© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:1812.00844 · Advanced Quantum Technologies

Estimating Coherence Measures with Untrusted Devices

Xingjian Zhang, Yunchao Liu, Xiao Yuan

Published Apr 28, 2021• 3 citations

Abstract

Abstract The superposition of quantum states, quantified by coherence, is a fundamental feature to distinguish quantum mechanics from classical theories. Estimations of coherence with perfectly characterised devices have been well‐studied. However, imperfections or malfunctions of realistic measurement devices might nullify the characterization. Device‐independent (DI) tests allow to witness and quantify the quantum feature of a system, such as entanglement, without trusting the implementation devices. Although DI test is a powerful tool in many quantum information tasks, it generally requires nonlocal settings. Little is known if single party coherence can be witnessed and estimated via untrusted devices. In this work, coherence witnesses and estimations with untrusted devices are systematically studied. First, a no‐go theorem for detecting existences of single party coherence via a DI or semi DI means is proven. A general prepare‐and‐measure semi DI scheme for witnessing and estimating the amount of coherence is then proposed. How to estimate the relative entropy and the l 1 norm of single party coherence with analytical and numerical approaches is shown. As coherence is an essential resource for tasks such as quantum random number generation and quantum key distribution, it is expected that this result may shed light on designing new quantum cryptographic schemes.

DOI: 10.1002/qute.202000153

Related papers

Robust Certification of Entanglement Structures in Noisy Quantum Systems: Device‐Independent and Semi‐Device‐Independent Approaches

Yansa Lu, Zhihua Chen, Yuan-Hong Tao

Abstract In the noisy intermediate‐scale quantum (NISQ) era, multipartite entanglement in realistic noisy environments exhibits complex structures. Characterizing entanglement structures—particularly entanglement depth and intactness—has become increasingly essential for quantum information processing tasks. Traditional methods like standard entanglement witnesses assume that experimenters can exactly implement specific quantum measurements. Even minor inaccuracies in standard witness can introduce significant errors in entanglement detection. Certification methods are proposed with relaxed assumptions about the system and measurements for entanglement structures. First, entanglement states are classified with the same intactness into three distinct types based on their depth. Next, analytical witnesses are derived to detect the entanglement structure of general n‐qubit systems in both device‐independent and semi‐device‐independent scenarios, where some observables are untrusted while others remain reliable. Furthermore, this framework is extended to account for small measurement imperfections, ensuring robustness in practical settings. It is demonstrated that this witness can detect larger entanglement regions compared to previous Bell‐type inequalities. Remarkably, for Type I 4‐partite quantum states, this entanglement witness with measurement imperfections is identical to both device‐dependent and semi‐device‐independent approaches.

Advanced Quantum Technologies•Aug 10, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Coherence Witness with Untrusted Measurement Devices

You-Qi Nie, Hongyi Zhou, Jian-Yu Guan +4 more

Coherence is a fundamental resource in quantum information processing, which can be certified by a coherence witness. Due to the imperfection of measurement devices, a conventional coherence witness may lead to fallacious results. We show that the conventional witness could mistake an incoherent state as a state with coherence due to the inaccurate settings of measurement bases. In order to make the witness result reliable, we propose a measurement-device-independent coherence witness scheme without any assumptions on the measurement settings. We introduce the decoy-state method to significantly increase the capability of recognizing states with coherence. Furthermore, we experimentally demonstrate the scheme in a time-bin encoding optical system.

arXiv:1908.05022•Physical Review Letters•Aug 28, 2019•18 citations

Practical measurement-device-independent entanglement quantification

Denis Rosset, Anthony Martin, E. Verbanis +2 more

The robust estimation of entanglement is key to the validation of implementations of quantum systems. On the one hand, the evaluation of standard entanglement measures, either using quantum tomography or using quantitative entanglement witnesses, requires perfect implementation of measurements. On the other hand, measurement-device-independent entanglement witnesses (MDIEWs) can certify entanglement of all entangled states using untrusted measurement devices. We show that MDIEWs can be used as well to quantify entanglement according to standard entanglement measures, and we present a practical method to derive such witnesses using experimental data only.

