Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1911.12953 · Physical Review A

Atomic test of higher-order interference

Kai Sheng Lee, Zhao Zhuo, Christophe Couteau, David Wilkowski, Tomasz Paterek

Published May 18, 2020• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum mechanics predicts that interference arising from multiple slits can be reduced to a sum of outcomes from the simpler one- and two-slit counterparts. Testing deviations from these results has been discussed as testing the validity of Born's rule. Here an experiment that considers the evolution between three levels of an atom as the quantum paths is devised, providing precision tools that can be used to test universality of Born's and to constrain theories designed to supersede quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.101.052111

Related papers

Ruling Out Multi-Order Interference in Quantum Mechanics

Urbasi Sinha, Christophe Couteau, Thomas D. Jennewein +2 more

Quantum mechanics and gravitation are two pillars of modern physics. Despite their success in describing the physical world around us, they seem to be incompatible theories. There are suggestions that one of these theories must be generalized to achieve unification. For example, Born's rule--one of the axioms of quantum mechanics--could be violated. Born's rule predicts that quantum interference, as shown by a double-slit diffraction experiment, occurs from pairs of paths. A generalized version of quantum mechanics might allow multipath (i.e., higher-order) interference, thus leading to a deviation from the theory. We performed a three-slit experiment with photons and bounded the magnitude of three-path interference to less than 10(-2) of the expected two-path interference, thus ruling out third- and higher-order interference and providing a bound on the accuracy of Born's rule. Our experiment is consistent with the postulate both in semiclassical and quantum regimes.

arXiv:1007.4193•Science•Jul 22, 2010•233 citations

Born Rule(s)

Urbasi Sinha, Dipankar Home, Guruprasad Kar +1 more

This paper is based on work published in [1]. It describes a triple slit experiment using single photons that has been used to provide a bound on one of the most fundamental axioms of quantum mechanics i.e. Born’s rule for probabilities [2]. In spite of being one of the most successful theories which describes various natural phenomena, quantum mechanics has enough intricacies and “weirdness” associated with it which makes many physicists believe that it may not be the final theory and hints towards the possibility of more generalized versions. Quantum interference as shown by a double slit diffraction experiment only occurs from pairs of paths. Even in multi‐slit versions, interference can only occur between pairs of possibilities and increasing the number of slits does not increase the complexity of the theory that still remains second‐order. However, more generalized versions of quantum mechanics may allow for multi‐path i.e. higher than second order interference. This experiment also provides a bound on the magnitude of such higher order interference. We have been able to bound the magnitude of three‐path interference to less than 10−2 of the expected two‐path interference, thus ruling out third and higher order interference and providing a bound on the accuracy of Born’s rule.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

A triple slit test for quantum mechanics

Urbasi Sinha, Christophe Couteau, Fay Dowker B +3 more

As one of the postulates of quantum mechanics, Born's rule tells us how to get probabilities for experimental outcomes from the complex wave function of the system. Its quadratic nature entails that interference occurs in pairs of paths. We present an experiment that sets out to test the correctness of Born's rule by testing for the presence or absence of genuine three-path interference. This is done using single photons and a three slit aperture.

•Jan 1, 2010•1 citation

Testing Born’s Rule in Quantum Mechanics with a Triple Slit Experiment

Urbasi Sinha, Christophe Couteau, Zachari Medendorp +11 more

In Mod. Phys. Lett. A 9, 3119 (1994), one of us (R.D.S) investigated a formulation of quantum mechanics as a generalized measure theory. Quantum mechanics computes probabilities from the absolute squares of complex amplitudes, and the resulting interference violates the (Kolmogorov) sum rule expressing the additivity of probabilities of mutually exclusive events. However, there is a higher order sum rule that quantum mechanics does obey, involving the probabilities of three mutually exclusive possibilities. We could imagine a yet more general theory by assuming that it violates the next higher sum rule. In this paper, we report results from an ongoing experiment that sets out to test the validity of this second sum rule by measuring the interference patterns produced by three slits and all the possible combinations of those slits being open or closed. We use attenuated laser light combined with single photon counting to confirm the particle character of the measured light.

arXiv:0811.2068•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2009•50 citations

Experimental higher-order interference in a nonlinear triple slit

Peter Namdar, Philipp K. Jenke, Irati Alonso Calafell +5 more

Interference between two waves is a well-known concept in physics, and its generalization to more than two waves is straightforward. The order of interference is defined as the number of paths that interfere in a manner that cannot be reduced to patterns of a lower order. In practice, second-order interference means that in, say, a triple-slit experiment, the interference pattern when all three slits are open can be predicted from the interference patterns between all possible pairs of slits. Quantum mechanics is often said to only exhibit second-order interference. However, this is only true under specific assumptions, typically single particles undergoing linear evolution. Here we experimentally show that nonlinear evolution can in fact lead to higher-order interference. The higher-order interference in our experiment can be understood using a simple classical or quantum description, namely optical coherent states interacting in a nonlinear medium. Our work shows that nonlinear evolution could open a loophole for experiments attempting to verify Born's rule by ruling out higher-order interference.

