Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1908.03145 · Physical Review A

Quantum-enhanced estimation of the optical phase gradient by use of image-inversion interferometry

Walker D. Larson, Bahaa E. A. Saleh

Published Jul 13, 2020• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound on the error of measurement of the optical phase gradient with a beam of finite width (or the wavefront tilt within a finite aperture) is consistent with the Fourier-transform uncertainty principle for the single-photon state, and is a factor of $N$ lower for the maximally entangled $N$-photon state. This fundamental bound therefore governs the tradeoff between quantum sensitivity and spatial resolution. Error bounds for a structured configuration using binary projective-field measurements implemented by an image-inversion (II) interferometer are higher, and the factor of $N$ advantage attained by the $N$-photon maximally entangled state is reduced and eventually washed out as the beam width or the phase gradient increases. This reduction is more rapid for larger $N$, so that the quantum advantage is more vulnerable. The precision of the II interferometer is greater than that based on a split detector placed in the focal plane of a lens.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.013712

Related papers

Quantum-enhanced Phase Estimation in Optical Interferometry

Jaspreet Sahota

Quantum-enhanced interferometers utilize non-classical states of light in order to surpass the limitations imposed by classical physics on phase measurement sensitivity and resolution. We review key scientific developments in this growing field of research and derive fundamental metrology concepts, namely the Cram\'{e}r-Rao bound and the Fisher information, which are used to analyze the metrological performance of quantum states of light. We propose a supersensitive quantum interferometry protocol that can be amplified to the macroscopic realm (i.e. the mean number of photons of the probe state can reach approximately 100,000 photons) using contemporary techniques of spontaneous parametric down conversion. The parity measurement on the output field asymptotically saturates the quantum Cram\'{e}r-Rao bound, which scales like the Heisenberg limit. We uncover the role of photon statistics on phase sensitivity and rule out the necessity of mode entanglement for quantum-enhanced interferometry. Based on these insights we outline a practical metrology technique (independent of mode entanglement) that measures a phase delay of a single-mode anti-squeezing operation. This scheme can also be scaled macroscopically using contemporary techniques and is shown to significantly surpass the shot-noise limit (SNL) in the presence of realistic losses. Finally, the physical resources that enable quantum-enhanced interferometry is studied by analyzing the quantum Fisher information (QFI) using the first quantization and the second quantization formalisms of quantum mechanics. It is shown that increasing the intra-mode correlations of an interferometer (as quantified by the second order Glauber coherence function) can be conducive to attaining a quantum advantage in phase estimation; whereas, introducing mode entanglement can reduce phase sensitivity. Using the first quantization description, we derive a formula for the QFI that shows explicitly how the Heisenberg scaling term depends on particle entanglement.

•Nov 1, 2017•0 citations

Quantum phase estimation with a general binary-outcome measurement

H.L. Zheng, Xuexin Ren, P. Liu +1 more

As the simplest phase estimation protocol, the inversion estimator has been widely adopted in the quantum metrology, since its performance can be simply quantified by the error-propagation formula. For a general binary-outcome measurement, we show that both the inversion estimator and the maximum likelihood estimator are the same and can asymptotically saturate the Cramér-Rao lower bound. These observations are applied to the parity detection and the zero-nonzero photon counting that have achieved super-resolved phase measurement near the shot-noise phase sensitivity in a coherent-state light Mach–Zehnder interferometer. We numerically show that the phase uncertainty almost follows the theoretical prediction of the lower bound. At the optimal working point, the best sensitivities also reach their associated analytic results for the two binary-outcome measurement schemes.

Results in Physics•Oct 18, 2022•3 citations

Tradeoff in simultaneous quantum-limited phase and loss estimation in interferometry

Philip J. D. Crowley, Animesh Datta, Marco Barbieri +1 more

Interferometry with quantum light is known to provide enhanced precision for estimating a single phase. However, depending on the parameters involved, the quantum limit for the simultaneous estimation of multiple parameters may not be attainable, leading to tradeoffs in the attainable precisions. Here we study the simultaneous estimation of two parameters related to optical interferometry: phase and loss, using a fixed number of photons. We derive a tradeoff in the estimation of these two parameters which shows that, in contrast to single-parameter estimation, it is impossible to design a strategy saturating the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound for loss and phase estimation in a single setup simultaneously. We design optimal quantum states with a fixed number of photons achieving the best possible simultaneous precisions. Our results reveal general features about concurrently estimating Hamiltonian and dissipative parameters and have implications for sophisticated sensing scenarios such as quantum imaging.

