Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1910.06355 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Topological spin liquids: Robustness under perturbations

Mohsin Iqbal, Helena Casademunt, Norbert Schuch

Published Mar 2, 2020• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the robustness of the paradigmatic kagome resonating valence bond (RVB) spin liquid and its orthogonal version, the quantum dimer model. The nonorthogonality of singlets in the RVB model and the induced finite length scale not only makes it difficult to analyze, but can also significantly affect its physics, such as how much noise resilience it exhibits. Surprisingly, we find that this is not the case: The amount of perturbations which the RVB spin liquid can tolerate is not affected by the finite correlation length, making the dimer model a viable model for studying RVB physics under perturbations. Remarkably, we find that this is a universal phenomenon protected by symmetries: First, the dominant correlations in the RVB are spinon correlations, making the state robust against doping with visons. Second, reflection symmetry stabilizes the spin liquid against doping with spinons, by forbidding mixing of the initially dominant correlations with those which lead to the breakdown of topological order.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.101.115101

Related papers

Robustness of critical U(1) spin liquids and emergent symmetries in tensor networks

Henrik Dreyer, Laurens Vanderstraeten, Ji-Yao Chen +2 more

We study the response of critical resonating valence bond (RVB) spin liquids to doping with longer-range singlets, and more generally of U ( 1 ) -symmetric tensor networks to nonsymmetric perturbations. Using a field theory description, we find that in the RVB, doping constitutes a relevant perturbation that immediately opens up a gap, contrary to previous observations. Our analysis predicts a very large correlation length even at significant doping, which we verify using high-accuracy numerical simulations. This emphasizes the need for careful analysis, but it also justifies the use of such states as a variational ansatz for critical systems. Finally, we give an example of a projected entangled pair state where nonsymmetric perturbations do not open up a gap and the U ( 1 ) symmetry reemerges. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2008.04833•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 21, 2024•5 citations

Ground-state uniqueness of the twelve-site RVB spin-liquid parent Hamiltonian on the kagome lattice

Zhenyu Zhou, Julia Wildeboer, Alexander Seidel

Anderson's idea of a (short-ranged) resonating valence bond (RVB) spin liquid has been the first ever proposal of what we now call a topologically ordered phase. Since then, a wealth of exactly solvable lattice models have been constructed that have topologically ordered ground states. For a long time, however, it has been difficult to realize Anderson's original vision in such solvable models, according to which the ground state has an unbroken SU(2) spin rotational symmetry and is dominated by fluctuation of singlet bonds. The kagome lattice is the simplest lattice geometry for which parent Hamiltonians stabilizing a prototypical spin-1$/$2 short-ranged RVB wave function has been constructed and strong evidence has been given that this state belongs to a topological phase. The uniqueness of the desired RVB-type ground states has, however, not been rigorously proven for the simplest possible such Hamiltonian, which acts on 12 spins at a time. Rather, this uniqueness has been demonstrated for a longer ranged (19-site) variant of this Hamiltonian by Schuch et al., via making contact with powerful results for projected entangled-pair states. In this paper, we extend this result to the 12-site Hamiltonian. Our result is based on numerical studies on finite clusters, for which we demonstrate a ``ground state intersection property'' with implications for arbitrary system size. We also review the relations between various constructions schemes for RVB parent Hamiltonians found in the literature.

arXiv:1310.8000•Physical Review B•Jan 16, 2014•15 citations

Vison condensation and spinon confinement in a kagome-lattice Z 2 spin liquid: A numerical study of a quantum dimer model

