Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1905.01724 · Physical Review A

Certification of spin-based quantum simulators

Abolfazl Bayat, B. Voisin, Gilles Buchs, Joe Salfi, Sven M. J. Rogge, Sougato Bose

Published May 29, 2020• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum simulators are engineered devices controllably designed to emulate complex and classically intractable quantum systems. A key challenge is to certify whether the simulator truly mimics the Hamiltonian of interest. This certification step requires the comparison of a simulator's output to a known answer, which is usually limited to small systems due to the exponential scaling of the Hilbert space. Here, in the context of Fermi-Hubbard spin-based analog simulators, we propose a modular many-body spin to charge conversion scheme that scales linearly with both the system size and the number of low-energy eigenstates to discriminate. Our protocol is based on the global charge state measurement of a 1D spin chain performed at different detuning potentials along the chain. In the context of semiconductor-based systems, we identify realistic conditions for detuning the chain adiabatically to avoid state mixing while preserving charge coherence. Large simulators with vanishing energy gaps, including 2D arrays, can be certified block-by-block with a number of measurements scaling only linearly with the system size.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.101.052344

Related papers

Quantum Simulation of Antiferromagnetic Heisenberg Chain with Gate-Defined Quantum Dots

Cornelis Jacobus van Diepen, Tzu-Kan Hsiao, U. Mukhopadhyay +3 more

Quantum-mechanical correlations of interacting fermions result in the emergence of exotic phases.Magnetic phases naturally arise in the Mott-insulator regime of the Fermi-Hubbard model, where charges are localized and the spin degree of freedom remains.In this regime, the occurrence of phenomena such as resonating valence bonds, frustrated magnetism, and spin liquids is predicted.Quantum systems with engineered Hamiltonians can be used as simulators of such spin physics to provide insights beyond the capabilities of analytical methods and classical computers.To be useful, methods for the preparation of intricate many-body spin states and access to relevant observables are required.Here, we show the quantum simulation of magnetism in the Mott-insulator regime with a linear quantum-dot array.We characterize the energy spectrum for a Heisenberg spin chain, from which we can identify when the conditions for homogeneous exchange couplings are met.Next, we study the multispin coherence with global exchange oscillations in both the singlet and triplet subspace of the Heisenberg Hamiltonian.Last, we adiabatically prepare the low-energy global singlet of the homogeneous spin chain and probe it with two-spin singlettriplet measurements on each nearest-neighbor pair and the correlations therein.The methods and control presented here open new opportunities for the simulation of quantum magnetism benefiting from the flexibility in tuning and layout of gate-defined quantum-dot arrays.

arXiv:2103.08238•Physical Review X•Nov 4, 2021•58 citations

Certifying Localizable Quantum Properties with Constant Sample Complexity

Zhenyu Du, Jinchang Liu, Elias X. Huber +2 more

Characterizing increasingly complex quantum systems is a central task in quantum information science, yet experimental costs often scale prohibitively with system size. Certifying key properties using simple local measurements is highly desirable but challenging. In this work, we introduce a highly general certification framework based on a physical phenomenon that we call localizable quantumness: for generic many-body states, essential quantum properties are robustly preserved within the projected ensembles on small subsystems after performing local projective measurements on the rest of the system. Leveraging this insight, we develop protocols to certify global properties—including multipartite entanglement, circuit complexity, and quantum magic—by witnessing them on a small, accessible subsystem. Remarkably, randomizing the local measurement bases extends this capability to certify state fidelity. Relying solely on local Pauli measurements, these protocols achieve constant sample complexity and robustness for almost all quantum states, including a wide range of physically relevant states. For certifying the fidelity of n -qubit states, this O ( 1 ) scaling dramatically improves upon state-of-the-art protocols requiring O ( n 4 ) samples. Our unified framework provides both a practical toolkit for large-scale quantum certification and a novel lens into complex many-body systems.

