Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1709.07194 · New Journal of Physics

Limitations of rotating-wave approximation in magnetic resonance: characterization and elimination of the Bloch–Siegert shift in magneto-optics

Julia Sudyka, Szymon Pustelny, Wojciech Gawlik

Published Dec 10, 2018• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present investigations of radio-frequency (RF) resonances observed in an optically pumped rubidium vapor. By measuring the systematic shifts (the Bloch–Siegert shifts) of RF resonances in low magnetic fields, we demonstrate limitations of the rotating-wave approximation in the case of angular momentum F ≥ 1. The resonance shifts and deformations are characterized in a wide range of parameters and it is shown that the observed behavior is far more complex than in a standard two-level system. It is also demonstrated that the shifts can be controllably turned on or off by switching between the oscillating and rotating magnetic field. Experimental results are supported with numerical calculations, reproducing all features of the observed signals. Besides fundamental aspect of the research, application of rotating magnetic field helps to suppress/evaluate spectroscopic-measurement and precise-metrology systematic errors. The reported study has also important implications for quantum metrology and information processing beyond RWA and standard two-state qubit dynamics.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/aaf778

Related papers

Effect of the Bloch-Siegert Shift on the Frequency Responses of Rabi Oscillations in the Case of Nutation Resonance

A. P. Saǐko, Fedoruk, G. G.

The dynamics of a two-level spin system dressed by bichromatic radiation is studied under the conditions of double resonance when the frequency of one (microwave) field is equal to the Larmor frequency of the spin system and the frequency of the other (radio-frequency) field ω_{rf} is close to the Rabi frequency ω_{1} in a micro-wave field. It is shown theoretically that Rabi oscillations between dressed-spin states with the frequency εare accompanied by higher-frequency oscillations at frequencies nω_{rf} and nω_{rf}\pm ε, where n = 1, 2, .... The most intense among these are the signals corresponding to n = 1. The counter-rotating (antiresonance) components of the RF field give rise to a shift of the dressed-state energy, i.e., to a frequency shift similar to the Bloch-Siegert shift. In particular, this shift is manifested as the dependence of the Rabi-oscillation frequency εon the sign of the detuning ω{1} -ω{rf} from resonance. In the case of double resonance, the oscillation amplitude is asymmetric; i.e., the amplitude at the sum frequency ω_{rf} +εincreases, while the amplitude at the difference frequency ω_{rf} -εdecreases. The predicted effects are confirmed by observations of the nutation signals of the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) of centers in quartz and should be taken into account to realize qubits with a low Rabi frequency in solids.

arXiv:0806.0534•Jun 3, 2008•0 citations

Suppression of error in qubit rotations due to Bloch–Siegert oscillation via the use of off-resonant Raman excitation

Prabhakar Pradhan, George C. Cardoso, M. S. Shahriar

The rotation of a quantum bit (qubit) is an important step in quantum computation. The rotation is generally performed using a Rabi oscillation. In a direct two-level qubit system, if the Rabi frequency is comparable to its resonance frequency, the rotating wave approximation is not valid, and the Rabi oscillation is accompanied by the so-called Bloch–Siegert oscillation (BSO) that occurs at twice the frequency of the driving field. One implication of the BSO is that for a given interaction time and Rabi frequency, the degree of rotation experienced by the qubit depends explicitly on the initial phase of the driving field. If this effect is not controlled, it leads to an apparent fluctuation in the rotation of the qubit. Here we show that when an off-resonant lambda system is used to realize a two-level qubit, the BSO is inherently negligible, thus eliminating this source of potential error.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Mar 9, 2009•4 citations

Effect of the Bloch-Siegert shift on the frequency responses of Rabi oscillations in the case of nutation resonance

A. P. Saǐko, Г. Г. Федорук

The dynamics of a two-level spin system dressed by bichromatic radiation is studied under the conditions of double resonance when the frequency of one (microwave) field is equal to the Larmor frequency of the spin system and the frequency of the other (radio-frequency) field ω rf is close to the Rabi frequency ω 1 in a microwave field. It is shown theoretically that Rabi oscillations between dressed-spin states with the frequency ɛ are accompanied by higher-frequency oscillations at frequencies n ω rf and n ω rf ± ɛ, where n = 1, 2,.... The most intense among these are the signals corresponding to n = 1. The counter-rotating (antiresonance) components of the RF field give rise to a shift of the dressed-state energy, i.e., to a frequency shift similar to the Bloch-Siegert shift. In particular, this shift is manifested as the dependence of the Rabi-oscillation frequency ɛ on the sign of the detuning ω 1 − ω rf from resonance. In the case of double resonance, the oscillation amplitude is asymmetric; i.e., the amplitude at the sum frequency ω rf + ɛ increases, while the amplitude at the difference frequency ω rf − ɛ decreases. The predicted effects are confirmed by observations of the nutation signals of the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) of E ′ 1 centers in quartz and should be taken into account to realize qubits with a low Rabi frequency in solids.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•Apr 1, 2008•25 citations