Kyusung Hwang

Quantum spin liquids are exotic many-body states featured with long-range entanglement and fractional anyon quasiparticles. Quantum phase transitions of spin liquids are particularly interesting problems related with novel phenomena of anyon condensation and anyon confinement. Here we study a quantum dimer model, which implements a transition between a Z 2 spin liquid ( Z 2 SL ) and a valence bond solid (VBS) on the kagome lattice. The transition is driven by the condensation of vison excitation of the Z 2 spin liquid, which impacts on other anyon excitations especially leading to the confinement of spinon excitations. By numerical exact diagonalization of the dimer model, we directly measure the vison condensation using vison string operators, and explicitly check a confining potential acting on spinon excitations in the VBS state. It is observed that topological degeneracy of the spin-liquid state is lifted concomitantly with the vison condensation. The dimer ordering pattern of the VBS state is identified by investigating dimer structure factor. Furthermore, we find an interesting state that exhibits features of spin liquid and VBS simultaneously. We discuss the origin of the mixed behaviors and possible scenarios expected in thermodynamic limit. This work complements the previous analytical studies on the dimer model [ and ] by providing numerical evidences on the vison condensation and the spinon confinement in the Z 2 SL -to-VBS transition. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2403.13154•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 16, 2024•1 citation

Spin Hamiltonians with Resonating-Valence-Bond Ground States

Jennifer Cano, Paul Fendley

Quantum dimer models exhibit quantum critical points and liquid states when the ground state is the resonating-valence bond (RVB) state. We construct SU(2)-invariant spin-1/2 Hamiltonians with the same RVB ground state. The main technical obstacle overcome is the fact that different dimer configurations in the spin model are not orthogonal. We show that the physics depends on how dimers are related to the spins, and find a Hamiltonian that is likely to be quantum critical.

arXiv:0910.5708•Physical Review Letters•Aug 5, 2010•37 citations

Properties of resonating-valence-bond spin liquids and critical dimer models

Ying Tang, Anders W. Sandvik, Christopher L. Henley

We use Monte Carlo simulations to study properties of Anderson's resonating-valence-bond (RVB) spin-liquid state on the square lattice (i.e., the equal superposition of all pairing of spins into nearest-neighbor singlet pairs) and compare with the classical dimer model (CDM). The latter system also corresponds to the ground state of the Rokhsar-Kivelson quantum dimer model at its critical point. We find that, although spin-spin correlations decay exponentially in the RVB, four-spin valence-bond-solid correlations are critical, qualitatively like the well-known dimer-dimer correlations of the CDM, but decaying more slowly (as $1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ with $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\approx}1.20$, compared with $\ensuremath{\alpha}=2$ for the CDM). We also compute the distribution of monomer (defect) pair separations, which decay by a larger exponent in the RVB than in the CDM. We further study both models in their different winding-number sectors and evaluate the relative weights of different sectors. Like the CDM, all the observed RVB behaviors can be understood in the framework of a mapping to a ``height'' model characterized by a gradient-squared stiffness constant $K$. Four independent measurements consistently show a value ${K}_{\mathrm{RVB}}\ensuremath{\approx}1.6{K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}$, with the same kinds of numerical evaluations of ${K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}$ giving results in agreement with the rigorously known value ${K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}=\ensuremath{\pi}/16$. The background of a nonzero winding-number gradient $W/L$ introduces spatial anisotropies and an increase in the effective $K$, both of which can be understood as a consequence of anharmonic terms in the height-model free energy, which are of relevance to the recently proposed scenario of ``Cantor deconfinement'' in extended quantum dimer models. In addition to the standard case of short bonds only, we also studied ensembles in which fourth-neighbor (bipartite) bonds are allowed at a density controlled by a tunable fugacity, resulting (as expected) in a smooth reduction of $K$.

arXiv:1010.6146•Physical Review B•Nov 21, 2011•69 citations

Simplex Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice with projected entangled pair states: Spinon and vison coherence lengths, topological entropy, and gapless edge modes

