Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1809.04498 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Ehrenfest+R dynamics. II. A semiclassical QED framework for Raman scattering

Hsing-Ta Chen, Tao E. Li, Maxim Sukharev, Abraham Nitzan, Joseph Eli Subotnik

Published Jan 24, 2019• 21 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In Paper I [Chen et al., J. Chem. Phys. 150, 044102 (2019)], we introduced Ehrenfest+R dynamics for a two-level system and showed how spontaneous emission can be heuristically included such that, after averaging over an ensemble of Ehrenfest+R trajectories, one can recover both coherent and incoherent electromagnetic fields. In the present paper, we now show that Ehrenfest+R dynamics can also correctly describe Raman scattering, whose features are completely absent from standard Ehrenfest dynamics. Ehrenfest+R dynamics appear to be quantitatively accurate both for resonant and off-resonant Raman signals, as compared with Kramers-Heisenberg-Dirac theory.

DOI
10.1063/1.5057366

Related papers

Where Semiclassical Radiation Theory Fails

ROBERT K. NESBET

Semiclassical radiation theory provides parallel derivations of spontaneous emission and of spontaneous incoherent scattering of radiation. In the latter case, in constrast to the former, the theory is in clear disagreement with established experimental data since it predicts equal intensity for Stokes and anti-Stokes lines in Raman scattering. A new postulate of semiquantization is proposed to restore agreement with experiment without quantizing the electromagnetic field.

Physical Review Letters•Aug 30, 1971•45 citations

Quantum initiation of stimulated Raman scattering

R. C. Swanson, David C. MacPherson, John L. Carlsten

In our studies of soliton formation in stimulated Raman scattering (SRS), we have discovered that a fully quantum mechanical theory predicts large shot-to-shot fluctuations in the SRS power spectrum, which leads to soliton decay. This theory, which includes a Langevin operator to simulate collision-induced fluctuations and maintain operator consistency, can be used to generate the statistics of the macroscopic SRS output. We have also studied a simpler model which uses a random vacuum field as an input to the semiclassical SRS equations. The vacuum field was numerically generated by summing a set of electromagnetic field modes that spanned the collisional Raman linewidth. Each mode was separated in frequency by less than the resolution of the system and given a random phase for each shot. Despite the lack of Langevin terms, the shot-to-shot variations and two-frequency correlation function from the simple approach were essentially indistinguishable from the fully quantum mechanical theory. This suggests that a simulation of SRS from spontaneous emission does not always require Langevin terms in the quantum noise.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1988•0 citations

Time-ordering in Heisenberg’s equation of motion as related to spontaneous radiation

Benjamin D. Strycker

Despite many years of research into Raman phenomena, the problem of how to include both spontaneous and stimulated Raman scattering into a unified set of partial differential equations persists. The issue is solved by formulating the quantum dynamics in the Heisenberg picture with a rigorous accounting for both time- and normal-ordering of the operators. It is shown how this can be done in a simple, straightforward way. Firstly, the technique is applied to a two-level Raman system, and comparison of analytical and numerical results verifies the approach. A connection to a fully time-dependent Langevin operator method is made for the spontaneous initiation of stimulated Raman scattering. Secondly, the technique is demonstrated for the much-studied two-level atom both in vacuum and in a lossy dielectric medium. It is shown to be fully consistent with accepted theories: using the rotating wave approximation, the Einstein A coefficient for the rate of spontaneous emission from a two-level atom can be derived in a manner parallel to the Weisskopf-Wigner approximation. The Lamb frequency shift is also calculated. It is shown throughout that field operators corresponding to spontaneous radiative terms do not commute with atomic/molecular operators. The approach may prove useful in many areas, including modeling the propagation of next-generation high-energy, high-intensity ultrafast laser pulses as well as spontaneous radiative processes in lossy media.

