Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1911.12169 · Physical Review A

Regimes of atomic diffraction: Raman versus Bragg diffraction in retroreflective geometries

Sabrina Hartmann, Jens Jenewein, Enno Giese, Sven Abend, Albert Roura, Ernst Maria Rasel, Wolfgang P. Schleich

Published May 8, 2020• 45 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We provide a comprehensive study of atomic Raman and Bragg diffraction when coupling to a pair of counterpropagating light gratings (double diffraction) or to a single one (single diffraction) and discuss the transition from one case to the other in a retroreflective geometry as the Doppler detuning changes. In contrast to single diffraction, double Raman loses its advantage of high diffraction efficiency for short pulses and has to be performed in a Bragg-type regime. Moreover, the structure of double diffraction leads to further limitations for broad momentum distributions on the efficiency of mirror pulses, making the use of (ultra)cold ensembles essential for high diffraction efficiency.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.101.053610

Related papers

Atomic Raman scattering: Third-order diffraction in a double geometry

Sabrina Hartmann, Jens Jenewein, Sven Abend +2 more

In a retroreflective scheme with an atom initially at rest, atomic Raman diffraction adopts some of the properties of Bragg diffraction due to additional couplings to off-resonant momenta. As a consequence, double Raman diffraction has to be performed in a Bragg-type regime, where the pulse duration is sufficiently long to suppress diffraction into spurious orders. Taking advantage of this regime, double Raman allows for resonant higher-order diffraction. We study theoretically the case of third-order diffraction and compare it to first order as well as a sequence of first-order Raman pulses giving rise to the same momentum transfer as the third-order pulse. Moreover, we demonstrate that interferometry is possible, and we investigate amplitude and contrast of a third-order double Raman Mach-Zehnder interferometer. In fact, third-order diffraction constitutes a competitive tool for the diffraction of ultracold atoms and interferometry based on large momentum transfer since it allows one to reduce the complexity of the experiment as well as the total duration of the diffraction process compared to a sequence, at the cost of higher pulse intensities.

arXiv:2007.02635•Physical Review A•Dec 22, 2020•15 citations

Double Bragg diffraction: A tool for atom optics

Enno Giese, Albert Roura, Gunnar Tackmann +2 more

The use of retroreflection in light-pulse atom interferometry under microgravity conditions naturally leads to a double-diffraction scheme. The two pairs of counterpropagating beams induce simultaneously transitions with opposite momentum transfer that, when acting on atoms initially at rest, give rise to symmetric interferometer configurations where the total momentum transfer is automatically doubled and where a number of noise sources and systematic effects cancel out. Here we extend earlier implementations for Raman transitions to the case of Bragg diffraction. In contrast with the single-diffraction case, the existence of additional off-resonant transitions between resonantly connected states precludes the use of the adiabatic elimination technique. Nevertheless, we have been able to obtain analytic results even beyond the deep Bragg regime by employing the so-called ``method of averaging,'' which can be applied to more general situations of this kind. Our results have been validated by comparison to numerical solutions of the basic equations describing the double-diffraction process.

arXiv:1308.5205•Physical Review A•Nov 8, 2013•89 citations

Atomic raman diffraction: Theoretical perspectives from semi-classical to second quantized frameworks

