Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1801.06951 · Science

Giant vortex clusters in a two-dimensional quantum fluid

Guillaume Gauthier, Matthew T. Reeves, Xiaoquan Yu, Ashton S. Bradley, Mark A. Baker, Thomas A. Bell, Halina H. Rubinsztein-Dunlop, Matthew J. Davis, Tyler W. Neely

Published Jun 27, 2019• 232 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Clustering vortices Many-body systems generally become more disordered as more energy is pumped into them. A curious exception to this rule was predicted in the context of turbulent flow by the physical chemist Lars Onsager. He suggested that the entropy of certain two-dimensional (2D) systems can decrease with increasing energy, corresponding to an effective negative temperature. Using 2D Bose-Einstein condensates of atoms, Gauthier et al. and Johnstone et al. put Onsager's theory to the test. They provided energy to the system by perturbing the condensate, creating vortices and antivortices. With increasing energy, the system became more ordered as clusters containing either only vortices or only antivortices emerged. Science , this issue p. 1264 , p. 1267

DOI
10.1126/science.aat5718

Related papers

Negative-Temperature Onsager Vortex Clusters in a Quantum Fluid

Guillaume Gauthier, Matthew T. Reeves, Xiaoquan Yu +6 more

Turbulence in classical fluids is a ubiquitous non-equilibrium phenomenon, yet a complete theoretical description for turbulent flow remains a challenging problem. A useful simplification for ideal two-dimensional (2D) fluids is to describe the turbulent flow with long-range-interacting point vortices, each possessing quantised circulation. In 1949, Onsager applied statistical mechanics to determine the equilibria of this model. He showed that at sufficiently high energies, like-circulation vortices preferentially aggregate into large-scale clusters, and are characterised by a negative absolute temperature. Onsager's theory has been highly influential, providing understanding of diverse quasi-2D systems such as turbulent soap films, guiding-centre plasmas, and self-gravitating systems. It also predicts the striking tendency of 2D turbulence to spontaneously form large-scale, long-lived vortices -- Jupiter's Great Red Spot is a well-known example. However, Onsager's theory doesn't quantitatively apply to classical fluids where vorticity is continuous, and experimental systems demonstrating Onsager's point-vortex statistical mechanics have remained elusive. Here we realise high energy, negative-temperature vortex clusters in a uniform superfluid Bose-Einstein condensate. Our results confirm Onsager's prediction of negative temperature clustered phases of quantum vortices, and demonstrate the utility of point-vortex statistical mechanics in 2D quantum fluids. This work opens future directions for the study of turbulent dynamics and we anticipate exploring the entire phase diagram of 2D quantum vortices, including the formation of clusters from 2D quantum turbulence.

•Jan 22, 2018•3 citations

True Mechanism of Spontaneous Order from Turbulence in Two-Dimensional Superfluid Manifolds

Toshiaki Kanai, Wei Guo

In a 2D turbulent fluid containing pointlike vortices, Lars Onsager predicted that adding energy to the fluid can lead to the formation of persistent clusters of like-signed vortices, i.e., Onsager vortex (OV) clusters. In the evolution of 2D superfluid turbulence in a uniform disk-shaped Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC), it was discovered that a pair of OV clusters with opposite signs can form without any energy input. This striking spontaneous order was explained as being due to a vortex evaporative-heating mechanism, i.e., annihilations of vortex-antivortex pairs which remove the lowest-energy vortices and thereby boost the mean energy per vortex. However, in our search for exotic OV states in a boundaryless 2D spherical BEC, we found that OV clusters never form despite the annihilations of vortex pairs. Our analysis reveals that contrary to the general belief, vortex-pair annihilation emits intense sound waves, which damp the motion of all vortices and hence suppress the formation of OV clusters. We also present unequivocal evidence showing that the true mechanism underlying the observed spontaneous OV state is the vortices exiting the BEC boundaries. Uncovering this mechanism paves the way for a comprehensive understanding of emergent vortex orders in 2D manifolds of superfluids driven far from equilibrium.

