Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1812.08862 · Science Advances

Training of quantum circuits on a hybrid quantum computer

Daiwei Zhu, Norbert M. Linke, Marcello Benedetti, K. A. Landsman, Nhung H. Nguyen, C. Huerta Alderete, Alejandro Perdomo‐Ortiz, Nathan Korda, A. Garfoot, Charles Brecque, Laird Egan, Oscar Mario Perdomo, Christopher R. Monroe

Published Oct 11, 2019• 214 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Generative modeling is a flavor of machine learning with applications ranging from computer vision to chemical design. It is expected to be one of the techniques most suited to take advantage of the additional resources provided by near-term quantum computers. Here, we implement a data-driven quantum circuit training algorithm on the canonical Bars-and-Stripes dataset using a quantum-classical hybrid machine. The training proceeds by running parameterized circuits on a trapped ion quantum computer and feeding the results to a classical optimizer. We apply two separate strategies, Particle Swarm and Bayesian optimization to this task. We show that the convergence of the quantum circuit to the target distribution depends critically on both the quantum hardware and classical optimization strategy. Our study represents the first successful training of a high-dimensional universal quantum circuit and highlights the promise and challenges associated with hybrid learning schemes.

DOI
10.1126/sciadv.aaw9918

Related papers

Quantum-classical generative models for machine learning

Marcello Benedetti

The combination of quantum and classical computational resources towards more effective algorithms is one of the most promising research directions in computer science. In such a hybrid framework, existing quantum computers can be used to their fullest extent and for practical applications. Generative modeling is one of the applications that could benefit the most, either by speeding up the underlying sampling methods or by unlocking more general models. In this work, we design a number of hybrid generative models and validate them on real hardware and datasets. The quantum-assisted Boltzmann machine is trained to generate realistic artificial images on quantum annealers. Several challenges in state-of-the-art annealers shall be overcome before one can assess their actual performance. We attack some of the most pressing challenges such as the sparse qubit-to-qubit connectivity, the unknown effective-temperature, and the noise on the control parameters. In order to handle datasets of realistic size and complexity, we include latent variables and obtain a more general model called the quantum-assisted Helmholtz machine. In the context of gate-based computers, the quantum circuit Born machine is trained to encode a target probability distribution in the wavefunction of a set of qubits. We implement this model on a trapped ion computer using low-depth circuits and native gates. We use the generative modeling performance on the canonical Bars-and-Stripes dataset to design a benchmark for hybrid systems. It is reasonable to expect that quantum data, i.e., datasets of wavefunctions, will become available in the future. We derive a quantum generative adversarial network that works with quantum data. Here, two circuits are optimized in tandem: one tries to generate suitable quantum states, the other tries to distinguish between target and generated states.

•Nov 28, 2019•3 citations

A generative modeling approach for benchmarking and training shallow quantum circuits

Marcello Benedetti, Delfina García Pintos, Oscar Mario Perdomo +3 more

Abstract Hybrid quantum-classical algorithms provide ways to use noisy intermediate-scale quantum computers for practical applications. Expanding the portfolio of such techniques, we propose a quantum circuit learning algorithm that can be used to assist the characterization of quantum devices and to train shallow circuits for generative tasks. The procedure leverages quantum hardware capabilities to its fullest extent by using native gates and their qubit connectivity. We demonstrate that our approach can learn an optimal preparation of the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states, also known as “cat states”. We further demonstrate that our approach can efficiently prepare approximate representations of coherent thermal states, wave functions that encode Boltzmann probabilities in their amplitudes. Finally, complementing proposals to characterize the power or usefulness of near-term quantum devices, such as IBM’s quantum volume, we provide a new hardware-independent metric called the qBAS score. It is based on the performance yield in a specific sampling task on one of the canonical machine learning data sets known as Bars and Stripes. We show how entanglement is a key ingredient in encoding the patterns of this data set; an ideal benchmark for testing hardware starting at four qubits and up. We provide experimental results and evaluation of this metric to probe the trade off between several architectural circuit designs and circuit depths on an ion-trap quantum computer.

arXiv:1801.07686•npj Quantum Information•May 27, 2019•379 citations

Learning and inference on generative adversarial quantum circuits

Jinfeng Zeng, Yufeng Wu, Jin-Guo Liu +2 more

Quantum mechanics is inherently probabilistic in light of Born's rule. Using quantum circuits as probabilistic generative models for classical data exploits their superior expressibility and efficient direct sampling ability. However, training of quantum circuits can be more challenging compared to classical neural networks due to the lack of an efficient differentiable learning algorithm. We devise an adversarial quantum-classical hybrid training scheme via coupling a quantum circuit generator and a classical neural network discriminator together. After training, the quantum circuit generative model can infer missing data with quadratic speed-up via amplitude amplification. We numerically simulate the learning and inference of generative adversarial quantum circuits using the prototypical bars-and-stripes dataset. Generative adversarial quantum circuits are a fresh approach to machine learning which may enjoy the practically useful quantum advantage of near-term quantum devices.