arXiv:1709.03090•Physical Review A•Nov 26, 2018•21 citations

Joint-measurability and quantum communication with untrusted devices

Michele Masini, Marie Ioannou, Nicolas Brunner +2 more

Photon loss represents a major challenge for the implementation of quantum communication protocols with untrusted devices, e.g. in the device-independent (DI) or semi-DI approaches. Determining critical loss thresholds is usually done in case-by-case studies. In the present work, we develop a general framework for characterizing the admissible levels of loss and noise in a wide range of scenarios and protocols with untrusted measurement devices. In particular, we present general bounds that apply to prepare-and-measure protocols for the semi-DI approach, as well as to Bell tests for DI protocols. A key step in our work is to establish a general connection between quantum protocols with untrusted measurement devices and the fundamental notions of channel extendibility and joint-measurability, which capture essential aspects of the communication and measurement of quantum information. In particular, this leads us to introduce the notion of partial joint-measurability, which naturally arises within quantum cryptography.

arXiv:2403.14785•Quantum•Dec 23, 2024•6 citations

Bounding the Amount of Entanglement from Witness Operators

Liang-Liang Sun, Xiang Zhou, Armin Tavakoli +2 more

We present an approach to estimate the operational distinguishability between an entangled state and any separable state directly from measuring an entanglement witness. We show that this estimation also implies bounds on a variety of other well-known entanglement quantifiers. This approach for entanglement estimation is then extended to both the measurement-device-independent scenario and the fully device-independent scenario, where we obtain nontrivial but suboptimal bounds. The procedure requires no numerical optimization and is easy to compute. It offers ways for experimenters to not only detect, but also quantify, entanglement from the standard entanglement witness procedure.

arXiv:2312.04897•Physical Review Letters•Mar 12, 2024•16 citations

Single trusted qubit is necessary and sufficient for quantum realization of extremal no-signaling correlations

Ravishankar Ramanathan, Michał Banacki, Ricard Ravell Rodríguez +1 more

Abstract The problem of achieving security of device-independent (or semi-device-independent) cryptography (for quantum key distribution and randomness generation) against the most general no-signaling adversaries has remained open. It has been recognized that the realization of extremal no-signaling non-local boxes (or extremal no-signaling non-local assemblages) could provide a route toward devising such highly secure protocols. We first prove a general no-go result that in the Bell non-locality scenario, quantum theory does not allow us to realize any extremal no-signaling non-local box, even if scenarios of arbitrary sequential measurements are considered. On the other hand, we secondly prove a positive result showing that a one-sided device-independent scenario where a single party trusts their qubit system is already sufficient for quantum theory to realize a self-testing extremal non-local point within the set of no-signaling assemblages.

arXiv:2004.14782•npj Quantum Information•Oct 4, 2022•7 citations

Abstract The superposition of quantum states, quantified by coherence, is a fundamental feature to distinguish quantum mechanics from classical theories. Estimations of coherence with perfectly characterised devices have been well‐studied. However, imperfections or malfunctions of realistic measurement devices might nullify the characterization. Device‐independent (DI) tests allow to witness and quantify the quantum feature of a system, such as entanglement, without trusting the implementation devices. Although DI test is a powerful tool in many quantum information tasks, it generally requires nonlocal settings. Little is known if single party coherence can be witnessed and estimated via untrusted devices. In this work, coherence witnesses and estimations with untrusted devices are systematically studied. First, a no‐go theorem for detecting existences of single party coherence via a DI or semi DI means is proven. A general prepare‐and‐measure semi DI scheme for witnessing and estimating the amount of coherence is then proposed. How to estimate the relative entropy and the l 1 norm of single party coherence with analytical and numerical approaches is shown. As coherence is an essential resource for tasks such as quantum random number generation and quantum key distribution, it is expected that this result may shed light on designing new quantum cryptographic schemes.