arXiv:1206.0043•Physical Review A•Feb 27, 2014•141 citations

Quantum-Enhanced Phase Estimation with Photon-Added Even and Odd Coherent States in an SU(1,1) Interferometer

Abdelmajid El Maaroufi, Mouad Ait Maskour, Bouchra Maroufi +2 more

We investigate phase estimation in an SU(1,1) interferometer employing $m$-photon-added even and odd coherent states as nonclassical input resources. The phase sensitivity is evaluated through intensity detection and the error propagation method, while the ultimate precision limit is determined from the quantum Cramér-Rao bound with the quantum Fisher information serving as the relevant metrological quantity. Our results demonstrate that photon addition significantly enhances the phase sensitivity, increases the quantum Fisher information, and reduces the quantum Cramér-Rao bound, leading to a clear improvement over the corresponding even and odd coherent states. Furthermore, the achievable sensitivity exceeds the standard quantum limit and gradually approaches the Heisenberg scaling with increasing photon-addition number. We also find that the $m$-photon-added even coherent states exhibit a modest advantage over their odd counterparts. As $m$ increases, however, this distinction becomes progressively weaker, suggesting that photon addition diminishes the role of the initial parity of the coherent state in determining the interferometric performance.

quant-pharXiv:2609.04064•Sep 4, 2026•0 citations

Multi-parameter Optical Metrology: Quantum and Classical

Walker D. Larson

The insights offered by quantum mechanics to the field of optical metrology are many-fold, with non-classical states of light themselves used to make sensors that surpass the sensitivity of sensors using classical states of light. Unfortunately, this advantage, referred to often as "super-sensitivity" is notoriously fragile, and even the slightest experimental imperfections may greatly reduce the efficacy of the non-classical sensors, sometimes completely obviating their advantage. In my thesis I have shown that the performance of an otherwise ideal two-photon interferometer, which exploits entanglement between photons to make super-sensitive measurements of phase, is crippled by the slightest introduction of decoherence between modes of the interferometer. I have shown further that such drastic reduction in sensitivity can also appear in classical measurement problems, specifically that the recently developed methods of estimating the separation between a pair of point sources are rendered less effective when the ideal assumption of complete spatial incoherence is relaxed. Towards overcoming these and other issues, I have designed new configurations that use ancillary optical degrees of freedom, a tool-set that has recently garnered much interest in the field of quantum optics. In the context of two-photon interferometry, I have shown that by coupling polarization to the spatial-structure of the two photon state used to probe phase it is possible to obviate the need for a reference phase, even in the context of decoherence and imperfections in the interferometer. In the context of two-point resolution, I have developed an anisotropic imaging system that performs the function of an image-inversion interferometer and is inherently stable, offering an attractive implementation of recently developed methods of sub-Rayleigh imaging. I have further shown both theoretically and experimentally that the same anisotropic image-inversion interferometer is useful in measuring spatially encoded phases, both in the context of classical illumination as well as quantum-aided two-photon super-sensing. In both cases, the ability to perform interferometric measurements of the spatial structure of an electric field without splitting beam paths forms a bridge between conception and implementation of precision-sensing measurement strategies. Finally, I have shown that binary interferometric method based on the common-path anisotropic imaging system that I introduced, are able to measure both phase gradients and transverse beam tilts with a sensitivity beating conventional systems that are used both commercially and in research laboratories.

Journal of International Crisis and Risk Communication Research•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Comparison of the Error Incurred in the Measurement of Nonblinking, Nonpoint-Source Objects Using Classical and Quantum Imaging

Dorian F. Twedt-Gutierrez, Emily A. Smith, Jacob W. Petrich +1 more

We present another step in our efforts to expand far-field imaging beyond the diffraction limit and beyond the limitations imposed by fluorescent labels. The model system we examine is based on the exploitation of entangled photon pairs at 810 nm generated by spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC) of a 405 nm source to resolve the separations of the line pairs of a series of two-dimensional objects. A ghost-imaging optical system directs signal and idler photons along two paths, one of which contains the objects. Images are constructed using a covariance analysis of the entangled pairs using typically 106 frames collected with an EMCCD detector that was calibrated to account for the number of entangled pairs of photons, which is necessary for an accurate determination of the resolution and its comparison with the classical method. Conservation of momentum requires that there is inversion symmetry between the transverse k vectors of the photons passing through the target and their entangled counterparts directed along the targetless path. Our covariance analysis not only addresses this symmetry but also that the width of the covariance peak is broader than a single pixel owing to the nature of SPDC and the details of the optical arrangement. Consideration of this broadening provides significant improvement of the image quality. The Heisenberg limit (HL) is achieved within experimental error: using the same optical alignment, the resolution obtained with entangled pairs of 810 nm photons is, within experimental error, twice that obtained with classical 810 nm photons. More importantly, the error bars of measurements with 810 nm entangled pairs are quantified by the Cramér-Rao lower bound (CRLB) and compared with those of the classical measurements. While other workers have done quantum imaging on nonpoint sources, to our knowledge we are the first group that not only has done the quantum imaging but also has compared the CRLB and the measured error of the quantum and classical measurements for a series of different-sized objects. (Similar comparisons have, however, been made for systems that can be approximated as point sources, e.g., determining the separation of two laser beams).

