Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1811.02110 · SciPost Physics

Snell's Law for a vortex dipole in a Bose-Einstein condensate

Michael MacCormick Cawte, Xiaoquan Yu, Brian P. Anderson, Ashton S. Bradley

Published Mar 13, 2019• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A quantum vortex dipole, comprised of a closely bound pair of vortices of equal strength with opposite circulation, is a spatially localized travelling excitation of a planar superfluid that carries linear momentum, suggesting a possible analogy with ray optics. We investigate numerically and analytically the motion of a quantum vortex dipole incident upon a step-change in the background superfluid density of an otherwise uniform two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate. Due to the conservation of fluid momentum and energy, the incident and refracted angles of the dipole satisfy a relation analogous to Snell’s law, when crossing the interface between regions of different density. The predictions of the analogue Snell’s law relation are confirmed for a wide range of incident angles by systematic numerical simulations of the Gross-Piteavskii equation. Near the critical angle for total internal reflection, we identify a regime of anomalous Snell’s law behaviour where the finite size of the dipole causes transient capture by the interface. Remarkably, despite the extra complexity of the interface interaction, the incoming and outgoing dipole paths obey Snell’s law.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.6.3.032

Related papers

Snell's Law and Necklace States for Vortex Dipoles in a Quantum Gas

Michael MacCormick Cawte

A quantum vortex is an excitation of a superfluid that carries angular momentum, in which the superfluid is expelled from and circulates around a region known as the vortex core. A quantum vortex dipole consists of two bound quantum vortices with opposite circulation, which together carry linear momentum. The topic of this thesis is two-fold, with a common theme of quantum vortex dipoles.\nIn the first part of the thesis, the motion of a quantum vortex dipole incident upon a step-change in the background superfluid density of an otherwise uniform two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate is investigated, both analytically and numerically.\nDue to the conservation of fluid momentum and energy, the incident and refracted angles of the dipole satisfy a relation analogous to Snell’s law, when crossing the interface between regions of different density. The predictions of the analogue Snell’s law relation are confirmed for a wide range of incident angles by systematic numerical simulations of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation (GPE). Near the critical angle for total internal reflection, we identify a regime of anomalous Snell’s law behaviour where the finite size of the dipole causes transient capture by the interface. Remarkably, despite the extra complexity of the surface interaction, the incoming and outgoing dipole paths obey Snell’s law.\nIn the second part of the thesis, the point-vortex model is used to find the stationary states of an arbitrary neutral number of vortices of alternating sign arranged on a ring in the simply bounded domain. These stationary states are collectively referred to as necklace states, due to the symmetry of their appearance. Curiously, the necklace states are found to have a simple relation to the metallic means, which are generalisations of the golden ratio. The necklace state is numerically simulated with different initial perturbations in both the point-vortex model and the GPE with a comparison of the results. Perturbations from the necklace solution evolve differently in the point-vortex model and GPE due to the healing length scale in the GPE enforcing a departure from the point-vortex model predictions. We introduce a simple numerical scheme to compensate for the healing length and confirm the necklace as a steady of the GPE. We find that the agreement between the point-vortex model and GPE for evolution of significant perturbations persists for longer as the healing length reduces compared to system size.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Vortex dipoles in a Bose-Einstein condensate

Tyler W. Neely, E. Carlo Samson, Ashton S. Bradley +2 more

While quantized vortices and vortex lattices in Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) have received much recent attention, the formation and dynamics of vortex dipoles have been nearly unexplored in experimental BECs. Vortex dipoles consist of a pair of vortices of opposite circulation moving under the influence of each other, and may be considered as metastable topological structures that carry linear momentum in a fluid. In this talk, a collaborative experimental and numerical study of the formation, dynamics, and lifetimes of vortex dipoles in BECs will be presented. In our work [1], single vortex dipoles were deterministically nucleated by causing highly oblate, harmonically trapped BECs to move past a repulsive obstacle above a supercritical flow velocity. Our measured critical velocity for vortex dipole shedding, and the subsequent dipole dynamics, are in good agreement with new numerical simulations. We find that vortex dipoles can survive for many seconds in the BEC without selfannihilation, and that multiply charged vortex dipoles can be formed with high enough flow velocities. References: 1. T.W. Neely, E.C. Samson, A.S. Bradley, M.J. Davis, and B.P. Anderson, preprint available at http://arxiv.org/abs/0912.3773.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Vortex dynamics and turbulence in dipolar Bose-Einstein condensates

