Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1803.08245 · Physical Review A

Joint quantum-state and measurement tomography with incomplete measurements

Adam C. Keith, Charles H. Baldwin, Scott Glancy, Emanuel H. Knill

Published Oct 12, 2018• 35 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Estimation of quantum states and measurements is crucial for the implementation of quantum information protocols. The standard method for each is quantum tomography. However, quantum tomography suffers from systematic errors caused by imperfect knowledge of the system. We present a procedure to simultaneously characterize quantum states and measurements that mitigates systematic errors by use of a single high-fidelity state preparation and a limited set of high-fidelity unitary operations. Such states and operations are typical of many state-of-the-art systems. For this situation we design a set of experiments and an optimization algorithm that alternates between maximizing the likelihood with respect to the states and measurements to produce estimates of each. In some cases, the procedure does not enable unique estimation of the states. For these cases, we show how one may identify a set of density matrices compatible with the measurements and use a semi-definite program to place bounds on the state's expectation values. We demonstrate the procedure on data from a simulated experiment with two trapped ions.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.98.042318

Related papers

Incomplete quantum state estimation: A comprehensive study

Yong Siah Teo, B. Stoklasa, Berthold‐Georg Englert +2 more

We present a detailed account of quantum state estimation by joint maximization of the likelihood and the entropy. After establishing the algorithms for both perfect and imperfect measurements, we apply the procedure to data from simulated and actual experiments. We demonstrate that the realistic situation of incomplete data from imperfect measurements can be handled successfully.

arXiv:1202.1713•Physical Review A•Apr 16, 2012•38 citations

Unitary quantum process tomography with unreliable pure input states

François Verdeil, Yannick Deville

Quantum process tomography (QPT) methods aim at identifying a given quantum process. QPT is a major quantum information processing tool, since it allows one to characterize the actual behavior of quantum gates, which are the building blocks of quantum computers. The present paper focuses on the estimation of a unitary process. This class is of particular interest because quantum mechanics postulates that the evolution of any closed quantum system is described by a unitary transformation. The standard approach of QPT is to measure copies of a particular set of predetermined (generally pure) states after they have been modified by the process to be identified. The main problem with this setup is that preparing an input state and setting it precisely to a predetermined value is challenging and thus yields errors. These errors can be decomposed into a sum of centered errors (i.e., whose average on all the copies is zero) and systematic errors that are the same for all the copies. The latter is often the main source of error in QPT. The algorithm we introduce works for any input states that make QPT theoretically possible (i.e., unless there are several solutions due to, e.g., a lack of diversity in the input states). The fact that we do not require the input states to be precisely set to predetermined values means that we can use a trick to remove the issue of systematic errors by considering that some states' copies are unknown but measured before they go through the process to be identified. We achieve this by splitting the copies of each input state into several groups and measuring the copies of the $k\mathrm{th}$ group after they have successively been transferred through $k$ instances of the process to be identified (each copy of each input state is used for only a single measurement). Using this approach, we can compute estimates of the measured states before and after they go through the process without using the knowledge we might have about the initial states. We test our algorithm with simulated data, and we assess its performance with a cnot gate on a trapped-ions qubit quantum computer.

arXiv:2306.07867•Physical Review A•Dec 11, 2023•2 citations

Systematic Errors in Current Quantum State Tomography Tools

Christian Schwemmer, Lukas Knips, Daniel Richart +4 more

Common tools for obtaining physical density matrices in experimental quantum state tomography are shown here to cause systematic errors. For example, using maximum likelihood or least squares optimization to obtain physical estimates for the quantum state, we observe a systematic underestimation of the fidelity and an overestimation of entanglement. Such strongly biased estimates can be avoided using linear evaluation of the data or by linearizing measurement operators yielding reliable and computational simple error bounds.

arXiv:1310.8465•Physical Review Letters•Feb 26, 2015•114 citations

Quantum tomography for quantum systems optimization

B. I. Bantysh, Yu. I. Bogdanov

Debugging quantum states transformations is an important task of modern quantum computing. The use of quantum tomography for these purposes significantly expands the range of possibilities. However, the presence of preparation and measurement errors complicates the practical use of this procedure. In this work, we investigate the possibility of estimating these errors from experiment. These estimates are subsequently used to build a robust quantum tomography model. The model allows one to accurately reconstruct unitary errors of single-qubit gates. We show that, having such imperfect single-qubit gates with pre-estimated errors, one can obtain transformations close to ideal ones. A similar approach can also significantly mitigate single-qubit gates cross-talk.

arXiv:2201.03255•International Conference on Micro- and Nano-Electronics (ICMNE)•Jan 31, 2022•0 citations

Certified optimal lower bound estimation of quantum properties using incomplete information: variational quantum tomography

Thiago O. Maciel, Reinaldo O. Vianna

It is assumed partial knowledge about the state of a quantum system. This knowledge is represented by the results of some measurements, spanning a certain subspace. We refer to this subspace as the known subspace, and to its complement as the unknown one. Then we introduce a variational method to estimate the expectation value of every observable. This estimate is optimal and reliable, in the sense that it is always smaller, in absolute value, than the true expectation value (the one that would be obtained if directly measured, of if the quantum state were known exactly). As a by-product of this approach, we obtain a method of reconstruction of the quantum state, using incomplete information. Our results make clear that it is typically not necessary to perform an informationally complete set of measurements, which grows exponentially with the Hilbert space size, in order to obtain certified optimal lower bounds to properties of a quantum system. The algorithm that implements our method is a linear convex problem, which has exact solution in terms of well known semidefinite programs.

