Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1807.09670 · Physical Review Letters

Bond-Disordered Spin Liquid and the Honeycomb Iridate H3LiIr2O6 : Abundant Low-Energy Density of States from Random Majorana Hopping

Johannes Knolle, Roderich Moessner, Natalia Borisovna Perkins

Published Feb 1, 2019• 88 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The 5d-electron honeycomb compound H_{3}LiIr_{2}O_{6} [K. Kitagawa et al., Nature (London) 554, 341 (2018)NATUAS0028-083610.1038/nature25482] exhibits an apparent quantum spin liquid state. In this intercalated spin-orbital compound, a remarkable pileup of low-energy states was experimentally observed in specific heat and spin relaxation. We show that a bond-disordered Kitaev model can naturally account for this phenomenon, suggesting that disorder plays an essential role in its theoretical description. In the exactly soluble Kitaev model, we obtain, via spin fractionalization, a random bipartite hopping problem of Majorana fermions in a random flux background. This has a divergent low-energy density of states of the required power-law form N(E)∝E^{-ν} with a drifting exponent which takes on the value ν≈1/2 for relatively strong bond disorder. Breaking time-reversal symmetry removes the divergence of the density of states, as does applying a magnetic field in experiment. We discuss the implication of our scenario, both for future experiments and from a broader perspective.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.122.047202

Related papers

Theory of a quantum spin liquid in the hydrogen-intercalated honeycomb iridate H3LiIr2O6

Kevin Slagle, Wonjune Choi, Li Ern Chern +1 more

We propose a theoretical model for a gapless spin liquid phase that may have been observed in a recent experiment on ${\mathrm{H}}_{3}{\mathrm{LiIr}}_{2}{\mathrm{O}}_{6}$. Despite the insulating and nonmagnetic nature of the material, the specific heat coefficient $C/T\ensuremath{\sim}1/\sqrt{T}$ in zero magnetic field and $C/T\ensuremath{\sim}T/{B}^{3/2}$ with finite magnetic field $B$ have been observed. In addition, the NMR relaxation rate shows $1/({T}_{1}T)\ensuremath{\sim}{(C/T)}^{2}$. Motivated by the fact that the interlayer/in-plane lattice parameters are reduced/elongated by the hydrogen intercalation of the parent compound ${\mathrm{Li}}_{2}{\mathrm{IrO}}_{3}$, we consider four layers of the Kitaev honeycomb lattice model with additional interlayer exchange interactions. It is shown that the resulting spin liquid excitations reside mostly in the top and bottom layers of such a layered structure and possess a quartic dispersion. In an applied magnetic field, each quartic mode is split into four Majorana cones with the velocity $v\ensuremath{\sim}{B}^{3/4}$. We suggest that the spin liquid phase in these ``defect'' layers, placed between different stacking patterns of the honeycomb layers, can explain the major phenomenology of the experiment, which can be taken as evidence that the Kitaev interaction plays the primary role in the formation of a quantum spin liquid in this material.

arXiv:1710.01307•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 28, 2018•33 citations

Randomly Hopping Majorana Fermions in the Diluted Kitaev System α - Ru0.8Ir0.2Cl3

Seung-Hwan Do, Chanhyeon Lee, Takumi Kihara +8 more

dc and ac magnetic susceptibility, magnetization, specific heat, and Raman scattering measurements are combined to probe low-lying spin excitations in α-Ru_{1-x}Ir_{x}Cl_{3} (x≈0.2), which realizes a disordered spin liquid. At intermediate energies (ℏω>3 meV), Raman spectroscopy evidences linearly ω-dependent Majorana-like excitations, obeying Fermi statistics. This points to robustness of a Kitaev paramagnetic state under spin vacancies. At low energies below 3 meV, we observe power-law dependences and quantum-critical-like scalings of the thermodynamic quantities, implying the presence of a weakly divergent low-energy density of states. This scaling phenomenology is interpreted in terms of the random hoppings of Majorana fermions. Our results demonstrate an emergent hierarchy of spin excitations in a diluted Kitaev honeycomb system subject to spin vacancies and bond randomness.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 31, 2020•52 citations