arXiv:1808.03425•Physical Review A•May 6, 2019•94 citations

Practicality of training a quantum-classical machine in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum era

Tarun Dutta, Alex Jin, Clarence Liu Huihong +2 more

Advancements in classical computing have propelled machine learning applications, yet inherent limitations persist in terms of energy, resource, and speed. Quantum machine learning offers a promising avenue to overcome these limitations but poses its own hurdles. This experimental study investigates the training limits of a real quantum-classical hybrid system on an ion-trap platform using supervised protocols. It addresses the challenges of coupling ion-trap systems with classical processors and highlights the effectiveness of genetic algorithms for NISQ devices and complex binary classification tasks with many local minima. The analysis reveals why gradient-based methods may not be ideal in the NISQ era. Our results provide insights into optimizing hybrid quantum-classical systems, emphasizing the importance of training strategies and hardware design. This work not only enhances understanding of such systems but also illustrates their practical potential in solving real-world problems without relying on classical simulators, bridging the gap between quantum and classical computing paradigms.

iScience•Jul 15, 2025•5 citations

Practicality of training a quantum-classical machine in the NISQ era

Tarun Dutta, Alex Jin, Clarence Liu Huihong +2 more

Advancements in classical computing have significantly enhanced machine learning applications, yet inherent limitations persist in terms of energy, resource and speed. Quantum machine learning algorithms offer a promising avenue to overcome these limitations but poses its own hurdles. This experimental study explores the limits of training a real experimental quantum classical hybrid system using supervised training protocols, on an ion trap platform. Challenges associated with ion trap-coupled classical processors are addressed, highlighting the $robustness$ of the genetic algorithm as a classical optimizer in navigating the noisy channels of NISQ-devices and the complex optimization landscape inherent in binary classification problems with many local minima. We intricately discuss why gradient-based optimizers may not be suitable in the NISQ era through a thorough analysis. These findings contribute insights into the performance of quantum-classical hybrid systems, emphasizing the significance of efficient training strategies and hardware considerations for practical quantum machine learning applications. This work not only advances the understanding of hybrid quantum-classical systems but also underscores the potential impact on real-world challenges through the convergence of quantum and classical computing paradigms operating without the aid of classical simulators.

arXiv:2401.12089•Jan 22, 2024•1 citation

Surviving The Barren Plateau in Variational Quantum Circuits with Bayesian Learning Initialization

Rad, Ali, Alireza Seif, Norbert M. Linke

Variational quantum-classical hybrid algorithms are seen as a promising strategy for solving practical problems on quantum computers in the near term. While this approach reduces the number of qubits and operations required from the quantum machine, it places a heavy load on a classical optimizer. While often under-appreciated, the latter is a computationally hard task due to the barren plateau phenomenon in parameterized quantum circuits. The absence of guiding features like gradients renders conventional optimization strategies ineffective as the number of qubits increases. Here, we introduce the fast-and-slow algorithm, which uses Bayesian Learning to identify a promising region in parameter space. This is used to initialize a fast local optimizer to find the global optimum point efficiently. We illustrate the effectiveness of this method on the Bars-and-Stripes (BAS) quantum generative model, which has been studied on several quantum hardware platforms. Our results move variational quantum algorithms closer to their envisioned applications in quantum chemistry, combinatorial optimization, and quantum simulation problems.

