Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1808.09257 · Physical Review A

Controlling chaos in the quantum regime using adaptive measurements

Jessica K. Eastman, Stuart S. Szigeti, J. J. Hope, Andre R. R. Carvalho

Published Jan 10, 2019• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The continuous monitoring of a quantum system strongly influences the emergence of chaotic dynamics near the transition from the quantum regime to the classical regime. Here we present a feedback control scheme that uses adaptive measurement techniques to control the degree of chaos in the driven-damped quantum Duffing oscillator. This control relies purely on the measurement backaction on the system, making it a uniquely quantum control, and is only possible due to the sensitivity of chaos to measurement. We quantify the effectiveness of our control by numerically computing the quantum Lyapunov exponent over a wide range of parameters. We demonstrate that adaptive measurement techniques can control the onset of chaos in the system, pushing the quantum-classical boundary further into the quantum regime.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.99.012111

Related papers

The emergence of chaos in continuously monitored open quantum systems

Jessica K. Eastman

This thesis makes a unique contribution to the field of quantum chaos by theoretically demonstrating the effect that measurement has on the emergence of chaos from the quantum world and demonstrating a means to control the onset of chaos in the quantum system using adaptive measurements. Here we investigate how the choice of the continuous measurement strategy for an open quantum system affects the emergence of chaos in the transition from the quantum limit to the classical limit when the system is dissipative. We consider two models in our research. The Duffing oscillator is classically chaotic and also dissipative( ie. an open quantum system), whereas the driven top is classically a closed system; adding dissipation via continuous measurement therefore changes the behaviour in from the classical limit. The first half of this thesis presents the investigation of a dissipative system whose classical limit is chaotic. We explore the emergence of chaos from the open quantum system that is continuously monitored and investigate the dependence on the choice of monitoring by changing a single parameter in a homodyne measurement scheme, effectively changing the information gained by the measurement. We show that the emergence of chaos in the regime where quantum effects are still present can be determined solely by changing the measurement parameter. This is a result of the interplay between the quantum interference effects induced by the nonlinear dynamics and the localisation and decoherence that occurs due to the measurement. We also investigate the case where the classical limit is regular for the Duffing oscillator, and demonstrate the semiclassical effect of chaos induced by the measurement back-action. A certain choice of measurement leads to a noise which drives the system to large spread in the dimensionless position enabling a non-classical transition mechanism that is classically forbidden, inducing chaos in the system. These results are verified by the numerical calculation of the maximal Lyapunov exponent in the quantum regime. The second part of this thesis investigates the possibility of controlling the degree of chaos with quantum control. We design an effective control scheme to control the degree of chaos using the measurement dependency of the state. We propose an adaptive measurement scheme which changes the homodyne measurement angle in real time depending on the direction of the state's interference fringes in phase space. This is done using the knowledge gained by the measurement signal. We show that this control scheme can enhance or suppress chaos. By enhancing the degree of chaos we are also able to push the onset of chaos further into the quantum regime than was possible before. By suppressing chaos we generate highly non-classical states and regular motion. The feasibility of experimentally realising this control technique is discussed in detail. The final section of this thesis considers a chaotic system that is not dissipative in the classical limit: the driven top. We investigate the effect that opening the quantum system to decoherence has on the degree of chaos when we continuously measure the system. We demonstrate that the presence of decoherence suppresses the chaos and alters the dynamics of the quantum system. This is seen to worsen as the strength of the measurement is increased unless a particular measurement is chosen that perfectly cancels out the decoherence resulting in the Hamiltonian evolution in addition to noise from the measurement. These results are verified by the separation time between classical and quantum dynamics.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Emergence of chaos controlled by quantum noise

Jessica K. Eastman, J. J. Hope, Andre R. R. Carvalho

We show that the Lyapunov exponents of quantum systems under monitoring are sensitive to the choice of measurement strategy. In particular, there is a region between the deep quantum regime and the classical limit where the choice of monitoring has a crucial effect on the complex behaviour of the system, leading to either the emergence or suppression of chaos. Our work shows that this effect stems from the interplay between the underlying nonlinear dynamics and the ways the system couples to the quantum noise for different measurement scenarios.

