Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1905.02390

On the Nonrelativistic Quantum-Mechanical Hamiltonian with $1/c^2$ terms. Transverse current-current interaction

L. Bányai

Published May 7, 2019• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We extend the standard solid-state quantum mechanical Hamiltonian containing only Coulomb interactions between the charged particles by inclusion of $1/c^2$ terms representing (transverse) current-current interaction. For its derivation we use the classical formulation of Landau-Lifshitz, however consequently in the Coulomb gauge. Our Hamiltonian does not coincide with the Darwin Hamiltonian and we emphasize the mathematical inconsistency in its derivation. We show, that the quantized version of our Hamiltonian is equivalent to the non-relativistic QED considering only states without photons and retaining only terms of order $1/c^2$. The importance of this extended Hamiltonian lies in the possibility to distinguish external from internal magnetic fields. This aspect may be relevant for theories of the Meissner effect.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1905.02390

Related papers

About Non-relativistic Quantum Mechanics and Electromagnetism

L. Bányai, M. Bundaru

We describe here the coherent formulation of electromagnetism in the nonrelativistic quantummechanical many-body theory. We use the mathematical frame of the field theory and its quantization in the spirit of the QED. This is necessary because of the manifold of misinterpretations emerging from the hystorical development of quantum mechanics, starting from the Schrödinger equation of a single particle in the presence of given electromagnetic fields, followed by the many-body theories of many charged identical particles having just Coulomb interactions inspired from the classical electromagnetic theory of point-like charges. However, this later is known to be inconsistent due to the self-interaction. This way could not be continued further to include properly the magnetic forces between the charged particles and lead to a lot of confusion about the interpretation of the magnetic field in the Hamiltonian, as well as about the gauge invariance. We emphasize the importance of the distinction between the applied (external fields) and the field in the matter. All these problems are length properly solved within the non-relativistic QED, nevertheless the confusion dominates in all the problems related to the magnetic properties of the solid state.

arXiv:2207.14390•Recent Progress in Materials•Dec 8, 2022•3 citations

A field-theoretical approach to non-relativistic QED

L. Bányai, M. Bundaru

We give here a field-theoretical derivation of the Hamiltonian of the non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics in the Coulomb gauge using the Lagrange formalism. It leads to the same result as the usual derivation, where one just replaces the classical vector potential in the minimal coupling of the second quantized electron Hamiltonian by the quantized one and adds the photon energy. This approach illustrates however the proper use of the Euler-Lagrange equations and the canonical formalism that fail if one tries to build up the many-body quantum theory starting from the classical theory of point-like particles interacting with electromagnetic fields.

arXiv:1907.13053•Jul 30, 2019•0 citations

Noncovariant gauge fixing in the quantum Dirac field theory of atoms and molecules

Adam Stokes

Starting from the Weyl gauge formulation of quantum electrodynamics (QED), the formalism of quantum-mechanical gauge fixing is extended using techniques from nonrelativistic QED. This involves expressing the redundant gauge degrees of freedom through an arbitrary functional of the gauge-invariant transverse degrees of freedom. Particular choices of functional can be made to yield the Coulomb gauge and Poincar\'e gauge representations. The Hamiltonian we derive therefore serves as a good starting point for the description of atoms and molecules by means of a relativistic Dirac field. We discuss important implications for the ontology of noncovariant canonical QED due to the gauge freedom that remains present in our formulation.

arXiv:1207.3196•Physical Review A•Jul 23, 2012•11 citations

Propagator picture of the spatial confinement of quantized light emitted from an atom