arXiv:2509.17580•Physical Review X•Sep 16, 2026•11 citations

Certified variational quantum algorithms for eigenstate preparation

Andrey Kardashin, Alexey Uvarov, Dmitry I. Yudin +1 more

Solutions to many-body problem instances often involve an intractable number of degrees of freedom and admit no known approximations in general form. In practice, representing quantum-mechanical states of a given Hamiltonian using available numerical methods, in particular those based on variational Monte Carlo simulations, become exponentially more challenging with increasing system size. Recently quantum algorithms implemented as variational models have been proposed to accelerate such simulations. The variational ansatz states are characterized by a polynomial number of parameters devised in a way to minimize the expectation value of a given Hamiltonian, which is emulated by local measurements. In this study, we develop a means to certify the termination of variational algorithms. We demonstrate our approach by applying it to three models: the transverse field Ising model, the model of one-dimensional spinless fermions with competing interactions, and the Schwinger model of quantum electrodynamics. By means of comparison, we observe that our approach shows better performance near critical points in these models. We hence take a further step to improve the applicability and to certify the results of variational quantum simulators.

arXiv:2006.13222•Physical Review A•Nov 9, 2020•16 citations

Dynamics and Excited States of Quantum Many-body Spin Systems with Trapped Ions

Crystal Senko

Certain classes of quantum many-body systems, including those supporting phenomena like high-$T_c$ superconductivity and spin liquids, are believed to be fundamentally intractable to classical modeling. Quantum simulations, in which synthetic materials are engineered by inducing well-controlled quantum systems like ultracold atoms to obey many-body Hamiltonians of interest, are a promising new approach to study this type of physics. In this work, I present several advances toward this ultimate goal of large-scale, highly controllable quantum simulations of many-body spin physics. We simulate long-range Ising and XY spin models in the presence of transverse and longitudinal magnetic fields using chains of up to 18 ultracold $^{171}$Yb$^+$ ions held in a linear Paul trap, where two hyperfine levels in each ion encode spin-1/2 states. The tunable spin-spin interactions and effective magnetic fields are engineered using laser fields, and the individual spin states are directly imaged with state-dependent fluorescence. The results in this thesis address several of the ongoing challenges in the development of synthetic quantum matter platforms. One such challenge is establishing more flexible capabilities in the sorts of Hamiltonians we can model. By observing suppression of the ground state spin ordering, we have demonstrated our ability to continuously tune the interaction range in a power-law interaction pattern, and hence the amount of frustration present in the spin system. We have additionally begun developing tools to study particles of higher spin, which could eventually be used to create and study topological phases of matter. Another challenge is the necessity of identifying problems that the next generation of experiments, with flexible (but not arbitrary) controls and classically intractable (but not infinitely large) system sizes, can feasibly shed new light on. We have made measurements of how the range of interaction affects dynamics of spin correlations propagating through the chain, and the excellent agreement between our observations and numerical simulations indicate that at larger sizes, our experiment can meaningfully contribute to the open question of the fundamental speed limit on the transfer of information through such a spin chain. Finally, for classically intractable system sizes, it will be crucial to have multiple techniques at our disposal for validating our understanding of the exact microscopic model being implemented. We have developed and demonstrated an MRI-like spectroscopic technique for probing the energies of the many-body Hamiltonian, which serves as a new method for validating quantum simulations of the transverse Ising model. Our experiments can potentially be scaled up in the near future to study fully connected lattice spin models with several tens of spins, where classical computation begins to fail, and the results described in this thesis contribute to the effort to build experiments that can break new ground in the study of quantum many-body physics.

