Comment on "Analyses of Mössbauer Experiments in a Rotating System: Proper and Improper Approaches"
Jaykov Foukzon
In paper [1] published recently A. L.Kholmetskii et al.argued that S.A.Podosenov et al. paper [2] wrong and cannot explain nowel Mossbauer experiment in a rotating system. However paper [1] contains a lot of principal mistakes: (i) first notice that [1] based on rejection Einstein equivalence principle (EEP) (see [3]) and misconception in basic notion of GRT. By using these misconception A. L.Kholmetskii et al.argued that: the problem of physical interpretation of observed energy shift between emission and absorption lines in a rotating system under framework of general relativity open. Ofcourse after rejection EEP under framework of general relativity one explains nothing. (ii) secondary note that paper [1] based on misleading in quantum optics. In quantum optics we dealing with probability density w(t,r),r∈ℝ³ such that w(t,‖r‖,Ω)δΩdt is probability of photon registration near point r, between instant t and t+dt by a detector with angular size δΩ≪1sr and located at point r∈ℝ³.The probability density w(t,r) is not highly localized in free space except unphysical 1D case known from literature (see [4],5B 1.2).A single photons cannot be localized by using photodetector. Nevertheless in order to disprove S.A.Podosenov et al. paper [2], A. L.Kholmetskii et al. in [1] naively argued that γ-quanta is a point particle and propagate along highly localized classical trajectory. But this is a missconcept. Remark 1. But more importantly, these authors deliberately mislead readers by reporting absolutely false information about experimental results stated in classical papers [5]-[9]. A. L.Kholmetskii et al. wrote (see [1] p.5): However, it becomes obvious that Podosenov et al. [26] did not even realize fact that Eq. (11) indicates a red shift of frequency of resonant radiation (i.e., ν_{R} ν₀. We add that same blue shift of frequency of resonant γ -quanta has been obtained in all other Mossbauer rotor experiments [1--6] (see corresponding ref.[5]-[9] in this paper) in configuration where source of resonant radiation was located on rotational axis, and resonant absorber was mounted on rotor rim. Remark 1. Note that in classical Mossbauer rotor experiments [1]--[6] only a red shift in full accordance with GRT prediction without any doubt were obtained. [Truncated by viXra Admin to <400 words]
•Dec 1, 2020•0 citations