Hartmann, Sabrina

This cumulative thesis consists of four publications [1-4], presented as three contributions (I) - (III), where the second one (II) consists of the joint publications [2,3]. All publications were written during the author's research activities at the Institute of Quantum Physics under the supervision of Prof. Dr. W. P. Schleich. All of the presented publications consider light-matter interactions and their potential application in atom interferometry, a comparatively young and rapidly evolving technique. Atom interferometers find application in high-precision measurements, the determination of physical constants, the testing of fundamental physics, and the provision of gravimeters and gyroscopes. The advancement of technology and science has led to significant improvements in performance and the development of ambitious mobile and space-based devices. The recent success of several experiments has led to the proposal of further experiments with the aim of opening up new frontiers. However, the construction of future devices necessitates a decision regarding the employed diffraction mechanism and geometry, depending on the specific technical and scientific requirements. Furthermore, it is necessary to enhance the sensitivity of future devices. The contributions in this dissertation address these issues. The first contribution (I) focuses on the diffraction of atoms by laser pulses which can be employed to generate atom-optical diffraction elements like beam splitters and mirrors. These diffraction elements can be combined to construct atom interferometers, which have been successfully employed for precision measurements regarding fundamental physics as well as practical applications. The article presents a numerical comparison of two distinct diffraction mechanisms (Bragg and Raman) and diffraction geometries (single and double diffraction) in microgravity. It discusses the fundamental differences between the mechanisms and geometries with respect to the diffraction efficiency, taking into account the width of the initial wave function and the duration of the light pulse. Additionally, it explores the transition between the two diffraction geometries when starting from an atom initially at rest and increasing its momentum. The results may serve as a reference for experimentalists in selecting the most suitable configuration, based on their aims and requirements in the realization of more advanced atom interferometers. The second contribution (II) is a follow-up to the previous one, but focuses exclusively on a single diffraction type in microgravity, namely the so-called double Raman diffraction. In contrast to the previous article, where we only discussed single two-photon processes, we consider in this article a six-photon process, also known as third-order diffraction, as well as three subsequent two-photon processes, which both lead to the same amount of transferred momentum and can both be used to realize large-momentum transfer (LMT). We demonstrate that third-order double Raman diffraction is a viable and advantageous method for the diffraction of small momentum distributions like Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) compared to a sequence of three two-photon processes. Furthermore, we show that third-order Raman pulses can be successfully applied to create higher-order Raman atom interferometers. Third-order diffraction can be perfectly combined with other LMT techniques and, moreover, allows for a reduction in the overall duration of the diffraction process and the complexity of the experimental set-up, as only two distinct laser frequencies are required. Moreover, we present a third-order Mach-Zehnder interferometer with spurious paths being disregarded. As demonstrated later on in [3], this interferometer generates optimal contrast and a substantial amplitude. The third contribution (III) extends the semi-classical λ-scheme of single Raman diffraction, as discussed in detail in contribution (I), into a fully quantized multi-atom multi-λ configuration with center-of-mass motion inside a cavity. Therefore, the incorporation of an internal structure allows for a more realistic modeling of the atoms, which is relevant for multi-photon interaction or cooling processes. We use for our analysis the framework of second quantization, i.e., we take into account the field-theoretical nature of the multi-particle atomic field as well as of the diffracting light field. We reduce this model with a Hamiltonian averaging theory applied to the atomic field operators and obtain an effective Hamiltonian, which determines the time evolution of the system. We demonstrate the efficiency of our model by the application of a typical initial state. Moreover, for a specific input state, we obtain the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect simultaneously in the atomic and the optical system. Our many-body formalism is perfectly suited to theoretically describe contemporary high-precision atom interferometric experiments based on entanglement between the atoms, that aim to surpass the shot-noise limit.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Aberrations of atomic diffraction - From ultracold atoms to hot ions

Antje Neumann

Atomic diffraction is the central concept of matter-wave interferometers, which provide the opportunity of high-precision rotation and acceleration sensing. Ultracold atoms are the ultimate quantum sensors for this purpose. Transferring photon momentum from two counterpropagating laser beams to atomic wavepackets prepares coherent superpositions in the momentum space, realising atomic beamsplitters and mirrors. Like classical optical systems, these matter-wave devices require exact specifications and ubiquitous imperfections need to be quantified. Therefore, in this thesis, the performance of (3+1)D atomic beamsplitters in the quasi-Bragg regime is studied numerically as well as analytically and is confirmed by experimental data [1]. Ideally, the incoming wavepacket can be split exactly into two parts or reflected perfectly with unit response, independent of its spatial and velocity distribution. However, the velocity selectivity of the Bragg diffraction, as well as losses into undesired diffraction orders in the quasi-Bragg regime, constitute aberrations, which cannot be neglected. The non-ideal behaviour due to spatial variations of the laser beam profiles and wavefront curvatures, regarding realistic Laguerre-Gaussian laser beams instead of ideal plane waves, reduces the diffraction efficiency and leads to rogue momentum components, just like misaligned lasers. In contrast, smooth temporal envelopes improve the beamsplitter performance. Different pulse shapes are taken into account, where some are amenable for closed analytical solutions. The realistic modelling and exhausting aberration studies characterises in detail atomic Bragg beamsplitters and demonstrate pathways for improvements, both required by challenging experiments. For hot ions in accelerator beams the atomic diffraction is used contrary to generate a velocity filter. Two counterpropagating far-detuned lasers transfer a narrow velocity class of ions from an initially broad distribution via a stimulated Raman transition between the ground states of a Λ-system. This colder subensemble prepares optimal initial conditions for precision collinear laser spectroscopy on fast ion beams. The efficiency of the filter is diminished by aberrations like the spontaneous emission from the two single-photon resonances, as well as the ground-state decoherence induced by laser noise. Spatial intensity variations of the ion and laser beams are considered, whereas wavefront curvature is negligible. A comprehensive master equation leads to conditions for the optimal frequency pair of lasers. The time-resolved population transfer characterises the filter performance and is evaluated numerically as well as analytically. Derived models match the numerical results, keeping the computational effort small. Taking into account the mentioned aberrations, the possible use of Raman transition as velocity filter for hot ions is demonstrated. Velocity classes with widths as low as 0.2 m/s can be transferred, achieving a significant population proportion from per mill to percent. Applying the analysis to current 40-Ca+ ion experiments, a sensitivity for measuring high ion acceleration voltages on the ppm level or below is substantiated.