•Jan 1, 2014•3 citations

Engineering a Quantum Many-body Hamiltonian with Trapped Ions

Aaron Christopher Lee

While fault-tolerant quantum computation might still be years away, analog quantum simulators offer a way to leverage current quantum technologies to study classically intractable quantum systems. Cutting edge quantum simulators such as those utilizing ultracold atoms are beginning to study physics which surpass what is classically tractable. As the system sizes of these quantum simulators increase, there are also concurrent gains in the complexity and types of Hamiltonians which can be simulated. In this work, I describe advances toward the realization of an adaptable, tunable quantum simulator capable of surpassing classical computation. We simulate long-ranged Ising and XY spin models which can have global arbitrary transverse and longitudinal fields in addition to individual transverse fields using a linear chain of up to 24 Yb+ 171 ions confined in a linear rf Paul trap. Each qubit is encoded in the ground state hyperfine levels of an ion. Spin-spin interactions are engineered by the application of spin-dependent forces from laser fields, coupling spin to motion. Each spin can be read independently using state-dependent fluorescence. The results here add yet more tools to an ever growing quantum simulation toolbox. One of many challenges has been the coherent manipulation of individual qubits. By using a surprisingly large fourth-order Stark shifts in a clock-state qubit, we demonstrate an ability to individually manipulate spins and apply independent Hamiltonian terms, greatly increasing the range of quantum simulations which can be implemented. As quantum systems grow beyond the capability of classical numerics, a constant question is how to verify a quantum simulation. Here, I present measurements which may provide useful metrics for large system sizes and demonstrate them in a system of up to 24 ions during a classically intractable simulation. The observed values are consistent with extremely large entangled states, as much as ~95% of the system entangled. Finally, we use many of these techniques in order to generate a spin Hamiltonian which fails to thermalize during experimental time scales due to a meta-stable state which is often called prethermal. The observed prethermal state is a new form of prethermalization which arises due to long-range interactions and open boundary conditions, even in the thermodynamic limit. This prethermalization is observed in a system of up to 22 spins. We expect that system sizes can be extended up to 30 spins with only minor upgrades to the current apparatus. These results emphasize that as the technology improves, the techniques and tools developed here can potentially be used to perform simulations which will surpass the capability of even the most sophisticated classical techniques, enabling the study of a whole new regime of quantum many-body physics.

•Jan 1, 2016•3 citations

Emulating Fermi-Hubbard physics with quantum dots

Toivo Hensgens

Interacting electrons on material lattices can build up strong quantum correlations, which in turn can lead to the emergence of a wide range of novel and potentially useful magnetic and electronic material properties. Our understanding of this physics, however, is severely limited by the exponential growth in complexity with system size, which leads all classical methods to fall fundamentally short. In this thesis, I show how artificial lattices of conduction band electrons in semiconductors, so-called quantum dot arrays, can be used to directly emulate and therefore elucidate such Fermi-Hubbard physics. To this end, I focus on two approaches. A top-down approach allows to scale easily, but lacks to ability to control or measure individual sites. A bottom-up approach on the other hand utilizes the small devices employed by the community for qubit experiments, in which the control of individual sites is both a blessing and a curse. We address the issue of control to the point where mapping to relevant models is possible and efficiently calibrating larger devices becomes feasible. These results open up the inherently well-suited and scalable platform of quantum dots to emulate novel quantum states of matter.