Evidence for the random singlet phase in the honeycomb iridate SrIr 2 O 6

Peng-Bo Song, Kejia Zhu, Fan Yang +13 more

Strong spin-orbital-coupling magnetic systems with the honeycomb structure can provide bond-directional interactions which may result in Kitaev quantum spin liquids and exotic anyonic excitations. However, one of the key ingredients in real materials---disorders---has been much less studied in Kitaev systems. Here we synthesized a trigonal ${\mathrm{SrIr}}_{2}{\mathrm{O}}_{6\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\delta}}$ with $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\approx}0.25$, which consists of two-dimensional honeycomb Ir planes with edge-sharing ${\mathrm{IrO}}_{6}$ octahedra. First-principles computation and experimental measurements suggest that the electronic system is gapped, and there should be no magnetic moment as the ${\mathrm{Ir}}^{5+}$ ion has no unpaired electrons. However, significant magnetism has been observed in the material, and it can be attributed to disorders that are most likely from oxygen vacancies. No magnetic order is found down to 0.05 K, and the low-temperature magnetic properties exhibit power-law behaviors in magnetic susceptibility and zero-field specific heat, and a single-parameter scaling of the specific heat under magnetic fields. These results provide strong evidence for the existence of the random singlet phase in ${\mathrm{SrIr}}_{2}{\mathrm{O}}_{6\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\delta}}$, which offers a different member to the family of spin-orbital entangled iridates and Kitaev materials.

arXiv:2103.05820•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 23, 2021•11 citations

Anderson–Kitaev spin liquid

Masahiko G. Yamada

Abstract The bond-disordered Kitaev model attracts much attention due to the experimental relevance in α-RuCl3 and A3LiIr2O6 (A = H, D, Ag, etc.). Applying a magnetic field to break the time-reversal symmetry leads to a strong modulation in mass terms for Dirac cones. Because of the smallness of the flux gap of the Kitaev model, a small bond disorder can have large influence on itinerant Majorana fermions. The quantization of the thermal Hall conductivity κxy/T disappears by a quantum Hall transition induced by a small disorder, and κxy/T shows a rapid crossover into a state with a negligible Hall current. We call this immobile liquid state Anderson–Kitaev spin liquid (AKSL). Especially, the critical disorder strength δJc1 ~ 0.05 in the unit of the Kitaev interaction would have many implications for the stability of Kitaev spin liquids.

arXiv:2004.06257•npj Quantum Materials•Nov 6, 2020•29 citations

Physical states and finite-size effects in Kitaev's honeycomb model: Bond disorder, spin excitations, and NMR line shape

Fabian Zschocke, Matthias Vojta C

Kitaev's compass model on the honeycomb lattice realizes a spin liquid whose emergent excitations are dispersive Majorana fermions and static ${\mathrm{Z}}_{2}$ gauge fluxes. We discuss the proper selection of physical states for finite-size simulations in the Majorana representation, based on a recent paper by F. L. Pedrocchi, S. Chesi, and D. Loss [Phys. Rev. B 84, 165414 (2011)]. Certain physical observables acquire large finite-size effects, in particular if the ground state is not fermion-free, which we prove to generally apply to the system in the gapless phase and with periodic boundary conditions. To illustrate our findings, we compute the static and dynamic spin susceptibilities for finite-size systems. Specifically, we consider random-bond disorder (which preserves the solubility of the model), calculate the distribution of local flux gaps, and extract the NMR line shape. We also predict a transition to a random-flux state with increasing disorder.

