Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1901.10127 · Physical Review A

Experimental comparison of tomography and self-testing in certifying entanglement

Koon Tong Goh, Chithrabhanu Perumangatt, Zhi Xian Lee, Alexander Ling, Valerio Scarani

Published Aug 7, 2019• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We assess the quality of a source of allegedly pure two-qubit states using both standard tomography and methods inspired by device-independent self-testing. Even when the detection and locality loopholes are open, the latter methods can dispense with modeling of the system and the measurements. However, due to finite sample fluctuations, the estimated probability distribution usually does not satisfy the no-signaling conditions exactly. We implement data analysis that is robust against these fluctuations. We demonstrate a high ratio ${f}_{s}/{f}_{t}\ensuremath{\approx}0.988$ between the fidelity estimated from self-testing and that estimated from full tomography, proving the high performance of self-testing methods.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.100.022305

Related papers

Experimental self-testing of entangled states

Wen-Hao Zhang, Geng Chen, Xing-Xiang Peng +12 more

Quantum entanglement is the key resource for quantum information processing. Device-independent certification of entangled states is a long standing open question, which arouses the concept of self-testing. The central aim of self-testing is to certify the state and measurements of quantum systems without any knowledge of their inner workings, even when the used devices cannot be trusted. Specifically, utilizing Bell's theorem, it is possible to place a boundary on the singlet fidelity of entangled qubits. Here, beyond this rough estimation, we experimentally demonstrate a complete self-testing process for various pure bipartite entangled states up to four dimensions, by simply inspecting the correlations of the measurement outcomes. We show that this self-testing process can certify the exact form of entangled states with fidelities higher than 99.9% for all the investigated scenarios, which indicates the superior completeness and robustness of this method. Our work promotes self-testing as a practical tool for developing quantum techniques.

arXiv:1803.10961•Mar 29, 2018•1 citation

Experimental demonstration of one-sided device-independent self-testing of any pure two-qubit entangled state

Zhihao Bian, A. S. Majumdar, Chellasamy Jebarathinam +5 more

We demonstrate one-sided device-independent self-testing of any pure two-qubit entangled state based on a fine-grained steering inequality. The maximum violation of a fine-grained steering inequality can be used to witness certain steerable correlations, which certify all pure two-qubit entangled states. Our experimental results identify which particular pure two-qubit entangled state has been self-tested and which measurement operators are used on the untrusted side. Furthermore, we analytically derive the robustness bound of our protocol, enabling our subsequent experimental verification of robustness through state tomography. Finally, we ensure that the requisite no-signaling constraints are maintained in the experiment.

arXiv:2001.10207•Physical Review A•Feb 7, 2020•20 citations

Robust Self-Testing of Multiparticle Entanglement

Dian Wu, Qi Zhao, Xuemei Gu +10 more

Quantum self-testing is a device-independent way to certify quantum states and measurements using only the input-output statistics, with minimal assumptions about the quantum devices. Because of the high demand on tolerable noise, however, experimental self-testing was limited to two-photon systems. Here, we demonstrate the first robust self-testing for multiphoton genuinely entangled quantum states. We prepare two examples of four-photon graph states, the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states with a fidelity of 0.957(2) and the linear cluster states with a fidelity of 0.945(2). Based on the observed input-output statistics, we certify the genuine four-photon entanglement and further estimate their qualities with respect to realistic noise in a device-independent manner.

arXiv:2105.10298•Physical Review Letters•Dec 3, 2021•22 citations

Experimentally Self-Testing Partially Entangled Two-Qubit States on an Optical Platform

Xin Zhao, Yan‐Han Yang, Li-Ming Zhao +1 more

We demonstrate a complete and experimentally validated self-testing protocol for two-qubit partially entangled states, which avoids the need for full tomographic reconstruction. Using a room-temperature type-II PPKTP polarization-entangled source and a free-space optical setup, we implement both quantum state tomography and optimal generalized Bell measurements within a single system. Our approach achieves high-fidelity self-testing of non-maximally entangled states under black-box assumptions, establishing a solid foundation for device-independent quantum information processing applications.

Entropy•Jan 9, 2026•0 citations

Experimentally Robust Self-testing for Bipartite and Tripartite Entangled States

Wen-Hao Zhang, Geng Chen, Xing-Xiang Peng +9 more

Self-testing is a method with which a classical user can certify the state and measurements of quantum systems in a device-independent way. In particular, self-testing of entangled states is of great importance in quantum information processing. An understandable example is that the maximal violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality necessarily implies that the bipartite system shares a singlet. One essential question in self-testing is that, when one observes a nonmaximum violation, how far is the tested state from the target state (which maximally violates a certain Bell inequality)? The answer to this question describes the robustness of the used self-testing criterion, which is highly important in a practical sense. Recently, J. Kaniewski derived two analytic self-testing bounds for bipartite and tripartite systems. In this Letter, we experimentally investigate these two bounds with high-quality two-qubit and three-qubit entanglement sources. The results show that these bounds are valid for various entangled states that we prepared. Thereby, a proof-of-concept demonstration of robust self-testing is achieved, which improves on the previous results significantly.