Didier Poilblanc, Norbert Schuch

Gapped ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ spin liquids have been proposed as candidates for the ground state of the $S=1/2$ quantum antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice. We extend the use of projected entangled pair states to construct (on the cylinder) resonating valence bond (RVB) states including both nearest-neighbor and next-nearest-neighbor singlet bonds. Our ansatz---dubbed ``simplex spin liquid''---allows for an asymmetry between the two types of triangles (of order $2%--3%$ in the energy density after optimization) leading to the breaking of inversion symmetry. We show that the topological ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ structure is still preserved and, by considering the presence or the absence of spinon and vison lines along an infinite cylinder, we explicitly construct four orthogonal RVB minimally entangled states. The spinon and vison coherence lengths are extracted from a finite size scaling with regard to the cylinder perimeter of the energy splittings of the four sectors and are found to be of the order of the lattice spacing. The entanglement spectrum of a partitioned (infinite) cylinder is found to be gapless, suggesting the occurrence, on a cylinder with real open boundaries, of gapless edge modes formally similar to Luttinger liquid (nonchiral) spin and charge modes. When inversion symmetry is spontaneously broken, the RVB spin liquid exhibits an extra Ising degeneracy, which might have been observed in recent exact diagonalization studies.

arXiv:1302.0306•Physical Review B•Apr 22, 2013•53 citations
We study the robustness of the paradigmatic kagome resonating valence bond (RVB) spin liquid and its orthogonal version, the quantum dimer model. The nonorthogonality of singlets in the RVB model and the induced finite length scale not only makes it difficult to analyze, but can also significantly affect its physics, such as how much noise resilience it exhibits. Surprisingly, we find that this is not the case: The amount of perturbations which the RVB spin liquid can tolerate is not affected by the finite correlation length, making the dimer model a viable model for studying RVB physics under perturbations. Remarkably, we find that this is a universal phenomenon protected by symmetries: First, the dominant correlations in the RVB are spinon correlations, making the state robust against doping with visons. Second, reflection symmetry stabilizes the spin liquid against doping with spinons, by forbidding mixing of the initially dominant correlations with those which lead to the breakdown of topological order.
We study the response of critical resonating valence bond (RVB) spin liquids to doping with longer-range singlets, and more generally of U ( 1 ) -symmetric tensor networks to nonsymmetric perturbations. Using a field theory description, we find that in the RVB, doping constitutes a relevant perturbation that immediately opens up a gap, contrary to previous observations. Our analysis predicts a very large correlation length even at significant doping, which we verify using high-accuracy numerical simulations. This emphasizes the need for careful analysis, but it also justifies the use of such states as a variational ansatz for critical systems. Finally, we give an example of a projected entangled pair state where nonsymmetric perturbations do not open up a gap and the U ( 1 ) symmetry reemerges. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Anderson's idea of a (short-ranged) resonating valence bond (RVB) spin liquid has been the first ever proposal of what we now call a topologically ordered phase. Since then, a wealth of exactly solvable lattice models have been constructed that have topologically ordered ground states. For a long time, however, it has been difficult to realize Anderson's original vision in such solvable models, according to which the ground state has an unbroken SU(2) spin rotational symmetry and is dominated by fluctuation of singlet bonds. The kagome lattice is the simplest lattice geometry for which parent Hamiltonians stabilizing a prototypical spin-1$/$2 short-ranged RVB wave function has been constructed and strong evidence has been given that this state belongs to a topological phase. The uniqueness of the desired RVB-type ground states has, however, not been rigorously proven for the simplest possible such Hamiltonian, which acts on 12 spins at a time. Rather, this uniqueness has been demonstrated for a longer ranged (19-site) variant of this Hamiltonian by Schuch et al., via making contact with powerful results for projected entangled-pair states. In this paper, we extend this result to the 12-site Hamiltonian. Our result is based on numerical studies on finite clusters, for which we demonstrate a ``ground state intersection property'' with implications for arbitrary system size. We also review the relations between various constructions schemes for RVB parent Hamiltonians found in the literature.