arXiv:2203.02464•Mar 4, 2022•6 citations
Generative modeling is a flavor of machine learning with applications ranging from computer vision to chemical design. It is expected to be one of the techniques most suited to take advantage of the additional resources provided by near-term quantum computers. Here, we implement a data-driven quantum circuit training algorithm on the canonical Bars-and-Stripes dataset using a quantum-classical hybrid machine. The training proceeds by running parameterized circuits on a trapped ion quantum computer and feeding the results to a classical optimizer. We apply two separate strategies, Particle Swarm and Bayesian optimization to this task. We show that the convergence of the quantum circuit to the target distribution depends critically on both the quantum hardware and classical optimization strategy. Our study represents the first successful training of a high-dimensional universal quantum circuit and highlights the promise and challenges associated with hybrid learning schemes.
The combination of quantum and classical computational resources towards more effective algorithms is one of the most promising research directions in computer science. In such a hybrid framework, existing quantum computers can be used to their fullest extent and for practical applications. Generative modeling is one of the applications that could benefit the most, either by speeding up the underlying sampling methods or by unlocking more general models. In this work, we design a number of hybrid generative models and validate them on real hardware and datasets. The quantum-assisted Boltzmann machine is trained to generate realistic artificial images on quantum annealers. Several challenges in state-of-the-art annealers shall be overcome before one can assess their actual performance. We attack some of the most pressing challenges such as the sparse qubit-to-qubit connectivity, the unknown effective-temperature, and the noise on the control parameters. In order to handle datasets of realistic size and complexity, we include latent variables and obtain a more general model called the quantum-assisted Helmholtz machine. In the context of gate-based computers, the quantum circuit Born machine is trained to encode a target probability distribution in the wavefunction of a set of qubits. We implement this model on a trapped ion computer using low-depth circuits and native gates. We use the generative modeling performance on the canonical Bars-and-Stripes dataset to design a benchmark for hybrid systems. It is reasonable to expect that quantum data, i.e., datasets of wavefunctions, will become available in the future. We derive a quantum generative adversarial network that works with quantum data. Here, two circuits are optimized in tandem: one tries to generate suitable quantum states, the other tries to distinguish between target and generated states.
Abstract Hybrid quantum-classical algorithms provide ways to use noisy intermediate-scale quantum computers for practical applications. Expanding the portfolio of such techniques, we propose a quantum circuit learning algorithm that can be used to assist the characterization of quantum devices and to train shallow circuits for generative tasks. The procedure leverages quantum hardware capabilities to its fullest extent by using native gates and their qubit connectivity. We demonstrate that our approach can learn an optimal preparation of the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states, also known as “cat states”. We further demonstrate that our approach can efficiently prepare approximate representations of coherent thermal states, wave functions that encode Boltzmann probabilities in their amplitudes. Finally, complementing proposals to characterize the power or usefulness of near-term quantum devices, such as IBM’s quantum volume, we provide a new hardware-independent metric called the qBAS score. It is based on the performance yield in a specific sampling task on one of the canonical machine learning data sets known as Bars and Stripes. We show how entanglement is a key ingredient in encoding the patterns of this data set; an ideal benchmark for testing hardware starting at four qubits and up. We provide experimental results and evaluation of this metric to probe the trade off between several architectural circuit designs and circuit depths on an ion-trap quantum computer.
Quantum mechanics is inherently probabilistic in light of Born's rule. Using quantum circuits as probabilistic generative models for classical data exploits their superior expressibility and efficient direct sampling ability. However, training of quantum circuits can be more challenging compared to classical neural networks due to the lack of an efficient differentiable learning algorithm. We devise an adversarial quantum-classical hybrid training scheme via coupling a quantum circuit generator and a classical neural network discriminator together. After training, the quantum circuit generative model can infer missing data with quadratic speed-up via amplitude amplification. We numerically simulate the learning and inference of generative adversarial quantum circuits using the prototypical bars-and-stripes dataset. Generative adversarial quantum circuits are a fresh approach to machine learning which may enjoy the practically useful quantum advantage of near-term quantum devices.
Advancements in classical computing have propelled machine learning applications, yet inherent limitations persist in terms of energy, resource, and speed. Quantum machine learning offers a promising avenue to overcome these limitations but poses its own hurdles. This experimental study investigates the training limits of a real quantum-classical hybrid system on an ion-trap platform using supervised protocols. It addresses the challenges of coupling ion-trap systems with classical processors and highlights the effectiveness of genetic algorithms for NISQ devices and complex binary classification tasks with many local minima. The analysis reveals why gradient-based methods may not be ideal in the NISQ era. Our results provide insights into optimizing hybrid quantum-classical systems, emphasizing the importance of training strategies and hardware design. This work not only enhances understanding of such systems but also illustrates their practical potential in solving real-world problems without relying on classical simulators, bridging the gap between quantum and classical computing paradigms.
Advancements in classical computing have significantly enhanced machine learning applications, yet inherent limitations persist in terms of energy, resource and speed. Quantum machine learning algorithms offer a promising avenue to overcome these limitations but poses its own hurdles. This experimental study explores the limits of training a real experimental quantum classical hybrid system using supervised training protocols, on an ion trap platform. Challenges associated with ion trap-coupled classical processors are addressed, highlighting the robustnessrobustnessrobustness of the genetic algorithm as a classical optimizer in navigating the noisy channels of NISQ-devices and the complex optimization landscape inherent in binary classification problems with many local minima. We intricately discuss why gradient-based optimizers may not be suitable in the NISQ era through a thorough analysis. These findings contribute insights into the performance of quantum-classical hybrid systems, emphasizing the significance of efficient training strategies and hardware considerations for practical quantum machine learning applications. This work not only advances the understanding of hybrid quantum-classical systems but also underscores the potential impact on real-world challenges through the convergence of quantum and classical computing paradigms operating without the aid of classical simulators.
Variational quantum-classical hybrid algorithms are seen as a promising strategy for solving practical problems on quantum computers in the near term. While this approach reduces the number of qubits and operations required from the quantum machine, it places a heavy load on a classical optimizer. While often under-appreciated, the latter is a computationally hard task due to the barren plateau phenomenon in parameterized quantum circuits. The absence of guiding features like gradients renders conventional optimization strategies ineffective as the number of qubits increases. Here, we introduce the fast-and-slow algorithm, which uses Bayesian Learning to identify a promising region in parameter space. This is used to initialize a fast local optimizer to find the global optimum point efficiently. We illustrate the effectiveness of this method on the Bars-and-Stripes (BAS) quantum generative model, which has been studied on several quantum hardware platforms. Our results move variational quantum algorithms closer to their envisioned applications in quantum chemistry, combinatorial optimization, and quantum simulation problems.