Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1810.07095 · Symmetry

Quasi-Lie Brackets and the Breaking of Time-Translation Symmetry for Quantum Systems Embedded in Classical Baths

Alessandro Sergi, Gabriel Hanna, Roberto Grimaudo, ANTONINO MESSINA

Published Oct 16, 2018• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many open quantum systems encountered in both natural and synthetic situations are embedded in classical-like baths. Often, the bath degrees of freedom may be represented in terms of canonically conjugate coordinates, but in some cases they may require a non-canonical or non-Hamiltonian representation. Herein, we review an approach to the dynamics and statistical mechanics of quantum subsystems embedded in either non-canonical or non-Hamiltonian classical-like baths which is based on operator-valued quasi-probability functions. These functions typically evolve through the action of quasi-Lie brackets and their associated Quantum-Classical Liouville Equations, or through quasi-Lie brackets augmented by dissipative terms. Quasi-Lie brackets possess the unique feature that, while conserving the energy (which the Noether theorem links to time-translation symmetry), they violate the time-translation symmetry of their algebra. This fact can be heuristically understood in terms of the dynamics of the open quantum subsystem. We then describe an example in which a quantum subsystem is embedded in a bath of classical spins, which are described by non-canonical coordinates. In this case, it has been shown that an off-diagonal open-bath geometric phase enters into the propagation of the quantum-classical dynamics. Next, we discuss how non-Hamiltonian dynamics may be employed to generate the constant-temperature evolution of phase space degrees of freedom coupled to the quantum subsystem. Constant-temperature dynamics may be generated by either a classical Langevin stochastic process or a Nosé–Hoover deterministic thermostat. These two approaches are not equivalent but have different advantages and drawbacks. In all cases, the calculation of the operator-valued quasi-probability function allows one to compute time-dependent statistical averages of observables. This may be accomplished in practice using a hybrid Molecular Dynamics/Monte Carlo algorithms, which we outline herein.

DOI
10.3390/sym10100518

Related papers

Statistics and Nosé formalism for Ehrenfest dynamics

J L Alonso, A Castro, Jesús Clemente-Gallardo +3 more

Quantum dynamics (i.e. the Schrödinger equation) and classical dynamics (i.e. Hamilton equations) can both be formulated in equal geometric terms: a Poisson bracket defined on a manifold. In this paper, we first show that the hybrid quantum-classical dynamics prescribed by the Ehrenfest equations can also be formulated within this general framework, what has been used in the literature to construct propagation schemes for Ehrenfest dynamics. Then, the existence of a well-defined Poisson bracket allows us to arrive to a Liouville equation for a statistical ensemble of Ehrenfest systems. The study of a generic toy model shows that the evolution produced by Ehrenfest dynamics is ergodic and therefore the only constants of motion are functions of the Hamiltonian. The emergence of the canonical ensemble characterized by the Boltzmann distribution follows after an appropriate application of the principle of equal a priori probabilities to this case. Once we know the canonical distribution of an Ehrenfest system, it is straightforward to extend the formalism of Nosé (invented to do constant temperature molecular dynamics by a non-stochastic method) to our Ehrenfest formalism. This work also provides the basis for extending stochastic methods to Ehrenfest dynamics.

arXiv:1104.2154•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 7, 2011•29 citations

Deterministic constant-temperature dynamics for dissipative quantum systems

Alessandro Sergi

A novel method is introduced in order to treat the dissipative dynamics of quantum systems interacting with a bath of classical degrees of freedom. The method is based upon an extension of the Nosè–Hoover chain (constant temperature) dynamics to quantum-classical systems. Both adiabatic and nonadiabatic numerical calculations on the relaxation dynamics of the spin-boson model show that the quantum-classical Nosè–Hoover chain dynamics represents the thermal noise of the bath in an accurate and simple way. Numerical comparisons, both with the constant-energy calculation and with the quantum-classical Brownian motion treatment of the bath, show that the quantum-classical Nosè–Hoover chain dynamics can be used to introduce dissipation in the evolution of a quantum subsystem even with just one degree of freedom for the bath. The algorithm can be computationally advantageous in modelling, within computer simulation, the dynamics of a quantum subsystem interacting with complex molecular environments.

arXiv:quant-ph/0701242•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 11, 2007•29 citations

