Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1902.07038 · Journal of Physics Condensed Matter

Ultrafast dynamics of strongly correlated fermions—nonequilibrium Green functions and selfenergy approximations

Niclas Schlünzen, S. Hermanns, Miriam Scharnke, M. Bönitz

Published Jun 27, 2019• 55 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This article presents an overview on recent progress in the theory of nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF). We discuss applications of NEGF simulations to describe the femtosecond dynamics of various finite fermionic systems following an excitation out of equilibrium. This includes the expansion dynamics of ultracold atoms in optical lattices following a confinement quench and the excitation of strongly correlated electrons in a solid by the impact of a charged particle. NEGF, presently, are the only ab initio quantum approach that is able to study the dynamics of correlations for long times in two and three dimensions. However, until recently, NEGF simulations have mostly been performed with rather simple selfenergy approximations such as the second-order Born approximation (SOA). While they correctly capture the qualitative trends of the relaxation towards equilibrium, the reliability and accuracy of these NEGF simulations has remained open, for a long time. Here we report on recent tests of NEGF simulations for finite lattice systems against exact-diagonalization and density-matrix-renormalization-group benchmark data. The results confirm the high accuracy and predictive capability of NEGF simulations-provided selfenergies are used that go beyond the SOA and adequately include strong correlation and dynamical-screening effects. With an extended arsenal of selfenergies that can be used effectively, the NEGF approach has the potential of becoming a powerful simulation tool with broad areas of new applications including strongly correlated solids and ultracold atoms. The present review aims at making such applications possible. To this end we present a selfcontained introduction to the theory of NEGF and give an overview on recent numerical applications to compute the ultrafast relaxation dynamics of correlated fermions. In the second part we give a detailed introduction to selfenergies beyond the SOA. Important examples are the third-order approximation, the [Formula: see text] approximation, the T-matrix approximation and the fluctuating-exchange approximation. We give a comprehensive summary of the explicit selfenergy expressions for a variety of systems of practical relevance, starting from the most general expressions (general basis) and the Feynman diagrams, and including also the important cases of diagonal basis sets, the Hubbard model and the differences occuring for bosons and fermions. With these details, and information on the computational effort and scaling with the basis size and propagation duration, readers will be able to choose the proper basis set and straightforwardly implement and apply advanced selfenergy approximations to a broad class of systems.

DOI
10.1088/1361-648x/ab2d32

Related papers

Achieving the Scaling Limit for Nonequilibrium Green Functions Simulations

Niclas Schlünzen, Jan‐Philip Joost, M. Bönitz

The dynamics of strongly correlated fermions following an external excitation reveals extremely rich collective quantum effects. Examples are fermionic atoms in optical lattices, electrons in correlated materials, and dense quantum plasmas. Presently, the only quantum-dynamics approach that rigorously describes these processes in two and three dimensions is the nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF) method. However, NEGF simulations are computationally expensive due to their T^{3} scaling with the simulation duration T. Recently, T^{2} scaling was achieved with the generalized Kadanoff-Baym ansatz (GKBA), for second-order Born (SOA) selfenergies, which has substantially extended the scope of NEGF simulations. Here we demonstrate that GKBA-NEGF simulations can be performed with order T^{1} scaling, both for SOA and GW selfenergies, and point out the remarkable capabilities of this approach.

arXiv:1909.11489•Physical Review Letters•Feb 19, 2020•100 citations

Nonequilibrium Green Functions Approach to Strongly Correlated Fermions in Lattice Systems