arXiv:1502.03063•Physical Review B•Jul 6, 2015•85 citations

Observation of two types of fractional excitation in the Kitaev honeycomb magnet

N. Janša, A. Zorko, Matjaž Gomilšek +6 more

Quantum spin liquid is a disordered but highly entangled magnetic state with fractional spin excitations1. The ground state of an exactly solved Kitaev honeycomb model is perhaps its clearest example2. Under a magnetic field, a spin flip in this model fractionalizes into two types of anyon, a quasiparticle with more complex exchange statistics than standard fermions or bosons: a pair of gauge fluxes and a Majorana fermion2,3. Here, we demonstrate this kind of fractionalization in the Kitaev paramagnetic state of the honeycomb magnet α-RuCl3. The spin excitation gap determined by nuclear magnetic resonance consists of the predicted Majorana fermion contribution following the cube of the applied magnetic field2,4,5, and a finite zero-field contribution matching the predicted size of the gauge flux gap2,6. The observed fractionalization into gapped anyons survives in a broad range of temperatures and magnetic fields, which establishes α-RuCl3 as a unique platform for future investigations of anyons.

•Jan 1, 2018•128 citations
The 5d-electron honeycomb compound H_{3}LiIr_{2}O_{6} [K. Kitagawa et al., Nature (London) 554, 341 (2018)NATUAS0028-083610.1038/nature25482] exhibits an apparent quantum spin liquid state. In this intercalated spin-orbital compound, a remarkable pileup of low-energy states was experimentally observed in specific heat and spin relaxation. We show that a bond-disordered Kitaev model can naturally account for this phenomenon, suggesting that disorder plays an essential role in its theoretical description. In the exactly soluble Kitaev model, we obtain, via spin fractionalization, a random bipartite hopping problem of Majorana fermions in a random flux background. This has a divergent low-energy density of states of the required power-law form N(E)∝E^{-ν} with a drifting exponent which takes on the value ν≈1/2 for relatively strong bond disorder. Breaking time-reversal symmetry removes the divergence of the density of states, as does applying a magnetic field in experiment. We discuss the implication of our scenario, both for future experiments and from a broader perspective.
We propose a theoretical model for a gapless spin liquid phase that may have been observed in a recent experiment on H3LiIr2O6{\mathrm{H}}_{3}{\mathrm{LiIr}}_{2}{\mathrm{O}}_{6}H3​LiIr2​O6​. Despite the insulating and nonmagnetic nature of the material, the specific heat coefficient $C/T\ensuremath{\sim}1/\sqrt{T}$ in zero magnetic field and $C/T\ensuremath{\sim}T/{B}^{3/2}$ with finite magnetic field BBB have been observed. In addition, the NMR relaxation rate shows $1/({T}_{1}T)\ensuremath{\sim}{(C/T)}^{2}$. Motivated by the fact that the interlayer/in-plane lattice parameters are reduced/elongated by the hydrogen intercalation of the parent compound Li2IrO3{\mathrm{Li}}_{2}{\mathrm{IrO}}_{3}Li2​IrO3​, we consider four layers of the Kitaev honeycomb lattice model with additional interlayer exchange interactions. It is shown that the resulting spin liquid excitations reside mostly in the top and bottom layers of such a layered structure and possess a quartic dispersion. In an applied magnetic field, each quartic mode is split into four Majorana cones with the velocity $v\ensuremath{\sim}{B}^{3/4}$. We suggest that the spin liquid phase in these ``defect'' layers, placed between different stacking patterns of the honeycomb layers, can explain the major phenomenology of the experiment, which can be taken as evidence that the Kitaev interaction plays the primary role in the formation of a quantum spin liquid in this material.
dc and ac magnetic susceptibility, magnetization, specific heat, and Raman scattering measurements are combined to probe low-lying spin excitations in α-Ru_{1-x}Ir_{x}Cl_{3} (x≈0.2), which realizes a disordered spin liquid. At intermediate energies (ℏω>3 meV), Raman spectroscopy evidences linearly ω-dependent Majorana-like excitations, obeying Fermi statistics. This points to robustness of a Kitaev paramagnetic state under spin vacancies. At low energies below 3 meV, we observe power-law dependences and quantum-critical-like scalings of the thermodynamic quantities, implying the presence of a weakly divergent low-energy density of states. This scaling phenomenology is interpreted in terms of the random hoppings of Majorana fermions. Our results demonstrate an emergent hierarchy of spin excitations in a diluted Kitaev honeycomb system subject to spin vacancies and bond randomness.
