Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1904.12977 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

When can quantum decoherence be mimicked by classical noise?

Bing Gu, Ignacio Franco

Published Jul 3, 2019• 41 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum decoherence arises due to uncontrollable entanglement between a system and its environment. However, the effects of decoherence are often thought of and modeled through a simpler picture in which the role of the environment is to introduce classical noise in the system's degrees of freedom. Here, we establish necessary conditions that the classical noise models need to satisfy to quantitatively model the decoherence. Specifically, for pure-dephasing processes, we identify well-defined statistical properties for the noise that are determined by the quantum many-point time correlation function of the environmental operators that enter into the system-bath interaction. In particular, for the exemplifying spin-boson problem with a Lorentz-Drude spectral density, we show that the high-temperature quantum decoherence is quantitatively mimicked by colored Gaussian noise. In turn, for dissipative environments, we show that classical noise models cannot describe decoherence effects due to relaxation through spontaneous emission of photons/phonons. These developments provide a rigorous platform to assess the validity of classical noise models of decoherence.

DOI
10.1063/1.5099499

Related papers

DECOHERENCE, NON-MARKOVIANITY AND QUANTUM ESTIMATION IN QUBIT SYSTEMS SUBJECT TO CLASSICAL NOISE

Claudia Benedetti

The unavoidable interaction of a quantum system with its environment usually degrades its coherence and quantumness. The environment and the decoherence process may be described as the interaction with a classical or quantized bath. As a matter of fact, the classical description becomes progressively more reliable as far as the environment has many degrees of freedom, i.e. it becomes complex, or when the interaction between a quantum system and a classical fluctuating field is taken into account. In this thesis, I consider a qubit system coupled to a stochastic classical field and address�the decoherence and non-Markovianity induced by the external noise as well as the spectral characterization of the classical field by quantum-limited measurement on the qubit. I thus analyze the dynamics of quantum correlations between two non-interacting, initially entangled qubits subject to a classical noise generated by a stochastic process. Two relevant classes of noise are taken into account: Gaussian noise, such as the Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process, and non-Gaussian noise, such as the random telgraph noise and the colored noise with 1/f spectrum. I also discuss the evaluation of non-Markovianity of the induced dynamical map and link the presence of revivals of quantum correlations with the information backflow to the system. The precise characterization of the stochastic process generating the classical noise, possibly using minimal resources, is a crucial ingredient for the design of high-precision measurements and reliable communication protocols. To this purpose, I also address the characterization of the spectral parameters of classical noise by quantum probes, e.g. a qubit coupled to the stochastic process generating the noise. By using the tools of quantum estimation theory, I explore the performances of quantum measurements on the qubit and show that it is possible to effectively extract information about the noise.

•Jan 30, 2015•1 citation

Mimicking classical noise in ion channels by quantum decoherence

Mina Seifi, Ali Soltanmanesh, Afshin Shafiee

The mechanism of selectivity in ion channels is still an open question in biology. Recent studies suggest that the selectivity filter may exhibit quantum coherence, which could help explain how ions are selected and conducted. However, environmental noise causes decoherence and loss of quantum effects. It is hoped that the effect of classical noise on ion channels can be modeled using the framework provided by quantum decoherence theory. In this paper, the behavior of the ion channel system was simulated using two models: the Spin-Boson model and the stochastic Hamiltonian model under classical noise. Additionally, using a different approach, the system's evolution was modeled as a two-level Spin-Boson model with tunneling, interacting with a bath of harmonic oscillators, based on decoherence theory. We investigated under what conditions the decoherence model approaches and deviates from the noise model. Specifically, we examined Gaussian noise and Ornstein-Uhlenbeck noise in our model. Gaussian noise shows a very good agreement with the decoherence model. By examining the results, it was found that the Spin-Boson model at a high hopping rate of potassium ions can simulate the behavior of the system in the classical noise approach for Gaussian noise.

