Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1805.03697 · Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Which-way measurement and momentum kicks

Tabish Qureshi

Published Sep 4, 2018• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Two-slit interference experiment with a which-way detector has been a topic of intense debate. Scientific community is divided on the question whether the particle receives a momentum kick because of the process of which-way measurement. It is shown here that the same experiment can be viewed in two different ways, depending on which basis of the which-way detector states one chooses to look at. In one view, the loss of interference arises due to the entanglement of the two paths of the particle with two orthogonal states of the which-way detector. In another view, the loss of interference can be interpreted as arising from random momentum kicks of magnitude $h/2d$ received by the particle, $d$ being the slit separation. The same scenario is shown to hold for a three-slit interference experiment. The random momentum kicks for the three-slit case are of two kinds, of magnitude $\pm h/3d$. The analysis is also generalized to the case of n-slit interference. The two alternate views are described by the same quantum state, and hence are completely equivalent. The concept of "local" versus "nonlocal" kicks, much discussed in the literature, is not needed here.

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/123/30007

Related papers

Momentum Kicks in Imperfect Which-Way Measurement

Neha Pathania, Tabish Qureshi

There has been an intense debate on the question as to whether a quanton, passing through a double-slit, experiences a 'momentum kick' due to the act of which-way detection. There have been conflicting points of view on this issue over many decades. This issue is addressed here in the general setting where the which-way detection may be imperfect. It is shown here that the loss of interference may still be interpreted as arising out of tiny momentum kicks which the quanton appears to receive, irrespective of the nature of the which-way detector. Interestingly, the magnitude of the random momentum kicks is always h/2d, d being the slit separation, irrespective of how perfect or imperfect the which-way detection is. This is contrary to what has been suggested in the earlier literature. The imperfection of which-way detection decides how frequent are the momentum kicks. It has been shown earlier that for perfect which-way detection, the quanton receives a momentum kick fifty percent of the time. Here it is shown that for imperfect which-way detection, the quanton receives momentum kicks of the same magnitude, but less often. A precise relation between the frequency of kicks and the visibility of interference is found here.

arXiv:2009.07045•Quantum•Jul 20, 2021•1 citation

Momentum kicks due to quantum localization

Short, A. J.

The momentum changes caused by position measurements are a central feature of wave-particle duality. Here we investigate two cases - localization by a single slit, and which-way detection in the double-slit interference experiment - and examine in detail the associated momentum changes. Particular attention is given to the transfer of momentum between particle and detector, and the recoil of the measuring device. We find that single-slit diffraction relies on a form of `interaction-free' scattering, and that an ideal which-way measurement can be made without any back-reaction on the detector.

arXiv:quant-ph/0112121•Dec 20, 2001•0 citations

Nonlocal momentum transfer inwelcher Wegmeasurements

Howard M. Wiseman, F. E. Harrison, Matthew J. Collett +3 more

A ``which-path'' (welcher Weg) measurement necessarily destroys the fringes in a double-slit interference experiment. We show that in all instances one may attribute this destruction to a disturbance of the particle's momentum by an amount equal to at least $\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\Elzxh}/2d$, where $d$ is the slit separation, in accordance with the uncertainty principle. However, this momentum transfer need not be local; that is, it need not act at either of the slits through which the particle passes. For well-known welcher Weg measurements such as Einstein's recoiling slit and Feynman's light microscope, the disturbance can be understood in terms of random classical momentum kicks that act locally. In some recent proposals, including that by Scully, Englert, and Walther [Nature (London) 351, 111 (1991)], the momentum transfer is of a peculiarly quantum, nonlocal nature. In this paper we introduce a formalism based on the Wigner function, as this describes both the local and nonlocal momentum transfer caused by any welcher Weg measurement. We show that for some examples, such as that of Scully, Englert, and Walther, there is no momentum disturbance at the slits even though the nonlocal momentum disturbance is sufficient to destroy the interference pattern. Finally, we discuss the experimental signatures of nonlocal versus local momentum transfer and demonstrate a strong similarity to the nonlocality of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1997•90 citations