•Apr 12, 2016•1 citation

Tuning quantum measurements to control chaos

Jessica K. Eastman, J. J. Hope, Andre R. R. Carvalho

Environment-induced decoherence has long been recognised as being of crucial importance in the study of chaos in quantum systems. In particular, the exact form and strength of the system-environment interaction play a major role in the quantum-to-classical transition of chaotic systems. In this work we focus on the effect of varying monitoring strategies, i.e. for a given decoherence model and a fixed environmental coupling, there is still freedom on how to monitor a quantum system. We show here that there is a region between the deep quantum regime and the classical limit where the choice of the monitoring parameter allows one to control the complex behaviour of the system, leading to either the emergence or suppression of chaos. Our work shows that this is a result from the interplay between quantum interference effects induced by the nonlinear dynamics and the effectiveness of the decoherence for different measurement schemes.

arXiv:1604.03494•Scientific Reports•Mar 20, 2017•29 citations

Measurement and Feedback Driven Entanglement Transition in the Probabilistic Control of Chaos

Thomas Iadecola, Sriram Ganeshan, J. H. Pixley +1 more

We uncover a dynamical entanglement transition in a monitored quantum system that is heralded by a local order parameter. Classically, chaotic systems can be stochastically controlled onto unstable periodic orbits and exhibit controlled and uncontrolled phases as a function of the rate at which the control is applied. We show that such control transitions persist in open quantum systems where control is implemented with local measurements and unitary feedback. Starting from a simple classical model with a known control transition, we define a quantum model that exhibits a diffusive transition between a chaotic volume-law entangled phase and a disentangled controlled phase. Unlike other entanglement transitions in monitored quantum circuits, this transition can also be probed by correlation functions without resolving individual quantum trajectories.

Physical Review Letters•Aug 8, 2023•45 citations

Observing quantum chaos with noisy measurements and highly mixed states

Jason F. Ralph, Kurt A. Jacobs, M. J. Everitt

A fundamental requirement for the emergence of classical behavior from an underlying quantum description is that certain observed quantum systems make a transition to chaotic dynamics as their action is increased relative to $\ensuremath{\hbar}$. While experiments have demonstrated some aspects of this transition, the emergence of quantum trajectories with a positive Lyapunov exponent has never been observed directly. Here, we remove a major obstacle to achieving this goal by showing that, for the Duffing oscillator, the transition to a positive Lyapunov exponent can be resolved clearly from observed trajectories even with measurement efficiencies as low as 20%. We also find that the positive Lyapunov exponent is robust to highly mixed, low-purity states and to variations in the parameters of the system.

arXiv:1609.07338•Physical Review A•Jan 26, 2017•10 citations

Quantum Lyapunov exponents beyond continuous measurements

Igor Yusipov, Olga Vershinina, S. Denisov +2 more

Quantum systems, when interacting with their environments, may exhibit nonequilibrium states that are tempting to be interpreted as quantum analogs of chaotic attractors. However, different from the Hamiltonian case, the toolbox for quantifying dissipative quantum chaos remains limited. In particular, quantum generalizations of Lyapunov exponents, the main quantifiers of classical chaos, are established only within the framework of continuous measurements. We propose an alternative generalization based on the unraveling of quantum master equation into an ensemble of "quantum trajectories," by using the so-called Monte Carlo wave-function method. We illustrate the idea with a periodically modulated open quantum dimer and demonstrate that the transition to quantum chaos matches the period-doubling route to chaos in the corresponding mean-field system.