arXiv:2311.10222•Scientific Reports•Jul 12, 2024•6 citations

Classical vs. Quantum Decoherence

Julius Helm

Based on the superposition principle, any two states of a quantum system may be coherently superposed to yield a novel state. Such a simple construction is at the heart of genuinely quantum phenomena such as interference of massive particles or quantum entanglement. Yet, these superpositions are susceptible to environmental influences, eventually leading to a complete disappearance of the system's quantum character. In principle, two distinct mechanisms responsible for this process of decoherence may be identified. In a classical decoherence setting, on the one hand, stochastic fluctuations of classical, ambient fields are the relevant source. This approach leads to a formulation in terms of stochastic Hamiltonians; the dynamics is unitary, yet stochastic. In a quantum decoherence scenario, on the other hand, the system is described in the language of open quantum systems. Here, the environmental degrees of freedom are to be treated quantum mechanically, too. The loss of coherence is then a direct consequence of growing correlations between system and environment. The purpose of the present thesis is to clarify the distinction between classical and quantum decoherence. It is known that there exist decoherence processes that are not reconcilable with the classical approach. We deem it desirable to have a simple, feasible model at hand of which it is known that it cannot be understood in terms of fluctuating fields. Indeed, we find such an example of true quantum decoherence. The calculation of the norm distance to the convex set of classical dynamics allows for a quantitative assessment of the results. In order to incorporate genuine irreversibility, we extend the original toy model by an additional bath. Here, the fragility of the true quantum nature of the dynamics under increasing coupling strength is evident. The geometric character of our findings offers remarkable insights into the geometry of the set of non-classical decoherence maps. We give a very intuitive geometrical measure---a volume---for the quantumness of dynamics. This enables us to identify the decoherence process of maximum quantumness, that is, having maximal distance to the convex set of dynamics consistent with the stochastic, classical approach. In addition, we observe a distinct correlation between the decoherence potential of a given dynamics and its achievable quantumness. In a last step, we study the notion of quantum decoherence in the context of a bipartite system which couples locally to the subsystems' respective environments. A simple argument shows that in the case of a separable environment the resulting dynamics is of classical nature. Based on a realistic experiment, we analyze the impact of entanglement between the local environments on the nature of the dynamics. Interestingly, despite the variety of entangled environmental states scrutinized, no single instance of true quantum decoherence is encountered. In part, the identification of the classical nature relies on numerical schemes. However, for a large class of dynamics, we are able to exclude analytically the true quantum nature.

•Oct 25, 2011•0 citations

Decoherence in qubits due to low-frequency noise

J Bergli, Y M Galperin, B. L. Altshuler

The efficiency of the future devices for quantum information processing will be limited mostly by the finite decoherence rates of the qubits. Recently, substantial progress was achieved in enhancing the time within which a solid-state qubit demonstrates coherent dynamics. This progress is based mostly on a successful isolation of the qubits from external decoherence sources. Under these conditions, the material-inherent sources of noise start to play a crucial role. In most cases, the noise that the quantum device demonstrates has a 1/ f spectrum. This suggests that the environment that destroys the phase coherence of the qubit can be thought of as a system of two-state fluctuators, which experience random hops between their states. In this short review, the current state of the theory of the decoherence due to the qubit interaction with the fluctuators is discussed. The effect of such an environment on two different protocols of the qubit manipulations, free induction and echo signal, is described. It turns out that in many important cases the noise produced by the fluctuators is non-Gaussian. Consequently, the results of the interaction of the qubit with the fluctuators are not determined by the pair correlation function alone. We describe the effect of the fluctuators using the so-called spin-fluctuator model. Being quite realistic, this model allows one to exactly evaluate the qubit dynamics in the presence of one fluctuator. This solution is found, and its features, including non-Gaussian effects, are analyzed in detail. We extend this consideration to systems of large numbers of fluctuators, which interact with the qubit and lead to the 1/ f noise. We discuss existing experiments on the Josephson qubit manipulation and try to identify non-Gaussian behavior.

arXiv:0904.4597•New Journal of Physics•Feb 25, 2009•153 citations

Spatially correlated decoherence: understanding and exploiting spatial noise correlations in quantum systems