arXiv:1804.01375•Physical Review Letters•Dec 13, 2018•31 citations

Robust self-test of the maximally entangled state of two-qubits without assuming unitary observables

Alexandre C. Orthey, Magdalena Stobińska-Moretto

Standard device-independent self-testing uses Naimark dilation to assume projective measurements, masking the operational limitations of realistic non-unitary observables. We establish a robust pure self-test for the singlet and Pauli observables that entirely circumvents dilation of the measurement apparatus. Assuming a pure state to model an untrusted source, we regularize the physical non-projective operators and derive an analytic $\mathcal{O}(\sqrtε)$ robustness bound. Our results suggest that device-independent certification of real implementations is significantly more demanding than standard projective models imply.

quant-pharXiv:2607.04035•Jul 7, 2026•0 citations
We assess the quality of a source of allegedly pure two-qubit states using both standard tomography and methods inspired by device-independent self-testing. Even when the detection and locality loopholes are open, the latter methods can dispense with modeling of the system and the measurements. However, due to finite sample fluctuations, the estimated probability distribution usually does not satisfy the no-signaling conditions exactly. We implement data analysis that is robust against these fluctuations. We demonstrate a high ratio fs/ft\ensuremath≈0.988{f}_{s}/{f}_{t}\ensuremath{\approx}0.988fs​/ft​\ensuremath≈0.988 between the fidelity estimated from self-testing and that estimated from full tomography, proving the high performance of self-testing methods.
Quantum entanglement is the key resource for quantum information processing. Device-independent certification of entangled states is a long standing open question, which arouses the concept of self-testing. The central aim of self-testing is to certify the state and measurements of quantum systems without any knowledge of their inner workings, even when the used devices cannot be trusted. Specifically, utilizing Bell's theorem, it is possible to place a boundary on the singlet fidelity of entangled qubits. Here, beyond this rough estimation, we experimentally demonstrate a complete self-testing process for various pure bipartite entangled states up to four dimensions, by simply inspecting the correlations of the measurement outcomes. We show that this self-testing process can certify the exact form of entangled states with fidelities higher than 99.9% for all the investigated scenarios, which indicates the superior completeness and robustness of this method. Our work promotes self-testing as a practical tool for developing quantum techniques.
We demonstrate one-sided device-independent self-testing of any pure two-qubit entangled state based on a fine-grained steering inequality. The maximum violation of a fine-grained steering inequality can be used to witness certain steerable correlations, which certify all pure two-qubit entangled states. Our experimental results identify which particular pure two-qubit entangled state has been self-tested and which measurement operators are used on the untrusted side. Furthermore, we analytically derive the robustness bound of our protocol, enabling our subsequent experimental verification of robustness through state tomography. Finally, we ensure that the requisite no-signaling constraints are maintained in the experiment.
Quantum self-testing is a device-independent way to certify quantum states and measurements using only the input-output statistics, with minimal assumptions about the quantum devices. Because of the high demand on tolerable noise, however, experimental self-testing was limited to two-photon systems. Here, we demonstrate the first robust self-testing for multiphoton genuinely entangled quantum states. We prepare two examples of four-photon graph states, the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states with a fidelity of 0.957(2) and the linear cluster states with a fidelity of 0.945(2). Based on the observed input-output statistics, we certify the genuine four-photon entanglement and further estimate their qualities with respect to realistic noise in a device-independent manner.
We demonstrate a complete and experimentally validated self-testing protocol for two-qubit partially entangled states, which avoids the need for full tomographic reconstruction. Using a room-temperature type-II PPKTP polarization-entangled source and a free-space optical setup, we implement both quantum state tomography and optimal generalized Bell measurements within a single system. Our approach achieves high-fidelity self-testing of non-maximally entangled states under black-box assumptions, establishing a solid foundation for device-independent quantum information processing applications.
Self-testing is a method with which a classical user can certify the state and measurements of quantum systems in a device-independent way. In particular, self-testing of entangled states is of great importance in quantum information processing. An understandable example is that the maximal violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality necessarily implies that the bipartite system shares a singlet. One essential question in self-testing is that, when one observes a nonmaximum violation, how far is the tested state from the target state (which maximally violates a certain Bell inequality)? The answer to this question describes the robustness of the used self-testing criterion, which is highly important in a practical sense. Recently, J. Kaniewski derived two analytic self-testing bounds for bipartite and tripartite systems. In this Letter, we experimentally investigate these two bounds with high-quality two-qubit and three-qubit entanglement sources. The results show that these bounds are valid for various entangled states that we prepared. Thereby, a proof-of-concept demonstration of robust self-testing is achieved, which improves on the previous results significantly.
Standard device-independent self-testing uses Naimark dilation to assume projective measurements, masking the operational limitations of realistic non-unitary observables. We establish a robust pure self-test for the singlet and Pauli observables that entirely circumvents dilation of the measurement apparatus. Assuming a pure state to model an untrusted source, we regularize the physical non-projective operators and derive an analytic O(ε)\mathcal{O}(\sqrtε)O(ε​) robustness bound. Our results suggest that device-independent certification of real implementations is significantly more demanding than standard projective models imply.