Experimental investigation of high-dimensional quantum key distribution protocols with twisted photons
Frédéric Bouchard, Khabat Heshami, Duncan G. England, Robert Fickler, Robert W. Boyd, Berthold‐Georg Englert, Luis Lorenzo Sánchez-Soto, Ebrahim Karimi
Quantum key distribution is on the verge of real world applications, where perfectly secure information can be distributed among multiple parties. Several quantum cryptographic protocols have been theoretically proposed and independently realized in different experimental conditions. Here, we develop an experimental platform based on high-dimensional orbital angular momentum states of single photons that enables implementation of multiple quantum key distribution protocols with a single experimental apparatus. Our versatile approach allows us to experimentally survey different classes of quantum key distribution techniques, such as the 1984 Bennett & Brassard (BB84), tomographic protocols including the six-state and the Singapore protocol, and to investigate, for the first time, a recently introduced differential phase shift (Chau15) protocol using twisted photons. This enables us to experimentally compare the performance of these techniques and discuss their benefits and deficiencies in terms of noise tolerance in different dimensions.
Quantum key distribution is on the verge of real world applications, where perfectly secure information can be distributed among multiple parties. Several quantum cryptographic protocols have been theoretically proposed and independently realized in different experimental conditions. Here, we develop an experimental platform based on high-dimensional orbital angular momentum states of single photons that enables implementation of multiple quantum key distribution protocols with a single experimental apparatus. Our versatile approach allows us to experimentally survey different classes of quantum key distribution techniques, such as the 1984 Bennett & Brassard (BB84), tomographic protocols including the six-state and the Singapore protocol, and to investigate, for the first time, a recently introduced differential phase shift (Chau15) protocol using twisted photons. This enables us to experimentally compare the performance of these techniques and discuss their benefits and deficiencies in terms of noise tolerance in different dimensions.
Light with a complex amplitude structure invokes interesting fundamental properties such as phase and polarization singularities, which also enables novel applications in classical and quantum optical experiments [1]. One feature, namely a twisted phase front and its orbital angular momentum, attracted a lot of attention due its broad range of applications. In the quantum domain, structured photons are highly beneficial since they serve as a physical realizations of high-dimensional states, which allow for example an enlarged information content per single carrier and are known to have a better noise resistance in quantum cryptography applications [2]. At first, I will present a set of laboratory experiments, in which we investigate different quantum cryptographic protocols. Our versatile approach relies on a heralded single photon source, a preparation stage at Alice’s sender, a 1 m-long quantum channel, and a detection stage at Bob’s receiver unit. Because the generation and detection is performed using computer generated, re-programmable holograms displayed on spatial light modulators, the same setup can be used to experimentally survey different quantum key distribution techniques and compare their benefits and deficiencies. The investigated protocols are all based on high-dimensional quantum states and include the seminal protocol of Bennett & Brassard, tomographic protocols, and recently introduced differential phase shift protocols [3,4]. We compare the performance of the different approaches in terms of noise resistance and secret key rates. Our study highlights the benefits of using structured photons and high-dimensional quantum states for different implementations and channel conditions. In a second series of experiments, we get a step closer to real world implementations and investigate long distance and underwater quantum cryptography using high-dimensional quantum information encoded on structured light. We establish an approx. 280m long intra-city quantum link and study the influence of turbulence on achievable key rates [5]. We further test the effect of water turbulences on an underwater quantum channel using twisted photons in an outdoor pool of 3 m length [6]. Although we are able establish a secure channel with three dimensional quantum states, we find mode deformations and vortex splitting due to strong turbulent conditions most probably caused by local variations in temperature. We perform a detailed analysis of the observed turbulence and find that underwater channels may give rise to turbulent conditions that are fundamentally different in terms of temporal and spatial disturbance from those present in a free-space channel. [1] H. Rubinsztein-Dunlop et al. Roadmap on structured light, Journal of Optics 19, 013001 (2017) [2] M. Erhard, R. Fickler, M. Krenn, A. Zeilinger, Twisted Photons: New Quantum Perspectives in High Dimensions, Nature Light: Science & Applications, 7 17146 (2018) [3] F. Bouchard et al. Experimental investigation of quantum key distribution protocols with twisted photons, arXiv:1802.05773 [4] F. Bouchard, A. Sit, K. Heshami, R. Fickler, E. Karimi, Round-Robin Differential Phase-Shift Quantum Key Distribution with Twisted Photons, arXiv:1803.00166 [5] A. Sit et al. High-Dimensional Intra-City Quantum Cryptography with Structured Photons, Optica 4, 1006 (2017) [6] F. Bouchard et al. Underwater Quantum Key Distribution in Outdoor Conditions with Twisted Photons, arXiv:1801.10299
Quantum key distribution (QKD) offers the possibility for two individuals to communicate a securely encrypted message. A common technical requirement is the monitoring of signal disturbance in a QKD system to bound the information leakage toward an unwanted eavesdropper. Recently, the round-robin differential-phase-shift (RRDPS) protocol, which encodes bits of information in a high-dimensional state space, was proposed to introduce an upper bound on the amount of Eve's information based on dimensionality of prepared quantum states and randomized measurement settings. Since its introduction, many realizations of the RRDPS protocol were demonstrated using trains of coherent pulses (time bin encoding). Given that this realization of the protocol requires active and random choice of many delays in a delayed Mach-Zehnder interferometer, its implementation can be technically demanding. Here, we propose and experimentally demonstrate an implementation of the RRDPS protocol using the photonic orbital angular momentum degree of freedom in dimensions L=3--8, 16, 32, and 64. In particular, we show that Alice's generation stage and Bob's detection stage can each be reduced to a single phase element, greatly simplifying the implementation. Our scheme offers a practical path to using RRDPS protocol in free-space quantum channels.
