Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1801.09947

Causality in Quantum Field Theory with Classical Sources - Quantum Electrodynamics

Bo-Sture Skagerstam, Eriksson, Karl-Erik, Per Kristian Rekdal

Published Jan 30, 2018• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In an exact quantum-mechanical framework, we show that expectation values of the second-quantized electro-magnetic fields in the Coulomb gauge, and in the presence of classical sources, automatically lead to causal and retarded electro-magnetic field strengths. The classical $\hbar$-independent Maxwell's equations naturally emerge from this fundamental quantum-mechanical approach in terms of expectation values of quantum fields, and are therefore also consistent with the special theory of relativity. The fundamental difference between interference phenomena due to the linear nature of the classical Maxwell theory as, e.g., in classical optics, and interference effects of quantum states is clarified. The framework outlined also provides for a simple approach to, e.g., spontaneous photon emission and/or absorption processes as well as to the classical Vavilov-Cherenkov radiation. The inherent and necessary quantum fluctuations, limiting a precise space-time knowledge of expectation values of the quantum fields considered, are, finally, recalled.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1801.09947

Related papers

Causality in quantum field theory with classical sources

Bo-Sture Skagerstam, Karl-Erik Eriksson, Per Kristian Rekdal

Abstract In an exact quantum-mechanical framework we show that space-time expectation values of the second-quantized electromagnetic fields in the Coulomb gauge in the presence of a classical conserved source automatically lead to causal and properly retarded ℏ-independent electromagnetic field strengths. The classical ℏ-independent and gauge invariant Maxwell’s equations naturally emerge in terms of quantum-mechanical expectation values and are therefore also consistent with the classical special theory of relativity. The fundamental difference between interference phenomena due to the linear nature of the classical Maxwell theory as considered in, e.g., classical optics, and interference effects of quantum states is clarified. In addition to these issues, the framework outlined also provides for a simple approach to invariance under time-reversal, some spontaneous photon emission and/or absorption processes as well as an approach to Vavilov-Čherenkov radiation. The inherent and necessary quantum uncertainty, limiting a precise space-time knowledge of expectation values of the quantum fields considered, is, finally, recalled.

Journal of Physics Communications•Aug 1, 2019•9 citations

Subclassical fields and polarization in electrodynamics

Mathieu Planat, János Polonyi

Expectation values of the electromagnetic field and the electric current are introduced at space-time resolution which belongs to the quantum domain. These allow us to approach some key features of classical electrodynamics from the underlying QED. One is the emergence of the radiation field in the retarded solution of the Maxwell equation, derived from an action principle. Another question discussed is the systematic derivation of the polarizability of a charge system. Furthermore, the decoherence and the consistency of the photon field are established by a perturbative calculation of the reduced density matrix for the electromagnetic field within the closed time path formalism.

arXiv:1002.2773•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Aug 19, 2010•7 citations

Electromagnetic Fields on a Quantum Scale. I.

Dale M. Grimes, Craig A. Grimes

This is the first in a series of two articles, the second of which provides an exact electro-magnetic field description of photon emission, absorption, and radiation pattern. Photon energy exchanges are analyzed and shown to be the triggered, regenerative response of a non-local eigenstate electron. This first article presents a model-based, hidden variable analysis of quantum theory that provides the statistical nature of wave functions. The analysis uses the equations of classical electro-magnetism and conservation of energy while modeling an eigenstate electron as a nonlocal entity. Essential to the analysis are physical properties that were discovered and analyzed only after the historical interpretation of quantum mechanics was established: electron non-locality and the standing electro-magnetic energy that accompanies and encompasses an active, electrically small volume. The standing energy produces a driving radiation reaction force that, under certain circumstances, is many orders of magnitude larger than currently accepted values. These properties provide a sufficient basis for the Schrödinger equation as a descriptor of non-relativistic eigenstate electrons in or near equilibrium. The uncertainty principle follows, as does the exclusion principle. The analysis leads to atomic stability and causality in the sense that the status of physical phenomena at any instant specifies the status an instant later.

Journal of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology•Oct 1, 2002•3 citations

Maxwell's Equations from Quantum Mechanics I: Gauge Invariance, Conserved Currents, and Hydrogen Atoms as the Sources of the Electromagnetic Field

Daniel Scretching

This paper examines how Maxwell electrodynamics can be recovered as the field-theoretic structure required to consistently couple quantum matter to electromagnetism, while distinguishing what follows from quantum mechanics from what must be supplied independently. Local phase invariance introduces electromagnetic potentials through minimal coupling and yields the homogeneous Maxwell equations as geometric identities, while quantum probability conservation provides a conserved electric current and Ehrenfest dynamics recover the Lorentz-force form. The inhomogeneous Maxwell equations require an additional Lorentz- and gauge-invariant electromagnetic field action, whose vacuum constants satisfy μ0ε0=1/c2\mu_0\varepsilon_0=1/c^2, linking the construction to the SQC/MSC electric–magnetic prefactor relation. Hydrogen is used as an explicit microscopic source: the 1s1s state generates a quantum charge distribution, 2p2p states provide orbital currents and magnetic moments, and 1s1s–2p2p superpositions produce radiative dipole transitions. The treatment is then extended from individual atoms to a hydrogen gas, where polarization and magnetization generate the macroscopic fields DD and HH. The resulting framework shows how quantum sources and material response fit consistently within Maxwell electrodynamics without claiming that quantum mechanics alone uniquely derives the complete electromagnetic field dynamics.

