Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1809.03562 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Projective quantum Monte Carlo simulations guided by unrestricted neural network states

Estelle M. Inack, Giuseppe E. Santoro, Luca Dell’Anna, Sebastiano Pilati

Published Dec 21, 2018• 37 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the use of variational wave functions that mimic stochastic recurrent neural networks, specifically, unrestricted Boltzmann machines, as guiding functions in projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) simulations of quantum spin models. As a preliminary step, we investigate the accuracy of such unrestricted neural network states as variational Ans\"atze for the ground state of the ferromagnetic quantum Ising chain. We find that by optimizing just three variational parameters, independently on the system size, accurate ground-state energies are obtained, comparable to those previously obtained using restricted Boltzmann machines with few variational parameters per spin. Chiefly, we show that if one uses optimized unrestricted neural network states as guiding functions for importance sampling, the efficiency of the PQMC algorithms is greatly enhanced, drastically reducing the most relevant systematic bias, namely, the one due to the finite random-walker population. The scaling of the computational cost with the system size changes from the exponential scaling characteristic of PQMC simulations performed without importance sampling, to a polynomial scaling, apparently even at the ferromagnetic quantum critical point. The important role of the protocol chosen to sample hidden-spin configurations, in particular at the critical point, is analyzed. We discuss the implications of these findings for what concerns the problem of simulating adiabatic quantum optimization using stochastic algorithms on classical computers.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.98.235145

Related papers

Simulating disordered quantum Ising chains via dense and sparse restricted Boltzmann machines

Sebastiano Pilati, P. Pieri

In recent years, generative artificial neural networks based on restricted Boltzmann machines (RBMs) have been successfully employed as accurate and flexible variational wave functions for clean quantum many-body systems. In this article, we explore their use in simulations of disordered quantum Ising chains. The standard dense RBM with all-to-all interlayer connectivity is not particularly appropriate for large disordered systems, since in such systems one cannot exploit translational invariance to reduce the amount of parameters to be optimized. To circumvent this problem, we implement sparse RBMs, whereby the visible spins are connected only to a subset of local hidden neurons, thus reducing the amount of parameters. We assess the performance of sparse RBMs as a function of the range of the allowed connections, and we compare it with that of dense RBMs. Benchmark results are provided for two sign-problem-free Hamiltonians, namely pure and random quantum Ising chains. The RBM Ansätzes are trained using the unsupervised learning scheme based on projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) algorithms. We find that the sparse connectivity facilitates the training process and allows sparse RBMs to outperform their dense counterparts. Furthermore, the use of sparse RBMs as guiding functions for PQMC simulations allows us to perform PQMC simulations at a reduced computational cost, avoiding possible biases due to finite random-walker populations. We obtain unbiased predictions for the ground-state energies and the magnetization profiles with fixed boundary conditions, at the ferromagnetic quantum critical point. The magnetization profiles agree with the Fisher-de Gennes scaling relation for conformally invariant systems, including the scaling dimension predicted by the renormalization-group analysis.

arXiv:2003.09765•Physical review. E•Jun 22, 2020•21 citations

Self-learning projective quantum Monte Carlo simulations guided by restricted Boltzmann machines

Sebastiano Pilati, Estelle M. Inack, P. Pieri

The projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) algorithms are among the most powerful computational techniques to simulate the ground-state properties of quantum many-body systems. However, they are efficient only if a sufficiently accurate trial wave function is used to guide the simulation. In the standard approach, this guiding wave function is obtained in a separate simulation that performs a variational minimization. Here we show how to perform PQMC simulations guided by an adaptive wave function based on a restricted Boltzmann machine. This adaptive wave function is optimized along the PQMC simulation via unsupervised machine learning, avoiding the need of a separate variational optimization. As a byproduct, this technique provides an accurate ansatz for the ground-state wave function, which is obtained by minimizing the Kullback-Leibler divergence with respect to the PQMC samples, rather than by minimizing the energy expectation value as in standard variational optimizations. The high accuracy of this self-learning PQMC technique is demonstrated for a paradigmatic sign-problem-free model, namely, the ferromagnetic quantum Ising chain, showing very precise agreement with the predictions of the Jordan-Wigner theory and of loop quantum Monte Carlo simulations performed in the low-temperature limit.

