Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1902.09207 · Physical Review A

Electromagnetic-wave propagation through an array of superconducting qubits: Manifestations of nonequilibrium steady states of qubits

M. V. Fistul, M. A. Iontsev

Published Aug 27, 2019• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We report a theoretical study of the propagation of electromagnetic waves (EWs) through an array of superconducting qubits, i.e., coherent two-level systems, embedded in a low-dissipation transmission line. We focus on the near-resonant case as the frequency of EWs $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\simeq}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{q}$, where ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{q}$ is the qubit frequency. In this limit we derive the effective dynamic nonlinear wave equation allowing one to obtain the frequency-dependent transmission coefficient of EWs, $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$. In the linear regime and a relatively wide frequency region we obtain a strong resonant suppression of $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$ in both cases of a single qubit and chains composed of a large number of densely arranged qubits. However, in narrow frequency regions a chain of qubits allows the resonant transmission of EWs with greatly enhanced $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$. In the nonlinear regime realized for a moderate power of applied microwave radiation, we predict and analyze various transitions between states characterized by high and low values of $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$. These transitions are manifestations of nonequilibrium steady states of an array of qubits achieved in this regime.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.100.023844

Related papers

Collective quantum coherent oscillations in a globally coupled array of superconducting qubits

Pavel A. Volkov, M. V. Fistul

We report a theoretical study of coherent collective quantum dynamic effects in an array of $N$ qubits (two-level systems) incorporated into a low-dissipation resonant cavity. Individual qubits are characterized by energy level differences ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{i}$ and a spread of ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{i}$ is taken into account. Noninteracting qubits display coherent quantum beatings with $N$ different frequencies, i.e., ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{i}={\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{i}/\ensuremath{\hbar}$. Virtual emission and absorption of cavity photons provides a long-range interaction between qubits. In the presence of such interaction we analyze quantum correlation functions of individual qubits ${C}_{i}(t)$ to obtain two collective quantum-mechanical coherent oscillations, characterized by frequencies ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}=\overline{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/\ensuremath{\hbar}$ and ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{2}={\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{R}$, where ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{R}$ is the resonant frequency of the cavity renormalized by interaction. The amplitude of these oscillations can be strongly enhanced in the resonant case when ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{2}$. These collective quantum oscillations can be directly observed, e.g., by measurements of frequency dependent transmission coefficient $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$ of electromagnetic field propagating in a transmission line coupled to the system.

arXiv:1305.7370•Physical Review B•Feb 18, 2014•18 citations

Double-resonance response of a superconducting quantum metamaterial: Manifestation of nonclassical states of photons

M. A. Iontsev, Sergei I. Mukhin, M. V. Fistul

We report a theoretical study of the ac response of superconducting quantum metamaterials (SQMs), i.e., an array of qubits (two-level systems) embedded in a low-dissipative resonator. By making use of a particular example of a SQM, namely the array of charge qubits capacitively coupled to the resonator, we obtain a second-order phase transition between an incoherent (the high-temperature phase) and coherent (the low-temperatures phase) state of photons. This phase transition in many aspects resembles the paramagnetic-ferromagnetic phase transition. The critical temperature of the phase transition, ${T}^{\ensuremath{\star}}$, is determined by the energy splitting of two-level systems $\ensuremath{\delta}$, number of qubits in the array $N$, and the strength of the interaction $\ensuremath{\eta}$ between qubits and photons in the cavity. We obtain that the photon states manifest themselves by resonant drops in the frequency-dependent transmission $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$ of electromagnetic waves propagating through a transmission line weakly coupled to the SQM. At high temperatures the $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$ displays a single resonant drop, and at low temperatures a peculiar double-resonance response has to be observed. The physical origin of such a resonant splitting is the quantum oscillations between two coherent states of photons of different polarizations.

arXiv:1606.09078•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 17, 2016•8 citations

Bose condensation and Bogoliubov excitation in resonator-embedded superconducting qubit network