Bohmian analysis of momentum transfer inwelcher Wegmeasurements

Howard M. Wiseman

Whether the loss of visibility due to measurement in two-slit interference patterns can always be attributed to momentum transfer depends upon how one defines the last term. The momentum transfer to a quantum particle can be determined unambiguously if it was initially in a momentum eigenstate, but that is not the state relevant to a two-slit experiment. A sensible answer for the two-slit problem was obtained by Wiseman et al. [Phys. Rev. A 56, 944 (1997)] using the formalism of the Wigner function. Here I show that a more general answer can be obtained using the Bohmian formulation of quantum mechanics, in which particles have a definite position and momentum at all times. By following all possible trajectories of the particle it is possible to calculate the probability distribution ${P}_{\mathrm{total}}^{B}{(p}^{\ensuremath{'}})$ for it to receive a momentum transfer ${p}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ as a result of the measurement. Furthermore, the 1-norm of this distribution obeys the relation $〈|{p}^{\ensuremath{'}}|{〉}_{\mathrm{total}}^{B}d>~2\ensuremath{\Elzxh}(1\ensuremath{-}V)/\ensuremath{\pi},$ where $V$ is the visibility of the interference pattern and $d$ is the slit separation. This confirms that the momentum transfer in a welcher Weg (which path) experiment is in accord with the uncertainty principle. Like the Wignerian analysis, the Bohmian analysis clearly distinguishes between a local momentum transfer (which occurs even if the particle is localized at a single slit) and a nonlocal momentum transfer (which occurs only if the particle is delocalized, at both slits). In the Bohmian analysis the former occurs at the time of the measurement, while the latter occurs after the measurement, and is a consequence of Bohm's ``quantum potential.''

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1998•20 citations

Observing momentum disturbance in double-slit “which-way” measurements

Ya Xiao, Howard M. Wiseman, Jin-Shi Xu +3 more

Making a "which-way" measurement (WWM) to identify which slit a particle goes through in a double-slit apparatus will reduce the visibility of interference fringes. There has been a long-standing controversy over whether this can be attributed to an uncontrollable momentum transfer. Here, by reconstructing the Bohmian trajectories of single photons, we experimentally obtain the distribution of momentum change. For our WWM, the change we see is not a momentum kick that occurs at the point of the WWM, but rather one that nonclassically accumulates during the propagation of the photons. We further confirm a quantitative relation between the loss of visibility consequent on a WWM and the total (late-time) momentum disturbance. Our results emphasize the role of the Bohmian momentum in giving an intuitive picture of wave-particle duality and complementarity.

arXiv:1805.02059•Science Advances•Jun 1, 2019•26 citations

Quantum double-double-slit experiment with momentum entangled photons

Manpreet Kaur, Mandip Singh

Double-double-slit thought experiment provides profound insight on interference of quantum entangled particles. This paper presents a detailed experimental realisation of quantum double-double-slit thought experiment with momentum entangled photons and theoretical analysis of the experiment. Experiment is configured in such a way that photons are path entangled and each photon can reveal the which-slit path information of the other photon. As a consequence, single photon interference is suppressed. However, two-photon interference pattern appears if locations of detection of photons are correlated without revealing the which-slit path information. It is also shown experimentally and theoretically that two-photon quantum interference disappears when the which-slit path of a photon in the double-double-slit is detected.

