Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1709.06615 · Physical Review A

Permutational symmetries for coincidence rates in multimode multiphotonic interferometry

Abdullah Khalid, Dylan Spivak, Barry C. Sanders, Hubert de Guise

Published Jun 4, 2018• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We obtain coincidence rates for passive optical interferometry by exploiting the permutational symmetries of partially distinguishable input photons, and our approach elucidates qualitative features of multiphoton coincidence landscapes. We treat the interferometer input as a product state of any number of photons in each input mode with photons distinguished by their arrival time. Detectors at the output of the interferometer count photons from each output mode over a long integration time. We generalize and prove the claim of Tillmann et al. [Phys. Rev. X 5, 041015 (2015)] that coincidence rates can be elegantly expressed in terms of immanants. Immanants are functions of matrices that exhibit permutational symmetries and the immanants appearing in our coincidence-rate expressions share permutational symmetries with the input state. Our results are obtained by employing representation theory of the symmetric group to analyze systems of an arbitrary number of photons in arbitrarily sized interferometers.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.97.063802

Related papers

Multi-Mode Multi-Photon Interferometry Applications for Quantum Information Processing

Abdullah Khalid

Quantum information holds enormous potential to achieve communication and computational tasks that are impossible using classical systems. Many quantum information processing tasks can be implemented by exploiting the passive interference of photons. In this thesis, we reports advances towards the analysis, simulation, characterization, and design of passive interferometry experiments for quantum information processing applications. First, we develop a theory of passive optical interferometry experiments that relates coincidence rates at the output of an interferometer to the permutational symmetries of partially distinguishable photons. In our formalism, coincidence rates are elegantly expressed in terms of immanants, which are matrix functions that exhibit permutational symmetries, and the immanants appearing in our coincidence-rate expressions share permutational symmetries with the input state. Our formalism thus provides an intuitive qualitative understanding of how the permutational symmetries of distinguishable photons determine their interference. Our approach can be used to better understand the effect of partial distinguishability in modeling passive interferometry experiments aiming to perform quantum information tasks such as linear optical quantum computing and BosonSampling. By exploiting symmetries, we can also reduce some calculational tasks and provide additional insights into relations between the coincidence rates in various situations. Second, we tackle the problem of characterizing passive interferometers, essential for modelling any passive interferometry experiment. We develop a characterization procedure that uses only one- and two-photon coincidence data, and makes a number of advancements over existing procedures. We estimate the errors in the characterization via bootstrapping, a statistical technique with the advantage of not assuming any particular error model on the experimental data. We also introduce a scattershot approach to reduce the experimental data collection time quadratically in the number of modes of the interferometer. Third, we study a relativistic quantum information task called quantum summoning. We cast quantum summoning as an interactive protocol between a verifier and a possibly dishonest prover. For the prover, we present a protocol and quantum codes to summon in any valid configuration of causal diamonds, and design the encoding and decoding circuits for our code. Our protocol decreases the space complexity for encoding by a factor of two compared to the previous best result and reduces the gate complexity from scaling as the cube to the square of the number of causal diamonds. Within our interactive protocol framework, we construct an operational definition of quantum summoning, and use this definition to present a verification test. We prove that our verification test is sound and complete, thereby showing that quantum summoning can be verified by a resource-limited verifier in an adversarial setting. Our protocol and verification procedures are amenable to implementation by passive interferometry, thereby extending the reach of passive interferometry in the field of relativistic quantum information processing.

•Sep 21, 2018•0 citations

Coincidence landscapes for three-channel linear optical networks

Hubert de Guise, Si-Hui Tan, Isaac P. Poulin +1 more

We use permutation-group methods plus SU(3) group-theoretic methods to determine the action of a three-channel passive optical interferometer on controllably delayed single-photon pulse inputs to each channel. Permutation-group techniques allow us to relate directly expressions for rates and, in particular, investigate symmetries in the coincidence landscape. These techniques extend the traditional Hong-Ou-Mandel effect analysis for two-channel interferometry to valleys and plateaus in three-channel interferometry. Our group-theoretic approach is intuitively appealing because the calculus of Wigner D functions partially accounts for permutational symmetries and directly reveals the connections among D functions, partial distinguishability, and immanants.