Niclas Schlünzen, M. Bönitz

Abstract Quantum dynamics in strongly correlated systems are of high current interest in many fields including dense plasmas, nuclear matter and condensed matter and ultracold atoms. An important model case are fermions in lattice systems that is well suited to analyze, in detail, a variety of electronic and magnetic properties of strongly correlated solids. Such systems have recently been reproduced with fermionic atoms in optical lattices which allow for a very accurate experimental analysis of the dynamics and of transport processes such as diffusion. The theoretical analysis of such systems far from equilibrium is very challenging since quantum and spin effects as well as correlations have to be treated non‐perturbatively. The only accurate method that has been successful so far are density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) simulations. However, these simulations are presently limited to one‐dimensional (1D) systems and short times. Extension of quantum dynamics simulations to two and three dimensions is commonly viewed as one of the major challenges in this field. Recently we have reported a breakthrough in this area [N. Schlünzen et al., Phys. Rev. B (2016)] where we were able to simulate the expansion dynamics of strongly correlated fermions in a Hubbard lattice following a quench of the confinement potential in 1D, 2D and 3D. The results not only exhibited excellent agreement with the experimental data but, in addition, revealed new features of the short‐time dynamics where correlations and entanglement are being build up. The method used in this work are nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF) which are found to be very powerful in the treatment of fermionic lattice systems filling the gap presently left open by DMRG in 2D and 3D. In this paper we present a detailed introduction in the NEGF approach and its application to inhomogeneous Hubbard clusters. In detail we discuss the proper strong coupling approximation which is given by T ‐matrix selfenergies that sum up two‐particle scattering processes to infinite order. The efficient numerical implemen‐tation of the method is discussed in detail as it has allowed us to achieve dramatic performance gains. This has been the basis for the treatment of more than 100 particles over large time intervals. The numerical results presented in this paper concentrate on the diffusion in 1D to 3D lattices. We find that the expansion dynamics consist of three different phases that are linked with the build‐up of correlations. In the long time limit, a universal scaling with the particle number is revealed. By extrapolating the expansion velocities to the macroscopic limit, the obtained results show excellent agreement with recent experiments on ultracold fermions in optical lattices. Moreover we present results for the site‐resolved behavior of correlations and entanglement that can be directly compared with experiments using the recently developed atomic microscope technique. (© 2015 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)

Contributions to Plasma Physics•Jan 1, 2016•55 citations

Nonequilibrium Green functions - selfenergy approximation techniques

S. Hermanns

The framework of nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGFs) is developed to accurately describe interacting quantum systems evolving in the presence of strongly exciting ultra-fast fields.At its core stands the selfconsistent determination of the selfenergy, a functional of the single-particle Green function, which incorporates all relevant many-body physics and, via diagrammatic techniques, guarantees the conservation of the constants of motion.Over the last decades, NEGFs have been successfully applied to a broad range of domains ranging from homogeneous systems such as non-ideal quantum gases and plasmas over condensed matter to highly inhomogeneous systems such as atoms and molecules photo-ionized by laser-fields or colliding nuclear matter.Only recently, the first accurate simulation of the expansion dynamics of clouds of ultra-cold fermionic atoms in a two-dimensional optical lattice could be achieved using NEGFs.The single-particle Green function is the solution of a coupled set of kinetic equations.Its intrinsic dependence on two independent time-arguments, ranging over the complete past of the system, not only enables the determination of all singleparticle observables but also provides access to important two-particle observables and spectral information.With this coupling to the history, though, comes the practical necessity to apply physically motivated approximation techniques to the structure of the selfenergy and the Green functions, to achieve numerical tractability.This thesis is devoted to provide a thorough overview of the possible approximation techniques including perturbative and non-perturbative approaches.Starting from the exact coupled set of equations of motion for the Green functions, the expressions for all selfenergy approximations are derived in the most general basis representation, i.e., for interaction tensor elements w ijkl .From this, the corresponding expressions in a diagonal basis, where the interaction can be described as a matrix w ij , and for the special case of the Hubbard model, where the interaction is just given as a scalar U , are deduced.

•Nov 1, 2017•2 citations

Accelerating Nonequilibrium Green Functions Simulations: The G1–G2 Scheme and Beyond

