Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1808.05659 · Physical Review Letters

Slow Relaxation and Diffusion in Holographic Quantum Critical Phases

Richard A. Davison, Simon A. Gentle, Blaise Goutéraux

Published Oct 4, 2019• 42 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The dissipative dynamics of strongly interacting systems are often characterized by the timescale set by the inverse temperature ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\hbar}/({k}_{B}T)$. We show that near a class of strongly interacting quantum critical points that arise in the infrared limit of translationally invariant holographic theories, there is a collective excitation (a quasinormal mode of the dual black hole spacetime) whose lifetime ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ is parametrically longer than ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}$: ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\gg}{T}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. The lifetime is enhanced due to its dependence on a dangerously irrelevant coupling that breaks the particle-hole symmetry and the invariance under Lorentz boosts of the quantum critical point. The thermal diffusivity (in units of the butterfly velocity) is anomalously large near the quantum critical point and is governed by ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ rather than ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}$. We conjecture that there exists a long-lived, propagating collective mode with velocity ${v}_{s}$, and in this case the relation $D={v}_{s}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ holds exactly in the limit $T{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\gg}1$. While scale invariance is broken, a generalized scaling theory still holds provided that the dependence of observables on the dangerously irrelevant coupling is incorporated. Our work further underlines the connection between dangerously irrelevant deformations and slow equilibration.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.123.141601

Related papers

Impact of irrelevant deformations on thermodynamics and transport in holographic quantum critical states

Richard A. Davison, Simon A. Gentle, Blaise Goutéraux

We study thermodynamic and transport observables of quantum critical states that arise in the infrared limit of holographic renormalization group flows. Although these observables are expected to exhibit quantum critical scaling, there are a number of cases in which their frequency and temperature dependences are in apparent contradiction with scaling theories. We study two different classes of examples and show in both cases that the apparent breakdown of scaling is a consequence of the dependence of observables on an irrelevant deformation of the quantum critical state. By assigning scaling dimensions to the near-horizon observables, we formulate improved scaling theories that are completely consistent with all explicit holographic results once the dependence on the dangerously irrelevant coupling is properly accounted for. In addition to governing thermodynamic and transport phenomena in these states, we show that the dangerously irrelevant coupling also controls late-time equilibration, which occurs at a rate parametrically slower than the temperature $1/{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\ll}T$. At very late times, transport is diffusion-dominated, with a diffusivity that can be written simply in terms of ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ and the butterfly velocity, $D\ensuremath{\sim}{v}_{B}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$. We conjecture that in such cases there exists a long-lived, propagating collective mode with velocity ${v}_{s}$, and in this case the relation $D={v}_{s}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ holds exactly in the limit ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}T\ensuremath{\gg}1$.

arXiv:1812.11060•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Oct 29, 2019•27 citations

Universal diffusion in incoherent black holes

Mike Blake

We study charge and energy diffusion in simple holographic theories with broken translational symmetry. We find that when the effects of momentum relaxation are very strong the diffusion constants take universal values ${D}_{c}\ensuremath{\sim}{D}_{e}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\hbar}{v}_{B}^{2}/({k}_{B}T)$. Here ${v}_{B}$ is the velocity of the butterfly effect and the coefficients of proportionality depend only on the scaling exponents of the infra-red fixed point. Our results suggest that diffusion in these incoherent black holes is controlled by $\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\hbar}/({k}_{B}T)$ independently of the mechanism of momentum relaxation.

arXiv:1604.01754•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Oct 31, 2016•123 citations

Hydrodynamic Diffusion and Its Breakdown near AdS2 Quantum Critical Points

Daniel Areán, Richard A. Davison, Blaise Goutéraux +1 more

Hydrodynamics provides a universal description of interacting quantum field theories at sufficiently long times and wavelengths, but breaks down at scales dependent on microscopic details of the theory.In the vicinity of a quantum critical point, it is expected that some aspects of the dynamics are universal and dictated by properties of the critical point.We use gauge-gravity duality to investigate the breakdown of diffusive hydrodynamics in two low-temperature states dual to black holes with AdS 2 horizons, which exhibit quantum critical dynamics with an emergent scaling symmetry in time.We find that the breakdown is characterized by a collision between the diffusive pole of the retarded Green's function with a pole associated to the AdS 2 region of the geometry, such that the local equilibration time is set by infrared properties of the theory.The absolute values of the frequency and wave vector at the collision (ω eq and k eq ) provide a natural characterization of all the low-temperature diffusivities D of the states via D ¼ ω eq =k 2 eq , where ω eq ¼ 2πΔT is set by the temperature T and the scaling dimension Δ of an operator of the infrared quantum critical theory.We confirm that these relations are also satisfied in a Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev chain model in the limit of strong interactions.Our work paves the way toward a deeper understanding of transport in quantum critical phases.

