arXiv:1708.04302 · Nature Communications

Quantum majorization and a complete set of entropic conditions for quantum thermodynamics

Gilad Gour, David Jennings, Francesco Buscemi, Runyao Duan, Iman Marvian

Published Dec 11, 2018• 454 citations

Abstract

What does it mean for one quantum process to be more disordered than another? Interestingly, this apparently abstract question arises naturally in a wide range of areas such as information theory, thermodynamics, quantum reference frames, and the resource theory of asymmetry. Here we use a quantum-mechanical generalization of majorization to develop a framework for answering this question, in terms of single-shot entropies, or equivalently, in terms of semi-definite programs. We also investigate some of the applications of this framework, and remarkably find that, in the context of quantum thermodynamics it provides the first complete set of necessary and sufficient conditions for arbitrary quantum state transformations under thermodynamic processes, which rigorously accounts for quantum-mechanical properties, such as coherence. Our framework of generalized thermal processes extends thermal operations, and is based on natural physical principles, namely, energy conservation, the existence of equilibrium states, and the requirement that quantum coherence be accounted for thermodynamically.

DOI: 10.1038/s41467-018-06261-7

Related papers

Higher-order quantum thermodynamics: equilibrium and causal structure

Simon Milz, Kyrylo Simonov, Zoltán Zimborás +3 more

Quantum thermodynamics is traditionally formulated as a theory of equilibrium states and state transformations. Recent advances in higher-order quantum transformations, which describe physical scenarios beyond states and channels and provide a systematic framework for causal order, raise the question of how equilibrium should be defined and preserved in this more general setting. Starting from the Gibbs state as the unique equilibrium state, we identify equilibrium preservation as its natural higher-order extension. We show that, while this principle can in general give rise to distinct classes of transformations, all such distinctions disappear when equilibrium preservation is required completely, namely under arbitrary ancillary extensions. Remarkably, every transformation satisfying this condition is causally ordered, making causal order an emergent consequence of thermodynamic equilibrium. We establish this result for arbitrary higher-order maps and use the resulting framework to introduce free-energy-like quantities for quantum channels. Our findings reveal a fundamental connection between thermodynamic equilibrium and causal structure, providing a foundation for a fully fledged theory of higher-order quantum thermodynamics.

quant-pharXiv:2609.15829Sep 15, 20260 citations

Randomness, catalysis and partial knowledge in quantum thermodynamics

Paul Boës

Quantum thermodynamics is a blossoming research program that uses tools and ideas from quantum information theory to extend the laws of thermodynamics to the domain of systems to which the laws of quantum mechanics apply and the thermodynamic limit does not necessarily apply. The contributions of this program are both foundational, in providing an approach to constructively derive the laws of phenomenological thermodynamics from the postulates of unitary quantum mechanics in a rigorous and bottom-up fashion, but also prac- tical, in providing the theory for an increasing number of experiments that attempt to build thermodynamic machines at scales that were previously inaccessible. One key mathematical tool used in quantum thermodynamics is the framework of resource theories, specifically the resource theory of thermal operations, in which the thermodynamic interaction of a system with a heat bath and various additional components such as work batteries, clocks or catalysts are modeled. In this cumulative thesis, various extensions and modifications of this framework are studied in order to derive novel results and insights about the possible thermodynamic evolution of quantum systems. In particular, following a system- atic exposition of the resource theory of thermal operations from first principles, I develop answers to the following questions: i) What is the smallest heat bath required to provide the necessary randomness for a system to undergo a given stochastic or thermodynamical evolution? ii) Does this size differ depending on whether the interaction between bath and system is quantum or classical? iii) How can quantum systems thermodynamically evolve in the presence of catalytic bystander systems and how can this be put to use? iv) What are the thermodynamic state transitions that an agent can operationally affect when she only has access to partial information about the underlying states of system and bath? v) How can we understand the emergence of the canonical ensemble in statistical thermodynamics from quantum mechanics? These questions cover a wide ground, but it will become clear that they can in fact all be discussed using the same formal tools. As such, the answers to the above questions provided in this thesis are both interesting in their own right — showing for example that there exists a gap in how efficiently randomness can be exploited quantumly as compared to classically or that catalytic bystander systems can be used to extract finite amounts of work per particle from macroscopic systems with non-vanishing probability — as well as illustrate the power of quantum thermodynamics as a set of tools to connect quantum mechanics and the theory of thermodynamics more generally.