M. Bönitz, Jan‐Philip Joost, Christopher Makait +3 more

The theory of nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF) has seen a rapid development over the recent three decades. Applications include diverse correlated many‐body systems in and out of equilibrium. Very good agreement with experiments and available exact theoretical results could be demonstrated if the proper selfenergy approximations were used. However, full two‐time NEGF simulations are computationally costly, as they suffer from a cubic scaling of the computation time with the simulation duration. Recently the G1–G2 scheme that exactly reformulates the generalized Kadanoff–Baym ansatz with Hartree–Fock propagators (HF‐GKBA) into time‐local equations is introduced, which achieves time‐linear scaling and allows for a dramatic speedup and extension of the simulations (Schluenzen et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2020, 124, 076601). Remarkably, this scaling is achieved quickly, and also for high‐level selfenergies, including the nonequilibrium GW and T‐matrix approximations (Joost et al. Phys. Rev. B 2020, 101, 245101). Even the dynamically screened ladder approximation is now feasible (Joost et al. Phys. Rev. B 2022, 105, 165155), and also applications to electron‐boson systems are demonstrated. Herein, an overview on recent results that are achieved with the G1–G2 scheme is presented. Problems and open questions are discussed and further ideas of how to overcome the current limitations of the scheme and present are presented. The G1–G2 scheme is illustrated by presenting applying it to the excitation dynamics of Hubbard clusters, to optical excitation of graphene, and to charge transfer during stopping of ions by correlated materials.

arXiv:2312.15030•physica status solidi (b)•Apr 25, 2024•15 citations

Nonequilibrium Green Functions Simulations for Large Correlated Systems

Erik Schroedter, M. Bönitz, Jan‐Philip Joost

Correlated real-time dynamics in large, spatially inhomogeneous quantum systems remain difficult to access with nonequilibrium many-body methods. Two-time nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF) retain dynamical correlations but their computational runtime grows cubically with the number of time steps $N_\mathrm{t}$. This scaling bottleneck could recently be overcome by introducing the G1--G2 scheme that is linear in $N_\mathrm{t}$, but requires propagation of a two-particle correlation function and may suffer from numerical instabilities. This has restricted simulations to small systems with $N_\mathrm{b} \sim 10^2$ basis states. Here we introduce a quantum-fluctuation formulation of nonequilibrium Green functions, denoted $δ$NEGF, that represents dynamical two-particle correlations through fluctuations of field-operator products, $δ\hat G$. This guarantees stable dynamics by preserving the positivity of the reduced density matrices, avoids the explicit storage of the two-particle Green function, and reduces the propagation to a finite ensemble of Hartree-Fock-like trajectories. Combined with a stochastic low-rank decomposition of the correlation functions, the method retains time-linear scaling while extending dynamical $GW$ and particle-particle and particle-hole $T$-matrix simulations to basis sizes of order $N_\mathrm{b}\sim 10^4$. We benchmark $δ$NEGF against exact and HF-GKBA results for lattice systems, finding stable correlated dynamics also at strong coupling. We further demonstrate large-scale simulations of diffusion in two-dimensional Hubbard lattices and ultrafast relaxation in graphene nanoribbon heterostructures with long-range Coulomb interactions. These results establish $δ$NEGF as a scalable route to dynamical self-energy simulations of large, spatially inhomogeneous correlated quantum systems beyond the reach of existing NEGF implementations.

arXiv:2606.10773•Jun 9, 2026•0 citations

G1-G2 scheme: Dramatic acceleration of nonequilibrium Green functions simulations within the Hartree-Fock generalized Kadanoff-Baym ansatz

Jan‐Philip Joost, Niclas Schlünzen, M. Bönitz

The time evolution in quantum many-body systems after external excitations is attracting high interest in many fields, including dense plasmas, correlated solids, laser-excited materials, or fermionic and bosonic atoms in optical lattices. The theoretical modeling of these processes is challenging, and the only rigorous quantum-dynamics approach that can treat correlated fermions in two and three dimensions is nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF). However, NEGF simulations are computationally expensive due to their ${T}^{3}$ scaling with the simulation duration $T$. Recently, ${T}^{2}$ scaling was achieved with the generalized Kadanoff-Baym ansatz (GKBA), for the second-order Born (SOA) self energy, which has substantially extended the scope of NEGF simulations. In a recent Letter [Schl\"unzen et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 076601 (2020).] we demonstrated that GKBA-NEGF simulations can be efficiently mapped onto coupled time-local equations for the single-particle and two-particle Green functions on the time diagonal, hence the method has been called the G1-G2 scheme. This allows one to perform the same simulations with order ${T}^{1}$ scaling, both for SOA and $GW$ self energies giving rise to a dramatic speedup. Here we present more details on the G1-G2 scheme, including derivations of the basic equations including results for a general basis, for Hubbard systems, and for jellium. Also, we demonstrate how to incorporate initial correlations into the G1-G2 scheme. Further, the derivations are extended to a broader class of self energies, including the $T$ matrix in the particle-particle and particle-hole channels and the dynamically-screened-ladder approximation. Finally, we demonstrate that, for all self energies, the CPU-time scaling of the G1-G2 scheme with the basis dimension ${N}_{b}$ can be improved compared to our first report: The overhead compared to the original GKBA is not more than an additional factor ${N}_{b}$, even for Hubbard systems.