•Jan 1, 2018•4 citations
Quantum simulators are engineered devices controllably designed to emulate complex and classically intractable quantum systems. A key challenge is to certify whether the simulator truly mimics the Hamiltonian of interest. This certification step requires the comparison of a simulator's output to a known answer, which is usually limited to small systems due to the exponential scaling of the Hilbert space. Here, in the context of Fermi-Hubbard spin-based analog simulators, we propose a modular many-body spin to charge conversion scheme that scales linearly with both the system size and the number of low-energy eigenstates to discriminate. Our protocol is based on the global charge state measurement of a 1D spin chain performed at different detuning potentials along the chain. In the context of semiconductor-based systems, we identify realistic conditions for detuning the chain adiabatically to avoid state mixing while preserving charge coherence. Large simulators with vanishing energy gaps, including 2D arrays, can be certified block-by-block with a number of measurements scaling only linearly with the system size.
Quantum-mechanical correlations of interacting fermions result in the emergence of exotic phases.Magnetic phases naturally arise in the Mott-insulator regime of the Fermi-Hubbard model, where charges are localized and the spin degree of freedom remains.In this regime, the occurrence of phenomena such as resonating valence bonds, frustrated magnetism, and spin liquids is predicted.Quantum systems with engineered Hamiltonians can be used as simulators of such spin physics to provide insights beyond the capabilities of analytical methods and classical computers.To be useful, methods for the preparation of intricate many-body spin states and access to relevant observables are required.Here, we show the quantum simulation of magnetism in the Mott-insulator regime with a linear quantum-dot array.We characterize the energy spectrum for a Heisenberg spin chain, from which we can identify when the conditions for homogeneous exchange couplings are met.Next, we study the multispin coherence with global exchange oscillations in both the singlet and triplet subspace of the Heisenberg Hamiltonian.Last, we adiabatically prepare the low-energy global singlet of the homogeneous spin chain and probe it with two-spin singlettriplet measurements on each nearest-neighbor pair and the correlations therein.The methods and control presented here open new opportunities for the simulation of quantum magnetism benefiting from the flexibility in tuning and layout of gate-defined quantum-dot arrays.
Characterizing increasingly complex quantum systems is a central task in quantum information science, yet experimental costs often scale prohibitively with system size. Certifying key properties using simple local measurements is highly desirable but challenging. In this work, we introduce a highly general certification framework based on a physical phenomenon that we call localizable quantumness: for generic many-body states, essential quantum properties are robustly preserved within the projected ensembles on small subsystems after performing local projective measurements on the rest of the system. Leveraging this insight, we develop protocols to certify global properties—including multipartite entanglement, circuit complexity, and quantum magic—by witnessing them on a small, accessible subsystem. Remarkably, randomizing the local measurement bases extends this capability to certify state fidelity. Relying solely on local Pauli measurements, these protocols achieve constant sample complexity and robustness for almost all quantum states, including a wide range of physically relevant states. For certifying the fidelity of n -qubit states, this O ( 1 ) scaling dramatically improves upon state-of-the-art protocols requiring O ( n 4 ) samples. Our unified framework provides both a practical toolkit for large-scale quantum certification and a novel lens into complex many-body systems.
Solutions to many-body problem instances often involve an intractable number of degrees of freedom and admit no known approximations in general form. In practice, representing quantum-mechanical states of a given Hamiltonian using available numerical methods, in particular those based on variational Monte Carlo simulations, become exponentially more challenging with increasing system size. Recently quantum algorithms implemented as variational models have been proposed to accelerate such simulations. The variational ansatz states are characterized by a polynomial number of parameters devised in a way to minimize the expectation value of a given Hamiltonian, which is emulated by local measurements. In this study, we develop a means to certify the termination of variational algorithms. We demonstrate our approach by applying it to three models: the transverse field Ising model, the model of one-dimensional spinless fermions with competing interactions, and the Schwinger model of quantum electrodynamics. By means of comparison, we observe that our approach shows better performance near critical points in these models. We hence take a further step to improve the applicability and to certify the results of variational quantum simulators.
