Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1903.11265 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Comment on ‘Two-dimensional position-dependent massive particles in the presence of magnetic fields’

Omar Mustafa

Published Dec 20, 2018• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Using the well known position-dependent mass (PDM) von Roos Hamiltonian et al (2009 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 42 025304) have studied the problem of two-dimensional PDM particles in the presence of magnetic fields. They have reported exact solutions for the wavefunctions and energies. In the first part of their study ‘PDM-Shrödinger equation in two-dimensional Cartesian coordinates’, they have used the so called Zhu and Kroemer’s ordering and (Zhu and Kroemer 1983 Phys. Rev . B 27 3519). While their treatment for this part is correct beyond doubt, their treatment of the second part of ‘PDM in a magnetic field’ is improper. We address these improper treatments and report the correct presentation for minimal coupling under PDM settings.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/aafa5b

Related papers

Two-dimensional position-dependent massive particles in the presence of magnetic fields

ALVARO DE SOUZA DUTRA, Juliano Antonio de Oliveira

In this work, we discuss the problem of a particle with a position-dependent mass interacting with a two-dimensional potential well with finite depth, as well as under the influence of a uniform magnetic field. The ordering ambiguity is taken in account, and we obtain the exact wavefunctions and energies for a complete set of eigenstates. It is shown that, even considering a finite-depth potential well, the system retains an infinite set of quantum states.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 2, 2008•21 citations

Comment on “Wave functions of a time-dependent harmonic oscillator in a static magnetic field”

Mustapha Maamache, Abdelhafid Bounames, N. Ferkous

We show that the procedure used by Ferreira et al. [Phys. Rev. A 66, 024103 (2002)] is not correct for the following reasons: (i) the invariant $I(t)$ they derived does not satisfy the Liouville--Von Neuman equation. (ii) They found that the eigenvalues of $I(t)$ are time dependent which should not be the case according to the Lewis-Riesenfeld theory. We give a correct procedure to find the solution of the system they considered, i.e., the Schr\"odinger equation for a two-dimensional harmonic oscillator with time-dependent mass and frequency in the presence of a static magnetic field.

Physical Review A•Jan 24, 2006•17 citations

On the role of quantum superpotentials in the position dependent mass Schrödinger equation

G. Ovando, José Juan Peña, J. Morales +1 more

The von Roos’ position dependent mass Schrödinger Equation (PDMSE) is given in terms of an effective potential, which is constructed by the potential under study and additional terms involving the position dependent mass and the ambiguity ordering parameters. At this regard, some of the most important approaches to the ambiguity parameters are those of BenDaniel-Duke, Gora-Williams, Zhu-Kroemer, Li-Kuhn and so on. In this work we show that for the cases of Zhu-Kroemer and BenDaniel-Duke it is possible to express any solvable potential through a couple of quantum superpotentials. For this, we stablish the factorization of the PDMSE Hamiltonian and the use of a point canonical transformation; these allow to identify a first superpotential W(x). Next, the term in the effective potential with ambiguity parameters is expressed through a function Z(x) and later the cases when Z(x) is a quantum superpotential are discussed. This way, the proposed superpotentials determine the solvable potentials in the PDMSE, the energy spectra and mass functions. We give some examples to explain the approach which can be straightforwardly applied to the solution of the PDMSE for other different potential models and mass distributions.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

On the singular position-dependent mass

F. C. E. Lima, F. M. Belchior, C. A. S. Almeida

Abstract Revisiting the issue associated with Position-Dependent Mass (PDM), we reaffirm that the appropriate framework for addressing a generic PDM is the symmetrization proposed by BenDaniel and Duke. To accomplish this result adopts the effective mass Hamiltonian proposed by von Roos, corrected by a symmetrized kinematic term. After verifying the appropriate ordering to approach the PDM issue, one investigates a crystalline lattice with a defect described by a singular PDM. The singular mass profile proves intriguing as it yields an atom’s cluster in the neighborhood of the singularity. Considering that a restoring force acts on the atoms, one notes that the confluent Heun function describes the quantum states. Furthermore, one highlights that when the effective mass distribution tends to a constant profile, we recover a system similar to the harmonic oscillator.

arXiv:2406.05899•Physica Scripta•Dec 9, 2024•5 citations

Position-dependent mass harmonic oscillator: classical-quantum mechanical correspondence and ordering-ambiguity

Omar Mustafa

We recycle Cruz et al.'s (Phys. Lett. A 369 (2007) 400) work on the classical and quantum position-dependent mass (PDM) oscillators. To elaborate on the ordering ambiguity, we properly amend some of the results reported in their work and discuss the classical and quantum mechanical correspondence for the PDM harmonic oscillators. We use a point canonical transformation and show that one unique quantum PDM oscillator Hamiltonian (consequently, one unique ordering-ambiguity parametric set j=l=-1/4 and k=-1/2) is obtained. To show that such a parametric set is not just a manifestation of the quantum PDM oscillator Hamiltonian, we consider the classical and quantum mechanical correspondence for quasi-free PDM particles moving under the influence of their own PDM force fields.