arXiv:2011.12301•Physical Review X•Jul 29, 2021•33 citations

Holographic butterfly effect at quantum critical points

Yi Ling, Peng Liu, Jian-Pin Wu

When the Lyapunov exponent λL in a quantum chaotic system saturates the bound λL ≤ 2πk B T , it is proposed that this system has a holographic dual described by a gravity theory. In particular, the butterfly effect as a prominent phenomenon of chaos can ubiquitously exist in a black hole system characterized by a shockwave solution near the horizon. In this paper we propose that the butterfly velocity can be used to diagnose quantum phase transition (QPT) in holographic theories. We provide evidences for this proposal with an anisotropic holographic model exhibiting metal-insulator transitions (MIT), in which the derivatives of the butterfly velocity with respect to system parameters characterizes quantum critical points (QCP) with local extremes in zero temperature limit. We also point out that this proposal can be tested by experiments in the light of recent progress on the measurement of out-of-time-order correlation function (OTOC).

arXiv:1610.02669•Journal of High Energy Physics•Oct 1, 2017•51 citations

Holographic butterfly effect and diffusion in quantum critical region

Yi Ling, Zhuo-Yu Xian

We investigate the butterfly effect and charge diffusion near the quantum phase transition in holographic approach. We argue that their criticality is controlled by the holographic scaling geometry with deformations induced by a relevant operator at finite temperature. Specifically, in the quantum critical region controlled by a single fixed point, the butterfly velocity decreases when deviating from the critical point. While, in the non-critical region, the behavior of the butterfly velocity depends on the specific phase at low temperature. Moreover, in the holographic Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition, the universal behavior of the butterfly velocity is absent. Finally, the tendency of our holographic results matches with the numerical results of Bose-Hubbard model. A comparison between our result and that in the O(N ) nonlinear sigma model is also given.

arXiv:1707.02843•Journal of High Energy Physics•Sep 1, 2017•28 citations

Universal Aspects of Quantum-Critical Dynamics in and Out of Equilibrium

Julia Steinberg

Quantum phase transitions occur strictly at zero temperature and are accessed by varying a physical parameter such as a magnetic field or chemical potential. While these transitions themselves are experimentally inaccessible, the existence of a zero temperature quantum critical point has remarkable effects on the dynamical properties of interacting quantum many-body systems at finite temperatures. In this thesis, we study dynamics in four strongly interacting many-body systems near quantum critical points in the context of NMR relaxation, quantum quenches, many-body quantum chaos, and charge diffusion. In chapter 1, we begin by revisiting the issue of NMR relaxation in the quantum disordered phase of Ising spin chains. We find that the imaginary part of the spin susceptibility at low frequences is dominated by rare quantum processes which leads to an NMR relaxation rate that scales as $1/T_{1}\sim \exp(-\frac{2\Delta}{T})$ near the quantum critical point rather than the previously conjectured $1/T_{1}\sim \exp(-\frac{\Delta}{T})$. These results resolve certain discrepancies between the energy scales measured with different experimental probes in the quantum disordered paramagnetic phase of the Ising chain system $\text{CoNb}_{2}\text{O}_{6}$. In chapter 2, we study the non-equilibrium dynamics of Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) models with $q$ body interactions after a quantum quench, considering a quench protocol which drives the system from an initial state with long-lived quasiparticle excitations to a final state lacking any long-lived quasiparticle excitations. For $q=4$, we find that the timescale for the system to locally thermalize $\tau_{eq}\sim\frac{\hbar}{k_{B}T}$ and for $q\rightarrow \infty$ we find that the system thermalizes instantaneously. In chapter 3, we study the real time dynamics of quantum electrodynamics in 2+1 dimensions with $N_{f}$ flavors of fermions. We focus on thermalization and the onset of many-body quantum chaos and compute the quantum Lyapunov exponent in a $\frac{1}{N_{f}}$ expansion. We briefly comment on chaos, locality, and gauge invariance. Finally, in Chapter 4 we consider whether the butterfly velocity - a speed at which quantum information propagates - may provide a fundamental bound on diffusion constants in dirty incoherent metals by computing the charge diffusion constant and the butterfly velocity in charge-neutral holographic matter with long wavelength ``hydrodynamic" disorder. In this limit, we find that the butterfly velocity does not set a sharp lower bound for the charge diffusion constant.

