Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1911.10213 · Physical Review Letters

Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz for Biscalar Conformal Field Theories in any Dimension

Benjamin Basso, Gwenaël Ferrando, Vladimir Kazakov, De-liang Zhong

Published Aug 24, 2020• 33 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present the TBA equations for the exact spectrum of multi-magnon local operators in the D-dimensional bi-scalar fishnet CFT. The mixing matrix of such operators is given in terms of fishnet planar graphs of multiwheel and multispiral type. These graphs probe the two key building blocks of the TBA approach, the magnon dispersion relation and scattering matrix, which we obtain by diagonalizing suitable graph-building operators. We also obtain the dual version of the TBA equations, which relates, in the continuum limit, D-dimensional graphs to two-dimensional sigma models in AdS_{D+1}.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.125.091601

Related papers

Effective Quantum Field Theory for the Thermodynamical Bethe Ansatz

Ivan K. Kostov

Abstract We construct an effective Quantum Field Theory for the wrapping effects in 1+1 dimensional models of factorised scattering. The recently developed graph-theoretical approach to TBA gives the perturbative desctiption of this QFT. For the sake of simplicity we limit ourselves to scattering matrices for a single neutral particle and no bound state poles, such as the sinh-Gordon one. On the other hand, in view of applications to AdS/CFT, we do not assume that the scattering matrix is of difference type. The effective QFT involves both bosonic and fermionic fields and possesses a symmetry which makes it one-loop exact. The corresponding path integral localises to a critical point determined by the TBA equation.

arXiv:1911.07343•Journal of High Energy Physics•Feb 1, 2020•13 citations

A diagrammatic approach towards the thermodynamics of integrable systems

Dinh-Long Vu

We propose an exact summation method to compute thermodynamic observables in integrable quantum field theories. The key idea is to use the matrix-tree theorem to write the Gaudin determinants that appear in the cluster expansion as a sum over graphs. For theories with a diagonal S-matrix, this method is more powerful than the standard Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) technique as it is exact to all orders of powers in inverse volume. We have obtained using this method the TBA equation, the excited state energies in finite volume, the Leclair-Mussardo formula for one point functions, the finite-temperature boundary entropy and cumulants of conserved charges in Generalized Gibbs Ensembles. Moreover, the graph expansion can also be regarded as an alternative to algebraic manipulations involving Gaudin determinants. We have applied this idea to derive the equations of state and other transport properties in Generalized Hydrodynamics. For theories with a non-diagonal S-matrix, the description of a complete set of states is more involved and it is not known how a cluster expansion can be implemented. It is nevertheless possible to apply the direct summation method in reverse and interpret known TBA equations with complex strings in terms of diagrams.

arXiv:2008.06901•Aug 16, 2020•0 citations

The thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz approach to exactly solvable models in statistical mechanics and quantum field theory

R.M. Ellem

RSOS models and their associated RZMS scattering QFT models, this is certainly not the case, and here the corresponding TBA equations have been derived only in a few special cases.This shortcoming provides the primary motivation for the work contained in this thesis.After presenting a brief review of the various techniques for deriving the TBA equations associated with the ground state energy for the 0 lj3 perturbations of the minimal CFT models, attempts are made at extending these techniques to the derivation of the TBA equations associated with the ground state energy of the 0 i;2 and perturbations of the minimal CFT models.More recently, the functional relation approach for constructing the ground state TBA equations was extended to the derivation of TBA-like integral equations which correspond to excited state energy levels.In principle, this approach can be used to determine the complete energy spectrum of the perturbed CFT, but in practice this is a very difficult undertaking and only the lowest few excited states are rela tively easily to obtain.In the final chapter of this thesis, this approach is used to determine the TBA-like equations corresponding to the lowest three energy levels of a particular simple perturbed CFT, notably the non-unitary minimal CFT perturbed by its operator <^2,i-L ist o f P u b lic a tio n sThe bulk of the original research content of this thesis is contained in Chapters 4, 5 and 6, with some numerical results tabulated in Appendices B and C. Various parts of this research are, or are soon to be, published as follows.The ground state TBA results of Chapter 5, appear in the paper:• R. M. Ellem, and V. V. Bazhanov: Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz for the subleading magnetic perturbation of the tricritical Ising Model, Nucl.Phys.B512 (1998), 563-580.The ground state and excited state TBA results of Sections 4.1, 5.1, 5.4 and Chapter 6, and the transfer matrix fusion relations in Section 4.2 and Chapter 6, appear in the paper:• R. M. Ellem, and V. V. Bazhanov: Excited State TBA for the < /> 2,i Perturbed A43;5 Model.To be submitted.The general 5-matrix amplitudes and bootstrap properties of Section 4.3, will ap pear in the paper:• R. M. Ellem: Scattering Structure of the (f)\i2 and (f)2,i Perturbed Minimal Conformal Field Theory Models. Currently in preparation.An extension of the integral equation techniques introduced in Chapter 6, to the fusion equation for the regime 1+ dilute A 2 model described in Section 4.2.1, will appear in the paper:• R. M. Ellem: Excited State TBA for the 02jl Perturbed M .%,4Model.Currently in preparation.