Scientific Reports•Nov 12, 2021•1 citation

Bridging quantum mechanics and nonlinear optics in Raman scattering

Naoki Fukutake, Hideaki Kano

We present a theoretical framework for spontaneous Raman scattering that fundamentally bridges quantum-mechanical and nonlinear-optical approaches. By conceptualizing spontaneous Raman scattering as a stimulated Raman gain or loss event seeded by the quantum vacuum field, we rigorously derive the spontaneous Raman cross-section directly from the third-order nonlinear susceptibility. Crucially, this framework predicts the existence of a hitherto unrecognized phenomenon: "spontaneous Raman loss" (sRL), which acts as the vacuum-seeded counterpart to stimulated Raman loss, complementing traditional spontaneous Raman scattering (spontaneous Raman gain, sRG). Furthermore, we establish a rigorous connection to the traditional Kramers-Heisenberg-Dirac (KHD) theory, revealing that the spontaneous process is governed by interference before a detector between the signal field emitted from molecules and the vacuum field itself that stimulates the molecules. This insight uncovers a direct correspondence between the sRG susceptibility and the rotating/counter-rotating interference terms in the KHD formula. Ultimately, we extend the foundational KHD theory by incorporating previously unrecognized essential terms, achieving perfect analytical agreement between the quantum mechanical and nonlinear optical descriptions of Raman scattering.

quant-pharXiv:2607.00463•Jul 2, 2026•0 citations

Dynamics of a three-level Raman coupled atom interacting with two classical and two quantized modes of the electromagnetic field

