distance.However, in systems with power-law-(1/r α ) decaying interactions, no analogous statement has been shown and there are serious mathematical obstacles to proving it with existing methods.In this paper, we prove that when α exceeds the spatial dimension D, the effect of local perturbations on local properties a distance r away is upper bounded by a power law 1/r α 1 in gapped ground states, provided that the perturbations do not close the spectral gap.The power-law exponent α 1 is tight if α > 2D and interactions are two-body, where we have α 1 = α.The proof is enabled by a method that avoids the use of quasiadiabatic continuation and incorporates techniques of complex analysis.This method also improves bounds on ground-state correlation decay, even in short-range interacting systems.Our work generalizes the fundamental notion that local perturbations have local effects to power-law interacting systems, with broad implications for numerical simulations and experiments.
For a class of tight-binding many-electron models on hypercubic lattices, the equal-time correlation functions at nonzero temperature are proved to decay exponentially in the distance between the center of positions of the electrons and the center of positions of the holes. The decay bounds hold in any space dimension in the thermodynamic limit if the interaction is sufficiently small depending on temperature. The proof is based on the U(1)-invariance property and volume-independent perturbative bounds of the finite dimensional Grassmann integrals formulating the correlation functions.
This thesis analyses several locality properties of extended quantum lattice systems, considering both spins and fermions. We begin by assuming locality of the Hamiltonian and then discuss how this translates into locality of the time evolution and the thermal states. Starting from a local Hamiltonian, it is well known that the Heisenberg time evolution satisfies Lieb-Robinson bounds, which quantify its locality. We strengthen these bounds for long-range interacting fermions and for commuting interactions. Furthermore, we establish the first Lieb-Robinson bounds for Hamiltonians whose local terms can grow linearly away from the origin. We also prove stability of Lieb-Robinson bounds with respect to local perturbations in the Hamiltonian. For the thermal states we focus on three types of locality known as decay of correlations, the local perturbations perturb locally (LPPL) principle and local indistinguishability. As a key tool we use spectral filters, which were introduced by Hastings in the 2000s for various applications. It enable us to use Lieb-Robinson bounds to obtain information about locality properties of states. In particular, we use quantum belief propagation to prove an equivalence of decay of correlations, LPPL and local indistinguishability for Gibbs states at any positive temperature. Using the improved Lieb-Robinson bounds mentioned before, we obtain improvements for decay of correlations in the ground state, the locality of the spectral flow and LPPL for long-range interacting systems and commuting Hamiltonians. Furthermore, we adjust the filter functions to achieve exponential decay for certain applications that were previously limited to stretched exponential decay. Spectral filters are also used to rigorously justify response theory, which usually requires a gapped system to begin with. To relax this assumption, we introduce various notions of local gaps, discuss their relations and use one to justify response theory and Kubo’s formula in the absence of a global gap. In another result we use local indistinguishability as an input to prove bulk-edge correspondence at finite temperature, in the sense that the bulk magnetisation is equal to the edge current. This result has mostly been studied for non-interacting models or at zero temperature before. Finally, we present a class of weakly interacting spin systems with an on-site gap and prove that the ground state satisfies a strong form of LPPL. Moreover, we show that these systems satisfy decay of correlations and local indistinguishability uniformly in temperature.