arXiv:2105.01253•Physical Review Letters•Aug 24, 2021•24 citations

Onsager Vortices at Negative Temperatures

Tapio Simula, Rahil N. Valani, Philip T. Starkey +6 more

We have theoretically [1-5] and experimentally [6] studied statistical mechanics of vortices in two-dimensional superfluids in confined geometries. We are particularly interested in the part of the phase diagram where negative absolute temperature states of the vortex degrees of freedom are realized. The vortex dynamics is driven by two opposing mechanisms: a vortex evaporative heating due to vortex-antivortex annihilations drives the system toward low entropy negative temperature states while the coupling to the  phonon bath results in cooling of the vortices driving the system toward vortex dipole dominated positiver temperature states. Furthermore, we have observed, both theoretically and experimentally, signatures of anomalous dynamical scaling and evolution toward non-thermal fixed points. For sufficiently high energies the Onsager vortex clusters are predicted to undergo Einstein-Bose condensation - a negative temperature counterpart to the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition. [1] T Simula, MJ Davis, K Helmerson, Emergence of Order from Turbulence in an Isolated Planar Superfluid , Physical Review Letters 113, 165302, (2014). [2] AJ Groszek, TP Simula, DM Paganin, K Helmerson, Onsager vortex formation in Bose-Einstein condensates in two-dimensional power-law traps, Physical Review A 93, 043614, (2016). [3] RN Valani, AJ Groszek, TP Simula, Einstein–Bose condensation of Onsager vortices , New Journal of Physics 20, 053038, (2018). [4] AJ Groszek, MJ Davis, DM Paganin, K Helmerson, TP Simula, Vortex thermometry for turbulent two-dimensional fluids, Physical Review Letters 120, 034504, (2018). [5] AJ Groszek, MJ Davis, TP Simula, Decaying quantum turbulence in a two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate at finite temperature , arXiv:1903.05528. [6] Shaun P Johnstone, Andrew J Groszek, Philip T Starkey, Christopher J Billington, Tapio P Simula, Kristian Helmerson, Order from chaos: Observation of large-scale flow from turbulence in a two-dimensional superfluid, arXiv:1801.06952.

StatPhys 27 Main Conference•May 15, 2019•0 citations

Order from chaos: Observation of large-scale flow from turbulence in a two-dimensional superfluid

Shaun Johnstone, Andrew J. Groszek, Philip T. Starkey +3 more

Interacting systems driven far from equilibrium tend to evolve to steady states exhibiting large-scale structure and order. In two-dimensional turbulent flow the seemingly random swirling motion of a fluid can evolve towards persistent large-scale vortices. Lars Onsager proposed a model based on statistical mechanics of quantized vortices to explain such behavior. Here we report the first experimental confirmation of Onsager's model of turbulence. We drag a grid barrier through an oblate superfluid Bose--Einstein condensate to generate non-equilibrium distributions of vortices. We observe an inverse energy cascade driven by the evaporative heating of vortices, leading to steady-state configurations characterized by negative temperatures. Our results open a pathway for quantitative studies of emergent structures in interacting quantum systems driven far from equilibrium.

•Jan 1, 2019•67 citations

Evolution of large-scale flow from turbulence in a two-dimensional superfluid

Shaun P. Johnstone, Andrew J. Groszek, Philip T. Starkey +3 more

Nonequilibrium interacting systems can evolve to exhibit large-scale structure and order. In two-dimensional turbulent flow, the seemingly random swirling motion of a fluid can evolve toward persistent large-scale vortices. To explain such behavior, Lars Onsager proposed a statistical hydrodynamic model based on quantized vortices. Here, we report on the experimental confirmation of Onsager's model. We dragged a grid barrier through an oblate superfluid Bose-Einstein condensate to generate nonequilibrium distributions of vortices. We observed signatures of an inverse energy cascade driven by the evaporative heating of vortices, leading to steady-state configurations characterized by negative absolute temperatures. Our results open a pathway for quantitative studies of emergent structures in interacting quantum systems driven far from equilibrium.

