Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1806.00438 · Physica Scripta

Flat bands and strongly correlated Fermi systems

V R Shaginyan, A Z Msezane, V A Stephanovich, G S Japaridze, Elena V. Kirichenko

Published Mar 18, 2019• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Many strongly correlated Fermi systems including heavy-fermion (HF) metals and high- T c superconductors belong to that class of quantum many-body systems for which Landau Fermi-liquid (LFL) theory fails. Instead, these systems exhibit non-Fermi-liquid properties that arise from violation of time-reversal ( T ) and particle-hole ( C ) invariance. Measurements of tunneling conductance provide a powerful experimental tool for detecting violations of these basic symmetries inherent to LFLs, which guarantee that the measured differential conductivity d I /d V , where I is the current and V the bias voltage, is a symmetric function of V . Thus, it has been predicted that the conductivity becomes asymmetric for HF metals such as CeCoIn 5 and YbRh 2 Si 2 . In these systems, the background electron liquid is considered to undergo a transformation that renders a portion of its excitation spectrum dispersionless, giving rise to so-called flat bands. The presence of a flat band indicates that the system is close to a special quantum critical point, namely a topological fermion-condensation quantum phase transition . An essential aspect of the behavior of a system hosting a flat band is that application of a magnetic field can restore its normal Fermi-liquid properties, including T - and C -invariance, with the differential conductivity again becoming a symmetric function of V . This behavior has been observed in recent measurements of tunneling conductivity in both YbRh 2 Si 2 and graphene. Also within the FC framework, we describe and explain recent empirical observations of scaling properties related to universal linear-temperature resistivity for a large number of strongly correlated high-temperature superconductors. We show that the observed scaling is explained by the emergence of flat bands formed by fermion condensation.

DOI
10.1088/1402-4896/ab10b4

Related papers

Flat Bands and Salient Experimental Features Supportingthe Fermion Condensation Theory of Strongly Correlated Fermi Systems

Vasily R. Shaginyan, M. Ya. Amusia, ALFRED Z. MSEZANE +3 more

Abstract The physics of strongly correlated Fermi systems, being the mainstream topic for more than half a century, still remains elusive. Recent advancements in experimental techniques permit to collect important data, which, in turn, allow us to make the conclusive statements about the underlying physics of strongly correlated Fermi systems. Such systems are close to a special quantum critical point represented by topological fermion-condensation quantum phase transition which separates normal Fermi liquid and that with a fermion condensate, forming flat bands. Our review paper considers recent exciting experimental observations of universal scattering rate related to linear temperature dependence of resistivity in a large number of strongly correlated Fermi systems as well as normal metals. We show that the observed scattering rate is explained by the emergence of flat bands, while the so-called Planckian limit occurs accidentally since the normal metals exhibit the same scattering rate behavior. We also analyze recent challenging experimental data on tunneling differential conductivity collected under the application of magnetic field on the twisted graphene and the archetypical heavy fermion metal YbRh $${}_{2}$$ Si $${}_{2}$$ . Also we describe recent empirical observations of scaling properties related to universal linear-temperature resistivity for a large number of strongly correlated high-temperature superconductors. We show that these observations support the fermion condensation theory. Our theoretical results are in good agreement with corps of different and seemingly unrelated experimental facts. They show that the fermion-condensation quantum phase transition is an intrinsic property of strongly correlated Fermi systems and can be viewed as the universal agent explaining their core physics.