•Jan 1, 2021•2 citations

Mechanisms of matter-wave diffraction and their application to interferometers

Enno Giese

Light pulses have proven to be a powerful and versatile tool to implement beam splitters and mirrors for matter waves enabling atom interferometers. However, for high-precision measurements with such devices the specific realization is crucial and novel techniques might increase the sensitivity. To illustrate the diversity of light-pulse beam splitting and the subtle differences between the diffraction mechanisms, we study atomic Raman, Bragg, and the new method of double Bragg diffraction in a coherent way. Moreover, we introduce a versatile formalism to determine the interference signal of a Mach-Zehnder geometry and give an interpretation in terms of proper-time difference. In addition, we explore the feasibility of a specular mirror for atoms, which might lead to an interferometer testing the equivalence principle.

Fortschritte der Physik•Jun 1, 2015•33 citations

Adiabatic-rapid-passage multiphoton Bragg atom optics

Tim Kovachy, Sheng‐wey Chiow, Mark A. Kasevich

The combination of adiabatic rapid passage and multiphoton Bragg diffraction (ARPMB pulses) to efficiently transfer many photon recoils of momentum ($\ensuremath{\hbar}k$) to cold-atom clouds is theoretically and experimentally investigated. This method is insensitive to perturbations of the pulse intensity or detuning. In particular, the theoretically calculated velocity acceptance can be up to $80%$ of one recoil velocity ${v}_{r}$, the theoretical maximum in Bragg diffraction. We experimentally demonstrate ARPMB pulses with transfer efficiency of 99.7$%$ per $\ensuremath{\hbar}k$ using $10\ensuremath{\hbar}k$ pulses, limited by spontaneous emission losses, and Mach-Zehnder interferometers with $80%$ contrast.

