Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1708.03149 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Surmounting the sign problem in nonrelativistic calculations: A case study with mass-imbalanced fermions

Lukas Rammelmüller, William J. Porter, Joaquín E. Drut, Jens Braun

Published Nov 16, 2017• 40 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The calculation of the ground state and thermodynamics of mass-imbalanced Fermi systems is a challenging many-body problem. Even in one spatial dimension, analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with standard Monte Carlo approaches is hindered by the sign problem. The focus of the present work is on the further development of methods to study imbalanced systems in a fully nonperturbative fashion. We report our calculations of the ground-state energy of mass-imbalanced fermions using two different approaches which are also very popular in the context of the theory of the strong interaction (quantum chromodynamics, QCD): (a) the hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm with imaginary mass imbalance, followed by an analytic continuation to the real axis; and (b) the complex Langevin algorithm. We cover a range of on-site interaction strengths that includes strongly attractive as well as strongly repulsive cases which we verify with nonperturbative renormalization group methods and perturbation theory. Our findings indicate that, for strong repulsive couplings, the energy starts to flatten out, implying interesting consequences for short-range and high-frequency correlation functions. Overall, our results clearly indicate that the complex Langevin approach is very versatile and works very well for imbalanced Fermi gases with both attractive and repulsive interactions.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.96.094506

Related papers

A complex Langevin approach to ultracold fermions

Lukas Rammelmüller, Joaquín E. Drut, Jens Braun

The theoretical treatment of Fermi systems consisting of particles with unequal masses is challenging. Even in one spatial dimension analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with Monte Carlo simulations is hindered by the sign-problem. To circumvent this issue, we exploit the Complex Langevin approach and study one-dimensional mass-imbalanced two-component Fermi gases with attractive and repulsive interactions. We find perfect agreement with results obtained by other methods in a range of parameter space. Promisingly, our approach is not limited to the specific model presented here and can easily be extended to finite spin polarization and, most notably, can also be applied in higher dimensions.

arXiv:1710.11421•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2018•7 citations

A complex Langevin approach to ultracold fermions

J.E. Drut, Lukas Rammelmüller, J. Braun

The theoretical treatment of Fermi systems consisting of particles with unequal masses is challenging. Even in one spatial dimension analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with Monte Carlo simulations is hindered by the sign-problem. To circumvent this issue, we exploit the Complex Langevin approach and study one-dimensional mass-imbalanced two-component Fermi gases with attractive and repulsive interactions. We find perfect agreement with results obtained by other methods in a range of parameter space. Promisingly, our approach is not limited to the specific model presented here and can easily be extended to finite spin polarization and, most notably, can also be applied in higher dimensions.

•Nov 9, 2022•0 citations

Exploring imbalanced Fermi gases with stochastic quantization

Lukas Rammelmüller

Strongly coupled quantum matter displays a rich phenomenology including phase transitions and often unexpected collective behavior. Remarkable advances in experiments with ultracold Fermi gases allow us to gain deep insight into these intriguing systems. Their theoretical description, however, is often challenging as exact analytic solutions are available only in a few special cases, and approximate techniques such as mean-field or perturbation theory are of limited use. Numerical treatment with Monte Carlo (MC) methods has led to profound success in this regard. Unfortunately, for many systems - and especially for asymmetric quantum gases - the infamous sign problem slows progress due to an exponentially scaling of the computational effort with inceasing system size. In this thesis, we set out to explore the rich physics of two-component Fermi gases in the presence of finite spin polarization and/or mass imbalance. To surmount an arising sign problem, we learn from methodological advances made in the field of quantum chromodynamics and further develop these lattice approaches in the context of nonrelativistic Fermi gases. An extensive overview of the numerical methods is presented, including several toy problems to detail the capabilities and shortcomings of the developed approaches. With these tools in hand, we perform extensive benchmarks of the hybrid Monte Carlo method with imaginary asymmetries (iHMC) and the complex Langevin (CL) method, which is based on a complex version of stochastic quantization. Both approaches are shown to yield excellent results for the ground-state energy equation of state of mass-imbalanced Fermi gases in one spatial dimension. Due to its great versatility, the CL method is subsequently employed to study pairing in one-dimensional Fermi gases, for which suitable two-body correlations are computed, revealing unexpected pairing patterns for spin- and mass-imbalanced systems. Another major system of interest in this thesis is the paradigmatic unitary Fermi gas which is investigated at finite temperature and spin polarization. A precise determination of the density equation of state in the normal phase enables us to explore a broad range of thermodynamic properties. We infer valuable information on the finite-temperature phase diagram, such as a flat phase boundary of the normal-to-superfluid transition near the balanced limit and indications for the absence of an extensive pseudogap phase above this transition. The presented results provide experimentally testable ab initio predictions for a range of previously inaccessible thermodynamic quantities.

