Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1901.03410 · Physical Review A

Leggett-Garg tests of macrorealism: Checks for noninvasiveness and generalizations to higher-order correlators

J. J. Halliwell

Published Feb 19, 2019• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the tests for macrorealism proposed by Leggett and Garg, the temporal correlation functions of a dichotomic variable $Q$ must be measured in a noninvasive way to rule out alternative classical explanations of Leggett-Garg inequality violations. Ideal negative measurements in which a null result is argued to be a noninvasive determination of the system's state are often used. From a quantum-mechanical perspective, such a measurement collapses the wave function and will therefore typically be found to be invasive under any experimental check. Here, a simple modified ideal negative measurement protocol is described for measuring the correlation functions, which is argued to be noninvasive from both classical and quantum perspectives and hence the noninvasiveness can then be checked experimentally, thereby permitting a quantitative measure of the degree of clumsiness of the measurement. It is also shown how this procedure may be extended to measure higher-order correlation functions, and a number of higher-order conditions for macrorealism are derived.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.99.022119

Related papers

Leggett-Garg correlation functions from a noninvasive velocity measurement continuous in time

J. J. Halliwell

In the Leggett-Garg approach to testing macrorealism, the two-time correlation functions, which are normally obtained by sequential measurements of a dichotomic variable $Q$, need to be measured in a noninvasive way in order to exclude certain types of alternative classical explanation. Here, it is shown, for a class of macrorealistic theories, that the correlation functions are readily expressed in terms of a time integral of the velocity corresponding to $Q$ and that this expression can be determined from a single final-time measurement of an auxiliary system in continual weak interaction with the primary system. The protocol has the form of a ``waiting detector,'' which clicks only when $Q$ changes sign. It shares features with both ideal negative measurements and weak measurements and we argue that it is essentially noninvasive, under certain reasonable assumptions. We show that the noninvasiveness persists to a quantum model of the process.

arXiv:1605.09241•Physical Review A•Nov 14, 2016•17 citations

Violation of noninvasive macrorealism by a superconducting qubit: Implementation of a Leggett-Garg test that addresses the clumsiness loophole

Emilie Huffman, Ari Mizel

The Leggett-Garg inequality holds for any macrorealistic system that is being measured noninvasively. A violation of the inequality can signal that a system does not conform to our primal intuition about the physical world. Alternatively, a violation can simply indicate that a ``clumsy'' experimental technique led to invasive measurements. Here, we consider a recent Leggett-Garg test designed to try to rule out the mundane second possibility. We tailor this Leggett-Garg test to the IBM 5Q Quantum Experience system and find compelling evidence that qubit ${Q}_{2}$ of the system cannot be described by noninvasive macrorealism.

arXiv:1609.05957•Physical Review A•Mar 29, 2017•59 citations

Tests of Macrorealism in Discrete and Continuous Variable Systems

C. Mawby

I study several aspects of tests of macrorealism (MR), which for a given data set serves to give a quantitative signal of the presence of a specific notion of non-classical behaviour. The insufficiency of classical understanding underpins both the paradoxes of quantum mechanics, its future technological promise, and so these tests are of interest both foundationally and pragmatically. I derive generalisations of the Leggett-Garg (LG) inequalities and Fine's theorem, which together establish the necessary and sufficient conditions for macrorealism. First, I extend these conditions to tests involving an arbitrary number of measurement times. Secondly, I generalise them beyond the standard dichotomic variable, to systems described by many-valued variables. I also perform a quantum mechanical analysis examining the interplay of different conditions of MR. I then develop the theoretical framework to support tests of macrorealism in continuous variable systems, where I define variables based on coarse-grainings of position. I calculate temporal correlators for general bound systems, and analyse LG violations within the quantum harmonic oscillator (QHO), in its energy eigenstates and coherent states. I analyse the precise physical mechanisms underpinning the violations in terms of probability currents, Bohm trajectories. Staying within continuous variable systems, we outline a different approach to meeting the invasiveness requirement of LG tests. Reasoning that we may approximately non-invasively measure whether a particle crosses the axis, we measure an object which is related to the standard correlators, and derive a set of macrorealistic inequalities for these modified correlators. We demonstrate violations of these modified LG inequalities for several states within the QHO.