A Study of Quantum-classical Dynamics in the Mapping Basis

Ali M. Nassimi

Solving quantum dynamics is an exponentially difficult problem. Thus, an exact numerical solution is inaccessible for any condensed matter system.\nA promising approach is to divide the system into a quantum subsystem containing degrees of freedom which are of greater interest or those which have more profound quantum character (e.g., have smaller mass) and a classical bath containing the rest of the system.\nImposing such a partition and treating the bath classically results in quantum-classical dynamics. The quantum-classical Liouville equation is a general equation in the Hilbert space of quantum degrees of freedom while it resides in the phase space of the classical degrees of freedom.\nAny numerical solution to this equation requires representation of the quantum subsystem in some basis. Solutions to this equation have been already proposed in the subsystem, adiabatic and force bases, each with its own cons and pros.\n\nIn this work, the quantum-classical equations of motion are cast in the subsystem basis and subsequently mapped to a number of fictitious harmonic oscillators.\nThe result is quantum-classical dynamics in the mapping basis which treats both quantum and classical degrees of freedom on the same footing, i.e., in phase space. Neglecting a portion of the back reaction of the quantum-subsystem to classical bath results in an expression for the time evolution of an operator (density matrix) equal to its Poisson bracket with the Hamiltonian.\nThis equation can be solved in terms of characteristics to provide a computationally tractable method for calculating quantum-classical dynamical properties. The expressions for expectation values and correlation functions in this formalism are derived.\nCalculations on spin-boson system, barrier crossing models---the so called Tully models---and the Fenna-Mathews-Olson pigments show very good agreement between the results of this method and numerical solutions to the Schrödinger equation.

•Aug 31, 2011•0 citations

Statistics and Nos\\'e formalism for Ehrenfest dynamics

José L. Alonso, Castro, Alberto, Jesús Clemente-Gallardo +3 more

Quantum dynamics (i.e. the Schrödinger equation) and classical dynamics (i.e. Hamilton equations) can both be formulated in equal geometric terms: a Poisson bracket defined on a manifold. In this paper, we first show that the hybrid quantum-classical dynamics prescribed by the Ehrenfest equations can also be formulated within this general framework, what has been used in the literature to construct propagation schemes for Ehrenfest dynamics. Then, the existence of a well-defined Poisson bracket allows us to arrive to a Liouville equation for a statistical ensemble of Ehrenfest systems. The study of a generic toy model shows that the evolution produced by Ehrenfest dynamics is ergodic and therefore the only constants of motion are functions of the Hamiltonian. The emergence of the canonical ensemble characterized by the Boltzmann distribution follows after an appropriate application of the principle of equal a priori probabilities to this case. Once we know the canonical distribution of an Ehrenfest system, it is straightforward to extend the formalism of Nosé (invented to do constant temperature molecular dynamics by a non-stochastic method) to our Ehrenfest formalism. This work also provides the basis for extending stochastic methods to Ehrenfest dynamics.

•May 8, 2019•30 citations

Isothermal quantum dynamics: Investigations for the harmonic oscillator

Detlef Mentrup

Thermostated time evolutions are on a firm ground and widely used in classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Hamilton´s equations of motion are supplemented by time-dependent pseudofriction terms that convert the microcanonical isoenergetic time evolution into a canonical isothermal time evolution, thus permitting the calculation of canonical ensemble averages by time averaging. However, similar methods for quantum MD schemes are still lacking. Given the rich dynamical behavior of ultracold trapped quantum gases depending on the value of the s-wave scattering length, it is timely to investigate how classical thermostating methods can be combined with powerful approximate quantum dynamics schemes to deal with interacting quantum systems at finite temperature. In this work, the popular method of Nose and Hoover to create canonically distributed positions and momenta in classical MD simulations is generalized to a genuine quantum system of infinite dimensionality. We show that for the quantum harmonic oscillator, the equations of motion in terms of coherent states may be modified in a Nose-Hoover manner to mimic the coupling of the system to a thermal bath and create a quantum canonical ensemble. The method is developed initially for a single particle and then generalized to the case of an arbitrary number of identical quantum particles, involving entangled distribution functions. The resulting isothermal equations of motion for bosons and fermions contain additional terms leading to Bose-attraction and Pauli-blocking, respectively. Questions of ergodicity are discussed for different coupling schemes. In the many-particle case, the superiority of the Nose-Hoover technique to a Langevin approach is demonstrated. In addition, the work contains an investigation of the Grilli-Tosatti thermostating method applied to the harmonic oscillator, and calculations for quantum wavefunctions moving with a time-invariant shape in a harmonic potential.