Jan 1, 20210 citations

Gaussian Thermal Operations and The Limits of Algorithmic Cooling

Alessio Serafini, Matteo Lostaglio, S Longden +3 more

The study of thermal operations allows one to investigate the ultimate possibilities of quantum states and of nanoscale thermal machines. Whilst fairly general, these results typically do not apply to continuous variable systems and do not take into account that, in many practically relevant settings, system-environment interactions are effectively bilinear. Here we tackle these issues by focusing on Gaussian quantum states and channels. We provide a complete characterization of the most general Gaussian thermal operation acting on an arbitrary number of bosonic modes, which turn out to be all embeddable in a Markovian dynamics, and derive necessary and sufficient conditions for state transformations under such operations in the single-mode case, encompassing states with nonzero coherence in the energy eigenbasis (i.e., squeezed states). Our analysis leads to a no-go result for the technologically relevant task of algorithmic cooling: We show that it is impossible to reduce the entropy of a system coupled to a Gaussian environment below its own or the environmental temperature, by means of a sequence of Gaussian thermal operations interspersed by arbitrary (even non-Gaussian) unitaries. These findings establish fundamental constraints on the usefulness of Gaussian resources for quantum thermodynamic processes.

arXiv:1909.06123Physical Review LettersJan 2, 202032 citations

Thermodynamics Beyond Equilibrium in Coherent Quantum Systems

Md Manirul Ali, Po-Wen Chen

A central open question in quantum thermodynamics is the identification of thermodynamic entropy away from equilibrium. Although thermodynamic entropy coincides with the von Neumann entropy for a Gibbs state at equilibrium, the thermodynamic role of quantum coherence generated during nonequilibrium evolution remains unclear. Here, we show that von Neumann entropy does not, in general, represent the thermodynamic entropy governing heat exchange in coherent nonequilibrium quantum systems. By integrating the resource theory of quantum coherence with thermodynamic principles, we develop a general framework for nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics. We identify thermodynamic entropy with the energy entropy derived from energy-measurement statistics and introduce a dynamical temperature extending the equilibrium concept to nonequilibrium states. Consequently, we obtain an exact entropy-balance relation separating the entropy flux associated with heat exchange from the coherence-loss contribution to entropy production, establishing an operational connection between quantum coherence, heat flow, and total entropy change. Unlike approaches relying on equilibrium reference states or stationary Gibbs ensembles, our framework uses instantaneous dynamical quantities and remains valid throughout transient nonequilibrium evolution. It provides consistent dynamical definitions of temperature, work, heat, and free energy. Applying the formalism to an exactly solvable open quantum system, we show that the first and second laws hold throughout transient evolution and that equilibrium thermodynamics emerges dynamically in the weak-coupling long-time limit. Our results establish a unified framework for coherent nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics and suggest opportunities for controlling heat dissipation through coherence engineering in quantum thermal technologies.

quant-pharXiv:2602.09074APL QuantumFeb 10, 20260 citations

The role of quantum coherence in non-equilibrium entropy production

Jader P. Santos, Lucas C. Céleri, Gabriel Teixeira Landi +1 more

Abstract Thermodynamic irreversibility is well characterized by the entropy production arising from non-equilibrium quantum processes. We show that the entropy production of a quantum system undergoing open-system dynamics can be formally split into a term that only depends on population unbalances, and one that is underpinned by quantum coherences. This allows us to identify a genuine quantum contribution to the entropy production in non-equilibrium quantum processes. We discuss how these features emerge both in Lindblad-Davies differential maps and finite maps subject to the constraints of thermal operations. We also show how this separation naturally leads to two independent entropic conservation laws for the global system-environment dynamics, one referring to the redistribution of populations between system and environment and the other describing how the coherence initially present in the system is distributed into local coherences in the environment and non-local coherences in the system-environment state. Finally, we discuss how the processing of quantum coherences and the incompatibility of non-commuting measurements leads to fundamental limitations in the description of quantum trajectories and fluctuation theorems.

arXiv:1707.08946npj Quantum InformationMar 1, 2019185 citations

Quantum Causal Structure and Quantum Thermodynamics

Mirjam Weilenmann

This thesis reports progress in two domains, causal structures and microscopic thermodynamics, both of which are pertinent in the development of quantum technologies. The first part is dedicated to the analysis of causal structure, which encodes the relationship between observed variables, in general restricting the set of possible correlations between them. Our considerations rely on a recent entropy vector method. Based on this, we develop techniques for deriving entropic constraints to differentiate between causal structures. We provide sufficient conditions for entropy vectors to be realisable within a causal structure and derive new, improved necessary conditions in terms of so-called non-Shannon inequalities. We also report that for a family of causal structures, including the bipartite Bell scenario and the bilocal causal structure, entropy vectors are unable to distinguish between classical and quantum causes, in spite of the existence of quantum correlations that are not classically reproducible. Hence, further development is needed in order to understand cause from a quantum perspective. In the second part we explore an axiomatic framework for modelling error-tolerant processes in microscopic thermodynamics. Our axiomatisation allows for the accommodation of finite precision levels, crucial for describing experiments in the microscopic regime. It leads to the emergence of manageable quantities that give insights into the feasibility and expenditure of processes, which for adiabatic processes are shown to be smooth entropy measures. Our framework also leads to thermodynamic behaviour at the macroscopic scale, meaning that for thermodynamic equilibrium states a unique function provides necessary and sufficient conditions for state transformations, like in the traditional second law.

arXiv:1807.06345Jul 17, 20185 citations