Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1710.04220 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Entanglement entropy from tensor network states for stabilizer codes

Huan He, Yunqin Zheng, Bogdan Andrei Bernevig, Nicolas Regnault

Published Mar 1, 2018• 79 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we present the construction of tensor network states (TNS) for some of the degenerate ground states of three-dimensional (3D) stabilizer codes. We then use the TNS formalism to obtain the entanglement spectrum and entropy of these ground states for some special cuts. In particular, we work out examples of the 3D toric code, the X-cube model, and the Haah code. The latter two models belong to the category of ``fracton'' models proposed recently, while the first one belongs to the conventional topological phases. We mention the cases for which the entanglement entropy and spectrum can be calculated exactly: For these, the constructed TNS is a singular value decomposition (SVD) of the ground states with respect to particular entanglement cuts. Apart from the area law, the entanglement entropies also have constant and linear corrections for the fracton models, while the entanglement entropies for the toric code models only have constant corrections. For the cuts we consider, the entanglement spectra of these three models are completely flat. We also conjecture that the negative linear correction to the area law is a signature of extensive ground-state degeneracy. Moreover, the transfer matrices of these TNSs can be constructed. We show that the transfer matrices are projectors whose eigenvalues are either 1 or 0. The number of nonzero eigenvalues is tightly related to the ground-state degeneracy.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.97.125102

Related papers

$\mathbb{Z}_N$ generalizations of three-dimensional stabilizer codes

Lee, Chanbeen, Yaozong Hu, Gil Young Cho +1 more

In this work, we generalize several three-dimensional Z2 stabilizer models--including the X-cube model, the three-dimensional toric code, and Haah's code--to their ZN counterparts. Under periodic boundary conditions, we analyze their ground state degeneracies and topological excitations, and uncover behaviors that strongly depend on system size. For the X-cube model, we identify excitations with mobility restricted under local operations but relaxed under nonlocal ones derived from global topology. These excitations, previously confined to open boundaries in the Z2 model, now appear even under periodic boundaries. In the toric code, we observe nontrivial braiding between string and point excitations despite the absence of ground state degeneracy, indicating long-range entanglement independent of topological degeneracy. Again, this effect extends from open to periodic boundaries in the generalized models. For Haah's code, we find new excitations--fracton tripoles and monopoles--that remain globally constrained, along with a relaxation of immobility giving rise to lineons and planons. These results reveal new forms of topological order and suggest a broader framework for understanding fracton phases beyond the conventional Z2 setting.

arXiv:2504.09847•Apr 14, 2025•0 citations

Topological entanglement entropy of fracton stabilizer codes

Han Ma, Albert T. Schmitz, S. A. Parameswaran +2 more

Entanglement entropy provides a powerful characterization of two-dimensional gapped topological phases of quantum matter, intimately tied to their description by topological quantum field theories (TQFTs). Fracton topological orders are three-dimensional gapped topologically ordered states of matter that lack a TQFT description. We show that three-dimensional fracton phases are nevertheless characterized, at least partially, by universal structure in the entanglement entropy of their ground-state wave functions. We explicitly compute the entanglement entropy for two archetypal fracton models, the ``X-cube model'' and ``Haah's code,'' and demonstrate the existence of a nonlocal contribution that scales linearly in subsystem size. We show via Schrieffer-Wolff transformations that this piece of the entanglement entropy of fracton models is robust against arbitrary local perturbations of the Hamiltonian. Finally, we argue that these results may be extended to characterize localization-protected fracton topological order in excited states of disordered fracton models.

arXiv:1710.01744•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 1, 2018•111 citations

Entanglement spectra of stabilizer codes: A window into gapped quantum phases of matter

Albert T. Schmitz, Sheng-Jie Huang, Abhinav Prem

The entanglement spectrum (ES) provides a barometer of quantum entanglement and encodes physical information beyond that contained in the entanglement entropy. In this paper, we explore the ES of stabilizer codes, which furnish exactly solvable models for a plethora of gapped quantum phases of matter. Studying the ES for stabilizer Hamiltonians in the presence of arbitrary weak local perturbations thus allows us to develop a general framework within which the entanglement features of gapped topological phases can be computed and contrasted. In particular, we study models harboring fracton order, both type-I and type-II, and compare the resulting ES with that of both conventional topological order and of (strong) subsystem symmetry protected topological (SSPT) states. We find that nonlocal surface stabilizers (NLSS), a set of symmetries of the Hamiltonian which form on the boundary of the entanglement cut, act as purveyors of universal nonlocal features appearing in the entanglement spectrum. While in conventional topological orders and fracton orders, the NLSS retain a form of topological invariance with respect to the entanglement cut, subsystem symmetric systems---fracton and SSPT phases---additionally show a nontrivial geometric dependence on the entanglement cut, corresponding to the subsystem symmetry. This sheds further light on the interplay between geometric and topological effects in fracton phases of matter and demonstrates that strong SSPT phases harbour a measure of quasilocal entanglement beyond that encountered in conventional SPT phases. We further show that a version of the edge-entanglement correspondence, established earlier for gapped two-dimensional topological phases, also holds for gapped three-dimensional fracton models.