Precise qubit control beyond the rotating wave approximation

Jochen Scheuer, Xi Kong, Ressa S. Said +9 more

Abstract Fast and accurate quantum operations of a single spin in room-temperature solids are required in many modern scientific areas, for instance in quantum information, quantum metrology, and magnetometry. However, the accuracy is limited if the Rabi frequency of the control is comparable with the transition frequency of the qubit due to the breakdown of the rotating wave approximation (RWA). We report here an experimental implementation of a control method based on quantum optimal control theory which does not suffer from such restriction. We demonstrate the most commonly used single qubit rotations, i.e. - and π-pulses, beyond the RWA regime with high fidelity and , respectively. They are in excellent agreement with the theoretical predictions, and . Furthermore, we perform two basic magnetic resonance experiments both in the rotating and the laboratory frames, where we are able to deliberately ‘switch’ between the frames, to confirm the robustness of our control method. Our method is general, hence it may immediately find its wide applications in magnetic resonance, quantum computing, quantum optics, and broadband magnetometry.

arXiv:1309.4399•New Journal of Physics•Sep 19, 2014•88 citations

Effects of the Bloch-Siegert Oscillation on the Precision of Qubit Rotations: Direct Two-Level vs. Off-Resonant Raman Excitation

Prabhakar Pradhan, George C. Cardoso, J. Morzinski +1 more

In a direct two-level qubit system, when the Rabi frequency is comparable to the resonance frequency, the rotating wave approximation is not appropriate. In this case, the Rabi oscillation is accompanied by another oscillation at twice the frequency of the driving field, the so called Bloch-Siegert oscillation (BSO), which depends on the initial phase of the driving field. This oscillation may restrict the precise rotation of a qubit made of direct two-level system. Here, we show that in case of an effectively two-level lambda system, the BSO is inherently negligible, implying a greater precision for rotation of a qubit made of such a lambda system when compared to a direct two-level qubit in a strong driving field.

arXiv:quant-ph/0402122•Feb 18, 2004•0 citations

Bloch-Siegert shift under a bias magnetic field along arbitrary direction

Zhichao Ding, Weipeng Wang

In order to reduce the measuring error of magnetic resonance frequency caused by Bloch-Siegert shift, and improve the measurement accuracy of optical pumped alkali-metal magnetometers, the Bloch-Siegert shift is studied under a bias magnetic field in any direction. In this condition, the evolution equation of atomic spin is deduced. Based on the numerical solution of this equation, a method for extracting the Bloch-Siegert shift is proposed, which avoids the difficulty in achieving the analytical solution of the evolution equation. The numerical and analytical solutions of the evolution equation under special conditions are compared, verifying the rationality and necessity of using the numerical solution instead of approximate analytical solution to study the Bloch-Siegert shift under the bias magnetic field in any direction. By studying the Bloch-Siegert shift under different conditions, the typical conditions are selected and the Bloch-Siegert shift is numerically calculated when the bias magnetic field is in different directions. Through the analysis and verification of the calculation results, a theoretical model of the Bloch-Siegert shift under the bias magnetic field in any direction is obtained. This model is of great significance for correcting and reducing the measurement error of optical pumped alkali-metal magnetometers.