•May 13, 2020•0 citations
The dissipative dynamics of strongly interacting systems are often characterized by the timescale set by the inverse temperature \ensuremathτP\ensuremath∼\ensuremathℏ/(kBT){\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\hbar}/({k}_{B}T)\ensuremathτP​\ensuremath∼\ensuremathℏ/(kB​T). We show that near a class of strongly interacting quantum critical points that arise in the infrared limit of translationally invariant holographic theories, there is a collective excitation (a quasinormal mode of the dual black hole spacetime) whose lifetime \ensuremathτeq{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremathτeq​ is parametrically longer than \ensuremathτP{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}\ensuremathτP​: \ensuremathτeq\ensuremath≫T\ensuremath−1{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\gg}{T}^{\ensuremath{-}1}\ensuremathτeq​\ensuremath≫T\ensuremath−1. The lifetime is enhanced due to its dependence on a dangerously irrelevant coupling that breaks the particle-hole symmetry and the invariance under Lorentz boosts of the quantum critical point. The thermal diffusivity (in units of the butterfly velocity) is anomalously large near the quantum critical point and is governed by \ensuremathτeq{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremathτeq​ rather than \ensuremathτP{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}\ensuremathτP​. We conjecture that there exists a long-lived, propagating collective mode with velocity vs{v}_{s}vs​, and in this case the relation D=vs2\ensuremathτeqD={v}_{s}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}D=vs2​\ensuremathτeq​ holds exactly in the limit T\ensuremathτeq\ensuremath≫1T{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\gg}1T\ensuremathτeq​\ensuremath≫1. While scale invariance is broken, a generalized scaling theory still holds provided that the dependence of observables on the dangerously irrelevant coupling is incorporated. Our work further underlines the connection between dangerously irrelevant deformations and slow equilibration.
We study thermodynamic and transport observables of quantum critical states that arise in the infrared limit of holographic renormalization group flows. Although these observables are expected to exhibit quantum critical scaling, there are a number of cases in which their frequency and temperature dependences are in apparent contradiction with scaling theories. We study two different classes of examples and show in both cases that the apparent breakdown of scaling is a consequence of the dependence of observables on an irrelevant deformation of the quantum critical state. By assigning scaling dimensions to the near-horizon observables, we formulate improved scaling theories that are completely consistent with all explicit holographic results once the dependence on the dangerously irrelevant coupling is properly accounted for. In addition to governing thermodynamic and transport phenomena in these states, we show that the dangerously irrelevant coupling also controls late-time equilibration, which occurs at a rate parametrically slower than the temperature $1/{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\ll}T$. At very late times, transport is diffusion-dominated, with a diffusivity that can be written simply in terms of ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ and the butterfly velocity, $D\ensuremath{\sim}{v}_{B}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$. We conjecture that in such cases there exists a long-lived, propagating collective mode with velocity vs{v}_{s}vs​, and in this case the relation $D={v}_{s}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ holds exactly in the limit ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}T\ensuremath{\gg}1$.
We study charge and energy diffusion in simple holographic theories with broken translational symmetry. We find that when the effects of momentum relaxation are very strong the diffusion constants take universal values ${D}_{c}\ensuremath{\sim}{D}_{e}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\hbar}{v}_{B}^{2}/({k}_{B}T)$. Here vB{v}_{B}vB​ is the velocity of the butterfly effect and the coefficients of proportionality depend only on the scaling exponents of the infra-red fixed point. Our results suggest that diffusion in these incoherent black holes is controlled by $\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\hbar}/({k}_{B}T)$ independently of the mechanism of momentum relaxation.
Hydrodynamics provides a universal description of interacting quantum field theories at sufficiently long times and wavelengths, but breaks down at scales dependent on microscopic details of the theory.In the vicinity of a quantum critical point, it is expected that some aspects of the dynamics are universal and dictated by properties of the critical point.We use gauge-gravity duality to investigate the breakdown of diffusive hydrodynamics in two low-temperature states dual to black holes with AdS 2 horizons, which exhibit quantum critical dynamics with an emergent scaling symmetry in time.We find that the breakdown is characterized by a collision between the diffusive pole of the retarded Green's function with a pole associated to the AdS 2 region of the geometry, such that the local equilibration time is set by infrared properties of the theory.The absolute values of the frequency and wave vector at the collision (ω eq and k eq ) provide a natural characterization of all the low-temperature diffusivities D of the states via D ¼ ω eq =k 2 eq , where ω eq ¼ 2πΔT is set by the temperature T and the scaling dimension Δ of an operator of the infrared quantum critical theory.We confirm that these relations are also satisfied in a Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev chain model in the limit of strong interactions.Our work paves the way toward a deeper understanding of transport in quantum critical phases.