Certain classes of quantum many-body systems, including those supporting phenomena like high-TcT_cTc​ superconductivity and spin liquids, are believed to be fundamentally intractable to classical modeling. Quantum simulations, in which synthetic materials are engineered by inducing well-controlled quantum systems like ultracold atoms to obey many-body Hamiltonians of interest, are a promising new approach to study this type of physics. In this work, I present several advances toward this ultimate goal of large-scale, highly controllable quantum simulations of many-body spin physics. We simulate long-range Ising and XY spin models in the presence of transverse and longitudinal magnetic fields using chains of up to 18 ultracold 171^{171}171Yb+^++ ions held in a linear Paul trap, where two hyperfine levels in each ion encode spin-1/2 states. The tunable spin-spin interactions and effective magnetic fields are engineered using laser fields, and the individual spin states are directly imaged with state-dependent fluorescence. The results in this thesis address several of the ongoing challenges in the development of synthetic quantum matter platforms. One such challenge is establishing more flexible capabilities in the sorts of Hamiltonians we can model. By observing suppression of the ground state spin ordering, we have demonstrated our ability to continuously tune the interaction range in a power-law interaction pattern, and hence the amount of frustration present in the spin system. We have additionally begun developing tools to study particles of higher spin, which could eventually be used to create and study topological phases of matter. Another challenge is the necessity of identifying problems that the next generation of experiments, with flexible (but not arbitrary) controls and classically intractable (but not infinitely large) system sizes, can feasibly shed new light on. We have made measurements of how the range of interaction affects dynamics of spin correlations propagating through the chain, and the excellent agreement between our observations and numerical simulations indicate that at larger sizes, our experiment can meaningfully contribute to the open question of the fundamental speed limit on the transfer of information through such a spin chain. Finally, for classically intractable system sizes, it will be crucial to have multiple techniques at our disposal for validating our understanding of the exact microscopic model being implemented. We have developed and demonstrated an MRI-like spectroscopic technique for probing the energies of the many-body Hamiltonian, which serves as a new method for validating quantum simulations of the transverse Ising model. Our experiments can potentially be scaled up in the near future to study fully connected lattice spin models with several tens of spins, where classical computation begins to fail, and the results described in this thesis contribute to the effort to build experiments that can break new ground in the study of quantum many-body physics.
While fault-tolerant quantum computation might still be years away, analog quantum simulators offer a way to leverage current quantum technologies to study classically intractable quantum systems. Cutting edge quantum simulators such as those utilizing ultracold atoms are beginning to study physics which surpass what is classically tractable. As the system sizes of these quantum simulators increase, there are also concurrent gains in the complexity and types of Hamiltonians which can be simulated. In this work, I describe advances toward the realization of an adaptable, tunable quantum simulator capable of surpassing classical computation. We simulate long-ranged Ising and XY spin models which can have global arbitrary transverse and longitudinal fields in addition to individual transverse fields using a linear chain of up to 24 Yb+ 171 ions confined in a linear rf Paul trap. Each qubit is encoded in the ground state hyperfine levels of an ion. Spin-spin interactions are engineered by the application of spin-dependent forces from laser fields, coupling spin to motion. Each spin can be read independently using state-dependent fluorescence. The results here add yet more tools to an ever growing quantum simulation toolbox. One of many challenges has been the coherent manipulation of individual qubits. By using a surprisingly large fourth-order Stark shifts in a clock-state qubit, we demonstrate an ability to individually manipulate spins and apply independent Hamiltonian terms, greatly increasing the range of quantum simulations which can be implemented. As quantum systems grow beyond the capability of classical numerics, a constant question is how to verify a quantum simulation. Here, I present measurements which may provide useful metrics for large system sizes and demonstrate them in a system of up to 24 ions during a classically intractable simulation. The observed values are consistent with extremely large entangled states, as much as ~95% of the system entangled. Finally, we use many of these techniques in order to generate a spin Hamiltonian which fails to thermalize during experimental time scales due to a meta-stable state which is often called prethermal. The observed prethermal state is a new form of prethermalization which arises due to long-range interactions and open boundary conditions, even in the thermodynamic limit. This prethermalization is observed in a system of up to 22 spins. We expect that system sizes can be extended up to 30 spins with only minor upgrades to the current apparatus. These results emphasize that as the technology improves, the techniques and tools developed here can potentially be used to perform simulations which will surpass the capability of even the most sophisticated classical techniques, enabling the study of a whole new regime of quantum many-body physics.
Interacting electrons on material lattices can build up strong quantum correlations, which in turn can lead to the emergence of a wide range of novel and potentially useful magnetic and electronic material properties. Our understanding of this physics, however, is severely limited by the exponential growth in complexity with system size, which leads all classical methods to fall fundamentally short. In this thesis, I show how artificial lattices of conduction band electrons in semiconductors, so-called quantum dot arrays, can be used to directly emulate and therefore elucidate such Fermi-Hubbard physics. To this end, I focus on two approaches. A top-down approach allows to scale easily, but lacks to ability to control or measure individual sites. A bottom-up approach on the other hand utilizes the small devices employed by the community for qubit experiments, in which the control of individual sites is both a blessing and a curse. We address the issue of control to the point where mapping to relevant models is possible and efficiently calibrating larger devices becomes feasible. These results open up the inherently well-suited and scalable platform of quantum dots to emulate novel quantum states of matter.