Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1801.03636 · Physical Review A

Testing collapse models by a thermometer

M. Bahrami

Published May 18, 2018• 60 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Collapse models postulate that space is filled with a collapse noise field, inducing quantum Brownian motions, which are dominant during the measurement, thus causing collapse of the wave function. An important manifestation of the collapse noise field, if any, is thermal energy generation, thus disturbing the temperature profile of a system. The experimental investigation of a collapse-driven heating effect has provided, so far, the most promising test of collapse models against standard quantum theory. In this paper, we calculate the collapse-driven heat generation for a three-dimensional multi-atomic Bravais lattice by solving stochastic Heisenberg equations. We perform our calculation for the mass-proportional continuous spontaneous localization collapse model with nonwhite noise. We obtain the temperature distribution of a sphere under stationary-state and insulated surface conditions. However, the exact quantification of the collapse-driven heat-generation effect highly depends on the actual value of cutoff in the collapse noise spectrum.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.97.052118

Related papers

Heating effects and localization mechanism in cold Bose gases

Marco Bilardello

Collapse models solve the measurement problem by adding non-linear and stochastic terms to the usual Schroedinger dynamics. The resulting dynamics localizes in position macroscopic systems, while preserves quantum mechanical predictions for microscopic systems. \nTwo of the main consequences of this resulting dynamics are: the loss of any initial spatial coherence, with a decoherence rate which increases with the dimensions of the system (amplification mechanism); and a heating effect induced on the system that, for long times, leads either to a divergent or to a convergent value of the energy, depending on the particular collapse model considered. \nAn interesting class of system to experimentally test collapse models are cold atomic gases. Besides their very low temperatures (T = 10^(-11) - 10^(-7)K), cold atomic gases show mesoscopic quantum properties, i.e. involving a number of atoms of order of N = 10^(3)– 10^(11). These are all necessary ingredients to experimentally test collapse models. In this thesis, we use cold bosonic atomic gas to test one of the most studied and complete among collapse models, i.e. CSL, and also its non-Markovian and dissipative extensions. In particular, in this thesis we put bounds on CSL free-parameters by studying the diffusion effect induced by collapse noise on a free expanding gas, and we compare the theoretical results with experimental data known in literature. The bounds we put are among the strongest ever found non only for CSL model, but especially for its non-Markovian extension. \nIn this thesis we also specialize the CSL dynamics in Bose-Josephson junctions, and we focus on the localization mechanism induced by the noise on initially entangled states. In particular, we focus on decoherence induced by CSL on typical entangled states as atomic coherent states and NOON states. We find that in the latter ones, CSL effects become significant when the NOON state is composed by a number of atoms of 10^(4) or greater. Moreover, we compare CSL decoherence with environmental decoherence induced by typical realistic sources, as an external thermal cloud, imperfections in the trapping laser, and three body effects. We then find which conditions experiments must fulfill in order to test CSL in a Bose-Josephson junction in conditions never

•Apr 12, 2017•2 citations

Colored collapse models from the non-interferometric perspective

Matteo Carlesso, Luca Ferialdi, Angelo Bassi

Abstract Models of spontaneous wave function collapse describe the quantum-to-classical transition by assuming a progressive breakdown of the superposition principle when the mass of the system increases, providing a well-defined phenomenology in terms of a non-linearly and stochastically modified Schrödinger equation, which can be tested experimentally. The most popular of such models is the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) model: in its original version, the collapse is driven by a white noise, and more recently, generalizations in terms of colored noises, which are more realistic, have been formulated. We will analyze how current non-interferometric tests bound the model, depending on the spectrum of the noise. We will find that low frequency purely mechanical experiments provide the most stable and strongest bounds. Graphical abstract