Scientific Reports•Jul 10, 2020•98 citations
Two-slit interference experiment with a which-way detector has been a topic of intense debate. Scientific community is divided on the question whether the particle receives a momentum kick because of the process of which-way measurement. It is shown here that the same experiment can be viewed in two different ways, depending on which basis of the which-way detector states one chooses to look at. In one view, the loss of interference arises due to the entanglement of the two paths of the particle with two orthogonal states of the which-way detector. In another view, the loss of interference can be interpreted as arising from random momentum kicks of magnitude h/2dh/2dh/2d received by the particle, ddd being the slit separation. The same scenario is shown to hold for a three-slit interference experiment. The random momentum kicks for the three-slit case are of two kinds, of magnitude ±h/3d\pm h/3d±h/3d. The analysis is also generalized to the case of n-slit interference. The two alternate views are described by the same quantum state, and hence are completely equivalent. The concept of "local" versus "nonlocal" kicks, much discussed in the literature, is not needed here.
There has been an intense debate on the question as to whether a quanton, passing through a double-slit, experiences a 'momentum kick' due to the act of which-way detection. There have been conflicting points of view on this issue over many decades. This issue is addressed here in the general setting where the which-way detection may be imperfect. It is shown here that the loss of interference may still be interpreted as arising out of tiny momentum kicks which the quanton appears to receive, irrespective of the nature of the which-way detector. Interestingly, the magnitude of the random momentum kicks is always h/2d, d being the slit separation, irrespective of how perfect or imperfect the which-way detection is. This is contrary to what has been suggested in the earlier literature. The imperfection of which-way detection decides how frequent are the momentum kicks. It has been shown earlier that for perfect which-way detection, the quanton receives a momentum kick fifty percent of the time. Here it is shown that for imperfect which-way detection, the quanton receives momentum kicks of the same magnitude, but less often. A precise relation between the frequency of kicks and the visibility of interference is found here.
The momentum changes caused by position measurements are a central feature of wave-particle duality. Here we investigate two cases - localization by a single slit, and which-way detection in the double-slit interference experiment - and examine in detail the associated momentum changes. Particular attention is given to the transfer of momentum between particle and detector, and the recoil of the measuring device. We find that single-slit diffraction relies on a form of `interaction-free' scattering, and that an ideal which-way measurement can be made without any back-reaction on the detector.
A ``which-path'' (welcher Weg) measurement necessarily destroys the fringes in a double-slit interference experiment. We show that in all instances one may attribute this destruction to a disturbance of the particle's momentum by an amount equal to at least $\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\Elzxh}/2d$, where ddd is the slit separation, in accordance with the uncertainty principle. However, this momentum transfer need not be local; that is, it need not act at either of the slits through which the particle passes. For well-known welcher Weg measurements such as Einstein's recoiling slit and Feynman's light microscope, the disturbance can be understood in terms of random classical momentum kicks that act locally. In some recent proposals, including that by Scully, Englert, and Walther [Nature (London) 351, 111 (1991)], the momentum transfer is of a peculiarly quantum, nonlocal nature. In this paper we introduce a formalism based on the Wigner function, as this describes both the local and nonlocal momentum transfer caused by any welcher Weg measurement. We show that for some examples, such as that of Scully, Englert, and Walther, there is no momentum disturbance at the slits even though the nonlocal momentum disturbance is sufficient to destroy the interference pattern. Finally, we discuss the experimental signatures of nonlocal versus local momentum transfer and demonstrate a strong similarity to the nonlocality of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.
Whether the loss of visibility due to measurement in two-slit interference patterns can always be attributed to momentum transfer depends upon how one defines the last term. The momentum transfer to a quantum particle can be determined unambiguously if it was initially in a momentum eigenstate, but that is not the state relevant to a two-slit experiment. A sensible answer for the two-slit problem was obtained by Wiseman et al. [Phys. Rev. A 56, 944 (1997)] using the formalism of the Wigner function. Here I show that a more general answer can be obtained using the Bohmian formulation of quantum mechanics, in which particles have a definite position and momentum at all times. By following all possible trajectories of the particle it is possible to calculate the probability distribution ${P}_{\mathrm{total}}^{B}{(p}^{\ensuremath{'}})$ for it to receive a momentum transfer ${p}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ as a result of the measurement. Furthermore, the 1-norm of this distribution obeys the relation $〈|{p}^{\ensuremath{'}}|{〉}_{\mathrm{total}}^{B}d>~2\ensuremath{\Elzxh}(1\ensuremath{-}V)/\ensuremath{\pi},$ where VVV is the visibility of the interference pattern and ddd is the slit separation. This confirms that the momentum transfer in a welcher Weg (which path) experiment is in accord with the uncertainty principle. Like the Wignerian analysis, the Bohmian analysis clearly distinguishes between a local momentum transfer (which occurs even if the particle is localized at a single slit) and a nonlocal momentum transfer (which occurs only if the particle is delocalized, at both slits). In the Bohmian analysis the former occurs at the time of the measurement, while the latter occurs after the measurement, and is a consequence of Bohm's ``quantum potential.''
Making a "which-way" measurement (WWM) to identify which slit a particle goes through in a double-slit apparatus will reduce the visibility of interference fringes. There has been a long-standing controversy over whether this can be attributed to an uncontrollable momentum transfer. Here, by reconstructing the Bohmian trajectories of single photons, we experimentally obtain the distribution of momentum change. For our WWM, the change we see is not a momentum kick that occurs at the point of the WWM, but rather one that nonclassically accumulates during the propagation of the photons. We further confirm a quantitative relation between the loss of visibility consequent on a WWM and the total (late-time) momentum disturbance. Our results emphasize the role of the Bohmian momentum in giving an intuitive picture of wave-particle duality and complementarity.
Double-double-slit thought experiment provides profound insight on interference of quantum entangled particles. This paper presents a detailed experimental realisation of quantum double-double-slit thought experiment with momentum entangled photons and theoretical analysis of the experiment. Experiment is configured in such a way that photons are path entangled and each photon can reveal the which-slit path information of the other photon. As a consequence, single photon interference is suppressed. However, two-photon interference pattern appears if locations of detection of photons are correlated without revealing the which-slit path information. It is also shown experimentally and theoretically that two-photon quantum interference disappears when the which-slit path of a photon in the double-double-slit is detected.