arXiv:1907.00907•Physical review. E•Oct 2, 2019•29 citations

Autoregressive Projective Quantum Monte Carlo: From a Hermitian to a Non-Hermitian Perspective

Lavoisier Wah, Remmy Zen, Flore K. Kunst

Accurately determining the ground-state properties of quantum many-body systems remains a central challenge. In this work, we introduce an autoregressive projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) framework that leverages recurrent neural networks (RNNs) to guide the stochastic dynamics. By incorporating autoregressive sampling into PQMC, we demonstrate substantial improvements in accuracy compared to standard unguided PQMC, while retaining polynomial computational cost. We benchmark our approach against conventional variational RNN ansätze and find that the autoregressive PQMC consistently achieves lower energies and higher fidelity, regardless of system size or whether the Hamiltonian is Hermitian or non-Hermitian. Our results highlight the versatility and power of neural-guided PQMC methods, paving the way for promising scalable simulations of low-energy states in complex quantum many-body systems.

quant-pharXiv:2608.09496•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

Are neural quantum states good at solving non-stoquastic spin Hamiltonians?

Chae-Yeun Park, Michael J. Kastoryano

Variational Monte Carlo with neural network quantum states has proven to be a promising avenue for evaluating the ground state energy of spin Hamiltonians. Based on anecdotal evidence, it has been claimed repeatedly in the literature that neural network quantum state simulations are insensitive to the sign problem. We present a detailed and systematic study of restricted Boltzmann machine (RBM) based variational Monte Carlo for quantum spin chains, resolving exactly how relevant stoquasticity is in this setting. We show that in most cases, when the Hamiltonian is phase connected with a stoquastic point, the complex RBM state can faithfully represent the ground state, and local quantities can be evaluated efficiently by sampling. On the other hand, we identify a number of new phases that are challenging for the RBM Ansatz, including non-topological robust non-stoquastic phases as well as stoquastic phases where sampling is nevertheless inefficient. Our results suggest that great care needs to be taken with neural network quantum state based variational Monte Carlo when the system under study is highly frustrated.

•Feb 8, 2021•7 citations

Probabilistic Computers for Neural Quantum States

Shuvro Chowdhury, Jasper Pieterse, Navid Anjum Aadit +3 more

Neural quantum states efficiently represent many-body wavefunctions with neural networks, but the cost of Monte Carlo sampling limits their scaling to large system sizes. Here we address this challenge by combining sparse Boltzmann machine architectures with probabilistic computing hardware. We implement a probabilistic computer on field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) and use it as a fast sampler for energy-based neural quantum states. For the two-dimensional transverse-field Ising model at criticality, we obtain accurate ground-state energies for lattices up to 80$\times$80 (6400 spins) using a custom multi-FPGA cluster. Furthermore, we introduce a dual-sampling algorithm to train deep Boltzmann machines, replacing intractable marginalization with conditional sampling over auxiliary layers. This enables the training of sparse deep models and improves parameter efficiency relative to shallow networks. We further implement this algorithm on a single FPGA, demonstrating the training of deep Boltzmann machines for systems as large as $30 \times 30$ (900 spins). Together, these results demonstrate that probabilistic hardware can overcome the sampling bottleneck in variational simulation of quantum many-body systems, opening a path to larger system sizes and deeper variational architectures.

quant-pharXiv:2512.24558•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Tunneling in projective quantum Monte Carlo simulations with guiding wave functions

