Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1708.07568 · Acta Physica Polonica B

Three-photon Entanglement from Ortho-Positronium Revisited

Marek Nowakowski, D. Bedoya Fierro

Published Jan 1, 2017• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Entanglement of three photons from the decay of ortho-positronium is re-analyzed. We use the full three body phase space to write down the entangled states classified according to the spin directions of the ortho-positronium. Even in the case when the spin is perpendicular to the decay plane, we find non-negligible phases entering the entangled state. This has not been noticed before. We advocate a fixed quantization axis of the spin for the sake of generality. A brief discussion of a three dimensional formalism for photons, including correlations, versus a two dimensional one is given.

DOI
10.5506/aphyspolb.48.1955

Related papers

Three-party entanglement from positronium

A. Acín, José Ignacio Latorre, P. Pascual

The decay of orthopositronium into three photons produces a physical realization of a pure state with three-party entanglement. Its quantum correlations are analyzed using recent results on quantum information theory, looking for the final state that has the maximal amount of Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger like correlations. This state allows for a statistical dismissal of local realism stronger than the one obtained using any entangled state of two spin one-half particles.

arXiv:quant-ph/0007080•Physical Review A•Mar 19, 2001•43 citations

Genuine Multipartite Entanglement in the 3-Photon Decay of Positronium

Beatrix C. Hiesmayr, Paweł Moskal

Abstract The electron-positron annihilation into two photons is a standard technology in medicine to observe e.g. metabolic processes in human bodies. A new tomograph will provide the possibility to observe not only direct e+e− annihilations but also the 3 photons from the decay of ortho-positronium atoms formed in the body. We show in this contribution that the three-photon state with respect to polarisation degrees of freedom depends on the angles between the photons and exhibits various specific entanglement features. In particular genuine multipartite entanglement, a type of entanglement involving all degrees of freedom, is subsistent if the positronium was in a definite spin eigenstate. Remarkably, when all spin eigenstates are mixed equally, entanglement –and even stronger genuine multipartite entanglement– survives. Due to a “symmetrization” process, however, Dicke-type or W-type entanglement remains whereas GHZ-type entanglement vanishes. The survival of particular entanglement properties in the mixing scenario may make it possible to extract quantum information in the form of distinct entanglement features, e.g., from metabolic processes in human bodies.

arXiv:1706.06505•Scientific Reports•Nov 6, 2017•53 citations

Entangled photons from para-positronium decay: Do coincidences from scattered photons imply a Bell state?

Paul Joos, Peter Kling

Electron and positron can form a meta-stable bound state called positronium that decays via pair annihilation. We show how polarization-dependent Compton scattering can be used to verify that the two annihilation photons in the spin-zero case (para-positronium) are emitted in a maximally entangled Bell state. Our theoretical approach based on two-photon density matrices connects concepts from relativistic quantum electrodynamics and quantum information theory.

quant-pharXiv:2606.31726•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Entanglement from Positronium Decay

Forrest Bullard

IntroductionIn this experiment we will explore whether photons emitted from the decay of positronium, a positron-electron composition, are quantum entangled. When talking about quantum entangled particles it is impossible to fully represent the quantum state of one particle independently of another such that if we know one photon from an entangled pair is horizontally polarized then the other must be vertically polarized. We will use this concept along with knowledge from previous experiments on positron-electron annihilation and Compton scattering to try to determine the truth of this model.ProcedureIn this experiment we used two NaI detectors, photo-multiplier tubes (PMT), pre-amplifiers, and amplifiers. Along with two single channel analyzers, a logic gate, a coincidence detector, a high-voltage supply, and a multi-channel analyzer (MCA) and of course two aluminum targets, a sodium-22 radioactive source, and loads of lead bricks. Our source was encased in the center of our detector configuration such that radiation from the source was focused towards both aluminum targets placed opposite of each other with respect to the source. Both detectors were then stationed so that photons coming from the source were detected after a 90 degree Compton scattering from the target. This ninety degree correlation is necessary for proof of quantum entanglement as we expect no coincidences to occur when both detectors are in the same plane do to quantum pairs anti-correlated polarization causing expected scattering to be related by this ninety degree angle. The picture below shows the basic geometry of this set up.