Jan Jeske

The challenge of making nano-scale quantum systems experimentally accessible is being overcome for an increasing diversity of systems by improved fabrication techniques and experimental control. Despite rapid progress, one of the main hindrances in all experiments is the difficulty of isolating the quantum system from the surrounding environment and its fluctuations. This experimental “noise” perturbs the quantum system, a process that is generally referred to as decoherence: the system slowly loses its distinguishing quantum features. In this thesis the effects of spatial correlations in the noise environment with a finite correlation length are investigated. The consequences for the experimental design of controlled quantum systems as well as the dynamics of solid state systems are presented. We utilize the Bloch-Redfield formalism, a Markovian master equation approach, which gives a close connection to the underpinning system-environment model. We show how to use this formalism to model any spatial correlation function of the noise environment. Using microscopic environmental models, several correlation functions are derived and their properties connected to the environmental parameters. Several phenomenological correlation functions are also studied and a mapping to the Lindblad master equation is presented, which provides a test of positivity for phenomenological models. For quantum transport through spin chains and networks, noise is generally detrimental. Spatial correlations however reduce the effect of dephasing noise and can reinstate the transport dynamics. The critical correlation length proves to be closely connected to the maximal packet width of one excitation in the transfer process. For dissipation noise, relaxation-free states emerge with spatial correlations. The decay of an excitation is therefore fundamentally modified into a fast decay towards an intermediate relaxation-reduced state and a subsequent decay to the ground state on a much longer time scale. In quantum metrology noise correlations have been observed in experiments with trapped ions, in which they limit the use of such experiments for metrology. Quantum advantage, i.e. a better precision scaling than the standard quantum limit has been proven impossible in the presence of uncorrelated Markovian noise only. We show that for certain optimized states the best possible quantum advantage, Heisenberg scaling, can be achieved in the presence of noise with a finite spatial decay of correlations. We furthermore identify how dephasing effects change and a topology dependence arises in strength with increasing correlation length for entangled states in a general way. Biological photosynthetic complexes have recently been found to potentially include quantum coherent dynamics, particularly in the process of transmitting an exciton from the point of creation to the reaction centre. We show how the formalism of spatially correlated decoherence adapts to this significantly different energy regime. Typical effects of decoherence in this field are presented and we show how the light-harvesting efficiency is influenced by spatial correlations in the noise. This thesis highlights the fundamental relevance of noise correlations to several fields of quantum physics and the importance of the efficient and comprehensive modelling techniques presented.

•Oct 9, 2014•1 citation

Correlated noise enhancement of coherence and fidelity in coupled qubits

Eric R. Bittner, Hao Li, Syed Ali Raza Shah +2 more

It is generally assumed that environmental noise arising from thermal fluctuations are detrimental to preserving coherence and entanglement in a quantum system. In the simplest sense, dephasing and decoherence are tied to energy fluctuations driven by coupling between the system and the normal modes of the bath. Here, we explore the role of noise correlation in an open-loop model quantum communication system whereby the ‘sender’ and the ‘receiver’ are subject to local environments with various degrees of correlation or anti-correlation. We introduce correlation within the spectral density by solving multidimensional stochastic differential equations and introduce these into the Redfield equations of motion for the system density matrix. We find that correlation can enhance both the fidelity and purity of a maximally entangled (Bell) state. Moreover, by comparing the evolution of different initial Bell states, we show that one can effectively probe the correlation between two local environments. These observations may be useful in the design of high-fidelity quantum gates and communication protocols.