Quantum spin liquids are exotic many-body states featured with long-range entanglement and fractional anyon quasiparticles. Quantum phase transitions of spin liquids are particularly interesting problems related with novel phenomena of anyon condensation and anyon confinement. Here we study a quantum dimer model, which implements a transition between a Z 2 spin liquid ( Z 2 SL ) and a valence bond solid (VBS) on the kagome lattice. The transition is driven by the condensation of vison excitation of the Z 2 spin liquid, which impacts on other anyon excitations especially leading to the confinement of spinon excitations. By numerical exact diagonalization of the dimer model, we directly measure the vison condensation using vison string operators, and explicitly check a confining potential acting on spinon excitations in the VBS state. It is observed that topological degeneracy of the spin-liquid state is lifted concomitantly with the vison condensation. The dimer ordering pattern of the VBS state is identified by investigating dimer structure factor. Furthermore, we find an interesting state that exhibits features of spin liquid and VBS simultaneously. We discuss the origin of the mixed behaviors and possible scenarios expected in thermodynamic limit. This work complements the previous analytical studies on the dimer model [ and ] by providing numerical evidences on the vison condensation and the spinon confinement in the Z 2 SL -to-VBS transition. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We use Monte Carlo simulations to study properties of Anderson's resonating-valence-bond (RVB) spin-liquid state on the square lattice (i.e., the equal superposition of all pairing of spins into nearest-neighbor singlet pairs) and compare with the classical dimer model (CDM). The latter system also corresponds to the ground state of the Rokhsar-Kivelson quantum dimer model at its critical point. We find that, although spin-spin correlations decay exponentially in the RVB, four-spin valence-bond-solid correlations are critical, qualitatively like the well-known dimer-dimer correlations of the CDM, but decaying more slowly (as $1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ with $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\approx}1.20$, compared with $\ensuremath{\alpha}=2$ for the CDM). We also compute the distribution of monomer (defect) pair separations, which decay by a larger exponent in the RVB than in the CDM. We further study both models in their different winding-number sectors and evaluate the relative weights of different sectors. Like the CDM, all the observed RVB behaviors can be understood in the framework of a mapping to a ``height'' model characterized by a gradient-squared stiffness constant KKK. Four independent measurements consistently show a value ${K}_{\mathrm{RVB}}\ensuremath{\approx}1.6{K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}$, with the same kinds of numerical evaluations of KCDM{K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}KCDM​ giving results in agreement with the rigorously known value ${K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}=\ensuremath{\pi}/16$. The background of a nonzero winding-number gradient W/LW/LW/L introduces spatial anisotropies and an increase in the effective KKK, both of which can be understood as a consequence of anharmonic terms in the height-model free energy, which are of relevance to the recently proposed scenario of ``Cantor deconfinement'' in extended quantum dimer models. In addition to the standard case of short bonds only, we also studied ensembles in which fourth-neighbor (bipartite) bonds are allowed at a density controlled by a tunable fugacity, resulting (as expected) in a smooth reduction of KKK.
Gapped Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ spin liquids have been proposed as candidates for the ground state of the S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2 quantum antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice. We extend the use of projected entangled pair states to construct (on the cylinder) resonating valence bond (RVB) states including both nearest-neighbor and next-nearest-neighbor singlet bonds. Our ansatz---dubbed ``simplex spin liquid''---allows for an asymmetry between the two types of triangles (of order 22%--3%2 in the energy density after optimization) leading to the breaking of inversion symmetry. We show that the topological Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ structure is still preserved and, by considering the presence or the absence of spinon and vison lines along an infinite cylinder, we explicitly construct four orthogonal RVB minimally entangled states. The spinon and vison coherence lengths are extracted from a finite size scaling with regard to the cylinder perimeter of the energy splittings of the four sectors and are found to be of the order of the lattice spacing. The entanglement spectrum of a partitioned (infinite) cylinder is found to be gapless, suggesting the occurrence, on a cylinder with real open boundaries, of gapless edge modes formally similar to Luttinger liquid (nonchiral) spin and charge modes. When inversion symmetry is spontaneously broken, the RVB spin liquid exhibits an extra Ising degeneracy, which might have been observed in recent exact diagonalization studies.