The Journal of Physical Chemistry B•Sep 30, 2026•0 citations
We show that the quantum Cram'er-Rao bound on the error of measurement of the optical phase gradient with a beam of finite width (or the wavefront tilt within a finite aperture) is consistent with the Fourier-transform uncertainty principle for the single-photon state, and is a factor of NNN lower for the maximally entangled NNN-photon state. This fundamental bound therefore governs the tradeoff between quantum sensitivity and spatial resolution. Error bounds for a structured configuration using binary projective-field measurements implemented by an image-inversion (II) interferometer are higher, and the factor of NNN advantage attained by the NNN-photon maximally entangled state is reduced and eventually washed out as the beam width or the phase gradient increases. This reduction is more rapid for larger NNN, so that the quantum advantage is more vulnerable. The precision of the II interferometer is greater than that based on a split detector placed in the focal plane of a lens.
Quantum-enhanced interferometers utilize non-classical states of light in order to surpass the limitations imposed by classical physics on phase measurement sensitivity and resolution. We review key scientific developments in this growing field of research and derive fundamental metrology concepts, namely the Cram\'{e}r-Rao bound and the Fisher information, which are used to analyze the metrological performance of quantum states of light. We propose a supersensitive quantum interferometry protocol that can be amplified to the macroscopic realm (i.e. the mean number of photons of the probe state can reach approximately 100,000 photons) using contemporary techniques of spontaneous parametric down conversion. The parity measurement on the output field asymptotically saturates the quantum Cram\'{e}r-Rao bound, which scales like the Heisenberg limit. We uncover the role of photon statistics on phase sensitivity and rule out the necessity of mode entanglement for quantum-enhanced interferometry. Based on these insights we outline a practical metrology technique (independent of mode entanglement) that measures a phase delay of a single-mode anti-squeezing operation. This scheme can also be scaled macroscopically using contemporary techniques and is shown to significantly surpass the shot-noise limit (SNL) in the presence of realistic losses. Finally, the physical resources that enable quantum-enhanced interferometry is studied by analyzing the quantum Fisher information (QFI) using the first quantization and the second quantization formalisms of quantum mechanics. It is shown that increasing the intra-mode correlations of an interferometer (as quantified by the second order Glauber coherence function) can be conducive to attaining a quantum advantage in phase estimation; whereas, introducing mode entanglement can reduce phase sensitivity. Using the first quantization description, we derive a formula for the QFI that shows explicitly how the Heisenberg scaling term depends on particle entanglement.
As the simplest phase estimation protocol, the inversion estimator has been widely adopted in the quantum metrology, since its performance can be simply quantified by the error-propagation formula. For a general binary-outcome measurement, we show that both the inversion estimator and the maximum likelihood estimator are the same and can asymptotically saturate the Cramér-Rao lower bound. These observations are applied to the parity detection and the zero-nonzero photon counting that have achieved super-resolved phase measurement near the shot-noise phase sensitivity in a coherent-state light Mach–Zehnder interferometer. We numerically show that the phase uncertainty almost follows the theoretical prediction of the lower bound. At the optimal working point, the best sensitivities also reach their associated analytic results for the two binary-outcome measurement schemes.
Interferometry with quantum light is known to provide enhanced precision for estimating a single phase. However, depending on the parameters involved, the quantum limit for the simultaneous estimation of multiple parameters may not be attainable, leading to tradeoffs in the attainable precisions. Here we study the simultaneous estimation of two parameters related to optical interferometry: phase and loss, using a fixed number of photons. We derive a tradeoff in the estimation of these two parameters which shows that, in contrast to single-parameter estimation, it is impossible to design a strategy saturating the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound for loss and phase estimation in a single setup simultaneously. We design optimal quantum states with a fixed number of photons achieving the best possible simultaneous precisions. Our results reveal general features about concurrently estimating Hamiltonian and dissipative parameters and have implications for sophisticated sensing scenarios such as quantum imaging.