•Oct 2, 2026•0 citations

On the causality of electrodynamics and the Aharonov-Bohm effect

Richard Kowar

This paper presents a \emph{non-instant field model} for electrodynamics that permits a causal explanation of the \emph{Aharonov-Bohm effect} and a \emph{covariant quantization} of the respective Maxwell equations via the \emph{Gupta-Bleuler method}. Our model satisfies the following \emph{correspondence principle}: if $A^μ$, $\vE$, $\vB$ denote the four potential, the electric field and the magnetic field of the non-instant field model, then the respective classical quantities are $\A[A^μ]$, $\A[\vE]$, $\A[\vB]$, where $\A$ is a covariant time averaging operator. Here $\A[A^μ]$ is interpreted as the best possible measurement of the four potential $A^μ$. Although the Lorentz condition is not satisfied for $A^μ$, it is satisfied for $\A[A^μ]$. The latter fact means that the Lorentz condition does not hold for the quantized field but for its expectation value (cf. \emph{Gupta-Bleuler method} of quantization). Finally, we derive the energy conservation law of our field model and show that the field energy is quantized.

arXiv:1111.5755•Nov 24, 2011•0 citations

Maxwell's Equations from Quantum Mechanics III: Synthesis: Gauge Invariance, Conserved Currents, and Hydrogen Atoms as the Sources of the Electromagnetic Field

Daniel Scretching

Maxwell’s equations, formulated in 1865, preceded quantum mechanics by six decades. When the logical direction is reversed, however, the electromagnetic field structure can be interpreted as the form required for a quantum theory of charged matter once three standard ingredients are imposed: local gauge invariance, conserved electric current, and a dynamical electromagnetic field. Quantum mechanics supplies the charged-particle state, probability amplitudes, quantum currents, and—through the Dirac equation—a relativistically consistent description of electron charge and spin. Gauge symmetry then organizes the electromagnetic interaction, while current conservation constrains the admissible source structure. The homogeneous Maxwell identities follow naturally from expressing the field through a four-potential, whereas the sourced Maxwell equations require an additional electromagnetic field action or equivalent dynamical assumption. The resulting framework clarifies both the strength and the limit of a “Maxwell from quantum mechanics” program: quantum theory and gauge structure strongly constrain electromagnetism, but Maxwell field dynamics are not obtained from the electron wave equation alone.