Subramaniyan Sabari, R. Kishor Kumar, Lauro Tomio

Quantum turbulence indicators in dipolar Bose-Einstein condensed fluids, following emissions of vortex-antivortex pairs generated by a circularly moving detuned laser, are being provided by numerical simulations of the corresponding quasi-two-dimensional Gross-Pitaevskii formalism with repulsive contact interactions combined with tunable dipole-dipole strength. The critical velocities of two variants of a circularly moving obstacle are determined and analyzed for vortex-antivortex nucleation in the form of regular and cluster emissions. The turbulent dynamical behavior is predicted to follow closely the initial emission of vortex-antivortex pairs, relying on the expected Kolmogorov classical scaling law, which is verified by the spectral analysis of the incompressible part of the kinetic energy. Within our aim to provide further support in the investigations to date of quantum turbulence, which have been focused on nondipolar Bose-Einstein condensates, we emphasize the role of dipole-dipole interactions in the fluid dynamics.

arXiv:2401.03548•Physical Review A•Feb 8, 2024•15 citations

Quantum reflection of vortices in Bose-Einstein condensates

M. Liu, L. She, Hongwei Xiong +1 more

We consider the quantum reflection of vortices in Bose-Einstein condensates incident on a solid surface. Compared with the condensate without angular momentum, the rotation of the vortex gives unique opportunities to consider the interaction process between a matter wave and a solid surface. Due to the atom-surface interaction and dynamic excitations induced by interatomic interaction, our numerical simulations show that the reflected vortex would become unstable for sufficiently low velocity and large interaction strength. The stability diagram for the reflected vortex is given, and physical mechanism for this stability diagram is discussed. It is found that the expansion ratio between the reflected and incident vortices gives the boundary between stable and unstable regions for the reflected vortex.

Physical Review A•Oct 26, 2006•6 citations

Controlling quantum vortex dynamics and vortex-antivortex annihilation in Bose-Einstein condensates with optical lattices

Francesco Ancilotto, L. Reatto

Superfluids with strong spatial modulation can be experimentally produced in the area of cold atoms under the influence of optical lattices. Here we address $^{87}\mathrm{Rb}$ bosons at $T=0$ K in a flat geometry under the influence of a periodic potential with the Gross-Pitaevskii theory. The statics and dynamics of vortex excitations are studied in the case of one-dimensional (1D) and of two-dimensional (2D) optical lattices, as function of the intensity of the optical lattice. We compute how the vortex energy depends on the position of its core and the energy barrier that a vortex has to surmount in order to move in the superfluid. The dynamics of a vortex dipole, a pair of vortices of opposite chirality, differ profoundly from the case of a uniform superfluid. In the 1D case, when parallel ridges of density are present, the dynamics depends on the positions of the two vortices. If they are in the same channel between two ridges, then the two vortices approach each other until they annihilate each other in a short time. If the two vortices are in distinct channels, the dipole undergoes a rigid translation but with a velocity depending on the intensity of the optical lattice and this translation velocity can even change sign with respect to the case of the uniform superfluid. Superimposed on this translation an oscillatory motion is also present. A superposition of translation along a channel and an oscillation is also found with a single vortex when the system is bounded inside a circular trap. These oscillatory motions can be both longitudinal, i.e., along the channel, as well as transverse. In all cases the transverse motions are one sided, in the sense that the vortex core never crosses the equilibrium position nearest the starting position. In the case of the 2D lattices we study (square, triangular, and honeycomb), the two vortices of a dipole move mainly by jumps between equilibrium positions and approach each other until annihilation. This behavior has some similarity with what has been found for a vortex dipole in the supersolid state of dipolar bosons. We show that a rapid ramp down of the optical potential improves the visibility of the density holes at the vortex core.

arXiv:2404.13705•Physical Review A•Jul 3, 2024•3 citations

Dynamics of vortex cluster crystallisation and single-vortex pinning in two-dimensional superfluids

Oliver R. Stockdale

In this thesis, we analytically and numerically study two different scenarios of vortex dynamics in a two-dimensional superfluid. The first system we explore is an expanding cluster of like-sign vortices, which recently suggested it could explain observations in a superfluid optomechanics experiment. We employ a recent theoretical model that approximates large collections of vortices as a fluid and present an analytic solution for its dynamics. Analysis suggests that as a cluster expands due to thermal friction, it forms a Rankine vortex (i.e., a top-hat distribution) that expands self-similarly in time regardless of initial vorticity distribution. Numerical simulations of point vortices confirm this universal expanding regime and further demonstrates vortex lattice formation that goes beyond the vortex fluid theory. We analyse correlations that emerge in the resulting lattices and observe decaying disorder as the cluster expands. Furthermore, we analyse experimental data from a quasi-two-dimensional 87Rb Bose-Einstein condensate, which supports the vortex fluid theory’s predictions.The second scenario considers the dynamics of a scattering event where a single quantum vortex interacts with a uniform, circular pinning potential in a steady two-dimensional superfluid flow. We first develop an approximate hydrodynamical model to understand the interaction between the vortex and the pinning potential in the conservative regime and find it is in good agreement with the mean-field Gross-Pitaevskii equation in the low-velocity limit. We further solve the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for higher background velocities to study how the vortex moves around pinning sites, interacts with it, and ultimately becomes pinned. We uncover four different regimes of vortex pinning, each marked with a characteristic emission of sound energy. Finally, we study how vortices become unpinned from a pinning site, revealing large vortex dipoles form to stabilise the system.Our work in this thesis takes significant steps towards advancing knowledge of both the collective dynamics of vortices and their individual interaction with defects upon surface substrates. Our numerical and analytical results opens up new avenues of exploration be it further understanding dissipation mechanisms in two-dimensional superfluids, or elucidating the nature of vortex pinning in systems such as neutron stars.