Ole Keller

A field-quantized electromagnetic propagator description emphasizing the spatial localization of light emitted from a single-electron atom is presented. With the aim of obtaining a better insight into the quantum electrodynamics in the near-field zone of the atom, two approaches, formally different but equivalent in respect to their physical predictions, are studied. From the Maxwell equations, among the transverse operators, a transverse propagator picture in which the source region for the field is identified with the spatial domain occupied by the transverse current density of the atom emerges. In this picture the field propagation is isotropic and always retarded. By identifying the source region with that of the total atomic current, the transverse propagator becomes anisotropic, and attains a nonretarded self-field part and a near-field part different from zero only for spacelike events. By changing the Coulomb Lagrangian, a nonrelativistic Hamiltonian formalism adequate for reconciling the photon concept with the anisotropic propagator picture is introduced. In this formalism the transverse self-field energy is transferred to the particle Hamiltonian, and the interaction Hamiltonian now includes an interaction between the retarded field and the transverse self-field dynamics. The link between the standard (nonpropagator) theory, often used to argue that the total electromagnetic field is always retarded, and the transverse propagator theory is established. The equivalence between the two approaches is proved by demonstrating that the standard theory in fact includes a nonretarded response in the spatial domain occupied by the longitudinal part of the induced atomic current density.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1998•30 citations

Condensed matter many-body theory in relativistic covariant form

Valério Olevano, Massimo Ladisa

We present a relativistic covariant form of many-body theory. The many-body covariant Lagrangian is derived from QED by integrating out the internal non-quantized electromagnetic field. The ordinary many-body Hamiltonian is recovered as an approximation to the exact covariant theory that contains many-body terms beyond the solely electrostatic interaction, e.g. the Lorentz force among electrons, spin-spin etc. Spin and relativistic terms, e.g. spin-orbit, are also automatically accounted. Moreover, the theory is compact, gauge-invariant and respects causality.