arXiv:1805.10100•The European Physical Journal D•Sep 1, 2018•30 citations

Proposing new experiments to test the quantum-to-classical transition

M Bahrami, Angelo Bassi

An open problem in modern physics is why microscopic quantum objects can be at two places at once (i.e. a superposed quantum state) while macroscpoic classical object never show such a behaviour. Collapse models provides a quantitative answer for this problem and explain how macroscopic classical world emerges out of microscopic quantum world. A universal noise field is postulated in collapse models, inducing appropriate Brownian- motion corrections to standard quantum dynamics. The strength of collapse-driven Brownian fluctuations depend on: (i) the parameters characterizing the system (e.g., mass, size, density), and (ii) two phenomenological parameters defining the statistical properties of the collapse noise. The collapse-driven Brownian motion works such that microscopic systems behave quantum mechanically, while macroscopic objects are classical. At the intermediate mesocopic scale, collapse models predict deviations from standard quantum predictions. This issue has been subject of experimental tests. All experiments to date have been at the scales where collapse effects are negligible for all practical purposes. However, recent experimental progress in revealing quantum features of larger objects, increases the hope for testing at unprecedented scales where collapse models can be falsified. Current experiments are mainly focused on the preparation of macroscopic systems in a spatial quantum superposition state. The collapse effects would then manifest as loss of visibility in the observed inference pattern. However, one needs a quantum interference with single particles of mass ∼ 10 10 amu for a decisive test of collapse models. Creating such massive superpositionsis quite challenging, and beyond currectstate-of-the-art. Quite recently, an alternative approach has been proposed where the collapse manifests in the fluctuating properties of light interacting with the quantum system. The great advantage of this new approach is that here there is no need for the preparation of a quantum superposed state. It has been discussed that promising results can be revealed in the spectrum of light interacting with a radiation pressure-driven mechanical oscillator in a cavity optomechanics setting. Here, we review the theoretical modelling of the above optomechenical proposal. We discuss how collapse-driven Brownian motion modifies the spectrum. We quantify the collapse effect and explain how it depends on the parameters of the mechanical oscillator (e.g., mass, density, geometry).

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 3, 2015•2 citations

Testing wave-function-collapse models using parametric heating of a trapped nanosphere

Daniel Goldwater, Mauro Paternostro, P. F. Barker

We propose a mechanism for testing the theory of collapse models such as continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) by examining the parametric heating rate of a trapped nanosphere. The random localizations of the center of mass for a given particle predicted by the CSL model can be understood as a stochastic force embodying a source of heating for the nanosphere. We show that by utilizing a Paul trap to levitate the particle and optical cooling, it is possible to reduce environmental decoherence to such a level that CSL dominates the dynamics and contributes the main source of heating. We show that this approach allows measurements to be made on the time scale of seconds and that the free parameter ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\mathrm{csl}}$ which characterizes the model ought to be testable to values as low as ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}12}$ Hz.

arXiv:1506.08782•Physical Review A•Jul 14, 2016•96 citations

Minimum Interior Temperature for Solid Objects Implied by Collapse Models

Stephen L. Adler

Heating induced by the noise postulated in wave function collapse models leads to a lower bound to the temperature of solid objects. For the noise parameter values $λ={\rm coupling~strength}\sim 10^{-8} {\rm s}^{-1}$ and $r_C ={\rm correlation~length} \sim 10^{-5} {\rm cm}$, which were suggested \cite{adler1} to make latent image formation an indicator of wave function collapse and which are consistent with the recent experiment of Vinante et al. \cite{vin}, the effect may be observable. For metals, where the heat conductivity is proportional to the temperature at low temperatures, the lower bound (specifically for RRR=30 copper) is $\sim 5\times 10^{-11} (L/r_C) $K, with L the size of the object. For the thermal insulator Torlon 4203, the comparable lower bound is $\sim 3 \times 10^{-6} (L/r_c)^{0.63}$ K. We first give a rough estimate for a cubical metal solid, and then give an exact solution of the heat transfer problem for a sphere.

arXiv:1712.01071•Dec 4, 2017•1 citation

Experimental test of spontaneous collapse models with mechanical systems

Andrea Vinante

Spontaneous collapse models have been proposed as a possible realist solution of the quantum measurement problem. They assume that the standard unitary evolution is valid only in the microscopic limit, with stochastic corrections leading to a dynamical reduction of the wave function at macroscopic level. A remarkable feature of collapse models is that, unlike interpretations of quantum mechanics, they predict departures from standard theory that can be experimentally tested. A common prediction is a violation of energy conservation, which manifests as an universal force noise acting on mechanical systems. Here, we will discuss recent bounds on collapse models set by mechanical experiments, focusing on ultracold cantilevers and gravitational wave detectors. First notable results are a partial exclusion of the CSL parameters proposed by Adler and a full exclusion of an early model based on quantum gravity arguments.