arXiv:1402.2391•Physical Review A•Jun 23, 2014•37 citations

Interferometrically estimating a quadratic form for any immanant of a matrix and its permutations

Aeysha Khalique, Hubert de Guise, Barry C. Sanders

We devise a multiphoton interferometry scheme for sampling a quadratic function of a specific immanant for any submatrix of a unitary matrix and its row permutations. The full unitary matrix describes a passive, linear interferometer, and its submatrix is used when photons enter in and are detected at subsets of possible input and output channels. Immanants are mathematical constructs that interpolate between the permanent and determinant; contrary to determinants and permanents, which have meaningful physical applications, immanants are devoid of physical meaning classically but here are shown to be meaningful in a quantum setting. Our quadratic form of immanants is sampled by injecting vacuum and single photons into interferometer input ports such that the photon arrival times are entangled, in contrast to previous methods that control arrival times without entangling. Our method works for any number of photons, and we solve explicitly the quadratic form for the two-, three-, and four-photon cases.

arXiv:2005.04819•Physical Review A•May 7, 2020•1 citation

Estimating immanants from interferometric photon coincidences

Barry C. Sanders, Si-Hui Tan, Hubert de Guise +1 more

We develop a theory for multi-channel passive optical interferometery with one or zero photon entering each input port, and we show that the output photon coincidences yield information about immanants of the interferometer transformation matrix.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

SU(3) Quantum Interferometry with Single-Photon Input Pulses

Si-Hui Tan, Yvonne Y. Gao, Hubert de Guise +1 more

We develop a framework for solving the action of a three-channel passive optical interferometer on single-photon pulse inputs to each channel using SU(3) group-theoretic methods, which can be readily generalized to higher-order photon-coincidence experiments. We show that features of the coincidence plots versus relative time delays of photons yield information about permanents, immanants, and determinants of the interferometer SU(3) matrix.

arXiv:1208.5677•Physical Review Letters•Mar 12, 2013•46 citations

Coincidence landscapes for polarized bosons

Jizhou Wu, Hubert de Guise, Barry C. Sanders

Passive optical interferometry with single photons injected into some input ports and vacuum into others is enriched by admitting polarization, thereby replacing the scalar electromagnetic description by a vector theory, with the recent triad phase being a celebrated example of this richness. On the other hand, incorporating polarization into interferometry is known to be equivalent to scalar theory if the number of channels is doubled. We show that passive multiphoton $m$-channel interferometry described by $\mathrm{SU}(m)$ transformations is replaced by $\mathrm{SU}(2m)$ interferometry if polarization is included and thus that the multiphoton coincidence landscape, whose domain corresponds to various relative delays between photon arrival times, is fully explained by the now-standard approach of using immanants to compute coincidence sampling probabilities. Consequently, we show that the triad phase is manifested simply as SU(6) interferometry with three input photons, with one photon in each of three different input ports. Our analysis incorporates passive polarization multichannel interferometry into the existing scalar-field approach to computing multiphoton coincidence probabilities in interferometry and demystifies the triad phase.