When the Lyapunov exponent λL in a quantum chaotic system saturates the bound λL ≤ 2πk B T , it is proposed that this system has a holographic dual described by a gravity theory. In particular, the butterfly effect as a prominent phenomenon of chaos can ubiquitously exist in a black hole system characterized by a shockwave solution near the horizon. In this paper we propose that the butterfly velocity can be used to diagnose quantum phase transition (QPT) in holographic theories. We provide evidences for this proposal with an anisotropic holographic model exhibiting metal-insulator transitions (MIT), in which the derivatives of the butterfly velocity with respect to system parameters characterizes quantum critical points (QCP) with local extremes in zero temperature limit. We also point out that this proposal can be tested by experiments in the light of recent progress on the measurement of out-of-time-order correlation function (OTOC).
We investigate the butterfly effect and charge diffusion near the quantum phase transition in holographic approach. We argue that their criticality is controlled by the holographic scaling geometry with deformations induced by a relevant operator at finite temperature. Specifically, in the quantum critical region controlled by a single fixed point, the butterfly velocity decreases when deviating from the critical point. While, in the non-critical region, the behavior of the butterfly velocity depends on the specific phase at low temperature. Moreover, in the holographic Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition, the universal behavior of the butterfly velocity is absent. Finally, the tendency of our holographic results matches with the numerical results of Bose-Hubbard model. A comparison between our result and that in the O(N ) nonlinear sigma model is also given.
Quantum phase transitions occur strictly at zero temperature and are accessed by varying a physical parameter such as a magnetic field or chemical potential. While these transitions themselves are experimentally inaccessible, the existence of a zero temperature quantum critical point has remarkable effects on the dynamical properties of interacting quantum many-body systems at finite temperatures. In this thesis, we study dynamics in four strongly interacting many-body systems near quantum critical points in the context of NMR relaxation, quantum quenches, many-body quantum chaos, and charge diffusion. In chapter 1, we begin by revisiting the issue of NMR relaxation in the quantum disordered phase of Ising spin chains. We find that the imaginary part of the spin susceptibility at low frequences is dominated by rare quantum processes which leads to an NMR relaxation rate that scales as 1/T1∼exp⁡(−2ΔT)1/T_{1}\sim \exp(-\frac{2\Delta}{T})1/T1​∼exp(−T2Δ​) near the quantum critical point rather than the previously conjectured 1/T1∼exp⁡(−ΔT)1/T_{1}\sim \exp(-\frac{\Delta}{T})1/T1​∼exp(−TΔ​). These results resolve certain discrepancies between the energy scales measured with different experimental probes in the quantum disordered paramagnetic phase of the Ising chain system CoNb2O6\text{CoNb}_{2}\text{O}_{6}CoNb2​O6​. In chapter 2, we study the non-equilibrium dynamics of Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) models with qqq body interactions after a quantum quench, considering a quench protocol which drives the system from an initial state with long-lived quasiparticle excitations to a final state lacking any long-lived quasiparticle excitations. For q=4q=4q=4, we find that the timescale for the system to locally thermalize τeq∼ℏkBT\tau_{eq}\sim\frac{\hbar}{k_{B}T}τeq​∼kB​Tℏ​ and for q→∞q\rightarrow \inftyq→∞ we find that the system thermalizes instantaneously. In chapter 3, we study the real time dynamics of quantum electrodynamics in 2+1 dimensions with NfN_{f}Nf​ flavors of fermions. We focus on thermalization and the onset of many-body quantum chaos and compute the quantum Lyapunov exponent in a 1Nf\frac{1}{N_{f}}Nf​1​ expansion. We briefly comment on chaos, locality, and gauge invariance. Finally, in Chapter 4 we consider whether the butterfly velocity - a speed at which quantum information propagates - may provide a fundamental bound on diffusion constants in dirty incoherent metals by computing the charge diffusion constant and the butterfly velocity in charge-neutral holographic matter with long wavelength ``hydrodynamic" disorder. In this limit, we find that the butterfly velocity does not set a sharp lower bound for the charge diffusion constant.