Physics of Atomic Nuclei•Mar 1, 2020•5 citations

From the Bose-Einstein to fermion condensation

M. Ya. Amusia, ALFRED Z. MSEZANE, Vasily R. Shaginyan

The appearance of the fermion condensation, which can be compared to the Bose-Einstein condensation, in different Fermi liquids is considered; its properties are discussed; and a large amount of experimental evidence in favor of the existence of the fermion condensate (FC) is presented. We show that the appearance of FC is a signature of the fermion condensation quantum phase transition (FCQPT), which separates the regions of normal and strongly correlated liquids. Beyond the FCQPT point, the quasiparticle system is divided into two subsystems, one containing normal quasiparticles and the other, FC, localized at the Fermi level. In the superconducting state, the quasiparticle dispersion in systems with FC can be represented by two straight lines, characterized by effective masses M FC * and M L * and intersecting near the binding energy E 0, which is of the order of the superconducting gap. The same quasiparticle picture and the energy scale E 0 persist in the normal state. We demonstrate that fermion systems with FC have features of a “quantum protectorate” and show that strongly correlated systems with FC, which exhibit large deviations from the Landau Fermi liquid behavior, can be driven into the Landau Fermi liquid by applying a small magnetic field B at low temperatures. Thus, the essence of strongly correlated electron liquids can be controlled by weak magnetic fields. A reentrance into the strongly correlated regime is observed if the magnetic field B decreases to zero, while the effective mass M* diverges as $$M^ * \propto {1 \mathord{\left/ {\vphantom {1 {\sqrt B }}} \right. \kern-\nulldelimiterspace} {\sqrt B }}$$ . The regime is restored at some temperature $$T^ * \propto \sqrt B $$ . The behavior of Fermi systems that approach FCQPT from the disordered phase is considered. This behavior can be viewed as a highly correlated one, because the effective mass is large and strongly depends on the density. We expect that FCQPT takes place in trapped Fermi gases and in low-density neutron matter, leading to stabilization of the matter by lowering its ground-state energy. When the system recedes from FCQPT, the effective mass becomes density independent and the system is suited perfectly to be conventional Landau Fermi liquid.

arXiv:cond-mat/0301077•Physics of Atomic Nuclei•Oct 1, 2003•2 citations

Is there a unified theory explaining all correlated electron systems?

Tao Li

The Landau theory of phase and phase transition, which describes the state of matter by the spontaneous symmetry breaking, and the Fermi liquid theory of interacting Fermi systems are the two corner stones of contemporary condensed matter physics. They act as our starting points to understand the structure, excitations and phase transitions of any condensed matter system. According to such a Landau paradigm, an interacting Fermi system will behave just as non-interacting Fermi gas system at sufficient low energy, if the interaction is not strong enough to induce a symmetry breaking phase transition in the system. In such a case, the perturbation expansion in the interaction strength is assumed to converge and the low energy excitation can be connected to that of a Fermi gas system adiabatically. In strongly correlated electron systems, such as the high temperature superconductors and quantum antiferromagnets, a pertubative picture on the interaction effect usually fails. The correlation effect between the electrons can induce new forms of order that are beyond the Landau symmetry breaking paradigm. Non-Fermi liquid behavior can emerge in the fully symmetric correlated phases. The Mott insulating phase and the quantum spin liquid phase are the most prominent example of such exotic state of matter. After about three decades of intensive studies, people find that the quantum non-locality effect is at the heart of such new forms of order. The quantum non-locality effect manifests itself in the emergence of gauge degree of freedom in the low energy physics of such strongly correlated system. Such emergent gauge filed is not only important for the characterization and classification of the ground state structure, but is also directly responsible for the non-Fermi liquid behavior of the system. The Landau paradigm should be extended to accommodate such new forms of order and the related new form of excitations and new universal class of phase transitions. Such an extension will elevate our understanding of the structure of matter to the level of quantum wave function. Unlike the conventional symmetry breaking order, which is characterized by the correlation functions between local physical observables, the new form of orders, which are commonly called quantum order (with the topological order as one of its typical example), can be better characterized by the entanglement property in the quantum wave function. From a mathematical point of view, the new form of order is closely related to the projective representation theory of the symmetry group, while the conventional symmetry breaking order is well described by the linear representation theory of the symmetry group.

Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)•Nov 8, 2016•1 citation

Fermion condensate generates a new state of matter by making flat bands

Vasily R. Shaginyan, Konstantin G. Popov, VICTOR A. KHODEL

This short review paper is devoted to 90th anniversary of S.T. Belyaev birthday. Belyaev’s ideas associated with the condensate state in Bose interacting systems have stimulated intensive studies of the possible manifestation of such a condensation in Fermi systems. In many Fermi systems and compounds at zero temperature a phase transition happens that leads to a quite specific state called fermion condensation. As a signal of such a fermion condensation quantum phase transition (FCQPT) serves unlimited increase of the effective mass of quasiparticles that determines the excitation spectrum and creates flat bands. We show that the class of Fermi liquids with the fermion condensate forms a new state of matter. We discuss the phase diagrams and the physical properties of systems located near that phase transition. A common and essential feature of such systems is quasiparticles different from those suggested by L.D. Landau by crucial dependence of their effective mass on temperature, external magnetic field, pressure, etc. It is demonstrated that a huge amount of experimental data collected on different compounds suggest that they, starting from some temperature and down, form the new state of matter, and are governed by the fermion condensation. Our discussion shows that the theory of fermion condensation develops completely good description of the NFL behavior of strongly correlated Fermi systems. Moreover, the fermion condensation can be considered as the universal reason for the NFL behavior observed in various HF metals, liquids, compounds with quantum spin liquids, and quasicrystals. We show that these systems exhibit universal scaling behavior of their thermodynamic properties. Therefore, the quantum critical physics of different strongly correlated compounds is universal, and emerges regardless of the underlying microscopic details of the compounds. This uniform behavior, governed by the universal quantum critical physics, allows us to view it as the main characteristic of the new state of matter.

arXiv:1311.0629•Physics of Atomic Nuclei•Sep 1, 2014•3 citations

Effect of superconductivity on the shape of flat bands

Vasily R. Shaginyan, ALFRED Z. MSEZANE, M. Ya. Amusia +1 more

Abstract For the first time, basing both on experimental facts and our theoretical consideration, we show that Fermi systems with flat bands should be tuned with the superconducting state. Experimental measurements on magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene of the Fermi velocity V F as a function of the temperature T c of superconduction phase transition have revealed , where N s (0) is the density of states at the Fermi level. We show that the high- T c compounds exhibit the same behavior. Such observation is a challenge to theories of high- T c superconductivity, since V F is negatively correlated with T c , for . We show that the theoretical idea of forming flat bands in strongly correlated Fermi systems can explain this behavior and other experimental data collected on both and twisted bilayer graphene. Our findings place stringent constraints on theories describing the nature of high- T c superconductivity and the deformation of flat band by the superconducting phase transition.

arXiv:2103.11848•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Apr 1, 2022•6 citations