arXiv:2112.06965•Physical Review A•Mar 13, 2023•11 citations

Effects of detector size and position on a test of Born's rule using a three-slit experiment

Etienne Gagnon, Christopher D. Brown, Amy L. Lytle

Recent high-precision measurements in a three-slit diffraction experiment [Sinha et al., Science 329, 418 (2010)] have been performed as an explicit test of the validity of Born's rule for quantum probabilities. This experiment aims to establish an upper limit to the possibility of higher-order interference, which, if observed, could support generalization of quantum probability theory. We reproduce this three-slit experiment using position-resolved detection, compare our results to a computational model, and find significant limitations to the normalization scheme proposed by Sinha et al. that influence interpretation. We further show that the dependence of the measurements on detector size and position must be taken into account for proper interpretation of results and meaningful comparison with other experimental schemes.

Physical Review A•Jul 23, 2014•9 citations
Quantum mechanics predicts that interference arising from multiple slits can be reduced to a sum of outcomes from the simpler one- and two-slit counterparts. Testing deviations from these results has been discussed as testing the validity of Born's rule. Here an experiment that considers the evolution between three levels of an atom as the quantum paths is devised, providing precision tools that can be used to test universality of Born's and to constrain theories designed to supersede quantum mechanics.
Quantum mechanics and gravitation are two pillars of modern physics. Despite their success in describing the physical world around us, they seem to be incompatible theories. There are suggestions that one of these theories must be generalized to achieve unification. For example, Born's rule--one of the axioms of quantum mechanics--could be violated. Born's rule predicts that quantum interference, as shown by a double-slit diffraction experiment, occurs from pairs of paths. A generalized version of quantum mechanics might allow multipath (i.e., higher-order) interference, thus leading to a deviation from the theory. We performed a three-slit experiment with photons and bounded the magnitude of three-path interference to less than 10(-2) of the expected two-path interference, thus ruling out third- and higher-order interference and providing a bound on the accuracy of Born's rule. Our experiment is consistent with the postulate both in semiclassical and quantum regimes.
This paper is based on work published in [1]. It describes a triple slit experiment using single photons that has been used to provide a bound on one of the most fundamental axioms of quantum mechanics i.e. Born’s rule for probabilities [2]. In spite of being one of the most successful theories which describes various natural phenomena, quantum mechanics has enough intricacies and “weirdness” associated with it which makes many physicists believe that it may not be the final theory and hints towards the possibility of more generalized versions. Quantum interference as shown by a double slit diffraction experiment only occurs from pairs of paths. Even in multi‐slit versions, interference can only occur between pairs of possibilities and increasing the number of slits does not increase the complexity of the theory that still remains second‐order. However, more generalized versions of quantum mechanics may allow for multi‐path i.e. higher than second order interference. This experiment also provides a bound on the magnitude of such higher order interference. We have been able to bound the magnitude of three‐path interference to less than 10−2 of the expected two‐path interference, thus ruling out third and higher order interference and providing a bound on the accuracy of Born’s rule.
In Mod. Phys. Lett. A 9, 3119 (1994), one of us (R.D.S) investigated a formulation of quantum mechanics as a generalized measure theory. Quantum mechanics computes probabilities from the absolute squares of complex amplitudes, and the resulting interference violates the (Kolmogorov) sum rule expressing the additivity of probabilities of mutually exclusive events. However, there is a higher order sum rule that quantum mechanics does obey, involving the probabilities of three mutually exclusive possibilities. We could imagine a yet more general theory by assuming that it violates the next higher sum rule. In this paper, we report results from an ongoing experiment that sets out to test the validity of this second sum rule by measuring the interference patterns produced by three slits and all the possible combinations of those slits being open or closed. We use attenuated laser light combined with single photon counting to confirm the particle character of the measured light.
Interference between two waves is a well-known concept in physics, and its generalization to more than two waves is straightforward. The order of interference is defined as the number of paths that interfere in a manner that cannot be reduced to patterns of a lower order. In practice, second-order interference means that in, say, a triple-slit experiment, the interference pattern when all three slits are open can be predicted from the interference patterns between all possible pairs of slits. Quantum mechanics is often said to only exhibit second-order interference. However, this is only true under specific assumptions, typically single particles undergoing linear evolution. Here we experimentally show that nonlinear evolution can in fact lead to higher-order interference. The higher-order interference in our experiment can be understood using a simple classical or quantum description, namely optical coherent states interacting in a nonlinear medium. Our work shows that nonlinear evolution could open a loophole for experiments attempting to verify Born's rule by ruling out higher-order interference.
Recent high-precision measurements in a three-slit diffraction experiment [Sinha et al., Science 329, 418 (2010)] have been performed as an explicit test of the validity of Born's rule for quantum probabilities. This experiment aims to establish an upper limit to the possibility of higher-order interference, which, if observed, could support generalization of quantum probability theory. We reproduce this three-slit experiment using position-resolved detection, compare our results to a computational model, and find significant limitations to the normalization scheme proposed by Sinha et al. that influence interpretation. We further show that the dependence of the measurements on detector size and position must be taken into account for proper interpretation of results and meaningful comparison with other experimental schemes.