Abstract In the noisy intermediate‐scale quantum (NISQ) era, multipartite entanglement in realistic noisy environments exhibits complex structures. Characterizing entanglement structures—particularly entanglement depth and intactness—has become increasingly essential for quantum information processing tasks. Traditional methods like standard entanglement witnesses assume that experimenters can exactly implement specific quantum measurements. Even minor inaccuracies in standard witness can introduce significant errors in entanglement detection. Certification methods are proposed with relaxed assumptions about the system and measurements for entanglement structures. First, entanglement states are classified with the same intactness into three distinct types based on their depth. Next, analytical witnesses are derived to detect the entanglement structure of general n‐qubit systems in both device‐independent and semi‐device‐independent scenarios, where some observables are untrusted while others remain reliable. Furthermore, this framework is extended to account for small measurement imperfections, ensuring robustness in practical settings. It is demonstrated that this witness can detect larger entanglement regions compared to previous Bell‐type inequalities. Remarkably, for Type I 4‐partite quantum states, this entanglement witness with measurement imperfections is identical to both device‐dependent and semi‐device‐independent approaches.

Coherence is a fundamental resource in quantum information processing, which can be certified by a coherence witness. Due to the imperfection of measurement devices, a conventional coherence witness may lead to fallacious results. We show that the conventional witness could mistake an incoherent state as a state with coherence due to the inaccurate settings of measurement bases. In order to make the witness result reliable, we propose a measurement-device-independent coherence witness scheme without any assumptions on the measurement settings. We introduce the decoy-state method to significantly increase the capability of recognizing states with coherence. Furthermore, we experimentally demonstrate the scheme in a time-bin encoding optical system.

The robust estimation of entanglement is key to the validation of implementations of quantum systems. On the one hand, the evaluation of standard entanglement measures, either using quantum tomography or using quantitative entanglement witnesses, requires perfect implementation of measurements. On the other hand, measurement-device-independent entanglement witnesses (MDIEWs) can certify entanglement of all entangled states using untrusted measurement devices. We show that MDIEWs can be used as well to quantify entanglement according to standard entanglement measures, and we present a practical method to derive such witnesses using experimental data only.

Photon loss represents a major challenge for the implementation of quantum communication protocols with untrusted devices, e.g. in the device-independent (DI) or semi-DI approaches. Determining critical loss thresholds is usually done in case-by-case studies. In the present work, we develop a general framework for characterizing the admissible levels of loss and noise in a wide range of scenarios and protocols with untrusted measurement devices. In particular, we present general bounds that apply to prepare-and-measure protocols for the semi-DI approach, as well as to Bell tests for DI protocols. A key step in our work is to establish a general connection between quantum protocols with untrusted measurement devices and the fundamental notions of channel extendibility and joint-measurability, which capture essential aspects of the communication and measurement of quantum information. In particular, this leads us to introduce the notion of partial joint-measurability, which naturally arises within quantum cryptography.

We present an approach to estimate the operational distinguishability between an entangled state and any separable state directly from measuring an entanglement witness. We show that this estimation also implies bounds on a variety of other well-known entanglement quantifiers. This approach for entanglement estimation is then extended to both the measurement-device-independent scenario and the fully device-independent scenario, where we obtain nontrivial but suboptimal bounds. The procedure requires no numerical optimization and is easy to compute. It offers ways for experimenters to not only detect, but also quantify, entanglement from the standard entanglement witness procedure.

Abstract The problem of achieving security of device-independent (or semi-device-independent) cryptography (for quantum key distribution and randomness generation) against the most general no-signaling adversaries has remained open. It has been recognized that the realization of extremal no-signaling non-local boxes (or extremal no-signaling non-local assemblages) could provide a route toward devising such highly secure protocols. We first prove a general no-go result that in the Bell non-locality scenario, quantum theory does not allow us to realize any extremal no-signaling non-local box, even if scenarios of arbitrary sequential measurements are considered. On the other hand, we secondly prove a positive result showing that a one-sided device-independent scenario where a single party trusts their qubit system is already sufficient for quantum theory to realize a self-testing extremal non-local point within the set of no-signaling assemblages.