•Jan 1, 1998•0 citations

Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz for the subleading magnetic perturbation of the tricritical Ising model

Ellem, R M, Bazhanov, V V

We give further support to Smirnov's conjecture on the exact kink S-matrix for the massive Quantum Field Theory describing the integrable perturbation of the c=0.7 minimal Conformal Field theory (known to describe the tri-critical Ising model) by the operator $\\phi_{2,1}$. This operator has conformal dimensions $(7/16,7/16)$ and is identified with the subleading magnetic operator of the tri-critical Ising model. In this paper we apply the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) approach to the kink scattering theory by explicitly utilising its relationship with the solvable lattice hard hexagon model. Analytically examining the ultraviolet scaling limit we recover the expected central charge c=0.7 of the tri-critical Ising model. We also compare numerical values for the ground state energy of the finite size system obtained from the TBA equations with the results obtained by the Truncated Conformal Space Approach and Conformal Perturbation Theory.

•Jan 1, 1998•9 citations

Z(_N)-symmetric field theories and the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz

Kevin E. Thompson

This thesis is concerned with perturbed conformal field theory, the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz technique and applications to statistical mechanics. In particular, the phase space of two dimensional Z(_N)-symmetric statistical models is examined using these techniques. The aim of the first two chapters is to review some general material concerning statistical mechanics, perturbed conformal field theory, integrable two-dimensional quantum field theory and the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz (TBA) technique. In the third chapter Z(_N)-symmetric statistical theories are discussed and the known features of the phase space of such models are surveyed. The field content of the conformal models in this space (called parafermionic models) is investigated in order to determine which perturbations can be used to investigate the phase space. In the fourth and fifth chapters TBA equations are proposed to describe massless and massive renormalisation flows from the Z(_N)-symmetric conformal theories under self-dual Z(_N)-symmetric perturbations. According to the sign of the perturbation parameter the infrared limits are shown to be either conformal c = 1 or massive theories. The ground state energies of these models can be discovered in all perturbative regimes via the TBA method and the results agree with perturbation theory in ultraviolet and infrared limits. Results from detailed studies of the N = 5, 6..10 models are presented throughout. It is also deduced that the parafermionic models lie exactly at the bifurcation point of the first-order transition region into the Kosterlitz-Thouless region of the Z(_N)-symmetric phase space. The sixth and seventh chapters deal solely with massive perturbations. In chapter six, results from the TBA equations are used to deduce the mass spectrum and the vacuum structure of the underlying scattering theory. In chapter seven, proposals for the massive S-matrices are made. For N odd the mass spectra proposed by the TBA method and that predicted by the S-matrix approach (using the minimality principle) differ. It is suggested therefore, that the N odd S-matrices contain zeroes in the physical strip, violating the minimality principle.