Edwin E. Hach

•Jan 1, 2000•0 citations

Ehrenfest dynamics with spontaneous localization

A. A. Tomaz, Rafael Souza Mattos, Saikat Mukherjee +1 more

We propose Ehrenfest Dynamics with Spontaneous Localization (SLED), a decoherence-corrected extension of Ehrenfest dynamics based on the Gisin-Percival quantum-state diffusion equation. In SLED, the electronic wave function evolves stochastically in the adiabatic energy basis, producing trajectory-level localization. The trajectory ensemble reproduces a Lindblad-type propagation of the reduced electronic density matrix. This approach ensures linearity, trace preservation, and complete positivity, providing a physically consistent alternative to ad hoc decoherence corrections commonly adopted in mixed quantum-classical methods. Benchmark simulations on one-dimensional Tully models and multidimensional spin-boson Hamiltonians demonstrate that SLED reproduces electronic populations and captures the essential features of coherence decay. The tests, however, also reveal that accurate treatment will require generalizing the localization kernel controlling the electron-nucleus coupling strength from a constant into a function of time and phase space coordinates. SLED is implemented in the newly developed Skitten program and will be integrated into Newton-X. While the present study serves as a proof of concept, SLED establishes a rigorous and extensible framework that bridges mixed quantum-classical dynamics with open quantum system theory.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 4, 2025•1 citation
In Paper I [Chen et al., J. Chem. Phys. 150, 044102 (2019)], we introduced Ehrenfest+R dynamics for a two-level system and showed how spontaneous emission can be heuristically included such that, after averaging over an ensemble of Ehrenfest+R trajectories, one can recover both coherent and incoherent electromagnetic fields. In the present paper, we now show that Ehrenfest+R dynamics can also correctly describe Raman scattering, whose features are completely absent from standard Ehrenfest dynamics. Ehrenfest+R dynamics appear to be quantitatively accurate both for resonant and off-resonant Raman signals, as compared with Kramers-Heisenberg-Dirac theory.
In our studies of soliton formation in stimulated Raman scattering (SRS), we have discovered that a fully quantum mechanical theory predicts large shot-to-shot fluctuations in the SRS power spectrum, which leads to soliton decay. This theory, which includes a Langevin operator to simulate collision-induced fluctuations and maintain operator consistency, can be used to generate the statistics of the macroscopic SRS output. We have also studied a simpler model which uses a random vacuum field as an input to the semiclassical SRS equations. The vacuum field was numerically generated by summing a set of electromagnetic field modes that spanned the collisional Raman linewidth. Each mode was separated in frequency by less than the resolution of the system and given a random phase for each shot. Despite the lack of Langevin terms, the shot-to-shot variations and two-frequency correlation function from the simple approach were essentially indistinguishable from the fully quantum mechanical theory. This suggests that a simulation of SRS from spontaneous emission does not always require Langevin terms in the quantum noise.
Despite many years of research into Raman phenomena, the problem of how to include both spontaneous and stimulated Raman scattering into a unified set of partial differential equations persists. The issue is solved by formulating the quantum dynamics in the Heisenberg picture with a rigorous accounting for both time- and normal-ordering of the operators. It is shown how this can be done in a simple, straightforward way. Firstly, the technique is applied to a two-level Raman system, and comparison of analytical and numerical results verifies the approach. A connection to a fully time-dependent Langevin operator method is made for the spontaneous initiation of stimulated Raman scattering. Secondly, the technique is demonstrated for the much-studied two-level atom both in vacuum and in a lossy dielectric medium. It is shown to be fully consistent with accepted theories: using the rotating wave approximation, the Einstein A coefficient for the rate of spontaneous emission from a two-level atom can be derived in a manner parallel to the Weisskopf-Wigner approximation. The Lamb frequency shift is also calculated. It is shown throughout that field operators corresponding to spontaneous radiative terms do not commute with atomic/molecular operators. The approach may prove useful in many areas, including modeling the propagation of next-generation high-energy, high-intensity ultrafast laser pulses as well as spontaneous radiative processes in lossy media.
We present a theoretical framework for spontaneous Raman scattering that fundamentally bridges quantum-mechanical and nonlinear-optical approaches. By conceptualizing spontaneous Raman scattering as a stimulated Raman gain or loss event seeded by the quantum vacuum field, we rigorously derive the spontaneous Raman cross-section directly from the third-order nonlinear susceptibility. Crucially, this framework predicts the existence of a hitherto unrecognized phenomenon: "spontaneous Raman loss" (sRL), which acts as the vacuum-seeded counterpart to stimulated Raman loss, complementing traditional spontaneous Raman scattering (spontaneous Raman gain, sRG). Furthermore, we establish a rigorous connection to the traditional Kramers-Heisenberg-Dirac (KHD) theory, revealing that the spontaneous process is governed by interference before a detector between the signal field emitted from molecules and the vacuum field itself that stimulates the molecules. This insight uncovers a direct correspondence between the sRG susceptibility and the rotating/counter-rotating interference terms in the KHD formula. Ultimately, we extend the foundational KHD theory by incorporating previously unrecognized essential terms, achieving perfect analytical agreement between the quantum mechanical and nonlinear optical descriptions of Raman scattering.
We propose Ehrenfest Dynamics with Spontaneous Localization (SLED), a decoherence-corrected extension of Ehrenfest dynamics based on the Gisin-Percival quantum-state diffusion equation. In SLED, the electronic wave function evolves stochastically in the adiabatic energy basis, producing trajectory-level localization. The trajectory ensemble reproduces a Lindblad-type propagation of the reduced electronic density matrix. This approach ensures linearity, trace preservation, and complete positivity, providing a physically consistent alternative to ad hoc decoherence corrections commonly adopted in mixed quantum-classical methods. Benchmark simulations on one-dimensional Tully models and multidimensional spin-boson Hamiltonians demonstrate that SLED reproduces electronic populations and captures the essential features of coherence decay. The tests, however, also reveal that accurate treatment will require generalizing the localization kernel controlling the electron-nucleus coupling strength from a constant into a function of time and phase space coordinates. SLED is implemented in the newly developed Skitten program and will be integrated into Newton-X. While the present study serves as a proof of concept, SLED establishes a rigorous and extensible framework that bridges mixed quantum-classical dynamics with open quantum system theory.