The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Apr 17, 2024•6 citations
Quantum decoherence arises due to uncontrollable entanglement between a system and its environment. However, the effects of decoherence are often thought of and modeled through a simpler picture in which the role of the environment is to introduce classical noise in the system's degrees of freedom. Here, we establish necessary conditions that the classical noise models need to satisfy to quantitatively model the decoherence. Specifically, for pure-dephasing processes, we identify well-defined statistical properties for the noise that are determined by the quantum many-point time correlation function of the environmental operators that enter into the system-bath interaction. In particular, for the exemplifying spin-boson problem with a Lorentz-Drude spectral density, we show that the high-temperature quantum decoherence is quantitatively mimicked by colored Gaussian noise. In turn, for dissipative environments, we show that classical noise models cannot describe decoherence effects due to relaxation through spontaneous emission of photons/phonons. These developments provide a rigorous platform to assess the validity of classical noise models of decoherence.
The unavoidable interaction of a quantum system with its environment usually degrades its coherence and quantumness. The environment and the decoherence process may be described as the interaction with a classical or quantized bath. As a matter of fact, the classical description becomes progressively more reliable as far as the environment has many degrees of freedom, i.e. it becomes complex, or when the interaction between a quantum system and a classical fluctuating field is taken into account. In this thesis, I consider a qubit system coupled to a stochastic classical field and address�the decoherence and non-Markovianity induced by the external noise as well as the spectral characterization of the classical field by quantum-limited measurement on the qubit. I thus analyze the dynamics of quantum correlations between two non-interacting, initially entangled qubits subject to a classical noise generated by a stochastic process. Two relevant classes of noise are taken into account: Gaussian noise, such as the Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process, and non-Gaussian noise, such as the random telgraph noise and the colored noise with 1/f spectrum. I also discuss the evaluation of non-Markovianity of the induced dynamical map and link the presence of revivals of quantum correlations with the information backflow to the system. The precise characterization of the stochastic process generating the classical noise, possibly using minimal resources, is a crucial ingredient for the design of high-precision measurements and reliable communication protocols. To this purpose, I also address the characterization of the spectral parameters of classical noise by quantum probes, e.g. a qubit coupled to the stochastic process generating the noise. By using the tools of quantum estimation theory, I explore the performances of quantum measurements on the qubit and show that it is possible to effectively extract information about the noise.
The mechanism of selectivity in ion channels is still an open question in biology. Recent studies suggest that the selectivity filter may exhibit quantum coherence, which could help explain how ions are selected and conducted. However, environmental noise causes decoherence and loss of quantum effects. It is hoped that the effect of classical noise on ion channels can be modeled using the framework provided by quantum decoherence theory. In this paper, the behavior of the ion channel system was simulated using two models: the Spin-Boson model and the stochastic Hamiltonian model under classical noise. Additionally, using a different approach, the system's evolution was modeled as a two-level Spin-Boson model with tunneling, interacting with a bath of harmonic oscillators, based on decoherence theory. We investigated under what conditions the decoherence model approaches and deviates from the noise model. Specifically, we examined Gaussian noise and Ornstein-Uhlenbeck noise in our model. Gaussian noise shows a very good agreement with the decoherence model. By examining the results, it was found that the Spin-Boson model at a high hopping rate of potassium ions can simulate the behavior of the system in the classical noise approach for Gaussian noise.
Based on the superposition principle, any two states of a quantum system may be coherently superposed to yield a novel state. Such a simple construction is at the heart of genuinely quantum phenomena such as interference of massive particles or quantum entanglement. Yet, these superpositions are susceptible to environmental influences, eventually leading to a complete disappearance of the system's quantum character. In principle, two distinct mechanisms responsible for this process of decoherence may be identified. In a classical decoherence setting, on the one hand, stochastic fluctuations of classical, ambient fields are the relevant source. This approach leads to a formulation in terms of stochastic Hamiltonians; the dynamics is unitary, yet stochastic. In a quantum decoherence scenario, on the other hand, the system is described in the language of open quantum systems. Here, the environmental degrees of freedom are to be treated quantum mechanically, too. The loss of coherence is then a direct consequence of growing correlations between system and environment. The purpose of the present thesis is to clarify the distinction between classical and quantum decoherence. It is known that there exist decoherence processes that are not reconcilable with the classical approach. We deem it desirable to have a simple, feasible model at hand of which it is known that it cannot be understood in terms of fluctuating fields. Indeed, we find such an example of true quantum decoherence. The calculation of the norm distance to the convex set of classical dynamics allows for a quantitative assessment of the results. In order to incorporate genuine irreversibility, we extend the original toy model by an additional bath. Here, the fragility of the true quantum nature of the dynamics under increasing coupling strength is evident. The geometric character of our findings offers remarkable insights into the geometry of the set of non-classical decoherence maps. We give a very intuitive geometrical measure---a volume---for the quantumness of dynamics. This enables us to identify the decoherence process of maximum quantumness, that is, having maximal distance to the convex set of dynamics consistent with the stochastic, classical approach. In addition, we observe a distinct correlation between the decoherence potential of a given dynamics and its achievable quantumness. In a last step, we study the notion of quantum decoherence in the context of a bipartite system which couples locally to the subsystems' respective environments. A simple argument shows that in the case of a separable environment the resulting dynamics is of classical nature. Based on a realistic experiment, we analyze the impact of entanglement between the local environments on the nature of the dynamics. Interestingly, despite the variety of entangled environmental states scrutinized, no single instance of true quantum decoherence is encountered. In part, the identification of the classical nature relies on numerical schemes. However, for a large class of dynamics, we are able to exclude analytically the true quantum nature.