arXiv:1806.09295•Chaos An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science•Jun 1, 2019•14 citations
The continuous monitoring of a quantum system strongly influences the emergence of chaotic dynamics near the transition from the quantum regime to the classical regime. Here we present a feedback control scheme that uses adaptive measurement techniques to control the degree of chaos in the driven-damped quantum Duffing oscillator. This control relies purely on the measurement backaction on the system, making it a uniquely quantum control, and is only possible due to the sensitivity of chaos to measurement. We quantify the effectiveness of our control by numerically computing the quantum Lyapunov exponent over a wide range of parameters. We demonstrate that adaptive measurement techniques can control the onset of chaos in the system, pushing the quantum-classical boundary further into the quantum regime.
This thesis makes a unique contribution to the field of quantum chaos by theoretically demonstrating the effect that measurement has on the emergence of chaos from the quantum world and demonstrating a means to control the onset of chaos in the quantum system using adaptive measurements. Here we investigate how the choice of the continuous measurement strategy for an open quantum system affects the emergence of chaos in the transition from the quantum limit to the classical limit when the system is dissipative. We consider two models in our research. The Duffing oscillator is classically chaotic and also dissipative( ie. an open quantum system), whereas the driven top is classically a closed system; adding dissipation via continuous measurement therefore changes the behaviour in from the classical limit. The first half of this thesis presents the investigation of a dissipative system whose classical limit is chaotic. We explore the emergence of chaos from the open quantum system that is continuously monitored and investigate the dependence on the choice of monitoring by changing a single parameter in a homodyne measurement scheme, effectively changing the information gained by the measurement. We show that the emergence of chaos in the regime where quantum effects are still present can be determined solely by changing the measurement parameter. This is a result of the interplay between the quantum interference effects induced by the nonlinear dynamics and the localisation and decoherence that occurs due to the measurement. We also investigate the case where the classical limit is regular for the Duffing oscillator, and demonstrate the semiclassical effect of chaos induced by the measurement back-action. A certain choice of measurement leads to a noise which drives the system to large spread in the dimensionless position enabling a non-classical transition mechanism that is classically forbidden, inducing chaos in the system. These results are verified by the numerical calculation of the maximal Lyapunov exponent in the quantum regime. The second part of this thesis investigates the possibility of controlling the degree of chaos with quantum control. We design an effective control scheme to control the degree of chaos using the measurement dependency of the state. We propose an adaptive measurement scheme which changes the homodyne measurement angle in real time depending on the direction of the state's interference fringes in phase space. This is done using the knowledge gained by the measurement signal. We show that this control scheme can enhance or suppress chaos. By enhancing the degree of chaos we are also able to push the onset of chaos further into the quantum regime than was possible before. By suppressing chaos we generate highly non-classical states and regular motion. The feasibility of experimentally realising this control technique is discussed in detail. The final section of this thesis considers a chaotic system that is not dissipative in the classical limit: the driven top. We investigate the effect that opening the quantum system to decoherence has on the degree of chaos when we continuously measure the system. We demonstrate that the presence of decoherence suppresses the chaos and alters the dynamics of the quantum system. This is seen to worsen as the strength of the measurement is increased unless a particular measurement is chosen that perfectly cancels out the decoherence resulting in the Hamiltonian evolution in addition to noise from the measurement. These results are verified by the separation time between classical and quantum dynamics.
We show that the Lyapunov exponents of quantum systems under monitoring are sensitive to the choice of measurement strategy. In particular, there is a region between the deep quantum regime and the classical limit where the choice of monitoring has a crucial effect on the complex behaviour of the system, leading to either the emergence or suppression of chaos. Our work shows that this effect stems from the interplay between the underlying nonlinear dynamics and the ways the system couples to the quantum noise for different measurement scenarios.
Environment-induced decoherence has long been recognised as being of crucial importance in the study of chaos in quantum systems. In particular, the exact form and strength of the system-environment interaction play a major role in the quantum-to-classical transition of chaotic systems. In this work we focus on the effect of varying monitoring strategies, i.e. for a given decoherence model and a fixed environmental coupling, there is still freedom on how to monitor a quantum system. We show here that there is a region between the deep quantum regime and the classical limit where the choice of the monitoring parameter allows one to control the complex behaviour of the system, leading to either the emergence or suppression of chaos. Our work shows that this is a result from the interplay between quantum interference effects induced by the nonlinear dynamics and the effectiveness of the decoherence for different measurement schemes.
We uncover a dynamical entanglement transition in a monitored quantum system that is heralded by a local order parameter. Classically, chaotic systems can be stochastically controlled onto unstable periodic orbits and exhibit controlled and uncontrolled phases as a function of the rate at which the control is applied. We show that such control transitions persist in open quantum systems where control is implemented with local measurements and unitary feedback. Starting from a simple classical model with a known control transition, we define a quantum model that exhibits a diffusive transition between a chaotic volume-law entangled phase and a disentangled controlled phase. Unlike other entanglement transitions in monitored quantum circuits, this transition can also be probed by correlation functions without resolving individual quantum trajectories.
A fundamental requirement for the emergence of classical behavior from an underlying quantum description is that certain observed quantum systems make a transition to chaotic dynamics as their action is increased relative to $\ensuremath{\hbar}$. While experiments have demonstrated some aspects of this transition, the emergence of quantum trajectories with a positive Lyapunov exponent has never been observed directly. Here, we remove a major obstacle to achieving this goal by showing that, for the Duffing oscillator, the transition to a positive Lyapunov exponent can be resolved clearly from observed trajectories even with measurement efficiencies as low as 20%. We also find that the positive Lyapunov exponent is robust to highly mixed, low-purity states and to variations in the parameters of the system.
Quantum systems, when interacting with their environments, may exhibit nonequilibrium states that are tempting to be interpreted as quantum analogs of chaotic attractors. However, different from the Hamiltonian case, the toolbox for quantifying dissipative quantum chaos remains limited. In particular, quantum generalizations of Lyapunov exponents, the main quantifiers of classical chaos, are established only within the framework of continuous measurements. We propose an alternative generalization based on the unraveling of quantum master equation into an ensemble of "quantum trajectories," by using the so-called Monte Carlo wave-function method. We illustrate the idea with a periodically modulated open quantum dimer and demonstrate that the transition to quantum chaos matches the period-doubling route to chaos in the corresponding mean-field system.