In this project we examine several different quantum key distribution protocols which we divide into ones utilizing qubits whose Hilbert spaces are two dimensional and ones whose Hilbert space dimension is greater than two, these units of data in quantum computers are known as qudits and in the papers we'll examine are implemented using the orbital angular momentum of twisted photons. In sections [3] and [4] the specific procedures of each protocol are briefly described and followed by an examination of the theoretical and experimental merits of each protocol. These merits are measured in the bit error rate tolerance eb, which quantifies the maximum channel noise and the key rate R which quantifies the rate at which data is transferred in the protocol. In section [7] we present a unified view of all the relevant data for the different protocols, and argue for the benefits and drawbacks of the different protocols for different applications.
Quantum communication (QC) concerns the faithful transmission of quantum states between separated parties, and represents a key enabler for many quantum applications, ranging from quantum key distribution (QKD) to distributed quantum computing. However, low information rates and short propagation distances, due to high channel losses and perturbations of the quantum states, limit the development of this field and its practical applications. High-dimensional (Hi-D) quantum communication can address these challenges by adding more information per photon, directly enhancing the information rate and the system's error tolerance. We transmit Hi-D quantum states using photons prepared in four orbital angular momentum (OAM) modes in a 1.2 km long OAM-carrying fiber. This is the first experimental demonstration of Hi-D quantum states transmission using the OAM basis over an optical fiber. Furthermore, we successfully implement a real-time decoy-state Hi-D QKD protocol, and demonstrate the highest secret key rate and longest transmission distance of OAM-QKD presented to date.
In quantum key distribution (QKD), protocols are tailored to adopt desirable experimental attributes, including high key rates, operation in high noise levels, and practical security considerations. The round-robin differential phase shift protocol (RRDPS), falling in the family of differential phase shift protocols, was introduced to remove restrictions on the security analysis, such as the requirement to monitor signal disturbances, improving its practicality in implementations. While the RRDPS protocol requires the encoding of single photons in high-dimensional quantum states, at most, only one bit of secret key is distributed per sifted photon. However, another family of protocols, namely high-dimensional (HD) QKD, enlarges the encoding alphabet, allowing single photons to carry more than one bit of secret key each. The high-dimensional BB84 protocol exemplifies the potential benefits of such an encoding scheme, such as larger key rates and higher noise tolerance. Here, we devise an approach to extend the RRDPS QKD to an arbitrarily large encoding alphabet and explore the security consequences. We demonstrate our new framework with a proof-of-concept experiment and show that it can adapt to various experimental conditions by optimizing the protocol parameters. Our approach offers insight into bridging the gap between seemingly incompatible quantum communication schemes by leveraging the unique approaches to information encoding of both HD and DPS QKD.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) promises information-theoretically secure communication, and is already on the verge of commercialization. Thus far, different QKD protocols have been proposed theoretically and implemented experimentally [1, 2]. The next step will be to implement high-dimensional protocols in order to improve noise resistance and increase the data rate [3-7]. Hitherto, no experimental verification of high-dimensional QKD in the single-photon regime has been conducted outside of the laboratory. Here, we report the realization of such a single-photon QKD system in a turbulent free-space link of 0.3 km over the city of Ottawa, taking advantage of both the spin and orbital angular momentum photonic degrees of freedom. This combination of optical angular momenta allows us to create a 4-dimensional state [8]; wherein, using a high-dimensional BB84 protocol [3, 4], a quantum bit error rate of 11\% was attained with a corresponding secret key rate of 0.65 bits per sifted photon. While an error rate of 5\% with a secret key rate of 0.43 bits per sifted photon is achieved for the case of 2-dimensional structured photons. Even through moderate turbulence without active wavefront correction, it is possible to securely transmit information carried by structured photons, opening the way for intra-city high-dimensional quantum communications under realistic conditions.