•Jan 1, 2020•4 citations

Fermi gases with imaginary mass imbalance and the sign problem in Monte-Carlo calculations

Dietrich Roscher, Jens Braun, Jiunn-Wei Chen +1 more

Fermi gases in strongly coupled regimes are inherently challenging for many-body methods. Although progress has been made analytically, quantitative results require ab initio numerical approaches, such as Monte-Carlo (MC) calculations. However, mass-imbalanced and spin-imbalanced gases are not accessible to MC calculations due to the infamous sign problem. For finite spin imbalance, the problem can be circumvented using imaginary polarizations and analytic continuation, and large parts of the phase diagram then become accessible. We propose to apply this strategy to the mass-imbalanced case, which opens up the possibility to study the associated phase diagram with MC calculations. We perform a first mean-field analysis which suggests that zero-temperature studies, as well as detecting a potential (tri)critical point, are feasible.

arXiv:1306.0798•Journal of Physics G Nuclear and Particle Physics•Mar 19, 2014•18 citations

A complex Langevin approach to ultracold fermions

Rammelmüller, Lukas, Drut, Joaquín E., Braun, Jens

The theoretical treatment of Fermi systems consisting of particles with unequal masses is challenging. Even in one spatial dimension analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with Monte Carlo simulations is hindered by the sign-problem. To circumvent this issue, we exploit the Complex Langevin approach and study one-dimensional mass-imbalanced two-component Fermi gases with attractive and repulsive interactions. We find perfect agreement with results obtained by other methods in a range of parameter space. Promisingly, our approach is not limited to the specific model presented here and can easily be extended to finite spin polarization and, most notably, can also be applied in higher dimensions.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

A complex Langevin approach to ultracold fermions

Lukas Rammelmüller, Joaquín E. Drut, Jens Braun

The theoretical treatment of Fermi systems consisting of particles with unequal masses is challenging. Even in one spatial dimension analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with Monte Carlo simulations is hindered by the sign-problem. To circumvent this issue, we exploit the Complex Langevin approach and study one-dimensional mass-imbalanced two-component Fermi gases with attractive and repulsive interactions. We find perfect agreement with results obtained by other methods in a range of parameter space. Promisingly, our approach is not limited to the specific model presented here and can easily be extended to finite spin polarization and, most notably, can also be applied in higher dimensions.