Patrick Navez, Valentina Di Meo, Berardo Ruggiero +12 more

Superconducting qubit networks (SQNs) embedded in a low-dissipative resonator is a promising device allowing one not only to establish the collective quantum dynamics on a macroscopic scale but also to greatly enhance the sensitivity of detectors of microwave photons. A quantum ac Stark effect provided by coupling between an SQN and microwave photons of a resonator, leads to a strong nonlinear interaction between photons. Here, we present a two-tone spectroscopy experiment in which a set of 10 superconducting flux qubits is coupled to the input R- resonator and the output T- transmission line. An external microwave pump field close to the resonance frequency populates macroscopically the resonator mode as a Bose-Einstein condensate, while a second probe beam scans the resonances referred also as Bogoliubov-like excitations. The corresponding excitation frequency measured from the transmission coefficient, |S21(f)| displays an abrupt change of the resonant dip position once the power of the pump field overcomes a critical value Pcr. This sharp shift occurs in a narrow region of pump frequencies, and can be tuned by an applied magnetic field. It is a signature of bistability of the photon number inside the resonator, in agreement with theory.

quant-pharXiv:2601.15101•Jan 22, 2026•0 citations

Quantum dynamics of disordered arrays of interacting superconducting qubits: Signatures of quantum collective states

M. V. Fistul, Oliver Neyenhuys, A. B. Bocaz +2 more

We study theoretically the collective quantum dynamics occurring in various interacting superconducting qubit arrays (SQAs) in the presence of a spread of individual qubit frequencies. The interaction is provided by mutual inductive coupling between adjacent qubits (short-range Ising interaction) or inductive coupling to a low-dissipative resonator (long-range exchange interaction). In the absence of interaction, the Fourier transform of the temporal correlation function of the total polarization ($z$ projection of the total spin), i.e., the dynamic susceptibility $C(\ensuremath{\omega})$, demonstrates a set of sharp small magnitude resonances corresponding to the transitions of individual superconducting qubits. We show that even a weak interaction between qubits can overcome the disorder with a simultaneous formation of the collective excited states. This collective behavior manifests itself by a single large resonance in $C(\ensuremath{\omega})$. In the presence of a weak nonresonant microwave photon field in the low-dissipative resonator, the positions of dominant resonances depend on the number of photons, i.e., the collective ac Stark effect. Coupling of an SQA to the transmission line allows a straightforward experimental access of the collective states in microwave transmission experiments and, at the same time, to employ SQAs as sensitive single-photon detectors.

arXiv:2111.14732•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 31, 2022•12 citations

Quantum synchronization in disordered superconducting metamaterials

M. V. Fistul

Abstract I report a theoretical study of collective coherent quantum-mechanical oscillations in disordered superconducting quantum metamaterials (SQMs), i.e. artificial arrays of interacting qubits (two-levels system). An unavoidable disorder in qubits parameters results in a substantial spread of qubits frequencies, and in the absence of electromagnetic interaction between qubits these individual quantum-mechanical oscillations of single qubits manifest themselves by a large number of small resonant dips in the frequency dependent transmission of electromagnetic waves, |S21(ω)|2. We show that even a weak electromagnetic interaction between adjacent qubits can overcome the disorder and establish completely or partially synchronized quantum-mechanical dynamic state in the disordered SQM. In such a state a large amount of qubits displays the collective quantum mechanical oscillations, and this collective behavior manifests itself by a few giant resonant dips in the |S21(ω)|2 dependence. The size of a system r0 showing the collective (synchronized) quantum-mechanical behavior is determined in the one-dimensional SQMs as r0 ≃ a [K/δΔ]2, where K, δΔ, a are the effective energy of nearest-neighbor interaction, the spread of qubits energy splitting, and the distance between qubits, accordingly. We show that this phenomenon is mapped to the Anderson localization of spinon-type excitations arising in the SQM.

arXiv:1609.04625•Scientific Reports•Mar 2, 2017•13 citations

Magnetically induced transparency of a quantum metamaterial composed of twin flux qubits

Kirill Shulga, Evgeni V. Il’ichev, M. V. Fistul +5 more

Quantum theory is expected to govern the electromagnetic properties of a quantum metamaterial, an artificially fabricated medium composed of many quantum objects acting as artificial atoms. Propagation of electromagnetic waves through such a medium is accompanied by excitations of intrinsic quantum transitions within individual meta-atoms and modes corresponding to the interactions between them. Here we demonstrate an experiment in which an array of double-loop type superconducting flux qubits is embedded into a microwave transmission line. We observe that in a broad frequency range the transmission coefficient through the metamaterial periodically depends on externally applied magnetic field. Field-controlled switching of the ground state of the meta-atoms induces a large suppression of the transmission. Moreover, the excitation of meta-atoms in the array leads to a large resonant enhancement of the transmission. We anticipate possible applications of the observed frequency-tunable transparency in superconducting quantum networks.