arXiv:1901.10486•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 8, 2019•31 citations

On the stability of topological order in tensor network states

Dominic J. Williamson, Clement Delcamp, Frank Verstraete +1 more

We construct a tensor network representation of the three-dimensional (3D) toric code ground state that is stable to a generating set of uniform local tensor perturbations, including those that do not map to local operators on the physical Hilbert space. The stability is established by mapping the phase diagram of the perturbed tensor network to that of the 3D Ising gauge theory, which has a nonzero finite temperature transition. More generally, we find that the stability of a topological tensor network state is determined by the form of its virtual symmetries and the topological excitations created by virtual operators that break those symmetries. In particular, a dual representation of the 3D toric code ground state, as well as representations of the $X$-cube and cubic code ground states, for which pointlike excitations are created by such operators, are found to be unstable.

arXiv:2012.15346•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 27, 2021•16 citations

Z N generalizations of three-dimensional stabilizer codes

Chanbeen Lee, Yaozong Hu, Gil Young Cho +1 more

The authors generalize here three-dimensional \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}${}_{2}$ stabilizer models---the X-cube, toric code, and Haah's code---to their \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}${}_{N}$ counterparts, revealing size-dependent ground-state degeneracy and novel excitations. They demonstrate that the generalized X-cube hosts quasi-fractons that remain immobile under local operations but become mobile via global ones. In the toric code, both closed-loop and open-string excitations emerge, while Haah's code features new fracton tripole and monopole excitations. These findings uncover unconventional topological orders and broaden the understanding of fracton phases beyond the conventional \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}${}_{2}$ framework.

Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 24, 2025•1 citation

Spectra of Tensor Networks and Entanglement Measures

PAULO SÉRGIO DE ANDRADE

Tensor networks have emerged as a powerful theoretical and computational framework for understanding and simulating quantum many-body systems. Their efficiency in representing quantum states, particularly those satisfying area laws of entanglement, is intimately linked to the structure of their constituent tensors. A fundamental aspect of these networks is their spectral properties, which manifest in various forms, such as the singular values of bond tensors or the eigenvalues of associated transfer matrices. Concurrently, entanglement measures provide quantitative insights into the quantum correlations present within these systems. This paper explores the intricate relationship between the spectra arising from tensor network representations and the different entanglement measures used to characterize quantum states. We delve into how the decay rates of singular values directly impact entanglement entropy, how entanglement spectra derived from Schmidt decompositions can reveal topological order, and how the spectral gaps of transfer matrices are connected to correlation lengths. By analyzing various tensor network architectures, including Matrix Product States (MPS) and Projected Entangled Pair States (PEPS), we elucidate the mechanisms through which their spectral features encode profound information about quantum entanglement. The study highlights how a deeper understanding of these spectral properties can not only guide the construction of more efficient tensor network algorithms but also provide fundamental insights into the nature of quantum phases and phase transitions.