Corfu Summer Institute School and Workshops on Elementary Particle Physics and Gravity (CORFU)•Aug 22, 2018•0 citations
Collapse models postulate that space is filled with a collapse noise field, inducing quantum Brownian motions, which are dominant during the measurement, thus causing collapse of the wave function. An important manifestation of the collapse noise field, if any, is thermal energy generation, thus disturbing the temperature profile of a system. The experimental investigation of a collapse-driven heating effect has provided, so far, the most promising test of collapse models against standard quantum theory. In this paper, we calculate the collapse-driven heat generation for a three-dimensional multi-atomic Bravais lattice by solving stochastic Heisenberg equations. We perform our calculation for the mass-proportional continuous spontaneous localization collapse model with nonwhite noise. We obtain the temperature distribution of a sphere under stationary-state and insulated surface conditions. However, the exact quantification of the collapse-driven heat-generation effect highly depends on the actual value of cutoff in the collapse noise spectrum.
Collapse models solve the measurement problem by adding non-linear and stochastic terms to the usual Schroedinger dynamics. The resulting dynamics localizes in position macroscopic systems, while preserves quantum mechanical predictions for microscopic systems. \nTwo of the main consequences of this resulting dynamics are: the loss of any initial spatial coherence, with a decoherence rate which increases with the dimensions of the system (amplification mechanism); and a heating effect induced on the system that, for long times, leads either to a divergent or to a convergent value of the energy, depending on the particular collapse model considered. \nAn interesting class of system to experimentally test collapse models are cold atomic gases. Besides their very low temperatures (T = 10^(-11) - 10^(-7)K), cold atomic gases show mesoscopic quantum properties, i.e. involving a number of atoms of order of N = 10^(3)– 10^(11). These are all necessary ingredients to experimentally test collapse models. In this thesis, we use cold bosonic atomic gas to test one of the most studied and complete among collapse models, i.e. CSL, and also its non-Markovian and dissipative extensions. In particular, in this thesis we put bounds on CSL free-parameters by studying the diffusion effect induced by collapse noise on a free expanding gas, and we compare the theoretical results with experimental data known in literature. The bounds we put are among the strongest ever found non only for CSL model, but especially for its non-Markovian extension. \nIn this thesis we also specialize the CSL dynamics in Bose-Josephson junctions, and we focus on the localization mechanism induced by the noise on initially entangled states. In particular, we focus on decoherence induced by CSL on typical entangled states as atomic coherent states and NOON states. We find that in the latter ones, CSL effects become significant when the NOON state is composed by a number of atoms of 10^(4) or greater. Moreover, we compare CSL decoherence with environmental decoherence induced by typical realistic sources, as an external thermal cloud, imperfections in the trapping laser, and three body effects. We then find which conditions experiments must fulfill in order to test CSL in a Bose-Josephson junction in conditions never
Abstract Models of spontaneous wave function collapse describe the quantum-to-classical transition by assuming a progressive breakdown of the superposition principle when the mass of the system increases, providing a well-defined phenomenology in terms of a non-linearly and stochastically modified Schrödinger equation, which can be tested experimentally. The most popular of such models is the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) model: in its original version, the collapse is driven by a white noise, and more recently, generalizations in terms of colored noises, which are more realistic, have been formulated. We will analyze how current non-interferometric tests bound the model, depending on the spectrum of the noise. We will find that low frequency purely mechanical experiments provide the most stable and strongest bounds. Graphical abstract