Metamorphoses of Electron Systems Hosting a Fermion Condensate

VICTOR A. KHODEL, J. W. Clark, MIKHAIL V. ZVEREV

We present a unified theory of strongly correlated electron systems with a fermion condensate. This theoretical framework facilitates quantitative analysis and explanation, on an equal footing, of (i) non-Fermi-liquid behavior of high- T c superconductors in which the critical temperature for superconductivity is proportional to the Fermi energy T F and (ii) the so-called quantum electron solid state in the two-dimensional electron liquid of MOSFETs and SiGe/Si/SiGe quantum wells. In this framework, low-temperature chaotic-like behavior that is documented in experimental studies of these systems is attributed to a spontaneous topological rearrangement of the conventional Landau state, quite in contrast to models in which the chaotic element is introduced deliberately in terms of a chaotic distribution of interaction matrix elements.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•Jan 1, 2020•1 citation
Abstract Many strongly correlated Fermi systems including heavy-fermion (HF) metals and high- T c superconductors belong to that class of quantum many-body systems for which Landau Fermi-liquid (LFL) theory fails. Instead, these systems exhibit non-Fermi-liquid properties that arise from violation of time-reversal ( T ) and particle-hole ( C ) invariance. Measurements of tunneling conductance provide a powerful experimental tool for detecting violations of these basic symmetries inherent to LFLs, which guarantee that the measured differential conductivity d I /d V , where I is the current and V the bias voltage, is a symmetric function of V . Thus, it has been predicted that the conductivity becomes asymmetric for HF metals such as CeCoIn 5 and YbRh 2 Si 2 . In these systems, the background electron liquid is considered to undergo a transformation that renders a portion of its excitation spectrum dispersionless, giving rise to so-called flat bands. The presence of a flat band indicates that the system is close to a special quantum critical point, namely a topological fermion-condensation quantum phase transition . An essential aspect of the behavior of a system hosting a flat band is that application of a magnetic field can restore its normal Fermi-liquid properties, including T - and C -invariance, with the differential conductivity again becoming a symmetric function of V . This behavior has been observed in recent measurements of tunneling conductivity in both YbRh 2 Si 2 and graphene. Also within the FC framework, we describe and explain recent empirical observations of scaling properties related to universal linear-temperature resistivity for a large number of strongly correlated high-temperature superconductors. We show that the observed scaling is explained by the emergence of flat bands formed by fermion condensation.
Abstract The physics of strongly correlated Fermi systems, being the mainstream topic for more than half a century, still remains elusive. Recent advancements in experimental techniques permit to collect important data, which, in turn, allow us to make the conclusive statements about the underlying physics of strongly correlated Fermi systems. Such systems are close to a special quantum critical point represented by topological fermion-condensation quantum phase transition which separates normal Fermi liquid and that with a fermion condensate, forming flat bands. Our review paper considers recent exciting experimental observations of universal scattering rate related to linear temperature dependence of resistivity in a large number of strongly correlated Fermi systems as well as normal metals. We show that the observed scattering rate is explained by the emergence of flat bands, while the so-called Planckian limit occurs accidentally since the normal metals exhibit the same scattering rate behavior. We also analyze recent challenging experimental data on tunneling differential conductivity collected under the application of magnetic field on the twisted graphene and the archetypical heavy fermion metal YbRh 2{}_{2}2​ Si 2{}_{2}2​ . Also we describe recent empirical observations of scaling properties related to universal linear-temperature resistivity for a large number of strongly correlated high-temperature superconductors. We show that these observations support the fermion condensation theory. Our theoretical results are in good agreement with corps of different and seemingly unrelated experimental facts. They show that the fermion-condensation quantum phase transition is an intrinsic property of strongly correlated Fermi systems and can be viewed as the universal agent explaining their core physics.
The appearance of the fermion condensation, which can be compared to the Bose-Einstein condensation, in different Fermi liquids is considered; its properties are discussed; and a large amount of experimental evidence in favor of the existence of the fermion condensate (FC) is presented. We show that the appearance of FC is a signature of the fermion condensation quantum phase transition (FCQPT), which separates the regions of normal and strongly correlated liquids. Beyond the FCQPT point, the quasiparticle system is divided into two subsystems, one containing normal quasiparticles and the other, FC, localized at the Fermi level. In the superconducting state, the quasiparticle dispersion in systems with FC can be represented by two straight lines, characterized by effective masses M FC * and M L * and intersecting near the binding energy E 0, which is of the order of the superconducting gap. The same quasiparticle picture and the energy scale E 0 persist in the normal state. We demonstrate that fermion systems with FC have features of a “quantum protectorate” and show that strongly correlated systems with FC, which exhibit large deviations from the Landau Fermi liquid behavior, can be driven into the Landau Fermi liquid by applying a small magnetic field B at low temperatures. Thus, the essence of strongly correlated electron liquids can be controlled by weak magnetic fields. A reentrance into the strongly correlated regime is observed if the magnetic field B decreases to zero, while the effective mass M* diverges as $$M^ * \propto {1 \mathord{\left/ {\vphantom {1 {\sqrt B }}} \right. \kern-\nulldelimiterspace} {\sqrt B }}$$ . The regime is restored at some temperature T∗∝BT^ * \propto \sqrt B T∗∝B​ . The behavior of Fermi systems that approach FCQPT from the disordered phase is considered. This behavior can be viewed as a highly correlated one, because the effective mass is large and strongly depends on the density. We expect that FCQPT takes place in trapped Fermi gases and in low-density neutron matter, leading to stabilization of the matter by lowering its ground-state energy. When the system recedes from FCQPT, the effective mass becomes density independent and the system is suited perfectly to be conventional Landau Fermi liquid.