arXiv:1801.06952•Science•Jun 27, 2019•192 citations

Onsager-Kraichnan Condensation in Decaying Two-Dimensional Quantum Turbulence

T. P. Billam, Matthew T. Reeves, Bennett Anderson +1 more

Despite the prominence of Onsager's point-vortex model as a statistical description of 2D classical turbulence, a first-principles development of the model for a realistic superfluid has remained an open problem. Here we develop a mapping of a system of quantum vortices described by the homogeneous 2D Gross-Pitaevskii equation (GPE) to the point-vortex model, enabling Monte Carlo sampling of the vortex microcanonical ensemble. We use this approach to survey the full range of vortex states in a 2D superfluid, from the vortex-dipole gas at positive temperature to negative-temperature states exhibiting both macroscopic vortex clustering and kinetic energy condensation, which we term an Onsager-Kraichnan condensate (OKC). Damped GPE simulations reveal that such OKC states can emerge dynamically, via aggregation of small-scale clusters into giant OKC clusters, as the end states of decaying 2D quantum turbulence in a compressible, finite-temperature superfluid. These statistical equilibrium states should be accessible in atomic Bose-Einstein condensate experiments.

arXiv:1307.6374•Physical Review Letters•Apr 11, 2014•105 citations
Clustering vortices Many-body systems generally become more disordered as more energy is pumped into them. A curious exception to this rule was predicted in the context of turbulent flow by the physical chemist Lars Onsager. He suggested that the entropy of certain two-dimensional (2D) systems can decrease with increasing energy, corresponding to an effective negative temperature. Using 2D Bose-Einstein condensates of atoms, Gauthier et al. and Johnstone et al. put Onsager's theory to the test. They provided energy to the system by perturbing the condensate, creating vortices and antivortices. With increasing energy, the system became more ordered as clusters containing either only vortices or only antivortices emerged. Science , this issue p. 1264 , p. 1267
Turbulence in classical fluids is a ubiquitous non-equilibrium phenomenon, yet a complete theoretical description for turbulent flow remains a challenging problem. A useful simplification for ideal two-dimensional (2D) fluids is to describe the turbulent flow with long-range-interacting point vortices, each possessing quantised circulation. In 1949, Onsager applied statistical mechanics to determine the equilibria of this model. He showed that at sufficiently high energies, like-circulation vortices preferentially aggregate into large-scale clusters, and are characterised by a negative absolute temperature. Onsager's theory has been highly influential, providing understanding of diverse quasi-2D systems such as turbulent soap films, guiding-centre plasmas, and self-gravitating systems. It also predicts the striking tendency of 2D turbulence to spontaneously form large-scale, long-lived vortices -- Jupiter's Great Red Spot is a well-known example. However, Onsager's theory doesn't quantitatively apply to classical fluids where vorticity is continuous, and experimental systems demonstrating Onsager's point-vortex statistical mechanics have remained elusive. Here we realise high energy, negative-temperature vortex clusters in a uniform superfluid Bose-Einstein condensate. Our results confirm Onsager's prediction of negative temperature clustered phases of quantum vortices, and demonstrate the utility of point-vortex statistical mechanics in 2D quantum fluids. This work opens future directions for the study of turbulent dynamics and we anticipate exploring the entire phase diagram of 2D quantum vortices, including the formation of clusters from 2D quantum turbulence.
In a 2D turbulent fluid containing pointlike vortices, Lars Onsager predicted that adding energy to the fluid can lead to the formation of persistent clusters of like-signed vortices, i.e., Onsager vortex (OV) clusters. In the evolution of 2D superfluid turbulence in a uniform disk-shaped Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC), it was discovered that a pair of OV clusters with opposite signs can form without any energy input. This striking spontaneous order was explained as being due to a vortex evaporative-heating mechanism, i.e., annihilations of vortex-antivortex pairs which remove the lowest-energy vortices and thereby boost the mean energy per vortex. However, in our search for exotic OV states in a boundaryless 2D spherical BEC, we found that OV clusters never form despite the annihilations of vortex pairs. Our analysis reveals that contrary to the general belief, vortex-pair annihilation emits intense sound waves, which damp the motion of all vortices and hence suppress the formation of OV clusters. We also present unequivocal evidence showing that the true mechanism underlying the observed spontaneous OV state is the vortices exiting the BEC boundaries. Uncovering this mechanism paves the way for a comprehensive understanding of emergent vortex orders in 2D manifolds of superfluids driven far from equilibrium.