Physical Review A•Jul 20, 2012•57 citations
We provide a comprehensive study of atomic Raman and Bragg diffraction when coupling to a pair of counterpropagating light gratings (double diffraction) or to a single one (single diffraction) and discuss the transition from one case to the other in a retroreflective geometry as the Doppler detuning changes. In contrast to single diffraction, double Raman loses its advantage of high diffraction efficiency for short pulses and has to be performed in a Bragg-type regime. Moreover, the structure of double diffraction leads to further limitations for broad momentum distributions on the efficiency of mirror pulses, making the use of (ultra)cold ensembles essential for high diffraction efficiency.
In a retroreflective scheme with an atom initially at rest, atomic Raman diffraction adopts some of the properties of Bragg diffraction due to additional couplings to off-resonant momenta. As a consequence, double Raman diffraction has to be performed in a Bragg-type regime, where the pulse duration is sufficiently long to suppress diffraction into spurious orders. Taking advantage of this regime, double Raman allows for resonant higher-order diffraction. We study theoretically the case of third-order diffraction and compare it to first order as well as a sequence of first-order Raman pulses giving rise to the same momentum transfer as the third-order pulse. Moreover, we demonstrate that interferometry is possible, and we investigate amplitude and contrast of a third-order double Raman Mach-Zehnder interferometer. In fact, third-order diffraction constitutes a competitive tool for the diffraction of ultracold atoms and interferometry based on large momentum transfer since it allows one to reduce the complexity of the experiment as well as the total duration of the diffraction process compared to a sequence, at the cost of higher pulse intensities.
The use of retroreflection in light-pulse atom interferometry under microgravity conditions naturally leads to a double-diffraction scheme. The two pairs of counterpropagating beams induce simultaneously transitions with opposite momentum transfer that, when acting on atoms initially at rest, give rise to symmetric interferometer configurations where the total momentum transfer is automatically doubled and where a number of noise sources and systematic effects cancel out. Here we extend earlier implementations for Raman transitions to the case of Bragg diffraction. In contrast with the single-diffraction case, the existence of additional off-resonant transitions between resonantly connected states precludes the use of the adiabatic elimination technique. Nevertheless, we have been able to obtain analytic results even beyond the deep Bragg regime by employing the so-called ``method of averaging,'' which can be applied to more general situations of this kind. Our results have been validated by comparison to numerical solutions of the basic equations describing the double-diffraction process.
This cumulative thesis consists of four publications [1-4], presented as three contributions (I) - (III), where the second one (II) consists of the joint publications [2,3]. All publications were written during the author's research activities at the Institute of Quantum Physics under the supervision of Prof. Dr. W. P. Schleich. All of the presented publications consider light-matter interactions and their potential application in atom interferometry, a comparatively young and rapidly evolving technique. Atom interferometers find application in high-precision measurements, the determination of physical constants, the testing of fundamental physics, and the provision of gravimeters and gyroscopes. The advancement of technology and science has led to significant improvements in performance and the development of ambitious mobile and space-based devices. The recent success of several experiments has led to the proposal of further experiments with the aim of opening up new frontiers. However, the construction of future devices necessitates a decision regarding the employed diffraction mechanism and geometry, depending on the specific technical and scientific requirements. Furthermore, it is necessary to enhance the sensitivity of future devices. The contributions in this dissertation address these issues. The first contribution (I) focuses on the diffraction of atoms by laser pulses which can be employed to generate atom-optical diffraction elements like beam splitters and mirrors. These diffraction elements can be combined to construct atom interferometers, which have been successfully employed for precision measurements regarding fundamental physics as well as practical applications. The article presents a numerical comparison of two distinct diffraction mechanisms (Bragg and Raman) and diffraction geometries (single and double diffraction) in microgravity. It discusses the fundamental differences between the mechanisms and geometries with respect to the diffraction efficiency, taking into account the width of the initial wave function and the duration of the light pulse. Additionally, it explores the transition between the two diffraction geometries when starting from an atom initially at rest and increasing its momentum. The results may serve as a reference for experimentalists in selecting the most suitable configuration, based on their aims and requirements in the realization of more advanced atom interferometers. The second contribution (II) is a follow-up to the previous one, but focuses exclusively on a single diffraction type in microgravity, namely the so-called double Raman diffraction. In contrast to the previous article, where we only discussed single two-photon processes, we consider in this article a six-photon process, also known as third-order diffraction, as well as three subsequent two-photon processes, which both lead to the same amount of transferred momentum and can both be used to realize large-momentum transfer (LMT). We demonstrate that third-order double Raman diffraction is a viable and advantageous method for the diffraction of small momentum distributions like Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) compared to a sequence of three two-photon processes. Furthermore, we show that third-order Raman pulses can be successfully applied to create higher-order Raman atom interferometers. Third-order diffraction can be perfectly combined with other