arXiv:1805.12023•Physical Review A•Jul 10, 2018•5 citations
We obtain coincidence rates for passive optical interferometry by exploiting the permutational symmetries of partially distinguishable input photons, and our approach elucidates qualitative features of multiphoton coincidence landscapes. We treat the interferometer input as a product state of any number of photons in each input mode with photons distinguished by their arrival time. Detectors at the output of the interferometer count photons from each output mode over a long integration time. We generalize and prove the claim of Tillmann et al. [Phys. Rev. X 5, 041015 (2015)] that coincidence rates can be elegantly expressed in terms of immanants. Immanants are functions of matrices that exhibit permutational symmetries and the immanants appearing in our coincidence-rate expressions share permutational symmetries with the input state. Our results are obtained by employing representation theory of the symmetric group to analyze systems of an arbitrary number of photons in arbitrarily sized interferometers.
Quantum information holds enormous potential to achieve communication and computational tasks that are impossible using classical systems. Many quantum information processing tasks can be implemented by exploiting the passive interference of photons. In this thesis, we reports advances towards the analysis, simulation, characterization, and design of passive interferometry experiments for quantum information processing applications. First, we develop a theory of passive optical interferometry experiments that relates coincidence rates at the output of an interferometer to the permutational symmetries of partially distinguishable photons. In our formalism, coincidence rates are elegantly expressed in terms of immanants, which are matrix functions that exhibit permutational symmetries, and the immanants appearing in our coincidence-rate expressions share permutational symmetries with the input state. Our formalism thus provides an intuitive qualitative understanding of how the permutational symmetries of distinguishable photons determine their interference. Our approach can be used to better understand the effect of partial distinguishability in modeling passive interferometry experiments aiming to perform quantum information tasks such as linear optical quantum computing and BosonSampling. By exploiting symmetries, we can also reduce some calculational tasks and provide additional insights into relations between the coincidence rates in various situations. Second, we tackle the problem of characterizing passive interferometers, essential for modelling any passive interferometry experiment. We develop a characterization procedure that uses only one- and two-photon coincidence data, and makes a number of advancements over existing procedures. We estimate the errors in the characterization via bootstrapping, a statistical technique with the advantage of not assuming any particular error model on the experimental data. We also introduce a scattershot approach to reduce the experimental data collection time quadratically in the number of modes of the interferometer. Third, we study a relativistic quantum information task called quantum summoning. We cast quantum summoning as an interactive protocol between a verifier and a possibly dishonest prover. For the prover, we present a protocol and quantum codes to summon in any valid configuration of causal diamonds, and design the encoding and decoding circuits for our code. Our protocol decreases the space complexity for encoding by a factor of two compared to the previous best result and reduces the gate complexity from scaling as the cube to the square of the number of causal diamonds. Within our interactive protocol framework, we construct an operational definition of quantum summoning, and use this definition to present a verification test. We prove that our verification test is sound and complete, thereby showing that quantum summoning can be verified by a resource-limited verifier in an adversarial setting. Our protocol and verification procedures are amenable to implementation by passive interferometry, thereby extending the reach of passive interferometry in the field of relativistic quantum information processing.
We use permutation-group methods plus SU(3) group-theoretic methods to determine the action of a three-channel passive optical interferometer on controllably delayed single-photon pulse inputs to each channel. Permutation-group techniques allow us to relate directly expressions for rates and, in particular, investigate symmetries in the coincidence landscape. These techniques extend the traditional Hong-Ou-Mandel effect analysis for two-channel interferometry to valleys and plateaus in three-channel interferometry. Our group-theoretic approach is intuitively appealing because the calculus of Wigner D functions partially accounts for permutational symmetries and directly reveals the connections among D functions, partial distinguishability, and immanants.
We devise a multiphoton interferometry scheme for sampling a quadratic function of a specific immanant for any submatrix of a unitary matrix and its row permutations. The full unitary matrix describes a passive, linear interferometer, and its submatrix is used when photons enter in and are detected at subsets of possible input and output channels. Immanants are mathematical constructs that interpolate between the permanent and determinant; contrary to determinants and permanents, which have meaningful physical applications, immanants are devoid of physical meaning classically but here are shown to be meaningful in a quantum setting. Our quadratic form of immanants is sampled by injecting vacuum and single photons into interferometer input ports such that the photon arrival times are entangled, in contrast to previous methods that control arrival times without entangling. Our method works for any number of photons, and we solve explicitly the quadratic form for the two-, three-, and four-photon cases.
Passive optical interferometry with single photons injected into some input ports and vacuum into others is enriched by admitting polarization, thereby replacing the scalar electromagnetic description by a vector theory, with the recent triad phase being a celebrated example of this richness. On the other hand, incorporating polarization into interferometry is known to be equivalent to scalar theory if the number of channels is doubled. We show that passive multiphoton mmm-channel interferometry described by SU(m)\mathrm{SU}(m)SU(m) transformations is replaced by SU(2m)\mathrm{SU}(2m)SU(2m) interferometry if polarization is included and thus that the multiphoton coincidence landscape, whose domain corresponds to various relative delays between photon arrival times, is fully explained by the now-standard approach of using immanants to compute coincidence sampling probabilities. Consequently, we show that the triad phase is manifested simply as SU(6) interferometry with three input photons, with one photon in each of three different input ports. Our analysis incorporates passive polarization multichannel interferometry into the existing scalar-field approach to computing multiphoton coincidence probabilities in interferometry and demystifies the triad phase.