Nature Communications•Jan 5, 2018•35 citations
We report a theoretical study of the propagation of electromagnetic waves (EWs) through an array of superconducting qubits, i.e., coherent two-level systems, embedded in a low-dissipation transmission line. We focus on the near-resonant case as the frequency of EWs \ensuremathω\ensuremath≃\ensuremathωq\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\simeq}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{q}\ensuremathω\ensuremath≃\ensuremathωq​, where \ensuremathωq{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{q}\ensuremathωq​ is the qubit frequency. In this limit we derive the effective dynamic nonlinear wave equation allowing one to obtain the frequency-dependent transmission coefficient of EWs, D(\ensuremathω)D(\ensuremath{\omega})D(\ensuremathω). In the linear regime and a relatively wide frequency region we obtain a strong resonant suppression of D(\ensuremathω)D(\ensuremath{\omega})D(\ensuremathω) in both cases of a single qubit and chains composed of a large number of densely arranged qubits. However, in narrow frequency regions a chain of qubits allows the resonant transmission of EWs with greatly enhanced D(\ensuremathω)D(\ensuremath{\omega})D(\ensuremathω). In the nonlinear regime realized for a moderate power of applied microwave radiation, we predict and analyze various transitions between states characterized by high and low values of D(\ensuremathω)D(\ensuremath{\omega})D(\ensuremathω). These transitions are manifestations of nonequilibrium steady states of an array of qubits achieved in this regime.
We report a theoretical study of coherent collective quantum dynamic effects in an array of NNN qubits (two-level systems) incorporated into a low-dissipation resonant cavity. Individual qubits are characterized by energy level differences ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{i}$ and a spread of ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{i}$ is taken into account. Noninteracting qubits display coherent quantum beatings with NNN different frequencies, i.e., ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{i}={\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{i}/\ensuremath{\hbar}$. Virtual emission and absorption of cavity photons provides a long-range interaction between qubits. In the presence of such interaction we analyze quantum correlation functions of individual qubits Ci(t){C}_{i}(t)Ci​(t) to obtain two collective quantum-mechanical coherent oscillations, characterized by frequencies ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}=\overline{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/\ensuremath{\hbar}$ and ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{2}={\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{R}$, where ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{R}$ is the resonant frequency of the cavity renormalized by interaction. The amplitude of these oscillations can be strongly enhanced in the resonant case when ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{2}$. These collective quantum oscillations can be directly observed, e.g., by measurements of frequency dependent transmission coefficient $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$ of electromagnetic field propagating in a transmission line coupled to the system.
We report a theoretical study of the ac response of superconducting quantum metamaterials (SQMs), i.e., an array of qubits (two-level systems) embedded in a low-dissipative resonator. By making use of a particular example of a SQM, namely the array of charge qubits capacitively coupled to the resonator, we obtain a second-order phase transition between an incoherent (the high-temperature phase) and coherent (the low-temperatures phase) state of photons. This phase transition in many aspects resembles the paramagnetic-ferromagnetic phase transition. The critical temperature of the phase transition, ${T}^{\ensuremath{\star}}$, is determined by the energy splitting of two-level systems $\ensuremath{\delta}$, number of qubits in the array NNN, and the strength of the interaction $\ensuremath{\eta}$ between qubits and photons in the cavity. We obtain that the photon states manifest themselves by resonant drops in the frequency-dependent transmission $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$ of electromagnetic waves propagating through a transmission line weakly coupled to the SQM. At high temperatures the $D(\ensuremath{\omega})$ displays a single resonant drop, and at low temperatures a peculiar double-resonance response has to be observed. The physical origin of such a resonant splitting is the quantum oscillations between two coherent states of photons of different polarizations.