We have theoretically [1-5] and experimentally [6] studied statistical mechanics of vortices in two-dimensional superfluids in confined geometries. We are particularly interested in the part of the phase diagram where negative absolute temperature states of the vortex degrees of freedom are realized. The vortex dynamics is driven by two opposing mechanisms: a vortex evaporative heating due to vortex-antivortex annihilations drives the system toward low entropy negative temperature states while the coupling to the  phonon bath results in cooling of the vortices driving the system toward vortex dipole dominated positiver temperature states. Furthermore, we have observed, both theoretically and experimentally, signatures of anomalous dynamical scaling and evolution toward non-thermal fixed points. For sufficiently high energies the Onsager vortex clusters are predicted to undergo Einstein-Bose condensation - a negative temperature counterpart to the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition. [1] T Simula, MJ Davis, K Helmerson, Emergence of Order from Turbulence in an Isolated Planar Superfluid , Physical Review Letters 113, 165302, (2014). [2] AJ Groszek, TP Simula, DM Paganin, K Helmerson, Onsager vortex formation in Bose-Einstein condensates in two-dimensional power-law traps, Physical Review A 93, 043614, (2016). [3] RN Valani, AJ Groszek, TP Simula, Einstein–Bose condensation of Onsager vortices , New Journal of Physics 20, 053038, (2018). [4] AJ Groszek, MJ Davis, DM Paganin, K Helmerson, TP Simula, Vortex thermometry for turbulent two-dimensional fluids, Physical Review Letters 120, 034504, (2018). [5] AJ Groszek, MJ Davis, TP Simula, Decaying quantum turbulence in a two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate at finite temperature , arXiv:1903.05528. [6] Shaun P Johnstone, Andrew J Groszek, Philip T Starkey, Christopher J Billington, Tapio P Simula, Kristian Helmerson, Order from chaos: Observation of large-scale flow from turbulence in a two-dimensional superfluid, arXiv:1801.06952.
Interacting systems driven far from equilibrium tend to evolve to steady states exhibiting large-scale structure and order. In two-dimensional turbulent flow the seemingly random swirling motion of a fluid can evolve towards persistent large-scale vortices. Lars Onsager proposed a model based on statistical mechanics of quantized vortices to explain such behavior. Here we report the first experimental confirmation of Onsager's model of turbulence. We drag a grid barrier through an oblate superfluid Bose--Einstein condensate to generate non-equilibrium distributions of vortices. We observe an inverse energy cascade driven by the evaporative heating of vortices, leading to steady-state configurations characterized by negative temperatures. Our results open a pathway for quantitative studies of emergent structures in interacting quantum systems driven far from equilibrium.
Nonequilibrium interacting systems can evolve to exhibit large-scale structure and order. In two-dimensional turbulent flow, the seemingly random swirling motion of a fluid can evolve toward persistent large-scale vortices. To explain such behavior, Lars Onsager proposed a statistical hydrodynamic model based on quantized vortices. Here, we report on the experimental confirmation of Onsager's model. We dragged a grid barrier through an oblate superfluid Bose-Einstein condensate to generate nonequilibrium distributions of vortices. We observed signatures of an inverse energy cascade driven by the evaporative heating of vortices, leading to steady-state configurations characterized by negative absolute temperatures. Our results open a pathway for quantitative studies of emergent structures in interacting quantum systems driven far from equilibrium.
Despite the prominence of Onsager's point-vortex model as a statistical description of 2D classical turbulence, a first-principles development of the model for a realistic superfluid has remained an open problem. Here we develop a mapping of a system of quantum vortices described by the homogeneous 2D Gross-Pitaevskii equation (GPE) to the point-vortex model, enabling Monte Carlo sampling of the vortex microcanonical ensemble. We use this approach to survey the full range of vortex states in a 2D superfluid, from the vortex-dipole gas at positive temperature to negative-temperature states exhibiting both macroscopic vortex clustering and kinetic energy condensation, which we term an Onsager-Kraichnan condensate (OKC). Damped GPE simulations reveal that such OKC states can emerge dynamically, via aggregation of small-scale clusters into giant OKC clusters, as the end states of decaying 2D quantum turbulence in a compressible, finite-temperature superfluid. These statistical equilibrium states should be accessible in atomic Bose-Einstein condensate experiments.