•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations

A Riemann-Hilbert formulation for the finite temperature Hubbard model

Andrea Cavaglià, Martina Cornagliotto, Massimo Mattelliano +1 more

Inspired by recent results in the context of AdS/CFT integrability, we reconsider the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz equations describing the 1D fermionic Hubbard model at finite temperature. We prove that the infinite set of TBA equations are equivalent to a simple nonlinear Riemann-Hilbert problem for a finite number of unknown functions. The latter can be transformed into a set of three coupled nonlinear integral equations defined over a finite support, which can be easily solved numerically. We discuss the emergence of an exact Bethe Ansatz and the link between the TBA approach and the results by Jüttner, Klümper and Suzuki based on the Quantum Transfer Matrix method. We also comment on the analytic continuation mechanism leading to excited states and on the mirror equations describing the finite-size Hubbard model with twisted boundary conditions.

arXiv:1501.04651•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jun 1, 2015•23 citations
We present the TBA equations for the exact spectrum of multi-magnon local operators in the D-dimensional bi-scalar fishnet CFT. The mixing matrix of such operators is given in terms of fishnet planar graphs of multiwheel and multispiral type. These graphs probe the two key building blocks of the TBA approach, the magnon dispersion relation and scattering matrix, which we obtain by diagonalizing suitable graph-building operators. We also obtain the dual version of the TBA equations, which relates, in the continuum limit, D-dimensional graphs to two-dimensional sigma models in AdS_{D+1}.
Abstract We construct an effective Quantum Field Theory for the wrapping effects in 1+1 dimensional models of factorised scattering. The recently developed graph-theoretical approach to TBA gives the perturbative desctiption of this QFT. For the sake of simplicity we limit ourselves to scattering matrices for a single neutral particle and no bound state poles, such as the sinh-Gordon one. On the other hand, in view of applications to AdS/CFT, we do not assume that the scattering matrix is of difference type. The effective QFT involves both bosonic and fermionic fields and possesses a symmetry which makes it one-loop exact. The corresponding path integral localises to a critical point determined by the TBA equation.
We propose an exact summation method to compute thermodynamic observables in integrable quantum field theories. The key idea is to use the matrix-tree theorem to write the Gaudin determinants that appear in the cluster expansion as a sum over graphs. For theories with a diagonal S-matrix, this method is more powerful than the standard Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) technique as it is exact to all orders of powers in inverse volume. We have obtained using this method the TBA equation, the excited state energies in finite volume, the Leclair-Mussardo formula for one point functions, the finite-temperature boundary entropy and cumulants of conserved charges in Generalized Gibbs Ensembles. Moreover, the graph expansion can also be regarded as an alternative to algebraic manipulations involving Gaudin determinants. We have applied this idea to derive the equations of state and other transport properties in Generalized Hydrodynamics. For theories with a non-diagonal S-matrix, the description of a complete set of states is more involved and it is not known how a cluster expansion can be implemented. It is nevertheless possible to apply the direct summation method in reverse and interpret known TBA equations with complex strings in terms of diagrams.
RSOS models and their associated RZMS scattering QFT models, this is certainly not the case, and here the corresponding TBA equations have been derived only in a few special cases.This shortcoming provides the primary motivation for the work contained in this thesis.After presenting a brief review of the various techniques for deriving the TBA equations associated with the ground state energy for the 0 lj3 perturbations of the minimal CFT models, attempts are made at extending these techniques to the derivation of the TBA equations associated with the ground state energy of the 0 i;2 and perturbations of the minimal CFT models.More recently, the functional relation approach for constructing the ground state TBA equations was extended to the derivation of TBA-like integral equations which correspond to excited state energy levels.In principle, this approach can be used to determine the complete energy spectrum of the perturbed CFT, but in practice this is a very difficult undertaking and only the lowest few excited states are rela tively easily to obtain.In the final chapter of this thesis, this approach is used to determine the TBA-like equations corresponding to the lowest three energy levels of a particular simple perturbed CFT, notably the non-unitary minimal CFT perturbed by its operator <^2,i-L ist o f P u b lic a tio n sThe bulk of the original research content of this thesis is contained in Chapters 4, 5 and 6, with some numerical results tabulated in Appendices