Superconducting qubit networks (SQNs) embedded in a low-dissipative resonator is a promising device allowing one not only to establish the collective quantum dynamics on a macroscopic scale but also to greatly enhance the sensitivity of detectors of microwave photons. A quantum ac Stark effect provided by coupling between an SQN and microwave photons of a resonator, leads to a strong nonlinear interaction between photons. Here, we present a two-tone spectroscopy experiment in which a set of 10 superconducting flux qubits is coupled to the input R- resonator and the output T- transmission line. An external microwave pump field close to the resonance frequency populates macroscopically the resonator mode as a Bose-Einstein condensate, while a second probe beam scans the resonances referred also as Bogoliubov-like excitations. The corresponding excitation frequency measured from the transmission coefficient, |S21(f)| displays an abrupt change of the resonant dip position once the power of the pump field overcomes a critical value Pcr. This sharp shift occurs in a narrow region of pump frequencies, and can be tuned by an applied magnetic field. It is a signature of bistability of the photon number inside the resonator, in agreement with theory.
We study theoretically the collective quantum dynamics occurring in various interacting superconducting qubit arrays (SQAs) in the presence of a spread of individual qubit frequencies. The interaction is provided by mutual inductive coupling between adjacent qubits (short-range Ising interaction) or inductive coupling to a low-dissipative resonator (long-range exchange interaction). In the absence of interaction, the Fourier transform of the temporal correlation function of the total polarization (zzz projection of the total spin), i.e., the dynamic susceptibility $C(\ensuremath{\omega})$, demonstrates a set of sharp small magnitude resonances corresponding to the transitions of individual superconducting qubits. We show that even a weak interaction between qubits can overcome the disorder with a simultaneous formation of the collective excited states. This collective behavior manifests itself by a single large resonance in $C(\ensuremath{\omega})$. In the presence of a weak nonresonant microwave photon field in the low-dissipative resonator, the positions of dominant resonances depend on the number of photons, i.e., the collective ac Stark effect. Coupling of an SQA to the transmission line allows a straightforward experimental access of the collective states in microwave transmission experiments and, at the same time, to employ SQAs as sensitive single-photon detectors.
Abstract I report a theoretical study of collective coherent quantum-mechanical oscillations in disordered superconducting quantum metamaterials (SQMs), i.e. artificial arrays of interacting qubits (two-levels system). An unavoidable disorder in qubits parameters results in a substantial spread of qubits frequencies, and in the absence of electromagnetic interaction between qubits these individual quantum-mechanical oscillations of single qubits manifest themselves by a large number of small resonant dips in the frequency dependent transmission of electromagnetic waves, |S21(ω)|2. We show that even a weak electromagnetic interaction between adjacent qubits can overcome the disorder and establish completely or partially synchronized quantum-mechanical dynamic state in the disordered SQM. In such a state a large amount of qubits displays the collective quantum mechanical oscillations, and this collective behavior manifests itself by a few giant resonant dips in the |S21(ω)|2 dependence. The size of a system r0 showing the collective (synchronized) quantum-mechanical behavior is determined in the one-dimensional SQMs as r0 ≃ a [K/δΔ]2, where K, δΔ, a are the effective energy of nearest-neighbor interaction, the spread of qubits energy splitting, and the distance between qubits, accordingly. We show that this phenomenon is mapped to the Anderson localization of spinon-type excitations arising in the SQM.
Quantum theory is expected to govern the electromagnetic properties of a quantum metamaterial, an artificially fabricated medium composed of many quantum objects acting as artificial atoms. Propagation of electromagnetic waves through such a medium is accompanied by excitations of intrinsic quantum transitions within individual meta-atoms and modes corresponding to the interactions between them. Here we demonstrate an experiment in which an array of double-loop type superconducting flux qubits is embedded into a microwave transmission line. We observe that in a broad frequency range the transmission coefficient through the metamaterial periodically depends on externally applied magnetic field. Field-controlled switching of the ground state of the meta-atoms induces a large suppression of the transmission. Moreover, the excitation of meta-atoms in the array leads to a large resonant enhancement of the transmission. We anticipate possible applications of the observed frequency-tunable transparency in superconducting quantum networks.