•Mar 1, 2021•0 citations
A quantum vortex dipole, comprised of a closely bound pair of vortices of equal strength with opposite circulation, is a spatially localized travelling excitation of a planar superfluid that carries linear momentum, suggesting a possible analogy with ray optics. We investigate numerically and analytically the motion of a quantum vortex dipole incident upon a step-change in the background superfluid density of an otherwise uniform two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate. Due to the conservation of fluid momentum and energy, the incident and refracted angles of the dipole satisfy a relation analogous to Snell’s law, when crossing the interface between regions of different density. The predictions of the analogue Snell’s law relation are confirmed for a wide range of incident angles by systematic numerical simulations of the Gross-Piteavskii equation. Near the critical angle for total internal reflection, we identify a regime of anomalous Snell’s law behaviour where the finite size of the dipole causes transient capture by the interface. Remarkably, despite the extra complexity of the interface interaction, the incoming and outgoing dipole paths obey Snell’s law.
A quantum vortex is an excitation of a superfluid that carries angular momentum, in which the superfluid is expelled from and circulates around a region known as the vortex core. A quantum vortex dipole consists of two bound quantum vortices with opposite circulation, which together carry linear momentum. The topic of this thesis is two-fold, with a common theme of quantum vortex dipoles.\nIn the first part of the thesis, the motion of a quantum vortex dipole incident upon a step-change in the background superfluid density of an otherwise uniform two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate is investigated, both analytically and numerically.\nDue to the conservation of fluid momentum and energy, the incident and refracted angles of the dipole satisfy a relation analogous to Snell’s law, when crossing the interface between regions of different density. The predictions of the analogue Snell’s law relation are confirmed for a wide range of incident angles by systematic numerical simulations of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation (GPE). Near the critical angle for total internal reflection, we identify a regime of anomalous Snell’s law behaviour where the finite size of the dipole causes transient capture by the interface. Remarkably, despite the extra complexity of the surface interaction, the incoming and outgoing dipole paths obey Snell’s law.\nIn the second part of the thesis, the point-vortex model is used to find the stationary states of an arbitrary neutral number of vortices of alternating sign arranged on a ring in the simply bounded domain. These stationary states are collectively referred to as necklace states, due to the symmetry of their appearance. Curiously, the necklace states are found to have a simple relation to the metallic means, which are generalisations of the golden ratio. The necklace state is numerically simulated with different initial perturbations in both the point-vortex model and the GPE with a comparison of the results. Perturbations from the necklace solution evolve differently in the point-vortex model and GPE due to the healing length scale in the GPE enforcing a departure from the point-vortex model predictions. We introduce a simple numerical scheme to compensate for the healing length and confirm the necklace as a steady of the GPE. We find that the agreement between the point-vortex model and GPE for evolution of significant perturbations persists for longer as the healing length reduces compared to system size.
While quantized vortices and vortex lattices in Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) have received much recent attention, the formation and dynamics of vortex dipoles have been nearly unexplored in experimental BECs. Vortex dipoles consist of a pair of vortices of opposite circulation moving under the influence of each other, and may be considered as metastable topological structures that carry linear momentum in a fluid. In this talk, a collaborative experimental and numerical study of the formation, dynamics, and lifetimes of vortex dipoles in BECs will be presented. In our work [1], single vortex dipoles were deterministically nucleated by causing highly oblate, harmonically trapped BECs to move past a repulsive obstacle above a supercritical flow velocity. Our measured critical velocity for vortex dipole shedding, and the subsequent dipole dynamics, are in good agreement with new numerical simulations. We find that vortex dipoles can survive for many seconds in the BEC without selfannihilation, and that multiply charged vortex dipoles can be formed with high enough flow velocities. References: 1. T.W. Neely, E.C. Samson, A.S. Bradley, M.J. Davis, and B.P. Anderson, preprint available at http://arxiv.org/abs/0912.3773.
Quantum turbulence indicators in dipolar Bose-Einstein condensed fluids, following emissions of vortex-antivortex pairs generated by a circularly moving detuned laser, are being provided by numerical simulations of the corresponding quasi-two-dimensional Gross-Pitaevskii formalism with repulsive contact interactions combined with tunable dipole-dipole strength. The critical velocities of two variants of a circularly moving obstacle are determined and analyzed for vortex-antivortex nucleation in the form of regular and cluster emissions. The turbulent dynamical behavior is predicted to follow closely the initial emission of vortex-antivortex pairs, relying on the expected Kolmogorov classical scaling law, which is verified by the spectral analysis of the incompressible part of the kinetic energy. Within our aim to provide further support in the investigations to date of quantum turbulence, which have been focused on nondipolar Bose-Einstein condensates, we emphasize the role of dipole-dipole interactions in the fluid dynamics.