•Dec 14, 2020•0 citations

Weak decay of the positronium ion

Nishat Ul Sani, M. Jamil Aslam, Ishtiaq Ahmed

The positronium ion ($\mathrm{Ps}^-$), a coulombic three-body bound state of two electrons and a positron, predominantly decays via electron-positron annihilation into electromagnetic final states. While its radiative decay channels have been extensively studied, much less attention has been given to weak processes in this system. In this work, we investigate the rare decay $\mathrm{Ps}^- \to e^- ν_μ\barν_μ$, obtained by replacing the photon in $\mathrm{Ps}^- \to e^- γ$ with a virtual $Z$ boson. Treating the three-body process as an effective two-body transition, $\mathrm{Ps}^- \to e^- Z^*\left(\to ν_μ\barν_μ\right)$, we compute the decay rate by explicitly evaluating all spin configurations of the initial bound state and final particles. The result agrees with that obtained using the standard spin-summation formalism of quantum field theory. We find that the branching ratio is comparable to that of the weak decay of ortho-positronium, $\mathrm{o\text{-}Ps} \to γν\barν$.

hep-phCross-listedarXiv:2606.25433•Jun 25, 2026

Molecule-fixed axes in many-body Hamiltonians

Mirjana Mladenović

The separation of the dynamics of the quantum many-body systems into the overall rotation and internal motions leads to their quantization in rotating frames. Whereas the rotating body frame is unique for a rigid body, there is a great degree of freedom for choosing a body frame for a general rotating and vibrating N-particle system. This, in turn, implies the need to study many-body systems for a class of body frames.The concept of vibrational coordinates and of rotational coordinates is particularly clear for the case of a triatomic molecule: three particles form a single plane, in which the molecule vibrates, and at the same time the molecular plane rotates in the space-fixed frame of reference. The overall molecular rotation is made explicit by means of an orthogonal transformation, which brings the space-fixed into the body-fixed axes. The direction perpendicular to the molecular plane uniquely determines one of the three axes of the frame. Rotation about this direction will change the position of the axes in the molecular plane, in fact the axis system. It is already intuitively clear that this axis transformation will not affect the vibrational portion of the kinetic energy operator. The other parts of the kinetic energy, the rotational part and the rotation-vibration coupling part, will then need to adjust themselves to the new definition of the body frame. In this fashion, we may address the problem of the interaction of rotations and vibrations, which is one of the most important problems in molecular studies.The variation of the rovibrational kinetic energy operator following a change of orientation of the axis system is investigated in the present work from the physical and mathematical points of view. Various types of axis embedding are analyzed in a systematic fashion for triatomic molecules of arbitrary structure, including the bisector, principal axis, and Eckart frames. We also consider the bisector axis embedding for tetratomic molecules and the local axis embedding for pentatomic molecules. Different axis conventions lead sometimes to a complex entanglement of rotational and vibrational motions, which may pose serious obstacles to numerically exact approaches.