We investigate phase estimation in an SU(1,1) interferometer employing mmm-photon-added even and odd coherent states as nonclassical input resources. The phase sensitivity is evaluated through intensity detection and the error propagation method, while the ultimate precision limit is determined from the quantum Cramér-Rao bound with the quantum Fisher information serving as the relevant metrological quantity. Our results demonstrate that photon addition significantly enhances the phase sensitivity, increases the quantum Fisher information, and reduces the quantum Cramér-Rao bound, leading to a clear improvement over the corresponding even and odd coherent states. Furthermore, the achievable sensitivity exceeds the standard quantum limit and gradually approaches the Heisenberg scaling with increasing photon-addition number. We also find that the mmm-photon-added even coherent states exhibit a modest advantage over their odd counterparts. As mmm increases, however, this distinction becomes progressively weaker, suggesting that photon addition diminishes the role of the initial parity of the coherent state in determining the interferometric performance.
The insights offered by quantum mechanics to the field of optical metrology are many-fold, with non-classical states of light themselves used to make sensors that surpass the sensitivity of sensors using classical states of light. Unfortunately, this advantage, referred to often as "super-sensitivity" is notoriously fragile, and even the slightest experimental imperfections may greatly reduce the efficacy of the non-classical sensors, sometimes completely obviating their advantage. In my thesis I have shown that the performance of an otherwise ideal two-photon interferometer, which exploits entanglement between photons to make super-sensitive measurements of phase, is crippled by the slightest introduction of decoherence between modes of the interferometer. I have shown further that such drastic reduction in sensitivity can also appear in classical measurement problems, specifically that the recently developed methods of estimating the separation between a pair of point sources are rendered less effective when the ideal assumption of complete spatial incoherence is relaxed. Towards overcoming these and other issues, I have designed new configurations that use ancillary optical degrees of freedom, a tool-set that has recently garnered much interest in the field of quantum optics. In the context of two-photon interferometry, I have shown that by coupling polarization to the spatial-structure of the two photon state used to probe phase it is possible to obviate the need for a reference phase, even in the context of decoherence and imperfections in the interferometer. In the context of two-point resolution, I have developed an anisotropic imaging system that performs the function of an image-inversion interferometer and is inherently stable, offering an attractive implementation of recently developed methods of sub-Rayleigh imaging. I have further shown both theoretically and experimentally that the same anisotropic image-inversion interferometer is useful in measuring spatially encoded phases, both in the context of classical illumination as well as quantum-aided two-photon super-sensing. In both cases, the ability to perform interferometric measurements of the spatial structure of an electric field without splitting beam paths forms a bridge between conception and implementation of precision-sensing measurement strategies. Finally, I have shown that binary interferometric method based on the common-path anisotropic imaging system that I introduced, are able to measure both phase gradients and transverse beam tilts with a sensitivity beating conventional systems that are used both commercially and in research laboratories.
We present another step in our efforts to expand far-field imaging beyond the diffraction limit and beyond the limitations imposed by fluorescent labels. The model system we examine is based on the exploitation of entangled photon pairs at 810 nm generated by spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC) of a 405 nm source to resolve the separations of the line pairs of a series of two-dimensional objects. A ghost-imaging optical system directs signal and idler photons along two paths, one of which contains the objects. Images are constructed using a covariance analysis of the entangled pairs using typically 106 frames collected with an EMCCD detector that was calibrated to account for the number of entangled pairs of photons, which is necessary for an accurate determination of the resolution and its comparison with the classical method. Conservation of momentum requires that there is inversion symmetry between the transverse k vectors of the photons passing through the target and their entangled counterparts directed along the targetless path. Our covariance analysis not only addresses this symmetry but also that the width of the covariance peak is broader than a single pixel owing to the nature of SPDC and the details of the optical arrangement. Consideration of this broadening provides significant improvement of the image quality. The Heisenberg limit (HL) is achieved within experimental error: using the same optical alignment, the resolution obtained with entangled pairs of 810 nm photons is, within experimental error, twice that obtained with classical 810 nm photons. More importantly, the error bars of measurements with 810 nm entangled pairs are quantified by the Cramér-Rao lower bound (CRLB) and compared with those of the classical measurements. While other workers have done quantum imaging on nonpoint sources, to our knowledge we are the first group that not only has done the quantum imaging but also has compared the CRLB and the measured error of the quantum and classical measurements for a series of different-sized objects. (Similar comparisons have, however, been made for systems that can be approximated as point sources, e.g., determining the separation of two laser beams).