arXiv:1002.2117•Feb 10, 2010•2 citations

Jaynes-Cummings Hamiltonian in a covariant gauge

C. Baxter

The minimal-coupling Hamiltonian for a nonrelativistic hydrogenic atom interacting with a photon field in the \ensuremath{\alpha}-Lorentz gauge is canonically gauge transformed to one with four arbitrary degrees of gauge freedom. The theory, nonrelativistic in the charge dynamics, is wholly covariant in its treatment of the scalar, transverse, and longitudinal electromagnetic fields. One degree of gauge freedom of the transformed Hamiltonian comes from the arbitrary scalar parameter contained within the \ensuremath{\alpha}-Lorentz gauge, while the others come from arbitrary parameters governing the gauge transformation. A Jaynes-Cummings-type model is constructed by suitable restrictions to the gauge freedom, and found to display an admixture of transverse and scalar interactions but no longitudinal component. The model gives the Lamb shift, correct to the second order of the electronic charge consistent with relativistic quantum electrodynamics.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1991•3 citations
On the Nonrelativistic Quantum-Mechanical Hamiltonian with 1/c21/c^21/c2 terms. Transverse current-current interaction
We extend the standard solid-state quantum mechanical Hamiltonian containing only Coulomb interactions between the charged particles by inclusion of 1/c21/c^21/c2 terms representing (transverse) current-current interaction. For its derivation we use the classical formulation of Landau-Lifshitz, however consequently in the Coulomb gauge. Our Hamiltonian does not coincide with the Darwin Hamiltonian and we emphasize the mathematical inconsistency in its derivation. We show, that the quantized version of our Hamiltonian is equivalent to the non-relativistic QED considering only states without photons and retaining only terms of order 1/c21/c^21/c2. The importance of this extended Hamiltonian lies in the possibility to distinguish external from internal magnetic fields. This aspect may be relevant for theories of the Meissner effect.
We describe here the coherent formulation of electromagnetism in the nonrelativistic quantummechanical many-body theory. We use the mathematical frame of the field theory and its quantization in the spirit of the QED. This is necessary because of the manifold of misinterpretations emerging from the hystorical development of quantum mechanics, starting from the Schrödinger equation of a single particle in the presence of given electromagnetic fields, followed by the many-body theories of many charged identical particles having just Coulomb interactions inspired from the classical electromagnetic theory of point-like charges. However, this later is known to be inconsistent due to the self-interaction. This way could not be continued further to include properly the magnetic forces between the charged particles and lead to a lot of confusion about the interpretation of the magnetic field in the Hamiltonian, as well as about the gauge invariance. We emphasize the importance of the distinction between the applied (external fields) and the field in the matter. All these problems are length properly solved within the non-relativistic QED, nevertheless the confusion dominates in all the problems related to the magnetic properties of the solid state.
We give here a field-theoretical derivation of the Hamiltonian of the non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics in the Coulomb gauge using the Lagrange formalism. It leads to the same result as the usual derivation, where one just replaces the classical vector potential in the minimal coupling of the second quantized electron Hamiltonian by the quantized one and adds the photon energy. This approach illustrates however the proper use of the Euler-Lagrange equations and the canonical formalism that fail if one tries to build up the many-body quantum theory starting from the classical theory of point-like particles interacting with electromagnetic fields.
Starting from the Weyl gauge formulation of quantum electrodynamics (QED), the formalism of quantum-mechanical gauge fixing is extended using techniques from nonrelativistic QED. This involves expressing the redundant gauge degrees of freedom through an arbitrary functional of the gauge-invariant transverse degrees of freedom. Particular choices of functional can be made to yield the Coulomb gauge and Poincar\'e gauge representations. The Hamiltonian we derive therefore serves as a good starting point for the description of atoms and molecules by means of a relativistic Dirac field. We discuss important implications for the ontology of noncovariant canonical QED due to the gauge freedom that remains present in our formulation.
A field-quantized electromagnetic propagator description emphasizing the spatial localization of light emitted from a single-electron atom is presented. With the aim of obtaining a better insight into the quantum electrodynamics in the near-field zone of the atom, two approaches, formally different but equivalent in respect to their physical predictions, are studied. From the Maxwell equations, among the transverse operators, a transverse propagator picture in which the source region for the field is identified with the spatial domain occupied by the transverse current density of the atom emerges. In this picture the field propagation is isotropic and always retarded. By identifying the source region with that of the total atomic current, the transverse propagator becomes anisotropic, and attains a nonretarded self-field part and a near-field part different from zero only for spacelike events. By changing the Coulomb Lagrangian, a nonrelativistic Hamiltonian formalism adequate for reconciling the photon concept with the anisotropic propagator picture is introduced. In this formalism the transverse self-field energy is transferred to the particle Hamiltonian, and the interaction Hamiltonian now includes an interaction between the retarded field and the transverse self-field dynamics. The link between the standard (nonpropagator) theory, often used to argue that the total electromagnetic field is always retarded, and the transverse propagator theory is established. The equivalence between the two approaches is proved by demonstrating that the standard theory in fact includes a nonretarded response in the spatial domain occupied by the longitudinal part of the induced atomic current density.
We present a relativistic covariant form of many-body theory. The many-body covariant Lagrangian is derived from QED by integrating out the internal non-quantized electromagnetic field. The ordinary many-body Hamiltonian is recovered as an approximation to the exact covariant theory that contains many-body terms beyond the solely electrostatic interaction, e.g. the Lorentz force among electrons, spin-spin etc. Spin and relativistic terms, e.g. spin-orbit, are also automatically accounted. Moreover, the theory is compact, gauge-invariant and respects causality.
The minimal-coupling Hamiltonian for a nonrelativistic hydrogenic atom interacting with a photon field in the \ensuremath{\alpha}-Lorentz gauge is canonically gauge transformed to one with four arbitrary degrees of gauge freedom. The theory, nonrelativistic in the charge dynamics, is wholly covariant in its treatment of the scalar, transverse, and longitudinal electromagnetic fields. One degree of gauge freedom of the transformed Hamiltonian comes from the arbitrary scalar parameter contained within the \ensuremath{\alpha}-Lorentz gauge, while the others come from arbitrary parameters governing the gauge transformation. A Jaynes-Cummings-type model is constructed by suitable restrictions to the gauge freedom, and found to display an admixture of transverse and scalar interactions but no longitudinal component. The model gives the Lamb shift, correct to the second order of the electronic charge consistent with relativistic quantum electrodynamics.