Tommaso Parolini, Estelle M. Inack, Giuliano Giudici +1 more

Quantum tunneling is a valuable resource exploited by quantum annealers to solve complex optimization problems. Tunneling events also occur during projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) simulations, and in a class of problems characterized by a double-well energy landscape their rate was found to scale linearly with the first energy gap, i.e., even more favorably than in physical quantum annealers, where the rate scales with the gap squared. Here we investigate how a guiding wave function---which is essential to make many-body PQMC simulations computationally feasible---affects the tunneling rate. The chosen test beds are a continuous-space double-well problem, the ferromagnetic quantum Ising chain, and the recently introduced shamrock model. As guiding wave function, we consider an approximate Boltzmann-type ansatz, the numerically exact ground state of the double-well model, and a neural-network wave function based on a Boltzmann machine. Remarkably, for each ansatz we find the same asymptotic linear scaling of the tunneling rate that was previously found in the PQMC simulations performed without a guiding wave function. We also provide a semiclassical theory for the double-well with exact guiding wave function that explains the observed linear scaling. These findings suggest that PQMC simulations guided by an accurate ansatz represent a valuable benchmark for physical quantum annealers and a potentially competitive quantum-inspired optimization technique.

arXiv:1908.10151•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 6, 2019•9 citations
We investigate the use of variational wave functions that mimic stochastic recurrent neural networks, specifically, unrestricted Boltzmann machines, as guiding functions in projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) simulations of quantum spin models. As a preliminary step, we investigate the accuracy of such unrestricted neural network states as variational Ans"atze for the ground state of the ferromagnetic quantum Ising chain. We find that by optimizing just three variational parameters, independently on the system size, accurate ground-state energies are obtained, comparable to those previously obtained using restricted Boltzmann machines with few variational parameters per spin. Chiefly, we show that if one uses optimized unrestricted neural network states as guiding functions for importance sampling, the efficiency of the PQMC algorithms is greatly enhanced, drastically reducing the most relevant systematic bias, namely, the one due to the finite random-walker population. The scaling of the computational cost with the system size changes from the exponential scaling characteristic of PQMC simulations performed without importance sampling, to a polynomial scaling, apparently even at the ferromagnetic quantum critical point. The important role of the protocol chosen to sample hidden-spin configurations, in particular at the critical point, is analyzed. We discuss the implications of these findings for what concerns the problem of simulating adiabatic quantum optimization using stochastic algorithms on classical computers.
In recent years, generative artificial neural networks based on restricted Boltzmann machines (RBMs) have been successfully employed as accurate and flexible variational wave functions for clean quantum many-body systems. In this article, we explore their use in simulations of disordered quantum Ising chains. The standard dense RBM with all-to-all interlayer connectivity is not particularly appropriate for large disordered systems, since in such systems one cannot exploit translational invariance to reduce the amount of parameters to be optimized. To circumvent this problem, we implement sparse RBMs, whereby the visible spins are connected only to a subset of local hidden neurons, thus reducing the amount of parameters. We assess the performance of sparse RBMs as a function of the range of the allowed connections, and we compare it with that of dense RBMs. Benchmark results are provided for two sign-problem-free Hamiltonians, namely pure and random quantum Ising chains. The RBM Ansätzes are trained using the unsupervised learning scheme based on projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) algorithms. We find that the sparse connectivity facilitates the training process and allows sparse RBMs to outperform their dense counterparts. Furthermore, the use of sparse RBMs as guiding functions for PQMC simulations allows us to perform PQMC simulations at a reduced computational cost, avoiding possible biases due to finite random-walker populations. We obtain unbiased predictions for the ground-state energies and the magnetization profiles with fixed boundary conditions, at the ferromagnetic quantum critical point. The magnetization profiles agree with the Fisher-de Gennes scaling relation for conformally invariant systems, including the scaling dimension predicted by the renormalization-group analysis.
The projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) algorithms are among the most powerful computational techniques to simulate the ground-state properties of quantum many-body systems. However, they are efficient only if a sufficiently accurate trial wave function is used to guide the simulation. In the standard approach, this guiding wave function is obtained in a separate simulation that performs a variational minimization. Here we show how to perform PQMC simulations guided by an adaptive wave function based on a restricted Boltzmann machine. This adaptive wave function is optimized along the PQMC simulation via unsupervised machine learning, avoiding the need of a separate variational optimization. As a byproduct, this technique provides an accurate ansatz for the ground-state wave function, which is obtained by minimizing the Kullback-Leibler divergence with respect to the PQMC samples, rather than by minimizing the energy expectation value as in standard variational optimizations. The high accuracy of this self-learning PQMC technique is demonstrated for a paradigmatic sign-problem-free model, namely, the ferromagnetic quantum Ising chain, showing very precise agreement with the predictions of the Jordan-Wigner theory and of loop quantum Monte Carlo simulations performed in the low-temperature limit.
Accurately determining the ground-state properties of quantum many-body systems remains a central challenge. In this work, we introduce an autoregressive projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) framework that leverages recurrent neural networks (RNNs) to guide the stochastic dynamics. By incorporating autoregressive sampling into PQMC, we demonstrate substantial improvements in accuracy compared to standard unguided PQMC, while retaining polynomial computational cost. We benchmark our approach against conventional variational RNN ansätze and find that the autoregressive PQMC consistently achieves lower energies and higher fidelity, regardless of system size or whether the Hamiltonian is Hermitian or non-Hermitian. Our results highlight the versatility and power of neural-guided PQMC methods, paving the way for promising scalable simulations of low-energy states in complex quantum many-body systems.
Variational Monte Carlo with neural network quantum states has proven to be a promising avenue for evaluating the ground state energy of spin Hamiltonians. Based on anecdotal evidence, it has been claimed repeatedly in the literature that neural network quantum state simulations are insensitive to the sign problem. We present a detailed and systematic study of restricted Boltzmann machine (RBM) based variational Monte Carlo for quantum spin chains, resolving exactly how relevant stoquasticity is in this setting. We show that in most cases, when the Hamiltonian is phase connected with a stoquastic point, the complex RBM state can faithfully represent the ground state, and local quantities can be evaluated efficiently by sampling. On the other hand, we identify a number of new phases that are challenging for the RBM Ansatz, including non-topological robust non-stoquastic phases as well as stoquastic phases where sampling is nevertheless inefficient. Our results suggest that great care needs to be taken with neural network quantum state based variational Monte Carlo when the system under study is highly frustrated.
Neural quantum states efficiently represent many-body wavefunctions with neural networks, but the cost of Monte Carlo sampling limits their scaling to large system sizes. Here we address this challenge by combining sparse Boltzmann machine architectures with probabilistic computing hardware. We implement a probabilistic computer on field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) and use it as a fast sampler for energy-based neural quantum states. For the two-dimensional transverse-field Ising model at criticality, we obtain accurate ground-state energies for lattices up to 80$\times$80 (6400 spins) using a custom multi-FPGA cluster. Furthermore, we introduce a dual-sampling algorithm to train deep Boltzmann machines, replacing intractable marginalization with conditional sampling over auxiliary layers. This enables the training of sparse deep models and improves parameter efficiency relative to shallow networks. We further implement this algorithm on a single FPGA, demonstrating the training of deep Boltzmann machines for systems as large as 30×3030 \times 3030×30 (900 spins). Together, these results demonstrate that probabilistic hardware can overcome the sampling bottleneck in variational simulation of quantum many-body systems, opening a path to larger system sizes and deeper variational architectures.
Quantum tunneling is a valuable resource exploited by quantum annealers to solve complex optimization problems. Tunneling events also occur during projective quantum Monte Carlo (PQMC) simulations, and in a class of problems characterized by a double-well energy landscape their rate was found to scale linearly with the first energy gap, i.e., even more favorably than in physical quantum annealers, where the rate scales with the gap squared. Here we investigate how a guiding wave function---which is essential to make many-body PQMC simulations computationally feasible---affects the tunneling rate. The chosen test beds are a continuous-space double-well problem, the ferromagnetic quantum Ising chain, and the recently introduced shamrock model. As guiding wave function, we consider an approximate Boltzmann-type ansatz, the numerically exact ground state of the double-well model, and a neural-network wave function based on a Boltzmann machine. Remarkably, for each ansatz we find the same asymptotic linear scaling of the tunneling rate that was previously found in the PQMC simulations performed without a guiding wave function. We also provide a semiclassical theory for the double-well with exact guiding wave function that explains the observed linear scaling. These findings suggest that PQMC simulations guided by an accurate ansatz represent a valuable benchmark for physical quantum annealers and a potentially competitive quantum-inspired optimization technique.