•Jan 1, 2024•7 citations
The calculation of the ground state and thermodynamics of mass-imbalanced Fermi systems is a challenging many-body problem. Even in one spatial dimension, analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with standard Monte Carlo approaches is hindered by the sign problem. The focus of the present work is on the further development of methods to study imbalanced systems in a fully nonperturbative fashion. We report our calculations of the ground-state energy of mass-imbalanced fermions using two different approaches which are also very popular in the context of the theory of the strong interaction (quantum chromodynamics, QCD): (a) the hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm with imaginary mass imbalance, followed by an analytic continuation to the real axis; and (b) the complex Langevin algorithm. We cover a range of on-site interaction strengths that includes strongly attractive as well as strongly repulsive cases which we verify with nonperturbative renormalization group methods and perturbation theory. Our findings indicate that, for strong repulsive couplings, the energy starts to flatten out, implying interesting consequences for short-range and high-frequency correlation functions. Overall, our results clearly indicate that the complex Langevin approach is very versatile and works very well for imbalanced Fermi gases with both attractive and repulsive interactions.
The theoretical treatment of Fermi systems consisting of particles with unequal masses is challenging. Even in one spatial dimension analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with Monte Carlo simulations is hindered by the sign-problem. To circumvent this issue, we exploit the Complex Langevin approach and study one-dimensional mass-imbalanced two-component Fermi gases with attractive and repulsive interactions. We find perfect agreement with results obtained by other methods in a range of parameter space. Promisingly, our approach is not limited to the specific model presented here and can easily be extended to finite spin polarization and, most notably, can also be applied in higher dimensions.
The theoretical treatment of Fermi systems consisting of particles with unequal masses is challenging. Even in one spatial dimension analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with Monte Carlo simulations is hindered by the sign-problem. To circumvent this issue, we exploit the Complex Langevin approach and study one-dimensional mass-imbalanced two-component Fermi gases with attractive and repulsive interactions. We find perfect agreement with results obtained by other methods in a range of parameter space. Promisingly, our approach is not limited to the specific model presented here and can easily be extended to finite spin polarization and, most notably, can also be applied in higher dimensions.
Strongly coupled quantum matter displays a rich phenomenology including phase transitions and often unexpected collective behavior. Remarkable advances in experiments with ultracold Fermi gases allow us to gain deep insight into these intriguing systems. Their theoretical description, however, is often challenging as exact analytic solutions are available only in a few special cases, and approximate techniques such as mean-field or perturbation theory are of limited use. Numerical treatment with Monte Carlo (MC) methods has led to profound success in this regard. Unfortunately, for many systems - and especially for asymmetric quantum gases - the infamous sign problem slows progress due to an exponentially scaling of the computational effort with inceasing system size. In this thesis, we set out to explore the rich physics of two-component Fermi gases in the presence of finite spin polarization and/or mass imbalance. To surmount an arising sign problem, we learn from methodological advances made in the field of quantum chromodynamics and further develop these lattice approaches in the context of nonrelativistic Fermi gases. An extensive overview of the numerical methods is presented, including several toy problems to detail the capabilities and shortcomings of the developed approaches. With these tools in hand, we perform extensive benchmarks of the hybrid Monte Carlo method with imaginary asymmetries (iHMC) and the complex Langevin (CL) method, which is based on a complex version of stochastic quantization. Both approaches are shown to yield excellent results for the ground-state energy equation of state of mass-imbalanced Fermi gases in one spatial dimension. Due to its great versatility, the CL method is subsequently employed to study pairing in one-dimensional Fermi gases, for which suitable two-body correlations are computed, revealing unexpected pairing patterns for spin- and mass-imbalanced systems. Another major system of interest in this thesis is the paradigmatic unitary Fermi gas which is investigated at finite temperature and spin polarization. A precise determination of the density equation of state in the normal phase enables us to explore a broad range of thermodynamic properties. We infer valuable information on the finite-temperature phase diagram, such as a flat phase boundary of the normal-to-superfluid transition near the balanced limit and indications for the absence of an extensive pseudogap phase above this transition. The presented results provide experimentally testable ab initio predictions for a range of previously inaccessible thermodynamic quantities.
Fermi gases in strongly coupled regimes are inherently challenging for many-body methods. Although progress has been made analytically, quantitative results require ab initio numerical approaches, such as Monte-Carlo (MC) calculations. However, mass-imbalanced and spin-imbalanced gases are not accessible to MC calculations due to the infamous sign problem. For finite spin imbalance, the problem can be circumvented using imaginary polarizations and analytic continuation, and large parts of the phase diagram then become accessible. We propose to apply this strategy to the mass-imbalanced case, which opens up the possibility to study the associated phase diagram with MC calculations. We perform a first mean-field analysis which suggests that zero-temperature studies, as well as detecting a potential (tri)critical point, are feasible.
The theoretical treatment of Fermi systems consisting of particles with unequal masses is challenging. Even in one spatial dimension analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with Monte Carlo simulations is hindered by the sign-problem. To circumvent this issue, we exploit the Complex Langevin approach and study one-dimensional mass-imbalanced two-component Fermi gases with attractive and repulsive interactions. We find perfect agreement with results obtained by other methods in a range of parameter space. Promisingly, our approach is not limited to the specific model presented here and can easily be extended to finite spin polarization and, most notably, can also be applied in higher dimensions.
The theoretical treatment of Fermi systems consisting of particles with unequal masses is challenging. Even in one spatial dimension analytic solutions are limited to special configurations and numerical progress with Monte Carlo simulations is hindered by the sign-problem. To circumvent this issue, we exploit the Complex Langevin approach and study one-dimensional mass-imbalanced two-component Fermi gases with attractive and repulsive interactions. We find perfect agreement with results obtained by other methods in a range of parameter space. Promisingly, our approach is not limited to the specific model presented here and can easily be extended to finite spin polarization and, most notably, can also be applied in higher dimensions.