arXiv:2402.16537•Feb 26, 2024•0 citations

Proposal for a loophole-free test of macroscopic realism

Devashish Pandey, Xavier Oriols, Guillermo Albareda

We propose a test of macrorealism that exploits the contextuality of two-time correlation functions to escape the so-called clumsiness loophole that plagues Leggett-Garg inequalities. The non-contextuality of reduced joint probability distributions is proven to be an unequivocal criterion to guarantee that measurements are carried out in the ideally-weak measurement regime of a class of generalized von Neumann measurements. In this regime, testing the so-called no-signaling in time condition allows to uncontextually ascertain whether a property of a given system is macrorealistic or non-macrorealistic. The resulting protocol allows for tests of macrorealism in situations where Leggett-Garg inequalities and ideal negative measurement cannot be used at all.

arXiv:1901.06183•Jan 18, 2019•0 citations

Interference experiment, anomalous weak value, and Leggett-Garg test of macrorealism

A. K. Pan

Macrorealism is a classical world view asserting that the properties of macro-objects exist independently and irrespective of observation. One practical approach to test this view in quantum theory is to observe the quantum coherence for a macro-object in an interference experiment. An elegant and conceptually appealing approach for testing the notion of macrorealism in quantum theory is through the violation of Leggett-Garg inequality. However, a conclusive Leggett-Garg test hinges on how the noninvasive measurability criteria are guaranteed in an experiment and remains a debated issue to date. In this work, we connect the practical and the conceptual approaches for testing the macrorealism through the weak value. We argue that whenever a quantum effect is observed in an interference experiment there is an existence of anomalous weak value. Further, we demonstrate that whenever such weak value exists, one obtains the violation of a Leggett-Garg inequality in any interference experiment. Since in a path-only interference experiment effectively no prior measurement is performed, the Leggett-Garg test of macrorealism presented here is without assuming the noninvasive measurability. We provide a rigorous discussion about the assumptions involved in the Leggett-Garg scenario and how our scheme fits into it. Further, we provide a simple argument about the macrorealistic understanding of our results by using the recently developed approach involving quasiprobability.

arXiv:2012.13875•Physical Review A•Sep 8, 2020•32 citations

Exploration of an augmented set of Leggett-Garg inequalities using a noninvasive continuous-in-time velocity measurement

Shayan Majidy, Hemant Katiyar, Galit Anikeeva +2 more

Macroscopic realism (MR) is the view that a system may possess definite properties at any time independent of past or future measurements and may be tested experimentally using the Leggett-Garg inequalities (LGIs). In this work we advance the study of LGIs in two ways using experiments carried out on a nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometer. First, we addresses the fact that the LGIs are only necessary conditions for MR but not sufficient ones. We implement a recently proposed test of necessary and sufficient conditions for MR which consists of a combination of the original four three-time LGIs augmented with a set of 12 two-time LGIs. We explore different regimes in which the two- and three-time LGIs may each be satisfied or violated. Second, we implement a recent proposal for a measurement protocol which determines the temporal correlation functions in an approximately noninvasive manner. It employs a measurement of the velocity of a dichotomic variable $Q$, continuous in time, from which a possible sign change of $Q$ may be determined in a single measurement of an ancilla coupled to the velocity. This protocol involves a significantly different set of assumptions to the traditional ideal negative measurement protocol, and a comparison with the latter is carried out.