•Nov 23, 2025•0 citations
In this paper, we present the construction of tensor network states (TNS) for some of the degenerate ground states of three-dimensional (3D) stabilizer codes. We then use the TNS formalism to obtain the entanglement spectrum and entropy of these ground states for some special cuts. In particular, we work out examples of the 3D toric code, the X-cube model, and the Haah code. The latter two models belong to the category of ``fracton'' models proposed recently, while the first one belongs to the conventional topological phases. We mention the cases for which the entanglement entropy and spectrum can be calculated exactly: For these, the constructed TNS is a singular value decomposition (SVD) of the ground states with respect to particular entanglement cuts. Apart from the area law, the entanglement entropies also have constant and linear corrections for the fracton models, while the entanglement entropies for the toric code models only have constant corrections. For the cuts we consider, the entanglement spectra of these three models are completely flat. We also conjecture that the negative linear correction to the area law is a signature of extensive ground-state degeneracy. Moreover, the transfer matrices of these TNSs can be constructed. We show that the transfer matrices are projectors whose eigenvalues are either 1 or 0. The number of nonzero eigenvalues is tightly related to the ground-state degeneracy.
ZN\mathbb{Z}_NZN​ generalizations of three-dimensional stabilizer codes
In this work, we generalize several three-dimensional Z2 stabilizer models--including the X-cube model, the three-dimensional toric code, and Haah's code--to their ZN counterparts. Under periodic boundary conditions, we analyze their ground state degeneracies and topological excitations, and uncover behaviors that strongly depend on system size. For the X-cube model, we identify excitations with mobility restricted under local operations but relaxed under nonlocal ones derived from global topology. These excitations, previously confined to open boundaries in the Z2 model, now appear even under periodic boundaries. In the toric code, we observe nontrivial braiding between string and point excitations despite the absence of ground state degeneracy, indicating long-range entanglement independent of topological degeneracy. Again, this effect extends from open to periodic boundaries in the generalized models. For Haah's code, we find new excitations--fracton tripoles and monopoles--that remain globally constrained, along with a relaxation of immobility giving rise to lineons and planons. These results reveal new forms of topological order and suggest a broader framework for understanding fracton phases beyond the conventional Z2 setting.
Entanglement entropy provides a powerful characterization of two-dimensional gapped topological phases of quantum matter, intimately tied to their description by topological quantum field theories (TQFTs). Fracton topological orders are three-dimensional gapped topologically ordered states of matter that lack a TQFT description. We show that three-dimensional fracton phases are nevertheless characterized, at least partially, by universal structure in the entanglement entropy of their ground-state wave functions. We explicitly compute the entanglement entropy for two archetypal fracton models, the ``X-cube model'' and ``Haah's code,'' and demonstrate the existence of a nonlocal contribution that scales linearly in subsystem size. We show via Schrieffer-Wolff transformations that this piece of the entanglement entropy of fracton models is robust against arbitrary local perturbations of the Hamiltonian. Finally, we argue that these results may be extended to characterize localization-protected fracton topological order in excited states of disordered fracton models.
The entanglement spectrum (ES) provides a barometer of quantum entanglement and encodes physical information beyond that contained in the entanglement entropy. In this paper, we explore the ES of stabilizer codes, which furnish exactly solvable models for a plethora of gapped quantum phases of matter. Studying the ES for stabilizer Hamiltonians in the presence of arbitrary weak local perturbations thus allows us to develop a general framework within which the entanglement features of gapped topological phases can be computed and contrasted. In particular, we study models harboring fracton order, both type-I and type-II, and compare the resulting ES with that of both conventional topological order and of (strong) subsystem symmetry protected topological (SSPT) states. We find that nonlocal surface stabilizers (NLSS), a set of symmetries of the Hamiltonian which form on the boundary of the entanglement cut, act as purveyors of universal nonlocal features appearing in the entanglement spectrum. While in conventional topological orders and fracton orders, the NLSS retain a form of topological invariance with respect to the entanglement cut, subsystem symmetric systems---fracton and SSPT phases---additionally show a nontrivial geometric dependence on the entanglement cut, corresponding to the subsystem symmetry. This sheds further light on the interplay between geometric and topological effects in fracton phases of matter and demonstrates that strong SSPT phases harbour a measure of quasilocal entanglement beyond that encountered in conventional SPT phases. We further show that a version of the edge-entanglement correspondence, established earlier for gapped two-dimensional topological phases, also holds for gapped three-dimensional fracton models.
We construct a tensor network representation of the three-dimensional (3D) toric code ground state that is stable to a generating set of uniform local tensor perturbations, including those that do not map to local operators on the physical Hilbert space. The stability is established by mapping the phase diagram of the perturbed tensor network to that of the 3D Ising gauge theory, which has a nonzero finite temperature transition. More generally, we find that the stability of a topological tensor network state is determined by the form of its virtual symmetries and the topological excitations created by virtual operators that break those symmetries. In particular, a dual representation of the 3D toric code ground state, as well as representations of the XXX-cube and cubic code ground states, for which pointlike excitations are created by such operators, are found to be unstable.
The authors generalize here three-dimensional \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}2{}_{2}2​ stabilizer models---the X-cube, toric code, and Haah's code---to their \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}N{}_{N}N​ counterparts, revealing size-dependent ground-state degeneracy and novel excitations. They demonstrate that the generalized X-cube hosts quasi-fractons that remain immobile under local operations but become mobile via global ones. In the toric code, both closed-loop and open-string excitations emerge, while Haah's code features new fracton tripole and monopole excitations. These findings uncover unconventional topological orders and broaden the understanding of fracton phases beyond the conventional \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}2{}_{2}2​ framework.
Tensor networks have emerged as a powerful theoretical and computational framework for understanding and simulating quantum many-body systems. Their efficiency in representing quantum states, particularly those satisfying area laws of entanglement, is intimately linked to the structure of their constituent tensors. A fundamental aspect of these networks is their spectral properties, which manifest in various forms, such as the singular values of bond tensors or the eigenvalues of associated transfer matrices. Concurrently, entanglement measures provide quantitative insights into the quantum correlations present within these systems. This paper explores the intricate relationship between the spectra arising from tensor network representations and the different entanglement measures used to characterize quantum states. We delve into how the decay rates of singular values directly impact entanglement entropy, how entanglement spectra derived from Schmidt decompositions can reveal topological order, and how the spectral gaps of transfer matrices are connected to correlation lengths. By analyzing various tensor network architectures, including Matrix Product States (MPS) and Projected Entangled Pair States (PEPS), we elucidate the mechanisms through which their spectral features encode profound information about quantum entanglement. The study highlights how a deeper understanding of these spectral properties can not only guide the construction of more efficient tensor network algorithms but also provide fundamental insights into the nature of quantum phases and phase transitions.