•Jan 12, 2010•0 citations

Verification of state and entanglement with incomplete tomography

Yong Siah Teo, Berthold‐Georg Englert, Jaroslav Řeháček +2 more

There exists, in general, a convex set of quantum state estimators that maximize the likelihood for informationally incomplete data. We propose an estimation scheme, catered to measurement data of this kind, to search for the exact maximum-likelihood-maximum-entropy estimator using semidefinite programming and a standard multi-dimensional function optimization routine. This scheme can be used to infer the expectation values of a set of entanglement witnesses that can be used to verify the entanglement of the unknown quantum state for composite systems. Next, we establish an alternative numerical scheme that is more computationally robust for the sole purpose of maximizing the likelihood and entropy.

arXiv:1207.5386•Jul 23, 2012•0 citations
Estimation of quantum states and measurements is crucial for the implementation of quantum information protocols. The standard method for each is quantum tomography. However, quantum tomography suffers from systematic errors caused by imperfect knowledge of the system. We present a procedure to simultaneously characterize quantum states and measurements that mitigates systematic errors by use of a single high-fidelity state preparation and a limited set of high-fidelity unitary operations. Such states and operations are typical of many state-of-the-art systems. For this situation we design a set of experiments and an optimization algorithm that alternates between maximizing the likelihood with respect to the states and measurements to produce estimates of each. In some cases, the procedure does not enable unique estimation of the states. For these cases, we show how one may identify a set of density matrices compatible with the measurements and use a semi-definite program to place bounds on the state's expectation values. We demonstrate the procedure on data from a simulated experiment with two trapped ions.
Quantum process tomography (QPT) methods aim at identifying a given quantum process. QPT is a major quantum information processing tool, since it allows one to characterize the actual behavior of quantum gates, which are the building blocks of quantum computers. The present paper focuses on the estimation of a unitary process. This class is of particular interest because quantum mechanics postulates that the evolution of any closed quantum system is described by a unitary transformation. The standard approach of QPT is to measure copies of a particular set of predetermined (generally pure) states after they have been modified by the process to be identified. The main problem with this setup is that preparing an input state and setting it precisely to a predetermined value is challenging and thus yields errors. These errors can be decomposed into a sum of centered errors (i.e., whose average on all the copies is zero) and systematic errors that are the same for all the copies. The latter is often the main source of error in QPT. The algorithm we introduce works for any input states that make QPT theoretically possible (i.e., unless there are several solutions due to, e.g., a lack of diversity in the input states). The fact that we do not require the input states to be precisely set to predetermined values means that we can use a trick to remove the issue of systematic errors by considering that some states' copies are unknown but measured before they go through the process to be identified. We achieve this by splitting the copies of each input state into several groups and measuring the copies of the kthk\mathrm{th}kth group after they have successively been transferred through kkk instances of the process to be identified (each copy of each input state is used for only a single measurement). Using this approach, we can compute estimates of the measured states before and after they go through the process without using the knowledge we might have about the initial states. We test our algorithm with simulated data, and we assess its performance with a cnot gate on a trapped-ions qubit quantum computer.
Common tools for obtaining physical density matrices in experimental quantum state tomography are shown here to cause systematic errors. For example, using maximum likelihood or least squares optimization to obtain physical estimates for the quantum state, we observe a systematic underestimation of the fidelity and an overestimation of entanglement. Such strongly biased estimates can be avoided using linear evaluation of the data or by linearizing measurement operators yielding reliable and computational simple error bounds.
Debugging quantum states transformations is an important task of modern quantum computing. The use of quantum tomography for these purposes significantly expands the range of possibilities. However, the presence of preparation and measurement errors complicates the practical use of this procedure. In this work, we investigate the possibility of estimating these errors from experiment. These estimates are subsequently used to build a robust quantum tomography model. The model allows one to accurately reconstruct unitary errors of single-qubit gates. We show that, having such imperfect single-qubit gates with pre-estimated errors, one can obtain transformations close to ideal ones. A similar approach can also significantly mitigate single-qubit gates cross-talk.
It is assumed partial knowledge about the state of a quantum system. This knowledge is represented by the results of some measurements, spanning a certain subspace. We refer to this subspace as the known subspace, and to its complement as the unknown one. Then we introduce a variational method to estimate the expectation value of every observable. This estimate is optimal and reliable, in the sense that it is always smaller, in absolute value, than the true expectation value (the one that would be obtained if directly measured, of if the quantum state were known exactly). As a by-product of this approach, we obtain a method of reconstruction of the quantum state, using incomplete information. Our results make clear that it is typically not necessary to perform an informationally complete set of measurements, which grows exponentially with the Hilbert space size, in order to obtain certified optimal lower bounds to properties of a quantum system. The algorithm that implements our method is a linear convex problem, which has exact solution in terms of well known semidefinite programs.
There exists, in general, a convex set of quantum state estimators that maximize the likelihood for informationally incomplete data. We propose an estimation scheme, catered to measurement data of this kind, to search for the exact maximum-likelihood-maximum-entropy estimator using semidefinite programming and a standard multi-dimensional function optimization routine. This scheme can be used to infer the expectation values of a set of entanglement witnesses that can be used to verify the entanglement of the unknown quantum state for composite systems. Next, we establish an alternative numerical scheme that is more computationally robust for the sole purpose of maximizing the likelihood and entropy.