•May 26, 2003•0 citations

Sampling the time evolution of mixed quantum-classical systems

Alessandro Sergi

Quantum mechanics is not logically closed with respect to the classical world.Its formalism unfolds as the quantization of a sub-set of classical Hamiltonians.The interpretation of quantum theory in terms of the measurement process inevitably requires to deal with systems composed by a mixture of both classical and quantum degrees of freedom.Moreover, when energy can flow between the quantum and classical degrees of freedom (i.e., in the case of nonadiabatic dynamics), there are more theoretical difficulties in order to obtain a fully consistent quantum-classical formalism.In order to perform calculations, one can renounce to the usual Lie algebraic structure of well-established physical theories, adopt non-Hamiltonian brackets, and obtain a formalism for the dynamics and statistics of quantum-classical systems that has an affordable computational complexity.Recent progress in the algorithms for the sampling of nonadiabatic dynamics of quantum-classical systems at long time is reviewed here.

Atti della Accademia Peloritana dei Pericolanti. Classe di Scienze Fisiche, Matematiche e Naturali/Atti della Accademia Peloritana dei Pericolanti, Classe di Scienze Fisiche, Matematiche e Naturali•May 1, 2011•1 citation
Many open quantum systems encountered in both natural and synthetic situations are embedded in classical-like baths. Often, the bath degrees of freedom may be represented in terms of canonically conjugate coordinates, but in some cases they may require a non-canonical or non-Hamiltonian representation. Herein, we review an approach to the dynamics and statistical mechanics of quantum subsystems embedded in either non-canonical or non-Hamiltonian classical-like baths which is based on operator-valued quasi-probability functions. These functions typically evolve through the action of quasi-Lie brackets and their associated Quantum-Classical Liouville Equations, or through quasi-Lie brackets augmented by dissipative terms. Quasi-Lie brackets possess the unique feature that, while conserving the energy (which the Noether theorem links to time-translation symmetry), they violate the time-translation symmetry of their algebra. This fact can be heuristically understood in terms of the dynamics of the open quantum subsystem. We then describe an example in which a quantum subsystem is embedded in a bath of classical spins, which are described by non-canonical coordinates. In this case, it has been shown that an off-diagonal open-bath geometric phase enters into the propagation of the quantum-classical dynamics. Next, we discuss how non-Hamiltonian dynamics may be employed to generate the constant-temperature evolution of phase space degrees of freedom coupled to the quantum subsystem. Constant-temperature dynamics may be generated by either a classical Langevin stochastic process or a Nosé–Hoover deterministic thermostat. These two approaches are not equivalent but have different advantages and drawbacks. In all cases, the calculation of the operator-valued quasi-probability function allows one to compute time-dependent statistical averages of observables. This may be accomplished in practice using a hybrid Molecular Dynamics/Monte Carlo algorithms, which we outline herein.
Quantum dynamics (i.e. the Schrödinger equation) and classical dynamics (i.e. Hamilton equations) can both be formulated in equal geometric terms: a Poisson bracket defined on a manifold. In this paper, we first show that the hybrid quantum-classical dynamics prescribed by the Ehrenfest equations can also be formulated within this general framework, what has been used in the literature to construct propagation schemes for Ehrenfest dynamics. Then, the existence of a well-defined Poisson bracket allows us to arrive to a Liouville equation for a statistical ensemble of Ehrenfest systems. The study of a generic toy model shows that the evolution produced by Ehrenfest dynamics is ergodic and therefore the only constants of motion are functions of the Hamiltonian. The emergence of the canonical ensemble characterized by the Boltzmann distribution follows after an appropriate application of the principle of equal a priori probabilities to this case. Once we know the canonical distribution of an Ehrenfest system, it is straightforward to extend the formalism of Nosé (invented to do constant temperature molecular dynamics by a non-stochastic method) to our Ehrenfest formalism. This work also provides the basis for extending stochastic methods to Ehrenfest dynamics.
A novel method is introduced in order to treat the dissipative dynamics of quantum systems interacting with a bath of classical degrees of freedom. The method is based upon an extension of the Nosè–Hoover chain (constant temperature) dynamics to quantum-classical systems. Both adiabatic and nonadiabatic numerical calculations on the relaxation dynamics of the spin-boson model show that the quantum-classical Nosè–Hoover chain dynamics represents the thermal noise of the bath in an accurate and simple way. Numerical comparisons, both with the constant-energy calculation and with the quantum-classical Brownian motion treatment of the bath, show that the quantum-classical Nosè–Hoover chain dynamics can be used to introduce dissipation in the evolution of a quantum subsystem even with just one degree of freedom for the bath. The algorithm can be computationally advantageous in modelling, within computer simulation, the dynamics of a quantum subsystem interacting with complex molecular environments.