Strong spin-orbital-coupling magnetic systems with the honeycomb structure can provide bond-directional interactions which may result in Kitaev quantum spin liquids and exotic anyonic excitations. However, one of the key ingredients in real materials---disorders---has been much less studied in Kitaev systems. Here we synthesized a trigonal ${\mathrm{SrIr}}_{2}{\mathrm{O}}_{6\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\delta}}$ with $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\approx}0.25$, which consists of two-dimensional honeycomb Ir planes with edge-sharing IrO6{\mathrm{IrO}}_{6}IrO6​ octahedra. First-principles computation and experimental measurements suggest that the electronic system is gapped, and there should be no magnetic moment as the Ir5+{\mathrm{Ir}}^{5+}Ir5+ ion has no unpaired electrons. However, significant magnetism has been observed in the material, and it can be attributed to disorders that are most likely from oxygen vacancies. No magnetic order is found down to 0.05 K, and the low-temperature magnetic properties exhibit power-law behaviors in magnetic susceptibility and zero-field specific heat, and a single-parameter scaling of the specific heat under magnetic fields. These results provide strong evidence for the existence of the random singlet phase in ${\mathrm{SrIr}}_{2}{\mathrm{O}}_{6\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\delta}}$, which offers a different member to the family of spin-orbital entangled iridates and Kitaev materials.
Abstract The bond-disordered Kitaev model attracts much attention due to the experimental relevance in α-RuCl3 and A3LiIr2O6 (A = H, D, Ag, etc.). Applying a magnetic field to break the time-reversal symmetry leads to a strong modulation in mass terms for Dirac cones. Because of the smallness of the flux gap of the Kitaev model, a small bond disorder can have large influence on itinerant Majorana fermions. The quantization of the thermal Hall conductivity κxy/T disappears by a quantum Hall transition induced by a small disorder, and κxy/T shows a rapid crossover into a state with a negligible Hall current. We call this immobile liquid state Anderson–Kitaev spin liquid (AKSL). Especially, the critical disorder strength δJc1 ~ 0.05 in the unit of the Kitaev interaction would have many implications for the stability of Kitaev spin liquids.
Kitaev's compass model on the honeycomb lattice realizes a spin liquid whose emergent excitations are dispersive Majorana fermions and static Z2{\mathrm{Z}}_{2}Z2​ gauge fluxes. We discuss the proper selection of physical states for finite-size simulations in the Majorana representation, based on a recent paper by F. L. Pedrocchi, S. Chesi, and D. Loss [Phys. Rev. B 84, 165414 (2011)]. Certain physical observables acquire large finite-size effects, in particular if the ground state is not fermion-free, which we prove to generally apply to the system in the gapless phase and with periodic boundary conditions. To illustrate our findings, we compute the static and dynamic spin susceptibilities for finite-size systems. Specifically, we consider random-bond disorder (which preserves the solubility of the model), calculate the distribution of local flux gaps, and extract the NMR line shape. We also predict a transition to a random-flux state with increasing disorder.
Quantum spin liquid is a disordered but highly entangled magnetic state with fractional spin excitations1. The ground state of an exactly solved Kitaev honeycomb model is perhaps its clearest example2. Under a magnetic field, a spin flip in this model fractionalizes into two types of anyon, a quasiparticle with more complex exchange statistics than standard fermions or bosons: a pair of gauge fluxes and a Majorana fermion2,3. Here, we demonstrate this kind of fractionalization in the Kitaev paramagnetic state of the honeycomb magnet α-RuCl3. The spin excitation gap determined by nuclear magnetic resonance consists of the predicted Majorana fermion contribution following the cube of the applied magnetic field2,4,5, and a finite zero-field contribution matching the predicted size of the gauge flux gap2,6. The observed fractionalization into gapped anyons survives in a broad range of temperatures and magnetic fields, which establishes α-RuCl3 as a unique platform for future investigations of anyons.