We consider the quantum reflection of vortices in Bose-Einstein condensates incident on a solid surface. Compared with the condensate without angular momentum, the rotation of the vortex gives unique opportunities to consider the interaction process between a matter wave and a solid surface. Due to the atom-surface interaction and dynamic excitations induced by interatomic interaction, our numerical simulations show that the reflected vortex would become unstable for sufficiently low velocity and large interaction strength. The stability diagram for the reflected vortex is given, and physical mechanism for this stability diagram is discussed. It is found that the expansion ratio between the reflected and incident vortices gives the boundary between stable and unstable regions for the reflected vortex.
Superfluids with strong spatial modulation can be experimentally produced in the area of cold atoms under the influence of optical lattices. Here we address 87Rb^{87}\mathrm{Rb}87Rb bosons at T=0T=0T=0 K in a flat geometry under the influence of a periodic potential with the Gross-Pitaevskii theory. The statics and dynamics of vortex excitations are studied in the case of one-dimensional (1D) and of two-dimensional (2D) optical lattices, as function of the intensity of the optical lattice. We compute how the vortex energy depends on the position of its core and the energy barrier that a vortex has to surmount in order to move in the superfluid. The dynamics of a vortex dipole, a pair of vortices of opposite chirality, differ profoundly from the case of a uniform superfluid. In the 1D case, when parallel ridges of density are present, the dynamics depends on the positions of the two vortices. If they are in the same channel between two ridges, then the two vortices approach each other until they annihilate each other in a short time. If the two vortices are in distinct channels, the dipole undergoes a rigid translation but with a velocity depending on the intensity of the optical lattice and this translation velocity can even change sign with respect to the case of the uniform superfluid. Superimposed on this translation an oscillatory motion is also present. A superposition of translation along a channel and an oscillation is also found with a single vortex when the system is bounded inside a circular trap. These oscillatory motions can be both longitudinal, i.e., along the channel, as well as transverse. In all cases the transverse motions are one sided, in the sense that the vortex core never crosses the equilibrium position nearest the starting position. In the case of the 2D lattices we study (square, triangular, and honeycomb), the two vortices of a dipole move mainly by jumps between equilibrium positions and approach each other until annihilation. This behavior has some similarity with what has been found for a vortex dipole in the supersolid state of dipolar bosons. We show that a rapid ramp down of the optical potential improves the visibility of the density holes at the vortex core.
In this thesis, we analytically and numerically study two different scenarios of vortex dynamics in a two-dimensional superfluid. The first system we explore is an expanding cluster of like-sign vortices, which recently suggested it could explain observations in a superfluid optomechanics experiment. We employ a recent theoretical model that approximates large collections of vortices as a fluid and present an analytic solution for its dynamics. Analysis suggests that as a cluster expands due to thermal friction, it forms a Rankine vortex (i.e., a top-hat distribution) that expands self-similarly in time regardless of initial vorticity distribution. Numerical simulations of point vortices confirm this universal expanding regime and further demonstrates vortex lattice formation that goes beyond the vortex fluid theory. We analyse correlations that emerge in the resulting lattices and observe decaying disorder as the cluster expands. Furthermore, we analyse experimental data from a quasi-two-dimensional 87Rb Bose-Einstein condensate, which supports the vortex fluid theory’s predictions.The second scenario considers the dynamics of a scattering event where a single quantum vortex interacts with a uniform, circular pinning potential in a steady two-dimensional superfluid flow. We first develop an approximate hydrodynamical model to understand the interaction between the vortex and the pinning potential in the conservative regime and find it is in good agreement with the mean-field Gross-Pitaevskii equation in the low-velocity limit. We further solve the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for higher background velocities to study how the vortex moves around pinning sites, interacts with it, and ultimately becomes pinned. We uncover four different regimes of vortex pinning, each marked with a characteristic emission of sound energy. Finally, we study how vortices become unpinned from a pinning site, revealing large vortex dipoles form to stabilise the system.Our work in this thesis takes significant steps towards advancing knowledge of both the collective dynamics of vortices and their individual interaction with defects upon surface substrates. Our numerical and analytical results opens up new avenues of exploration be it further understanding dissipation mechanisms in two-dimensional superfluids, or elucidating the nature of vortex pinning in systems such as neutron stars.