arXiv:1208.2109•Aug 10, 2012•11 citations

A complete set of eigenstates for position-dependent massive particles in a Morse-like scenario

R. A. C. Correa, ALVARO DE SOUZA DUTRA, Juliano Antonio de Oliveira +1 more

In this work, we analyze a system consisting in two-dimensional position-dependent massive particles in the presence of a Morse-like potential in two spatial dimensions. We obtain the exact wavefunctions and energies for a complete set of eigenstates for a given dependence of the mass with the spatial variables. Furthermore, we argue that this scenario can play an important role to construct more realistic ones by using their solution in perturbative approaches.

arXiv:1505.07899•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2017•5 citations
Abstract Using the well known position-dependent mass (PDM) von Roos Hamiltonian et al (2009 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 42 025304) have studied the problem of two-dimensional PDM particles in the presence of magnetic fields. They have reported exact solutions for the wavefunctions and energies. In the first part of their study ‘PDM-Shrödinger equation in two-dimensional Cartesian coordinates’, they have used the so called Zhu and Kroemer’s ordering and (Zhu and Kroemer 1983 Phys. Rev . B 27 3519). While their treatment for this part is correct beyond doubt, their treatment of the second part of ‘PDM in a magnetic field’ is improper. We address these improper treatments and report the correct presentation for minimal coupling under PDM settings.
We show that the procedure used by Ferreira et al. [Phys. Rev. A 66, 024103 (2002)] is not correct for the following reasons: (i) the invariant I(t)I(t)I(t) they derived does not satisfy the Liouville--Von Neuman equation. (ii) They found that the eigenvalues of I(t)I(t)I(t) are time dependent which should not be the case according to the Lewis-Riesenfeld theory. We give a correct procedure to find the solution of the system they considered, i.e., the Schr\"odinger equation for a two-dimensional harmonic oscillator with time-dependent mass and frequency in the presence of a static magnetic field.
The von Roos’ position dependent mass Schrödinger Equation (PDMSE) is given in terms of an effective potential, which is constructed by the potential under study and additional terms involving the position dependent mass and the ambiguity ordering parameters. At this regard, some of the most important approaches to the ambiguity parameters are those of BenDaniel-Duke, Gora-Williams, Zhu-Kroemer, Li-Kuhn and so on. In this work we show that for the cases of Zhu-Kroemer and BenDaniel-Duke it is possible to express any solvable potential through a couple of quantum superpotentials. For this, we stablish the factorization of the PDMSE Hamiltonian and the use of a point canonical transformation; these allow to identify a first superpotential W(x). Next, the term in the effective potential with ambiguity parameters is expressed through a function Z(x) and later the cases when Z(x) is a quantum superpotential are discussed. This way, the proposed superpotentials determine the solvable potentials in the PDMSE, the energy spectra and mass functions. We give some examples to explain the approach which can be straightforwardly applied to the solution of the PDMSE for other different potential models and mass distributions.
Abstract Revisiting the issue associated with Position-Dependent Mass (PDM), we reaffirm that the appropriate framework for addressing a generic PDM is the symmetrization proposed by BenDaniel and Duke. To accomplish this result adopts the effective mass Hamiltonian proposed by von Roos, corrected by a symmetrized kinematic term. After verifying the appropriate ordering to approach the PDM issue, one investigates a crystalline lattice with a defect described by a singular PDM. The singular mass profile proves intriguing as it yields an atom’s cluster in the neighborhood of the singularity. Considering that a restoring force acts on the atoms, one notes that the confluent Heun function describes the quantum states. Furthermore, one highlights that when the effective mass distribution tends to a constant profile, we recover a system similar to the harmonic oscillator.
We recycle Cruz et al.'s (Phys. Lett. A 369 (2007) 400) work on the classical and quantum position-dependent mass (PDM) oscillators. To elaborate on the ordering ambiguity, we properly amend some of the results reported in their work and discuss the classical and quantum mechanical correspondence for the PDM harmonic oscillators. We use a point canonical transformation and show that one unique quantum PDM oscillator Hamiltonian (consequently, one unique ordering-ambiguity parametric set j=l=-1/4 and k=-1/2) is obtained. To show that such a parametric set is not just a manifestation of the quantum PDM oscillator Hamiltonian, we consider the classical and quantum mechanical correspondence for quasi-free PDM particles moving under the influence of their own PDM force fields.