arXiv:2002.12717•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 1, 2020•66 citations
This article presents an overview on recent progress in the theory of nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF). We discuss applications of NEGF simulations to describe the femtosecond dynamics of various finite fermionic systems following an excitation out of equilibrium. This includes the expansion dynamics of ultracold atoms in optical lattices following a confinement quench and the excitation of strongly correlated electrons in a solid by the impact of a charged particle. NEGF, presently, are the only ab initio quantum approach that is able to study the dynamics of correlations for long times in two and three dimensions. However, until recently, NEGF simulations have mostly been performed with rather simple selfenergy approximations such as the second-order Born approximation (SOA). While they correctly capture the qualitative trends of the relaxation towards equilibrium, the reliability and accuracy of these NEGF simulations has remained open, for a long time. Here we report on recent tests of NEGF simulations for finite lattice systems against exact-diagonalization and density-matrix-renormalization-group benchmark data. The results confirm the high accuracy and predictive capability of NEGF simulations-provided selfenergies are used that go beyond the SOA and adequately include strong correlation and dynamical-screening effects. With an extended arsenal of selfenergies that can be used effectively, the NEGF approach has the potential of becoming a powerful simulation tool with broad areas of new applications including strongly correlated solids and ultracold atoms. The present review aims at making such applications possible. To this end we present a selfcontained introduction to the theory of NEGF and give an overview on recent numerical applications to compute the ultrafast relaxation dynamics of correlated fermions. In the second part we give a detailed introduction to selfenergies beyond the SOA. Important examples are the third-order approximation, the [Formula: see text] approximation, the T-matrix approximation and the fluctuating-exchange approximation. We give a comprehensive summary of the explicit selfenergy expressions for a variety of systems of practical relevance, starting from the most general expressions (general basis) and the Feynman diagrams, and including also the important cases of diagonal basis sets, the Hubbard model and the differences occuring for bosons and fermions. With these details, and information on the computational effort and scaling with the basis size and propagation duration, readers will be able to choose the proper basis set and straightforwardly implement and apply advanced selfenergy approximations to a broad class of systems.
The dynamics of strongly correlated fermions following an external excitation reveals extremely rich collective quantum effects. Examples are fermionic atoms in optical lattices, electrons in correlated materials, and dense quantum plasmas. Presently, the only quantum-dynamics approach that rigorously describes these processes in two and three dimensions is the nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF) method. However, NEGF simulations are computationally expensive due to their T^{3} scaling with the simulation duration T. Recently, T^{2} scaling was achieved with the generalized Kadanoff-Baym ansatz (GKBA), for second-order Born (SOA) selfenergies, which has substantially extended the scope of NEGF simulations. Here we demonstrate that GKBA-NEGF simulations can be performed with order T^{1} scaling, both for SOA and GW selfenergies, and point out the remarkable capabilities of this approach.
Abstract Quantum dynamics in strongly correlated systems are of high current interest in many fields including dense plasmas, nuclear matter and condensed matter and ultracold atoms. An important model case are fermions in lattice systems that is well suited to analyze, in detail, a variety of electronic and magnetic properties of strongly correlated solids. Such systems have recently been reproduced with fermionic atoms in optical lattices which allow for a very accurate experimental analysis of the dynamics and of transport processes such as diffusion. The theoretical analysis of such systems far from equilibrium is very challenging since quantum and spin effects as well as correlations have to be treated non‐perturbatively. The only accurate method that has been successful so far are density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) simulations. However, these simulations are presently limited to one‐dimensional (1D) systems and short times. Extension of quantum dynamics simulations to two and three dimensions is commonly viewed as one of the major challenges in this field. Recently we have