•Jan 8, 2020•0 citations
Entanglement of three photons from the decay of ortho-positronium is re-analyzed. We use the full three body phase space to write down the entangled states classified according to the spin directions of the ortho-positronium. Even in the case when the spin is perpendicular to the decay plane, we find non-negligible phases entering the entangled state. This has not been noticed before. We advocate a fixed quantization axis of the spin for the sake of generality. A brief discussion of a three dimensional formalism for photons, including correlations, versus a two dimensional one is given.
Abstract The electron-positron annihilation into two photons is a standard technology in medicine to observe e.g. metabolic processes in human bodies. A new tomograph will provide the possibility to observe not only direct e+e− annihilations but also the 3 photons from the decay of ortho-positronium atoms formed in the body. We show in this contribution that the three-photon state with respect to polarisation degrees of freedom depends on the angles between the photons and exhibits various specific entanglement features. In particular genuine multipartite entanglement, a type of entanglement involving all degrees of freedom, is subsistent if the positronium was in a definite spin eigenstate. Remarkably, when all spin eigenstates are mixed equally, entanglement –and even stronger genuine multipartite entanglement– survives. Due to a “symmetrization” process, however, Dicke-type or W-type entanglement remains whereas GHZ-type entanglement vanishes. The survival of particular entanglement properties in the mixing scenario may make it possible to extract quantum information in the form of distinct entanglement features, e.g., from metabolic processes in human bodies.
IntroductionIn this experiment we will explore whether photons emitted from the decay of positronium, a positron-electron composition, are quantum entangled. When talking about quantum entangled particles it is impossible to fully represent the quantum state of one particle independently of another such that if we know one photon from an entangled pair is horizontally polarized then the other must be vertically polarized. We will use this concept along with knowledge from previous experiments on positron-electron annihilation and Compton scattering to try to determine the truth of this model.ProcedureIn this experiment we used two NaI detectors, photo-multiplier tubes (PMT), pre-amplifiers, and amplifiers. Along with two single channel analyzers, a logic gate, a coincidence detector, a high-voltage supply, and a multi-channel analyzer (MCA) and of course two aluminum targets, a sodium-22 radioactive source, and loads of lead bricks. Our source was encased in the center of our detector configuration such that radiation from the source was focused towards both aluminum targets placed opposite of each other with respect to the source. Both detectors were then stationed so that photons coming from the source were detected after a 90 degree Compton scattering from the target. This ninety degree correlation is necessary for proof of quantum entanglement as we expect no coincidences to occur when both detectors are in the same plane do to quantum pairs anti-correlated polarization causing expected scattering to be related by this ninety degree angle. The picture below shows the basic geometry of this set up.
The positronium ion (Ps−\mathrm{Ps}^-Ps−), a coulombic three-body bound state of two electrons and a positron, predominantly decays via electron-positron annihilation into electromagnetic final states. While its radiative decay channels have been extensively studied, much less attention has been given to weak processes in this system. In this work, we investigate the rare decay Ps−→e−νμνˉμ\mathrm{Ps}^- \to e^- ν_μ\barν_μPs−→e−νμ​νˉμ​, obtained by replacing the photon in Ps−→e−γ\mathrm{Ps}^- \to e^- γPs−→e−γ with a virtual ZZZ boson. Treating the three-body process as an effective two-body transition, Ps−→e−Z∗(→νμνˉμ)\mathrm{Ps}^- \to e^- Z^*\left(\to ν_μ\barν_μ\right)Ps−→e−Z∗(→νμ​νˉμ​), we compute the decay rate by explicitly evaluating all spin configurations of the initial bound state and final particles. The result agrees with that obtained using the standard spin-summation formalism of quantum field theory. We find that the branching ratio is comparable to that of the weak decay of ortho-positronium, o-Ps→γννˉ\mathrm{o\text{-}Ps} \to γν\barνo-Ps→γννˉ.
The separation of the dynamics of the quantum many-body systems into the overall rotation and internal motions leads to their quantization in rotating frames. Whereas the rotating body frame is unique for a rigid body, there is a great degree of freedom for choosing a body frame for a general rotating and vibrating N-particle system. This, in turn, implies the need to study many-body systems for a class of body frames.The concept of vibrational coordinates and of rotational coordinates is particularly clear for the case of a triatomic molecule: three particles form a single plane, in which the molecule vibrates, and at the same time the molecular plane rotates in the space-fixed frame of reference. The overall molecular rotation is made explicit by means of an orthogonal transformation, which brings the space-fixed into the body-fixed axes. The direction perpendicular to the molecular plane uniquely determines one of the three axes of the frame. Rotation about this direction will change the position of the axes in the molecular plane, in fact the axis system. It is already intuitively clear that this axis transformation will not affect the vibrational portion of the kinetic energy operator. The other parts of the kinetic energy, the rotational part and the rotation-vibration coupling part, will then need to adjust themselves to the new definition of the body frame. In this fashion, we may address the problem of the interaction of rotations and vibrations, which is one of the most important problems in molecular studies.The variation of the rovibrational kinetic energy operator following a change of orientation of the axis system is investigated in the present work from the physical and mathematical points of view. Various types of axis embedding are analyzed in a systematic fashion for triatomic molecules of arbitrary structure, including the bisector, principal axis, and Eckart frames. We also consider the bisector axis embedding for tetratomic molecules and the local axis embedding for pentatomic molecules. Different axis conventions lead sometimes to a complex entanglement of rotational and vibrational motions, which may pose serious obstacles to numerically exact approaches.