Solving quantum dynamics is an exponentially difficult problem. Thus, an exact numerical solution is inaccessible for any condensed matter system.\nA promising approach is to divide the system into a quantum subsystem containing degrees of freedom which are of greater interest or those which have more profound quantum character (e.g., have smaller mass) and a classical bath containing the rest of the system.\nImposing such a partition and treating the bath classically results in quantum-classical dynamics. The quantum-classical Liouville equation is a general equation in the Hilbert space of quantum degrees of freedom while it resides in the phase space of the classical degrees of freedom.\nAny numerical solution to this equation requires representation of the quantum subsystem in some basis. Solutions to this equation have been already proposed in the subsystem, adiabatic and force bases, each with its own cons and pros.\n\nIn this work, the quantum-classical equations of motion are cast in the subsystem basis and subsequently mapped to a number of fictitious harmonic oscillators.\nThe result is quantum-classical dynamics in the mapping basis which treats both quantum and classical degrees of freedom on the same footing, i.e., in phase space. Neglecting a portion of the back reaction of the quantum-subsystem to classical bath results in an expression for the time evolution of an operator (density matrix) equal to its Poisson bracket with the Hamiltonian.\nThis equation can be solved in terms of characteristics to provide a computationally tractable method for calculating quantum-classical dynamical properties. The expressions for expectation values and correlation functions in this formalism are derived.\nCalculations on spin-boson system, barrier crossing models---the so called Tully models---and the Fenna-Mathews-Olson pigments show very good agreement between the results of this method and numerical solutions to the Schrödinger equation.
Quantum dynamics (i.e. the Schrödinger equation) and classical dynamics (i.e. Hamilton equations) can both be formulated in equal geometric terms: a Poisson bracket defined on a manifold. In this paper, we first show that the hybrid quantum-classical dynamics prescribed by the Ehrenfest equations can also be formulated within this general framework, what has been used in the literature to construct propagation schemes for Ehrenfest dynamics. Then, the existence of a well-defined Poisson bracket allows us to arrive to a Liouville equation for a statistical ensemble of Ehrenfest systems. The study of a generic toy model shows that the evolution produced by Ehrenfest dynamics is ergodic and therefore the only constants of motion are functions of the Hamiltonian. The emergence of the canonical ensemble characterized by the Boltzmann distribution follows after an appropriate application of the principle of equal a priori probabilities to this case. Once we know the canonical distribution of an Ehrenfest system, it is straightforward to extend the formalism of Nosé (invented to do constant temperature molecular dynamics by a non-stochastic method) to our Ehrenfest formalism. This work also provides the basis for extending stochastic methods to Ehrenfest dynamics.
Thermostated time evolutions are on a firm ground and widely used in classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Hamilton´s equations of motion are supplemented by time-dependent pseudofriction terms that convert the microcanonical isoenergetic time evolution into a canonical isothermal time evolution, thus permitting the calculation of canonical ensemble averages by time averaging. However, similar methods for quantum MD schemes are still lacking. Given the rich dynamical behavior of ultracold trapped quantum gases depending on the value of the s-wave scattering length, it is timely to investigate how classical thermostating methods can be combined with powerful approximate quantum dynamics schemes to deal with interacting quantum systems at finite temperature. In this work, the popular method of Nose and Hoover to create canonically distributed positions and momenta in classical MD simulations is generalized to a genuine quantum system of infinite dimensionality. We show that for the quantum harmonic oscillator, the equations of motion in terms of coherent states may be modified in a Nose-Hoover manner to mimic the coupling of the system to a thermal bath and create a quantum canonical ensemble. The method is developed initially for a single particle and then generalized to the case of an arbitrary number of identical quantum particles, involving entangled distribution functions. The resulting isothermal equations of motion for bosons and fermions contain additional terms leading to Bose-attraction and Pauli-blocking, respectively. Questions of ergodicity are discussed for different coupling schemes. In the many-particle case, the superiority of the Nose-Hoover technique to a Langevin approach is demonstrated. In addition, the work contains an investigation of the Grilli-Tosatti thermostating method applied to the harmonic oscillator, and calculations for quantum wavefunctions moving with a time-invariant shape in a harmonic potential.
Quantum mechanics is not logically closed with respect to the classical world.Its formalism unfolds as the quantization of a sub-set of classical Hamiltonians.The interpretation of quantum theory in terms of the measurement process inevitably requires to deal with systems composed by a mixture of both classical and quantum degrees of freedom.Moreover, when energy can flow between the quantum and classical degrees of freedom (i.e., in the case of nonadiabatic dynamics), there are more theoretical difficulties in order to obtain a fully consistent quantum-classical formalism.In order to perform calculations, one can renounce to the usual Lie algebraic structure of well-established physical theories, adopt non-Hamiltonian brackets, and obtain a formalism for the dynamics and statistics of quantum-classical systems that has an affordable computational complexity.Recent progress in the algorithms for the sampling of nonadiabatic dynamics of quantum-classical systems at long time is reviewed here.