reported a breakthrough in this area [N. Schlünzen et al., Phys. Rev. B (2016)] where we were able to simulate the expansion dynamics of strongly correlated fermions in a Hubbard lattice following a quench of the confinement potential in 1D, 2D and 3D. The results not only exhibited excellent agreement with the experimental data but, in addition, revealed new features of the short‐time dynamics where correlations and entanglement are being build up. The method used in this work are nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF) which are found to be very powerful in the treatment of fermionic lattice systems filling the gap presently left open by DMRG in 2D and 3D. In this paper we present a detailed introduction in the NEGF approach and its application to inhomogeneous Hubbard clusters. In detail we discuss the proper strong coupling approximation which is given by T ‐matrix selfenergies that sum up two‐particle scattering processes to infinite order. The efficient numerical implemen‐tation of the method is discussed in detail as it has allowed us to achieve dramatic performance gains. This has been the basis for the treatment of more than 100 particles over large time intervals. The numerical results presented in this paper concentrate on the diffusion in 1D to 3D lattices. We find that the expansion dynamics consist of three different phases that are linked with the build‐up of correlations. In the long time limit, a universal scaling with the particle number is revealed. By extrapolating the expansion velocities to the macroscopic limit, the obtained results show excellent agreement with recent experiments on ultracold fermions in optical lattices. Moreover we present results for the site‐resolved behavior of correlations and entanglement that can be directly compared with experiments using the recently developed atomic microscope technique. (© 2015 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)
The framework of nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGFs) is developed to accurately describe interacting quantum systems evolving in the presence of strongly exciting ultra-fast fields.At its core stands the selfconsistent determination of the selfenergy, a functional of the single-particle Green function, which incorporates all relevant many-body physics and, via diagrammatic techniques, guarantees the conservation of the constants of motion.Over the last decades, NEGFs have been successfully applied to a broad range of domains ranging from homogeneous systems such as non-ideal quantum gases and plasmas over condensed matter to highly inhomogeneous systems such as atoms and molecules photo-ionized by laser-fields or colliding nuclear matter.Only recently, the first accurate simulation of the expansion dynamics of clouds of ultra-cold fermionic atoms in a two-dimensional optical lattice could be achieved using NEGFs.The single-particle Green function is the solution of a coupled set of kinetic equations.Its intrinsic dependence on two independent time-arguments, ranging over the complete past of the system, not only enables the determination of all singleparticle observables but also provides access to important two-particle observables and spectral information.With this coupling to the history, though, comes the practical necessity to apply physically motivated approximation techniques to the structure of the selfenergy and the Green functions, to achieve numerical tractability.This thesis is devoted to provide a thorough overview of the possible approximation techniques including perturbative and non-perturbative approaches.Starting from the exact coupled set of equations of motion for the Green functions, the expressions for all selfenergy approximations are derived in the most general basis representation, i.e., for interaction tensor elements w ijkl .From this, the corresponding expressions in a diagonal basis, where the interaction can be described as a matrix w ij , and for the special case of the Hubbard model, where the interaction is just given as a scalar U , are deduced.
The theory of nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF) has seen a rapid development over the recent three decades. Applications include diverse correlated many‐body systems in and out of equilibrium. Very good agreement with experiments and available exact theoretical results could be demonstrated if the proper selfenergy approximations were used. However, full two‐time NEGF simulations are computationally costly, as they suffer from a cubic scaling of the computation time with the simulation duration. Recently the G1–G2 scheme that exactly reformulates the generalized Kadanoff–Baym ansatz with Hartree–Fock propagators (HF‐GKBA) into time‐local equations is introduced, which achieves time‐linear scaling and allows for a dramatic speedup and extension of the simulations (Schluenzen et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2020, 124, 076601). Remarkably, this scaling is achieved quickly, and also for high‐level selfenergies, including the nonequilibrium GW and T‐matrix approximations (Joost et al. Phys. Rev. B 2020, 101, 245101). Even the dynamically screened ladder approximation is now feasible (Joost et al. Phys. Rev. B 2022, 105, 165155), and also applications to electron‐boson systems are demonstrated. Herein, an overview on recent results that are achieved with the G1–G2 scheme is presented. Problems and open questions are discussed and further ideas of how to overcome the current limitations of the scheme and present are presented. The G1–G2 scheme is illustrated by presenting applying it to the excitation dynamics of Hubbard clusters, to optical excitation of graphene, and to charge transfer during stopping of ions by correlated materials.
Correlated real-time dynamics in large, spatially inhomogeneous quantum systems remain difficult to access with nonequilibrium many-body methods. Two-time nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF) retain dynamical correlations but their computational runtime grows cubically with the number of time steps NtN_\mathrm{t}Nt​. This scaling bottleneck could recently be overcome by introducing the G1--G2 scheme that is linear in NtN_\mathrm{t}Nt​, but requires propagation of a two-particle correlation function and may suffer from numerical instabilities. This has restricted simulations to small systems with Nb∼102N_\mathrm{b} \sim 10^2Nb​∼102 basis states. Here we introduce a quantum-fluctuation formulation of nonequilibrium Green functions, denoted δδδNEGF, that represents dynamical two-particle correlations through fluctuations of field-operator products, δG^δ\hat GδG^. This guarantees stable dynamics by preserving the positivity of the reduced density matrices, avoids the explicit storage of the two-particle Green function, and reduces the propagation to a finite ensemble of Hartree-Fock-like trajectories. Combined with a stochastic low-rank decomposition of the correlation functions, the method retains time-linear scaling while extending dynamical GWGWGW and particle-particle and particle-hole TTT-matrix simulations to basis sizes of order Nb∼104N_\mathrm{b}\sim 10^4Nb​∼104. We benchmark δδδNEGF against exact and HF-GKBA results for lattice systems, finding stable correlated dynamics also at strong coupling. We further demonstrate large-scale simulations of diffusion in two-dimensional Hubbard lattices and ultrafast relaxation in graphene nanoribbon heterostructures with long-range Coulomb interactions. These results establish δδδNEGF as a scalable route to dynamical self-energy simulations of large, spatially inhomogeneous correlated quantum systems beyond the reach of existing NEGF implementations.
The time evolution in quantum many-body systems after external excitations is attracting high interest in many fields, including dense plasmas, correlated solids, laser-excited materials, or fermionic and bosonic atoms in optical lattices. The theoretical modeling of these processes is challenging, and the only rigorous quantum-dynamics approach that can treat correlated fermions in two and three dimensions is nonequilibrium Green functions (NEGF). However, NEGF simulations are computationally expensive due to their T3{T}^{3}T3 scaling with the simulation duration TTT. Recently, T2{T}^{2}T2 scaling was achieved with the generalized Kadanoff-Baym ansatz (GKBA), for the second-order Born (SOA) self energy, which has substantially extended the scope of NEGF simulations. In a recent Letter [Schl\"unzen et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 076601 (2020).] we demonstrated that GKBA-NEGF simulations can be efficiently mapped onto coupled time-local equations for the single-particle and two-particle Green functions on the time diagonal, hence the method has been called the G1-G2 scheme. This allows one to perform the same simulations with order T1{T}^{1}T1 scaling, both for SOA and GWGWGW self energies giving rise to a dramatic speedup. Here we present more details on the G1-G2 scheme, including derivations of the basic equations including results for a general basis, for Hubbard systems, and for jellium. Also, we demonstrate how to incorporate initial correlations into the G1-G2 scheme. Further, the derivations are extended to a broader class of self energies, including the TTT matrix in the particle-particle and particle-hole channels and the dynamically-screened-ladder approximation. Finally, we demonstrate that, for all self energies, the CPU-time scaling of the G1-G2 scheme with the basis dimension Nb{N}_{b}Nb​ can be improved compared to our first report: The overhead compared to the original GKBA is not more than an additional factor Nb{N}_{b}Nb​, even for Hubbard systems.