arXiv:1907.05489•Physical Review A•Oct 21, 2019•31 citations
In the tests for macrorealism proposed by Leggett and Garg, the temporal correlation functions of a dichotomic variable QQQ must be measured in a noninvasive way to rule out alternative classical explanations of Leggett-Garg inequality violations. Ideal negative measurements in which a null result is argued to be a noninvasive determination of the system's state are often used. From a quantum-mechanical perspective, such a measurement collapses the wave function and will therefore typically be found to be invasive under any experimental check. Here, a simple modified ideal negative measurement protocol is described for measuring the correlation functions, which is argued to be noninvasive from both classical and quantum perspectives and hence the noninvasiveness can then be checked experimentally, thereby permitting a quantitative measure of the degree of clumsiness of the measurement. It is also shown how this procedure may be extended to measure higher-order correlation functions, and a number of higher-order conditions for macrorealism are derived.
In the Leggett-Garg approach to testing macrorealism, the two-time correlation functions, which are normally obtained by sequential measurements of a dichotomic variable QQQ, need to be measured in a noninvasive way in order to exclude certain types of alternative classical explanation. Here, it is shown, for a class of macrorealistic theories, that the correlation functions are readily expressed in terms of a time integral of the velocity corresponding to QQQ and that this expression can be determined from a single final-time measurement of an auxiliary system in continual weak interaction with the primary system. The protocol has the form of a ``waiting detector,'' which clicks only when QQQ changes sign. It shares features with both ideal negative measurements and weak measurements and we argue that it is essentially noninvasive, under certain reasonable assumptions. We show that the noninvasiveness persists to a quantum model of the process.
The Leggett-Garg inequality holds for any macrorealistic system that is being measured noninvasively. A violation of the inequality can signal that a system does not conform to our primal intuition about the physical world. Alternatively, a violation can simply indicate that a ``clumsy'' experimental technique led to invasive measurements. Here, we consider a recent Leggett-Garg test designed to try to rule out the mundane second possibility. We tailor this Leggett-Garg test to the IBM 5Q Quantum Experience system and find compelling evidence that qubit Q2{Q}_{2}Q2​ of the system cannot be described by noninvasive macrorealism.
I study several aspects of tests of macrorealism (MR), which for a given data set serves to give a quantitative signal of the presence of a specific notion of non-classical behaviour. The insufficiency of classical understanding underpins both the paradoxes of quantum mechanics, its future technological promise, and so these tests are of interest both foundationally and pragmatically. I derive generalisations of the Leggett-Garg (LG) inequalities and Fine's theorem, which together establish the necessary and sufficient conditions for macrorealism. First, I extend these conditions to tests involving an arbitrary number of measurement times. Secondly, I generalise them beyond the standard dichotomic variable, to systems described by many-valued variables. I also perform a quantum mechanical analysis examining the interplay of different conditions of MR. I then develop the theoretical framework to support tests of macrorealism in continuous variable systems, where I define variables based on coarse-grainings of position. I calculate temporal correlators for general bound systems, and analyse LG violations within the quantum harmonic oscillator (QHO), in its energy eigenstates and coherent states. I analyse the precise physical mechanisms underpinning the violations in terms of probability currents, Bohm trajectories. Staying within continuous variable systems, we outline a different approach to meeting the invasiveness requirement of LG tests. Reasoning that we may approximately non-invasively measure whether a particle crosses the axis, we measure an object which is related to the standard correlators, and derive a set of macrorealistic inequalities for these modified correlators. We demonstrate violations of these modified LG inequalities for several states within the QHO.
We propose a test of macrorealism that exploits the contextuality of two-time correlation functions to escape the so-called clumsiness loophole that plagues Leggett-Garg inequalities. The non-contextuality of reduced joint probability distributions is proven to be an unequivocal criterion to guarantee that measurements are carried out in the ideally-weak measurement regime of a class of generalized von Neumann measurements. In this regime, testing the so-called no-signaling in time condition allows to uncontextually ascertain whether a property of a given system is macrorealistic or non-macrorealistic. The resulting protocol allows for tests of macrorealism in situations where Leggett-Garg inequalities and ideal negative measurement cannot be used at all.
Macrorealism is a classical world view asserting that the properties of macro-objects exist independently and irrespective of observation. One practical approach to test this view in quantum theory is to observe the quantum coherence for a macro-object in an interference experiment. An elegant and conceptually appealing approach for testing the notion of macrorealism in quantum theory is through the violation of Leggett-Garg inequality. However, a conclusive Leggett-Garg test hinges on how the noninvasive measurability criteria are guaranteed in an experiment and remains a debated issue to date. In this work, we connect the practical and the conceptual approaches for testing the macrorealism through the weak value. We argue that whenever a quantum effect is observed in an interference experiment there is an existence of anomalous weak value. Further, we demonstrate that whenever such weak value exists, one obtains the violation of a Leggett-Garg inequality in any interference experiment. Since in a path-only interference experiment effectively no prior measurement is performed, the Leggett-Garg test of macrorealism presented here is without assuming the noninvasive measurability. We provide a rigorous discussion about the assumptions involved in the Leggett-Garg scenario and how our scheme fits into it. Further, we provide a simple argument about the macrorealistic understanding of our results by using the recently developed approach involving quasiprobability.
Macroscopic realism (MR) is the view that a system may possess definite properties at any time independent of past or future measurements and may be tested experimentally using the Leggett-Garg inequalities (LGIs). In this work we advance the study of LGIs in two ways using experiments carried out on a nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometer. First, we addresses the fact that the LGIs are only necessary conditions for MR but not sufficient ones. We implement a recently proposed test of necessary and sufficient conditions for MR which consists of a combination of the original four three-time LGIs augmented with a set of 12 two-time LGIs. We explore different regimes in which the two- and three-time LGIs may each be satisfied or violated. Second, we implement a recent proposal for a measurement protocol which determines the temporal correlation functions in an approximately noninvasive manner. It employs a measurement of the velocity of a dichotomic variable QQQ, continuous in time, from which a possible sign change of QQQ may be determined in a single measurement of an ancilla coupled to the velocity. This protocol involves a significantly different set of assumptions to the traditional ideal negative measurement protocol, and a comparison with the latter is carried out.