•Oct 4, 2026•0 citations
In an exact quantum-mechanical framework, we show that expectation values of the second-quantized electro-magnetic fields in the Coulomb gauge, and in the presence of classical sources, automatically lead to causal and retarded electro-magnetic field strengths. The classical ℏ\hbarℏ-independent Maxwell's equations naturally emerge from this fundamental quantum-mechanical approach in terms of expectation values of quantum fields, and are therefore also consistent with the special theory of relativity. The fundamental difference between interference phenomena due to the linear nature of the classical Maxwell theory as, e.g., in classical optics, and interference effects of quantum states is clarified. The framework outlined also provides for a simple approach to, e.g., spontaneous photon emission and/or absorption processes as well as to the classical Vavilov-Cherenkov radiation. The inherent and necessary quantum fluctuations, limiting a precise space-time knowledge of expectation values of the quantum fields considered, are, finally, recalled.
Abstract In an exact quantum-mechanical framework we show that space-time expectation values of the second-quantized electromagnetic fields in the Coulomb gauge in the presence of a classical conserved source automatically lead to causal and properly retarded ℏ-independent electromagnetic field strengths. The classical ℏ-independent and gauge invariant Maxwell’s equations naturally emerge in terms of quantum-mechanical expectation values and are therefore also consistent with the classical special theory of relativity. The fundamental difference between interference phenomena due to the linear nature of the classical Maxwell theory as considered in, e.g., classical optics, and interference effects of quantum states is clarified. In addition to these issues, the framework outlined also provides for a simple approach to invariance under time-reversal, some spontaneous photon emission and/or absorption processes as well as an approach to Vavilov-Čherenkov radiation. The inherent and necessary quantum uncertainty, limiting a precise space-time knowledge of expectation values of the quantum fields considered, is, finally, recalled.
Expectation values of the electromagnetic field and the electric current are introduced at space-time resolution which belongs to the quantum domain. These allow us to approach some key features of classical electrodynamics from the underlying QED. One is the emergence of the radiation field in the retarded solution of the Maxwell equation, derived from an action principle. Another question discussed is the systematic derivation of the polarizability of a charge system. Furthermore, the decoherence and the consistency of the photon field are established by a perturbative calculation of the reduced density matrix for the electromagnetic field within the closed time path formalism.
This is the first in a series of two articles, the second of which provides an exact electro-magnetic field description of photon emission, absorption, and radiation pattern. Photon energy exchanges are analyzed and shown to be the triggered, regenerative response of a non-local eigenstate electron. This first article presents a model-based, hidden variable analysis of quantum theory that provides the statistical nature of wave functions. The analysis uses the equations of classical electro-magnetism and conservation of energy while modeling an eigenstate electron as a nonlocal entity. Essential to the analysis are physical properties that were discovered and analyzed only after the historical interpretation of quantum mechanics was established: electron non-locality and the standing electro-magnetic energy that accompanies and encompasses an active, electrically small volume. The standing energy produces a driving radiation reaction force that, under certain circumstances, is many orders of magnitude larger than currently accepted values. These properties provide a sufficient basis for the Schrödinger equation as a descriptor of non-relativistic eigenstate electrons in or near equilibrium. The uncertainty principle follows, as does the exclusion principle. The analysis leads to atomic stability and causality in the sense that the status of physical phenomena at any instant specifies the status an instant later.
This paper examines how Maxwell electrodynamics can be recovered as the field-theoretic structure required to consistently couple quantum matter to electromagnetism, while distinguishing what follows from quantum mechanics from what must be supplied independently. Local phase invariance introduces electromagnetic potentials through minimal coupling and yields the homogeneous Maxwell equations as geometric identities, while quantum probability conservation provides a conserved electric current and Ehrenfest dynamics recover the Lorentz-force form. The inhomogeneous Maxwell equations require an additional Lorentz- and gauge-invariant electromagnetic field action, whose vacuum constants satisfy μ0ε0=1/c2\mu_0\varepsilon_0=1/c^2, linking the construction to the SQC/MSC electric–magnetic prefactor relation. Hydrogen is used as an explicit microscopic source: the 1s1s state generates a quantum charge distribution, 2p2p states provide orbital currents and magnetic moments, and 1s1s–2p2p superpositions produce radiative dipole transitions. The treatment is then extended from individual atoms to a hydrogen gas, where polarization and magnetization generate the macroscopic fields DD and HH. The resulting framework shows how quantum sources and material response fit consistently within Maxwell electrodynamics without claiming that quantum mechanics alone uniquely derives the complete electromagnetic field dynamics.
This paper presents a \emph{non-instant field model} for electrodynamics that permits a causal explanation of the \emph{Aharonov-Bohm effect} and a \emph{covariant quantization} of the respective Maxwell equations via the \emph{Gupta-Bleuler method}. Our model satisfies the following \emph{correspondence principle}: if AμA^μAμ, $\vE$, $\vB$ denote the four potential, the electric field and the magnetic field of the non-instant field model, then the respective classical quantities are $\A[A^μ]$, $\A[\vE]$, $\A[\vB]$, where $\A$ is a covariant time averaging operator. Here $\A[A^μ]$ is interpreted as the best possible measurement of the four potential AμA^μAμ. Although the Lorentz condition is not satisfied for AμA^μAμ, it is satisfied for $\A[A^μ]$. The latter fact means that the Lorentz condition does not hold for the quantized field but for its expectation value (cf. \emph{Gupta-Bleuler method} of quantization). Finally, we derive the energy conservation law of our field model and show that the field energy is quantized.
Maxwell’s equations, formulated in 1865, preceded quantum mechanics by six decades. When the logical direction is reversed, however, the electromagnetic field structure can be interpreted as the form required for a quantum theory of charged matter once three standard ingredients are imposed: local gauge invariance, conserved electric current, and a dynamical electromagnetic field. Quantum mechanics supplies the charged-particle state, probability amplitudes, quantum currents, and—through the Dirac equation—a relativistically consistent description of electron charge and spin. Gauge symmetry then organizes the electromagnetic interaction, while current conservation constrains the admissible source structure. The homogeneous Maxwell identities follow naturally from expressing the field through a four-potential, whereas the sourced Maxwell equations require an additional electromagnetic field action or equivalent dynamical assumption. The resulting framework clarifies both the strength and the limit of a “Maxwell from quantum mechanics” program: quantum theory and gauge structure strongly constrain electromagnetism, but Maxwell field dynamics are not obtained from the electron wave equation alone.