The efficiency of the future devices for quantum information processing will be limited mostly by the finite decoherence rates of the qubits. Recently, substantial progress was achieved in enhancing the time within which a solid-state qubit demonstrates coherent dynamics. This progress is based mostly on a successful isolation of the qubits from external decoherence sources. Under these conditions, the material-inherent sources of noise start to play a crucial role. In most cases, the noise that the quantum device demonstrates has a 1/ f spectrum. This suggests that the environment that destroys the phase coherence of the qubit can be thought of as a system of two-state fluctuators, which experience random hops between their states. In this short review, the current state of the theory of the decoherence due to the qubit interaction with the fluctuators is discussed. The effect of such an environment on two different protocols of the qubit manipulations, free induction and echo signal, is described. It turns out that in many important cases the noise produced by the fluctuators is non-Gaussian. Consequently, the results of the interaction of the qubit with the fluctuators are not determined by the pair correlation function alone. We describe the effect of the fluctuators using the so-called spin-fluctuator model. Being quite realistic, this model allows one to exactly evaluate the qubit dynamics in the presence of one fluctuator. This solution is found, and its features, including non-Gaussian effects, are analyzed in detail. We extend this consideration to systems of large numbers of fluctuators, which interact with the qubit and lead to the 1/ f noise. We discuss existing experiments on the Josephson qubit manipulation and try to identify non-Gaussian behavior.
The challenge of making nano-scale quantum systems experimentally accessible is being overcome for an increasing diversity of systems by improved fabrication techniques and experimental control. Despite rapid progress, one of the main hindrances in all experiments is the difficulty of isolating the quantum system from the surrounding environment and its fluctuations. This experimental “noise” perturbs the quantum system, a process that is generally referred to as decoherence: the system slowly loses its distinguishing quantum features. In this thesis the effects of spatial correlations in the noise environment with a finite correlation length are investigated. The consequences for the experimental design of controlled quantum systems as well as the dynamics of solid state systems are presented. We utilize the Bloch-Redfield formalism, a Markovian master equation approach, which gives a close connection to the underpinning system-environment model. We show how to use this formalism to model any spatial correlation function of the noise environment. Using microscopic environmental models, several correlation functions are derived and their properties connected to the environmental parameters. Several phenomenological correlation functions are also studied and a mapping to the Lindblad master equation is presented, which provides a test of positivity for phenomenological models. For quantum transport through spin chains and networks, noise is generally detrimental. Spatial correlations however reduce the effect of dephasing noise and can reinstate the transport dynamics. The critical correlation length proves to be closely connected to the maximal packet width of one excitation in the transfer process. For dissipation noise, relaxation-free states emerge with spatial correlations. The decay of an excitation is therefore fundamentally modified into a fast decay towards an intermediate relaxation-reduced state and a subsequent decay to the ground state on a much longer time scale. In quantum metrology noise correlations have been observed in experiments with trapped ions, in which they limit the use of such experiments for metrology. Quantum advantage, i.e. a better precision scaling than the standard quantum limit has been proven impossible in the presence of uncorrelated Markovian noise only. We show that for certain optimized states the best possible quantum advantage, Heisenberg scaling, can be achieved in the presence of noise with a finite spatial decay of correlations. We furthermore identify how dephasing effects change and a topology dependence arises in strength with increasing correlation length for entangled states in a general way. Biological photosynthetic complexes have recently been found to potentially include quantum coherent dynamics, particularly in the process of transmitting an exciton from the point of creation to the reaction centre. We show how the formalism of spatially correlated decoherence adapts to this significantly different energy regime. Typical effects of decoherence in this field are presented and we show how the light-harvesting efficiency is influenced by spatial correlations in the noise. This thesis highlights the fundamental relevance of noise correlations to several fields of quantum physics and the importance of the efficient and comprehensive modelling techniques presented.
It is generally assumed that environmental noise arising from thermal fluctuations are detrimental to preserving coherence and entanglement in a quantum system. In the simplest sense, dephasing and decoherence are tied to energy fluctuations driven by coupling between the system and the normal modes of the bath. Here, we explore the role of noise correlation in an open-loop model quantum communication system whereby the ‘sender’ and the ‘receiver’ are subject to local environments with various degrees of correlation or anti-correlation. We introduce correlation within the spectral density by solving multidimensional stochastic differential equations and introduce these into the Redfield equations of motion for the system density matrix. We find that correlation can enhance both the fidelity and purity of a maximally entangled (Bell) state. Moreover, by comparing the evolution of different initial Bell states, we show that one can effectively probe the correlation between two local environments. These observations may be useful in the design of high-fidelity quantum gates and communication protocols.