Results in Physics•Dec 12, 2024•0 citations
We present investigations of radio-frequency (RF) resonances observed in an optically pumped rubidium vapor. By measuring the systematic shifts (the Bloch–Siegert shifts) of RF resonances in low magnetic fields, we demonstrate limitations of the rotating-wave approximation in the case of angular momentum F ≥ 1. The resonance shifts and deformations are characterized in a wide range of parameters and it is shown that the observed behavior is far more complex than in a standard two-level system. It is also demonstrated that the shifts can be controllably turned on or off by switching between the oscillating and rotating magnetic field. Experimental results are supported with numerical calculations, reproducing all features of the observed signals. Besides fundamental aspect of the research, application of rotating magnetic field helps to suppress/evaluate spectroscopic-measurement and precise-metrology systematic errors. The reported study has also important implications for quantum metrology and information processing beyond RWA and standard two-state qubit dynamics.
The dynamics of a two-level spin system dressed by bichromatic radiation is studied under the conditions of double resonance when the frequency of one (microwave) field is equal to the Larmor frequency of the spin system and the frequency of the other (radio-frequency) field ω_{rf} is close to the Rabi frequency ω_{1} in a micro-wave field. It is shown theoretically that Rabi oscillations between dressed-spin states with the frequency εare accompanied by higher-frequency oscillations at frequencies nω_{rf} and nω_{rf}\pm ε, where n = 1, 2, .... The most intense among these are the signals corresponding to n = 1. The counter-rotating (antiresonance) components of the RF field give rise to a shift of the dressed-state energy, i.e., to a frequency shift similar to the Bloch-Siegert shift. In particular, this shift is manifested as the dependence of the Rabi-oscillation frequency εon the sign of the detuning ω{1} -ω{rf} from resonance. In the case of double resonance, the oscillation amplitude is asymmetric; i.e., the amplitude at the sum frequency ω_{rf} +εincreases, while the amplitude at the difference frequency ω_{rf} -εdecreases. The predicted effects are confirmed by observations of the nutation signals of the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) of centers in quartz and should be taken into account to realize qubits with a low Rabi frequency in solids.
The rotation of a quantum bit (qubit) is an important step in quantum computation. The rotation is generally performed using a Rabi oscillation. In a direct two-level qubit system, if the Rabi frequency is comparable to its resonance frequency, the rotating wave approximation is not valid, and the Rabi oscillation is accompanied by the so-called Bloch–Siegert oscillation (BSO) that occurs at twice the frequency of the driving field. One implication of the BSO is that for a given interaction time and Rabi frequency, the degree of rotation experienced by the qubit depends explicitly on the initial phase of the driving field. If this effect is not controlled, it leads to an apparent fluctuation in the rotation of the qubit. Here we show that when an off-resonant lambda system is used to realize a two-level qubit, the BSO is inherently negligible, thus eliminating this source of potential error.
The dynamics of a two-level spin system dressed by bichromatic radiation is studied under the conditions of double resonance when the frequency of one (microwave) field is equal to the Larmor frequency of the spin system and the frequency of the other (radio-frequency) field ω rf is close to the Rabi frequency ω 1 in a microwave field. It is shown theoretically that Rabi oscillations between dressed-spin states with the frequency ɛ are accompanied by higher-frequency oscillations at frequencies n ω rf and n ω rf ± ɛ, where n = 1, 2,.... The most intense among these are the signals corresponding to n = 1. The counter-rotating (antiresonance) components of the RF field give rise to a shift of the dressed-state energy, i.e., to a frequency shift similar to the Bloch-Siegert shift. In particular, this shift is manifested as the dependence of the Rabi-oscillation frequency ɛ on the sign of the detuning ω 1 − ω rf from resonance. In the case of double resonance, the oscillation amplitude is asymmetric; i.e., the amplitude at the sum frequency ω rf + ɛ increases, while the amplitude at the difference frequency ω rf − ɛ decreases. The predicted effects are confirmed by observations of the nutation signals of the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) of E ′ 1 centers in quartz and should be taken into account to realize qubits with a low Rabi frequency in solids.
Abstract Fast and accurate quantum operations of a single spin in room-temperature solids are required in many modern scientific areas, for instance in quantum information, quantum metrology, and magnetometry. However, the accuracy is limited if the Rabi frequency of the control is comparable with the transition frequency of the qubit due to the breakdown of the rotating wave approximation (RWA). We report here an experimental implementation of a control method based on quantum optimal control theory which does not suffer from such restriction. We demonstrate the most commonly used single qubit rotations, i.e. - and π-pulses, beyond the RWA regime with high fidelity and , respectively. They are in excellent agreement with the theoretical predictions, and . Furthermore, we perform two basic magnetic resonance experiments both in the rotating and the laboratory frames, where we are able to deliberately ‘switch’ between the frames, to confirm the robustness of our control method. Our method is general, hence it may immediately find its wide applications in magnetic resonance, quantum computing, quantum optics, and broadband magnetometry.
In a direct two-level qubit system, when the Rabi frequency is comparable to the resonance frequency, the rotating wave approximation is not appropriate. In this case, the Rabi oscillation is accompanied by another oscillation at twice the frequency of the driving field, the so called Bloch-Siegert oscillation (BSO), which depends on the initial phase of the driving field. This oscillation may restrict the precise rotation of a qubit made of direct two-level system. Here, we show that in case of an effectively two-level lambda system, the BSO is inherently negligible, implying a greater precision for rotation of a qubit made of such a lambda system when compared to a direct two-level qubit in a strong driving field.
In order to reduce the measuring error of magnetic resonance frequency caused by Bloch-Siegert shift, and improve the measurement accuracy of optical pumped alkali-metal magnetometers, the Bloch-Siegert shift is studied under a bias magnetic field in any direction. In this condition, the evolution equation of atomic spin is deduced. Based on the numerical solution of this equation, a method for extracting the Bloch-Siegert shift is proposed, which avoids the difficulty in achieving the analytical solution of the evolution equation. The numerical and analytical solutions of the evolution equation under special conditions are compared, verifying the rationality and necessity of using the numerical solution instead of approximate analytical solution to study the Bloch-Siegert shift under the bias magnetic field in any direction. By studying the Bloch-Siegert shift under different conditions, the typical conditions are selected and the Bloch-Siegert shift is numerically calculated when the bias magnetic field is in different directions. Through the analysis and verification of the calculation results, a theoretical model of the Bloch-Siegert shift under the bias magnetic field in any direction is obtained. This model is of great significance for correcting and reducing the measurement error of optical pumped alkali-metal magnetometers.