B and C. Various parts of this research are, or are soon to be, published as follows.The ground state TBA results of Chapter 5, appear in the paper:• R. M. Ellem, and V. V. Bazhanov: Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz for the subleading magnetic perturbation of the tricritical Ising Model, Nucl.Phys.B512 (1998), 563-580.The ground state and excited state TBA results of Sections 4.1, 5.1, 5.4 and Chapter 6, and the transfer matrix fusion relations in Section 4.2 and Chapter 6, appear in the paper:• R. M. Ellem, and V. V. Bazhanov: Excited State TBA for the < /> 2,i Perturbed A43;5 Model.To be submitted.The general 5-matrix amplitudes and bootstrap properties of Section 4.3, will ap pear in the paper:• R. M. Ellem: Scattering Structure of the (f)\i2 and (f)2,i Perturbed Minimal Conformal Field Theory Models. Currently in preparation.An extension of the integral equation techniques introduced in Chapter 6, to the fusion equation for the regime 1+ dilute A 2 model described in Section 4.2.1, will appear in the paper:• R. M. Ellem: Excited State TBA for the 02jl Perturbed M .%,4Model.Currently in preparation.
We give further support to Smirnov's conjecture on the exact kink S-matrix for the massive Quantum Field Theory describing the integrable perturbation of the c=0.7 minimal Conformal Field theory (known to describe the tri-critical Ising model) by the operator phi2,1\\phi_{2,1}phi2,1​. This operator has conformal dimensions (7/16,7/16)(7/16,7/16)(7/16,7/16) and is identified with the subleading magnetic operator of the tri-critical Ising model. In this paper we apply the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) approach to the kink scattering theory by explicitly utilising its relationship with the solvable lattice hard hexagon model. Analytically examining the ultraviolet scaling limit we recover the expected central charge c=0.7 of the tri-critical Ising model. We also compare numerical values for the ground state energy of the finite size system obtained from the TBA equations with the results obtained by the Truncated Conformal Space Approach and Conformal Perturbation Theory.
This thesis is concerned with perturbed conformal field theory, the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz technique and applications to statistical mechanics. In particular, the phase space of two dimensional Z(_N)-symmetric statistical models is examined using these techniques. The aim of the first two chapters is to review some general material concerning statistical mechanics, perturbed conformal field theory, integrable two-dimensional quantum field theory and the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz (TBA) technique. In the third chapter Z(_N)-symmetric statistical theories are discussed and the known features of the phase space of such models are surveyed. The field content of the conformal models in this space (called parafermionic models) is investigated in order to determine which perturbations can be used to investigate the phase space. In the fourth and fifth chapters TBA equations are proposed to describe massless and massive renormalisation flows from the Z(_N)-symmetric conformal theories under self-dual Z(_N)-symmetric perturbations. According to the sign of the perturbation parameter the infrared limits are shown to be either conformal c = 1 or massive theories. The ground state energies of these models can be discovered in all perturbative regimes via the TBA method and the results agree with perturbation theory in ultraviolet and infrared limits. Results from detailed studies of the N = 5, 6..10 models are presented throughout. It is also deduced that the parafermionic models lie exactly at the bifurcation point of the first-order transition region into the Kosterlitz-Thouless region of the Z(_N)-symmetric phase space. The sixth and seventh chapters deal solely with massive perturbations. In chapter six, results from the TBA equations are used to deduce the mass spectrum and the vacuum structure of the underlying scattering theory. In chapter seven, proposals for the massive S-matrices are made. For N odd the mass spectra proposed by the TBA method and that predicted by the S-matrix approach (using the minimality principle) differ. It is suggested therefore, that the N odd S-matrices contain zeroes in the physical strip, violating the minimality principle.
Inspired by recent results in the context of AdS/CFT integrability, we reconsider the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz equations describing the 1D fermionic Hubbard model at finite temperature. We prove that the infinite set of TBA equations are equivalent to a simple nonlinear Riemann-Hilbert problem for a finite number of unknown functions. The latter can be transformed into a set of three coupled nonlinear integral equations defined over a finite support, which can be easily solved numerically. We discuss the emergence of an exact Bethe Ansatz and the link between the TBA approach and the results by Jüttner, Klümper and Suzuki based on the Quantum Transfer Matrix method. We also comment on the analytic continuation mechanism leading to excited states and on the mirror equations describing the finite-size Hubbard model with twisted boundary conditions.