Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1810.10278 · Foundations of Physics

Law Without Law or “Just” Limit Theorems? Some Reflections About a Proposal of Wheeler’s

S. Caprara, Angelo Vulpiani

Published Aug 23, 2018• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1007/s10701-018-0210-z

Related papers

On Wheeler's notion of “law without law” in physics

David Deutsch

Foundations of Physics•Jun 1, 1986•41 citations

Remark on the Laws of Large Numbers and the Central Limit Theorems on a Logic

Anatolij Dvurečenskij

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1978•1 citation

Schrödinger’s Equation as a Consequence of the Central Limit Theorem Without Assuming Prior Physical Laws

P. M. Grinwald

Abstract The central limit theorem has been found to apply to random vectors in complex Hilbert space. This amounts to sufficient reason to study the complex–valued Gaussian, looking for relevance to quantum mechanics. Here we show that the Gaussian, with all terms fully complex, acting as a propagator, leads to Schrödinger’s non-relativistic equation including scalar and vector potentials, assuming only that the norm is conserved. No physical laws need to be postulated a priori. It thereby presents as a process of irregular motion analogous to the real random walk but executed under the rules of the complex number system. There is a standard view that Schrödinger’s equation is deterministic, whereas wavefunction “collapse” is probabilistic (by Born’s rule)—we have now a demonstrated linkage to the central limit theorem, indicating a stochastic picture at the foundation of Schrödinger’s equation itself. It may be an example of Wheeler’s “It from bit” with “No underlying law”. Reasons for the primary role of $$\mathbf {C}$$ C are open to discussion. The present derivation is compared with recent reconstructions of the quantum formalism, which have the aim of rationalizing its obscurities.

arXiv:1407.5954•Foundations of Physics•Apr 1, 2022•1 citation

The Wave–Particle Dualism of Photons as Seen from an Informational Point of View

Gerhard Müller

This paper deals with J. A. Wheeler’s proposal that each piece of reality owes its existence to observation—an approach to physics, which implies that all physical entities at their bottom are informational in character. Focusing on the double-slit experiment with photons, which is the key evidence for the wave–particle dualism of photons, this paper follows Wheeler’s observational approach and interprets this experiment as a question posed to nature. Considering how the enquiry regarding the wave–particle duality of photons is answered by nature, it is shown that experimental questions are being answered by nature in the form of spatiotemporal patterns of elementary observations (EOs) which are binary pieces of information, produced by the dissipation of energy. Working through this line of thought, Wheeler’s statements of “binary information gain”, “observer participance” and the “impossibility of continuum idealizations of physical laws” are elucidated and connections to the Landauer Principle are made.

Entropy•Oct 3, 2025•1 citation

Logical Reflections on the Kochen-Specker Theorem

John L. Bell

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1996•7 citations

Two experiments from the perspective of the structural probability theory

Paolo Rocchi

Current literature presents about a dozen probability (P) interpretations: frequentist, Bayesian etc. Each one illustrates a partial aspect of indeterminism and turns out to be incompatible with the others on the logical plane. Basically, every model of P deals with a specific relation of P with the world and this fragmentary theorization inevitably has negative impact on quantum physics which is intrinsically indeterministic. Popper believed that the base issues of quantum mechanics cannot be untangled unless the unified probability theory is set up. So, we have conducted an attempt to integrate all the probability models and used the theoretical results to interpret quantum duality, wave collapse and measurement. The entire work, published in a recent book, exceeds the limits of this paper. Here we put forward a summary that concisely recalls the main definitions and five theorems out fifteen that have been proved. Finally, these theoretical tools will be used to discuss a thought experiment of Einstein and the Wheeler experiment. This proposal has the following features: (1) It addresses classical and quantum issues using the same theorems; (2) It develops a quantum interpretation that agrees with intuition and refutes disputable and bizarre views.

Advanced Studies in Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
Abstract The central limit theorem has been found to apply to random vectors in complex Hilbert space. This amounts to sufficient reason to study the complex–valued Gaussian, looking for relevance to quantum mechanics. Here we show that the Gaussian, with all terms fully complex, acting as a propagator, leads to Schrödinger’s non-relativistic equation including scalar and vector potentials, assuming only that the norm is conserved. No physical laws need to be postulated a priori. It thereby presents as a process of irregular motion analogous to the real random walk but executed under the rules of the complex number system. There is a standard view that Schrödinger’s equation is deterministic, whereas wavefunction “collapse” is probabilistic (by Born’s rule)—we have now a demonstrated linkage to the central limit theorem, indicating a stochastic picture at the foundation of Schrödinger’s equation itself. It may be an example of Wheeler’s “It from bit” with “No underlying law”. Reasons for the primary role of C\mathbf {C}C C are open to discussion. The present derivation is compared with recent reconstructions of the quantum formalism, which have the aim of rationalizing its obscurities.
This paper deals with J. A. Wheeler’s proposal that each piece of reality owes its existence to observation—an approach to physics, which implies that all physical entities at their bottom are informational in character. Focusing on the double-slit experiment with photons, which is the key evidence for the wave–particle dualism of photons, this paper follows Wheeler’s observational approach and interprets this experiment as a question posed to nature. Considering how the enquiry regarding the wave–particle duality of photons is answered by nature, it is shown that experimental questions are being answered by nature in the form of spatiotemporal patterns of elementary observations (EOs) which are binary pieces of information, produced by the dissipation of energy. Working through this line of thought, Wheeler’s statements of “binary information gain”, “observer participance” and the “impossibility of continuum idealizations of physical laws” are elucidated and connections to the Landauer Principle are made.
Current literature presents about a dozen probability (P) interpretations: frequentist, Bayesian etc. Each one illustrates a partial aspect of indeterminism and turns out to be incompatible with the others on the logical plane. Basically, every model of P deals with a specific relation of P with the world and this fragmentary theorization inevitably has negative impact on quantum physics which is intrinsically indeterministic. Popper believed that the base issues of quantum mechanics cannot be untangled unless the unified probability theory is set up. So, we have conducted an attempt to integrate all the probability models and used the theoretical results to interpret quantum duality, wave collapse and measurement. The entire work, published in a recent book, exceeds the limits of this paper. Here we put forward a summary that concisely recalls the main definitions and five theorems out fifteen that have been proved. Finally, these theoretical tools will be used to discuss a thought experiment of Einstein and the Wheeler experiment. This proposal has the following features: (1) It addresses classical and quantum issues using the same theorems; (2) It develops a quantum interpretation that agrees with intuition and refutes disputable and bizarre views.