The Landau theory of phase and phase transition, which describes the state of matter by the spontaneous symmetry breaking, and the Fermi liquid theory of interacting Fermi systems are the two corner stones of contemporary condensed matter physics. They act as our starting points to understand the structure, excitations and phase transitions of any condensed matter system. According to such a Landau paradigm, an interacting Fermi system will behave just as non-interacting Fermi gas system at sufficient low energy, if the interaction is not strong enough to induce a symmetry breaking phase transition in the system. In such a case, the perturbation expansion in the interaction strength is assumed to converge and the low energy excitation can be connected to that of a Fermi gas system adiabatically. In strongly correlated electron systems, such as the high temperature superconductors and quantum antiferromagnets, a pertubative picture on the interaction effect usually fails. The correlation effect between the electrons can induce new forms of order that are beyond the Landau symmetry breaking paradigm. Non-Fermi liquid behavior can emerge in the fully symmetric correlated phases. The Mott insulating phase and the quantum spin liquid phase are the most prominent example of such exotic state of matter. After about three decades of intensive studies, people find that the quantum non-locality effect is at the heart of such new forms of order. The quantum non-locality effect manifests itself in the emergence of gauge degree of freedom in the low energy physics of such strongly correlated system. Such emergent gauge filed is not only important for the characterization and classification of the ground state structure, but is also directly responsible for the non-Fermi liquid behavior of the system. The Landau paradigm should be extended to accommodate such new forms of order and the related new form of excitations and new universal class of phase transitions. Such an extension will elevate our understanding of the structure of matter to the level of quantum wave function. Unlike the conventional symmetry breaking order, which is characterized by the correlation functions between local physical observables, the new form of orders, which are commonly called quantum order (with the topological order as one of its typical example), can be better characterized by the entanglement property in the quantum wave function. From a mathematical point of view, the new form of order is closely related to the projective representation theory of the symmetry group, while the conventional symmetry breaking order is well described by the linear representation theory of the symmetry group.
This short review paper is devoted to 90th anniversary of S.T. Belyaev birthday. Belyaev’s ideas associated with the condensate state in Bose interacting systems have stimulated intensive studies of the possible manifestation of such a condensation in Fermi systems. In many Fermi systems and compounds at zero temperature a phase transition happens that leads to a quite specific state called fermion condensation. As a signal of such a fermion condensation quantum phase transition (FCQPT) serves unlimited increase of the effective mass of quasiparticles that determines the excitation spectrum and creates flat bands. We show that the class of Fermi liquids with the fermion condensate forms a new state of matter. We discuss the phase diagrams and the physical properties of systems located near that phase transition. A common and essential feature of such systems is quasiparticles different from those suggested by L.D. Landau by crucial dependence of their effective mass on temperature, external magnetic field, pressure, etc. It is demonstrated that a huge amount of experimental data collected on different compounds suggest that they, starting from some temperature and down, form the new state of matter, and are governed by the fermion condensation. Our discussion shows that the theory of fermion condensation develops completely good description of the NFL behavior of strongly correlated Fermi systems. Moreover, the fermion condensation can be considered as the universal reason for the NFL behavior observed in various HF metals, liquids, compounds with quantum spin liquids, and quasicrystals. We show that these systems exhibit universal scaling behavior of their thermodynamic properties. Therefore, the quantum critical physics of different strongly correlated compounds is universal, and emerges regardless of the underlying microscopic details of the compounds. This uniform behavior, governed by the universal quantum critical physics, allows us to view it as the main characteristic of the new state of matter.
Abstract For the first time, basing both on experimental facts and our theoretical consideration, we show that Fermi systems with flat bands should be tuned with the superconducting state. Experimental measurements on magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene of the Fermi velocity V F as a function of the temperature T c of superconduction phase transition have revealed , where N s (0) is the density of states at the Fermi level. We show that the high- T c compounds exhibit the same behavior. Such observation is a challenge to theories of high- T c superconductivity, since V F is negatively correlated with T c , for . We show that the theoretical idea of forming flat bands in strongly correlated Fermi systems can explain this behavior and other experimental data collected on both and twisted bilayer graphene. Our findings place stringent constraints on theories describing the nature of high- T c superconductivity and the deformation of flat band by the superconducting phase transition.
We present a unified theory of strongly correlated electron systems with a fermion condensate. This theoretical framework facilitates quantitative analysis and explanation, on an equal footing, of (i) non-Fermi-liquid behavior of high- T c superconductors in which the critical temperature for superconductivity is proportional to the Fermi energy T F and (ii) the so-called quantum electron solid state in the two-dimensional electron liquid of MOSFETs and SiGe/Si/SiGe quantum wells. In this framework, low-temperature chaotic-like behavior that is documented in experimental studies of these systems is attributed to a spontaneous topological rearrangement of the conventional Landau state, quite in contrast to models in which the chaotic element is introduced deliberately in terms of a chaotic distribution of interaction matrix elements.