An open problem in modern physics is why microscopic quantum objects can be at two places at once (i.e. a superposed quantum state) while macroscpoic classical object never show such a behaviour. Collapse models provides a quantitative answer for this problem and explain how macroscopic classical world emerges out of microscopic quantum world. A universal noise field is postulated in collapse models, inducing appropriate Brownian- motion corrections to standard quantum dynamics. The strength of collapse-driven Brownian fluctuations depend on: (i) the parameters characterizing the system (e.g., mass, size, density), and (ii) two phenomenological parameters defining the statistical properties of the collapse noise. The collapse-driven Brownian motion works such that microscopic systems behave quantum mechanically, while macroscopic objects are classical. At the intermediate mesocopic scale, collapse models predict deviations from standard quantum predictions. This issue has been subject of experimental tests. All experiments to date have been at the scales where collapse effects are negligible for all practical purposes. However, recent experimental progress in revealing quantum features of larger objects, increases the hope for testing at unprecedented scales where collapse models can be falsified. Current experiments are mainly focused on the preparation of macroscopic systems in a spatial quantum superposition state. The collapse effects would then manifest as loss of visibility in the observed inference pattern. However, one needs a quantum interference with single particles of mass ∼ 10 10 amu for a decisive test of collapse models. Creating such massive superpositionsis quite challenging, and beyond currectstate-of-the-art. Quite recently, an alternative approach has been proposed where the collapse manifests in the fluctuating properties of light interacting with the quantum system. The great advantage of this new approach is that here there is no need for the preparation of a quantum superposed state. It has been discussed that promising results can be revealed in the spectrum of light interacting with a radiation pressure-driven mechanical oscillator in a cavity optomechanics setting. Here, we review the theoretical modelling of the above optomechenical proposal. We discuss how collapse-driven Brownian motion modifies the spectrum. We quantify the collapse effect and explain how it depends on the parameters of the mechanical oscillator (e.g., mass, density, geometry).
We propose a mechanism for testing the theory of collapse models such as continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) by examining the parametric heating rate of a trapped nanosphere. The random localizations of the center of mass for a given particle predicted by the CSL model can be understood as a stochastic force embodying a source of heating for the nanosphere. We show that by utilizing a Paul trap to levitate the particle and optical cooling, it is possible to reduce environmental decoherence to such a level that CSL dominates the dynamics and contributes the main source of heating. We show that this approach allows measurements to be made on the time scale of seconds and that the free parameter ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\mathrm{csl}}$ which characterizes the model ought to be testable to values as low as ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}12}$ Hz.
Heating induced by the noise postulated in wave function collapse models leads to a lower bound to the temperature of solid objects. For the noise parameter values λ=coupling strength∼10−8s−1λ={\rm coupling~strength}\sim 10^{-8} {\rm s}^{-1}λ=coupling strength∼10−8s−1 and rC=correlation length∼10−5cmr_C ={\rm correlation~length} \sim 10^{-5} {\rm cm}rC​=correlation length∼10−5cm, which were suggested \cite{adler1} to make latent image formation an indicator of wave function collapse and which are consistent with the recent experiment of Vinante et al. \cite{vin}, the effect may be observable. For metals, where the heat conductivity is proportional to the temperature at low temperatures, the lower bound (specifically for RRR=30 copper) is $\sim 5\times 10^{-11} (L/r_C) $K, with L the size of the object. For the thermal insulator Torlon 4203, the comparable lower bound is ∼3×10−6(L/rc)0.63\sim 3 \times 10^{-6} (L/r_c)^{0.63}∼3×10−6(L/rc​)0.63 K. We first give a rough estimate for a cubical metal solid, and then give an exact solution of the heat transfer problem for a sphere.
Spontaneous collapse models have been proposed as a possible realist solution of the quantum measurement problem. They assume that the standard unitary evolution is valid only in the microscopic limit, with stochastic corrections leading to a dynamical reduction of the wave function at macroscopic level. A remarkable feature of collapse models is that, unlike interpretations of quantum mechanics, they predict departures from standard theory that can be experimentally tested. A common prediction is a violation of energy conservation, which manifests as an universal force noise acting on mechanical systems. Here, we will discuss recent bounds on collapse models set by mechanical experiments, focusing on ultracold cantilevers and gravitational wave detectors. First notable results are a partial exclusion of the CSL parameters proposed by Adler and a full exclusion of an early model based on quantum gravity arguments.