LMT techniques and, moreover, allows for a reduction in the overall duration of the diffraction process and the complexity of the experimental set-up, as only two distinct laser frequencies are required. Moreover, we present a third-order Mach-Zehnder interferometer with spurious paths being disregarded. As demonstrated later on in [3], this interferometer generates optimal contrast and a substantial amplitude. The third contribution (III) extends the semi-classical λ-scheme of single Raman diffraction, as discussed in detail in contribution (I), into a fully quantized multi-atom multi-λ configuration with center-of-mass motion inside a cavity. Therefore, the incorporation of an internal structure allows for a more realistic modeling of the atoms, which is relevant for multi-photon interaction or cooling processes. We use for our analysis the framework of second quantization, i.e., we take into account the field-theoretical nature of the multi-particle atomic field as well as of the diffracting light field. We reduce this model with a Hamiltonian averaging theory applied to the atomic field operators and obtain an effective Hamiltonian, which determines the time evolution of the system. We demonstrate the efficiency of our model by the application of a typical initial state. Moreover, for a specific input state, we obtain the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect simultaneously in the atomic and the optical system. Our many-body formalism is perfectly suited to theoretically describe contemporary high-precision atom interferometric experiments based on entanglement between the atoms, that aim to surpass the shot-noise limit.
Atomic diffraction is the central concept of matter-wave interferometers, which provide the opportunity of high-precision rotation and acceleration sensing. Ultracold atoms are the ultimate quantum sensors for this purpose. Transferring photon momentum from two counterpropagating laser beams to atomic wavepackets prepares coherent superpositions in the momentum space, realising atomic beamsplitters and mirrors. Like classical optical systems, these matter-wave devices require exact specifications and ubiquitous imperfections need to be quantified. Therefore, in this thesis, the performance of (3+1)D atomic beamsplitters in the quasi-Bragg regime is studied numerically as well as analytically and is confirmed by experimental data [1]. Ideally, the incoming wavepacket can be split exactly into two parts or reflected perfectly with unit response, independent of its spatial and velocity distribution. However, the velocity selectivity of the Bragg diffraction, as well as losses into undesired diffraction orders in the quasi-Bragg regime, constitute aberrations, which cannot be neglected. The non-ideal behaviour due to spatial variations of the laser beam profiles and wavefront curvatures, regarding realistic Laguerre-Gaussian laser beams instead of ideal plane waves, reduces the diffraction efficiency and leads to rogue momentum components, just like misaligned lasers. In contrast, smooth temporal envelopes improve the beamsplitter performance. Different pulse shapes are taken into account, where some are amenable for closed analytical solutions. The realistic modelling and exhausting aberration studies characterises in detail atomic Bragg beamsplitters and demonstrate pathways for improvements, both required by challenging experiments. For hot ions in accelerator beams the atomic diffraction is used contrary to generate a velocity filter. Two counterpropagating far-detuned lasers transfer a narrow velocity class of ions from an initially broad distribution via a stimulated Raman transition between the ground states of a Λ-system. This colder subensemble prepares optimal initial conditions for precision collinear laser spectroscopy on fast ion beams. The efficiency of the filter is diminished by aberrations like the spontaneous emission from the two single-photon resonances, as well as the ground-state decoherence induced by laser noise. Spatial intensity variations of the ion and laser beams are considered, whereas wavefront curvature is negligible. A comprehensive master equation leads to conditions for the optimal frequency pair of lasers. The time-resolved population transfer characterises the filter performance and is evaluated numerically as well as analytically. Derived models match the numerical results, keeping the computational effort small. Taking into account the mentioned aberrations, the possible use of Raman transition as velocity filter for hot ions is demonstrated. Velocity classes with widths as low as 0.2 m/s can be transferred, achieving a significant population proportion from per mill to percent. Applying the analysis to current 40-Ca+ ion experiments, a sensitivity for measuring high ion acceleration voltages on the ppm level or below is substantiated.
Light pulses have proven to be a powerful and versatile tool to implement beam splitters and mirrors for matter waves enabling atom interferometers. However, for high-precision measurements with such devices the specific realization is crucial and novel techniques might increase the sensitivity. To illustrate the diversity of light-pulse beam splitting and the subtle differences between the diffraction mechanisms, we study atomic Raman, Bragg, and the new method of double Bragg diffraction in a coherent way. Moreover, we introduce a versatile formalism to determine the interference signal of a Mach-Zehnder geometry and give an interpretation in terms of proper-time difference. In addition, we explore the feasibility of a specular mirror for atoms, which might lead to an interferometer testing the equivalence principle.
The combination of adiabatic rapid passage and multiphoton Bragg diffraction (ARPMB pulses) to efficiently transfer many photon recoils of momentum ($\ensuremath{\hbar}k$) to cold-atom clouds is theoretically and experimentally investigated. This method is insensitive to perturbations of the pulse intensity or detuning. In particular, the theoretically calculated velocity acceptance can be up to 8080%80 of one recoil velocity vr{v}_{r}vr​, the theoretical maximum in Bragg diffraction. We experimentally demonstrate ARPMB pulses with transfer efficiency of 99.7% per $\ensuremath{\hbar}k$ using $10\ensuremath{\hbar}k$ pulses, limited by spontaneous emission losses, and Mach-Zehnder interferometers with 8080%80 contrast.